Nobody downloaded yet

Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Name Instructor Course Date Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System Introduction The role of the court system is to protect the law by punishing those who break the law. A state must protect its citizens from the acts of law offenders through appropriate channels of punishment…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System"

Download file to see previous pages These models are the inquisitorial and the adversary models. The Canadian Court System mostly applies the adversarial process in its legal processes. Adversarial justice system is the best approach to addressing justice and equality in court systems and the Canadian Courts should continue using it. Reasons for the Adversary Justice System The ultimate concern of the adversary court system is to ensure equal treatment between the prosecution and defense. The court assumes a neutral position and acts as referee between the two parties. This system requires all parties to adhere to the law in responding to different issues in the court. For instance, police officers must use the procedures that the law accepts to obtain evidence from suspects or the accused. The court will determine whether the police used the appropriate ways of gathering evidence that are recognized by the law and are free from deception and other malpractices. The neutral state of the court ensures a fair trial for the accused (see Law Commission). Adversary system stresses on strict observance of the law in seeking justice for all parties involved in a case. This characteristic gives the system an added advantage over the inquisitorial justice system. Inquisitorial justice system involves the court in determining facts and evidence about a case. Therefore, the system gives room for bias where the court can favor one side of the case. This is unlike the adversary system that advocates for observance of the law in determining facts about a case. Moreover, the inquisitorial system denies the accused the right of privacy. The system requires the accused to collaborate with the police and other court officials in the process of gathering evidence. The accused has no right of remaining silent throughout the process unlike in the adversary system where the accused has the right of choosing to remain silent throughout the court process. Courts in the adversary justice system act as supervisors of the actions of the prosecution and the accused and eliminate any practices that conflict with the law. The system does not grant the court the authority of supporting the prosecution against the accused. This form of fairness does not exist in the inquisitorial justice system. It is possible for the authority or the police to coerce their authority on the accused in their attempt to gather evidence against him or her. The law does not allow use of evidence that is a result of coercion of authority. Police officers are known to use excessive power in their attempt to gather evidence against victims of crime. Therefore, involving the court and the police in the process is not in the best interests of ensuring equal and just treatment for offenders (see Prasad). The adversary system becomes even stronger when looking at emerging trends in the field of law. For instance, there have been efforts to introduce the system of restorative justice in the court process. Restorative justice is an emerging trend in the court system where victims and offenders interact in the process of seeking justice. Legal procedures are not the basic requirements of punishing an offender under restorative justice. Instead, the offender must take absolute responsibility for his or her actions by convincing the victims that he or she will not repeat such an offense in the future. The system does not recognize the state as an agent that feels the effect of law breaking. It holds the notion that actions of offenders ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1463536-analysis-critique-of-canadian-court-system
(Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1463536-analysis-critique-of-canadian-court-system.
“Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1463536-analysis-critique-of-canadian-court-system.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System

Court system

...with it. This isn't a good depiction of what our justice system is like or should be. In New York's Times Square, the reaction to the verdict was emotional. "I'm sick, you know, she killed a little girl," said Susan McDougal. "So she gets off and she goes home and maybe has another baby that she can abuse and hurt." Law enforcement officials roped off a door where Cindy and George Anthony were expected to exit out of, and bystanders chanted "Appeal! Appeal!" and "justice for Caylee." Page 2 of 3 ORLANDO, Fla. July 5, 2011 Casey Anthony's Shocking Verdict At the heart of the case was Casey Anthony's fantastic lie that a babysitter named Zenaida, referred to in court as "Zanny the nanny," had stolen Caylee...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Canadian Electoral System

.... The Elections Act in Canada restricted some people from voting in the elections held. These included; The Chief Electorate Officer, his assistant, the returning officers, mentally unstable persons and also judges. However, the evolution of laws led to the amendment of the act which enabled them to vote. Prisoners nowadays are liable to vote. This is unlike before where they could not vote. Prisoners serving a sentence of more than two years in prison were not allowed to vote. However, this restriction has since been lifted by the Canadian courts (Malcolmson 2009, 88).10 The electoral system in Canada is supposed to specify the amount of money that is to be spent during elections. The...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Canadian Healthcare System

...? Canadian Healthcare System Introduction The healthcare system of Canada affects all citizens of this country, regardless of their cultural or economic background. Canada has emerged among the top nations in the world because it provides basic healthcare to all citizens free of charge (Campbell 2002, p. 22). However, Canada faces a health crisis due to overcrowding of hospitals, aging population that must be cared for, and shortage of medical personnel (Campbell 2002, p. 22). These challenges pose a substantial threat to the high standards of Medicare that Canadians boast of, and unless it is fixed immediately and effectively, then Canada will face a health crisis. This...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Drug Court System

...? Drug court system Criminal justice system can be the procedures and means formed by the administrative government to regulate crime and punish those who go against the laws. In America, there is no single criminal justice system but several similar, independent systems. The criminal justice system is dependent on the jurisdiction in charge that can be tribal government, county, city, state or military facility. The government has always been committed to rebalance and reform the country’s criminal justice system for purposes of delivering justice for all citizens, and to safeguard the victim’s interests, communities and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Canadian Criminal Justice System

...that they did not commit (Alvi, 2000). However, there are substantial pitfalls that are left by these two models of justice administration. If these pitfalls go unattended, they can shake the significant reputation of the Canadian legal and judicial system. Therefore, the legislation has been working hard to ensure that they arrive at a common ground in the administration of justice to the Canadian citizens, and in handling of criminals and sexual offenders (Ehrlich, 2001). A case study of sexual offense involved Benjamin Rand who was charged in court for sexual assault. The details of the crimes that Rand committed to minors, and his eventual prosecution reveals the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

American Court System U5IP

...? Wichita Police Department Major Crimes Unit’s Recommendations for the Filing of Cases against Jones, Smith and Thompson. Name Professor’s Name University Name City, State Date Jones, who has been previously convicted, assisted in the investigation that ensured the success of these cases. Justice demands that Jones is charged before a federal court, where maximum sentences are available (Wold, 2004). The police department however, in view of his cooperation, recommends that Jones’ February 6, 2005 cocaine possession case is filed in the District Court, unlike the rest of Sedgwick County where people found to be possessing small amounts of illegal drugs in Wichita were no longer sent to jail. Jones will be a key witness and his... drug...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Canadian education system

...Canadian Education System Assignment Answers Jacqueline Savage Athabasca Assignment # 1 Part 1 1. Select one of the historical perspectives discussed in Unit 1, and explain why that perspective appeals to you more than the others. Introduction The Canadian Education system has had its beginnings in the 1840s and has been evolving ever since. Public education has been more in vogue (as compared to private education), catalyzing the transformation of societies, during the last two centuries. However, contrary views, like that of Henry Fielding (1707-1754), the English novelist and dramatist, on the subject, "Public schools are the nurseries of all vice and immorality"...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

The American Court System

...THE AMERICAN COURT SYSTEM 25 February THE AMERICAN COURT SYSTEM The American court system is a branch of the larger government system that consists of the executive, the legislature, and the judiciary. The main function of the court system is interpretation of the constitution. The courts, with this respect, arbitrate over conflicts in civil and criminal law in order to ensure justice through informed interpretation of laws. This paper seeks to analyze an article that relates to the American court system. The paper will review key points...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

Federal Court System

...Federal Court System Supreme Court has the highest ity in American criminal justice system or federal judiciary. Below Supreme Court, two levels of federal courts are functioning; trail courts or district courts and appellate courts. The nine member Supreme Court judges’ panel consists of a Chief Justice and eight other justices. Supreme Court normally functions based on the guidelines, passed by the Congress. Under normal circumstances, Supreme Court hears cases which were unresolved in trail courts, appellate...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Court analysis

...in the best professional way. The Impact of victim rights laws on Court proceedings: This part of the essay shall discuss the impact of the victim’s rights in the court proceedings as of today. Along with discussing the present day status, the essay shall also understand the past with respect to the victim’s rights in the Courts. “You have the right to be treated with courtesy and sensitivity by the court system and the people in the prosecutors office. If the police are holding any of your property as evidence, they have to take reasonable care of it and return it to you when it is no longer needed, as long as it was legal for you to have it in the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Analysis & Critique of Canadian Court System for FREE!

Contact Us