The Law of Evidence - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Law of Evidence 1. The possibility of evidence being excluded since it was gained by a trick. David has been charged for handling stolen goods. The police obtained the confession of David by putting him into a trick. There is a huge possibility of the evidence being excluded since it was obtained by the trick of the police…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
The Law of Evidence
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Law of Evidence"

Download file to see previous pages In order to proceed further, it is pertinent to define the meaning of trick and understand whether that meaning falls into the conundrum of facts of the case. “A cunning or skilful act or scheme intended to deceive or outwit someone. Intended or used to deceive or mystify, or to create an illusion.”1 To trick someone into something is to make the other person believe that he is showing him the true face of the situation, but, on the other hand he is infact putting him through a fake image of illusion and therefore cheating him to deceive him according to his whims and fancies. ...
helps the accused as the departure from the strict procedure has been adopted by design with a view to securing the admission of evidence obtained by an unfair trick. As per the findings of Lord Cooper, "I can find nothing to suggest that any departure from the strict procedure was deliberately adopted ... in the present instance the irregularity ought to be ‘excused’.”150 The Privy Council, in its opinion delivered on an appeal from Kenya, mentioned, as a ground for excluding relevant evidence that it had been obtained by a "trick." 1:;1 Kingsmill Moore ]., admitting evidence of this kind in an Irish case, said: "I can find no evidence of deliberate treachery, imposition [or]deceit." 152 As a ground for rejecting evidence, the Supreme Court of Canada has pointed out: "Admittedly, the statement by the accused was procured by trickery, duress and improper inducements." Therefore, in the first instance, according to the precedents laid down by the Courts worldwide as well as the law in the PACE Act, it has been clearly stated that any evidence produced by putting the individual under a trick is negligible and liable to be excluded under the law. Thus David may be supported with the help of the same. 2. The Law governing the admissibility of the confession Section 82(1) of the PACE Act defines the law governing the admissibility of confession. The Section is as follows: “confession”, includes any statement wholly or partly adverse to the person who made it, whether made to a person in authority or not and whether made in words or otherwise”.4 According to the facts of the case, it is a clear cut proposition that David was oppressed into confessing that he knew about the stolen nature of the car radio. The Court should look at this situation from a holistic ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Law of Evidence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The Law of Evidence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words)
“The Law of Evidence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document


Introduction to the Law of Evidence

...?Introduction to the Law of Evidence Introduction In case a crime has been committed, the normal procedure during the investigation process is for the police officers to try to find out who is responsible for the crime and ensure that he or she is punished for violating the law or the natural rule of justice. In case the criminal is caught while in the act of committing the robbery, then he or she must be apprehended and the police officers have to collect credible evidence to affirm that the suspect was caught while in the act of committing a crime and not that he/ she was a victim of circumstance. However, in case the police arrive at a crime scene and there is no suspect within the site, then the police officers have to conduct... , they...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Law Evidence

...Part One This research will begin with examining the THREE cases of obtaining evidence as confessions.,illegally, or improperly obtained evidence and silence as evidence put forth in Ian Dennis argument. The argument will be constructed in light of the laws that govern each individual case and conclude with the research. Improperly obtained evidence- The English Law in its fairness decides it is rational to exclude improperly obtained evidence so England's policy was to include the evidence regardless of the source or how it was obtained. The most frequently quoted authority was the 1861...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

Law of evidence

...Number Word Count: 1459 Expert Witnesses The rules regarding expert witnesses seemingly regulate and limit any amateur witnesses from coming in and submitting evidence as an expert witness. These rules come from the statutory provisions set out in the Criminal Procedure Rules 2005 and Civil Procedure Rules 1998, as well as a selection of case law which tends to limit who can be considered a witness for trial purposes.1 By analysing the law that governs the use and admission of expert witness testimony, it can be determined if amateurs are in fact allowed to testify in situations where the area of expertise is sufficiently obscure, or if they are in fact considered experts with regards...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Evidence Law

...Evidence Law Matters relating to Mr. Harry Collingwood and Mr. Fred Vaughan In this case, the matters of major significance are forced confessions received from the alleged offenders, Harry and Fred, and also the incriminating evidences found in their possession. Section 76 (2) (b) of the Police and Evidence Act 1984 says that the confession gained should not have been extracted from the defendant as a result of anything said or done. The judge is obliged to exclude a confession if the prosecution cannot refute an allegation that it was obtained under oppression. (Law Quarterly review. 1991). In other words, it is necessary that the confession obtained,...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

The Law of Evidence

...The Law of Evidence The law of evidence does not stop with the guarantee of the truthfulness of the evidence. They also require that the non-expert witnesses testify according to their personal knowledge and in what they call "language of perception." Witnesses must testify in a highly conventional style, quite difficult to master, often enforced by the judge's orders, "Just tell us what you saw" or "Just tell us what you did." The court is not interested in the witness's interpretations of what occurred, or his opinions of states of affairs he could not perceive through one of his five senses (McKay and Colman, 1991). That would, of course, "usurp the...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Law of Evidence

...Law of Evidence In asking for prior ments to be admitted in testimony, the prosecution can invoke Section 3 of the Criminal Procedure Act of 1865 if the witness’ present testimony in the court proves to be adverse. The relevant provision states that when a witness has made a former statement which is inconsistent with his testimony in Court, “proof may be given that he did indeed make it” and the Prosecution could use this argument to justify admitting his oral statements to Duane as evidence1. In this case, the testimony of WPC Kite is going to be averse to Duane’s interests and on this basis, the prosecution counsel can contradict by introducing prior oral statements that are inconsistent with the oral...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Law of Criminal Evidence

...Law of Criminal Evidence Question What are the potential legal consequences of Imtiaz making no comments in his police interview? Answer: There is often an argument in legal circles to count on silence of accused as a sign of guilt because he is supposed to provide reasons and defense arguments for every question raised during pre-trail investigation. In our question we will deal with the same issue. Is there any reason other than guilt for Imtiaz to keep his silence during pre-trail period? There might be a number of reasons to keep silence during pre-trail period besides guilt. Some of these may be as follow: 1- a negative and distrustful attitude toward police; 2- protection of other people or facts...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Law of Evidence

...Introduction In English law, the normal trend is for the accuser to present evidence against the accused. It is the existence of evidence that creates a case and this is the basis for the contestability of a given claim or issue in court. This is because when an accused person has not done anything wrong, there can be no criminal case against him and in civil cases, this principle exists to a large extent. If there is nothing to be contested, a case cannot proceed. In R V Johnstone1, it was identified that there could be exceptional circumstances where the burden of proof could be reversed from the prosecution to the accused person. This is often done to preserve some fundamental...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Law of Evidence: Testimony

... is not on duty then civilian is what he/she will wear but if the officer is on duty then official standard uniform is expected. Works cited Roberts, Paul, and A A. S. Zuckerman. Criminal Evidence. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004. Print. Bergman, Paul, and Sara J. Berman-Barrett. The Criminal Law Handbook: Know Your Rights, Survive the System. Berkeley: Nolo Press, 2000. Internet resource.... When something is taken as non-testimonial evidence it implies evidence that can only be accepted into evidence as exhibits. It is one of which the prosecutor of the subject matter cannot obtain personal knowledge by observation. They are deemed not to have the same impact as speech. Non...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Law of evidence

...Law of Evidence Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 Discussion 3 Conclusion 5 References 6 Introduction Law and justice are considered important elements in the creation of an ideal society. Unlike law and justice, the criminal activity is also considered a vital factor accountable for breaking the sound harmony in a society. To maintain harmony and balance between negative and positive activities, people need to stay focus regarding their activity. In this context, law and justice has been playing a guidance role for advising the people to act in accordance with several standards and legislations1. The objective of the essay is to...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Law of Evidence for FREE!

Contact Us