Nobody downloaded yet

Moral Obligation and Legal Duty - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Medical law Laws are a conglomerate of principles and rules with respect to all matters of life which the authorities formulate for the standardization of limits within which individuals in the society can perform. Unlike morality, someone makes laws1. Individuals are bound to respect the laws or they incur financial and/or other kinds of liabilities…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
Moral Obligation and Legal Duty
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Moral Obligation and Legal Duty"

Download file to see previous pages “A civilized society's first line of defense is not the law, police and courts but customs, traditions and moral values. Behavioral norms, mostly transmitted by example, word of mouth and religious teachings, represent a body of wisdom distilled over the ages through experience and trial and error”2. Laws are primarily meant to safeguard the moral values of the nation, but this itself raises a number of challenges for the law-making agencies given the morals of a society alter with time depending upon the demands of the time. Coleridge said, “It would not be correct to say that every moral obligation involves a legal duty; but every legal duty is founded on a moral obligation. A legal common law duty is nothing else than the enforcing by law of that which is a moral obligation without legal enforcement”3. This paper reviews the English medical laws other than the law of clinical negligence with an intent to evaluate whether the extent to which the enforcers of these laws see a moral obligation to their duties. For this, the issues discussed include abortion and euthanasia. If they do so, that would mean that their legal duties are founded on moral obligations. In the last, the recent development of the law of human rights is commented upon from the standpoint of the very issue. Different theories of abortion have emerged over the years. Many people claim that abortion is morally justified since it is a legal procedure. “There is a subtle type of argumentation here that basically is saying that if it is legal, it is moral; and if it is legal and moral, then it is immoral to oppose it”4. A woman who involves herself in sex voluntarily and without the use of contraceptives, she in a way signs a bond with the fetus. “A contract entails the demonstrated existence of a reasonably (and reasonable) free will. If the fulfillment of the obligations in a contract between individuals could be life-threatening – it is fair and safe to assume that no rational free will was involved”5. But a pregnancy happens as a result of rape or forced sex, it is morally feasible to terminate it since the mother never entered the contract willingly, thus rendering it invalid. This in turn justifies all measures taken to terminate the pregnancy before it reaches the stage when doing so would threaten the life of the mother. Judith Jarvis Thomson considers abortion impermissible but not on the grounds that most anti-abortionists base their claims on6 Abortion is not wrong because fetus is a human being and has a right to live, but it is impermissible because a woman carrying her pregnancy to term displays good samaritanism. From a moral standpoint, a woman that carries pregnancy to term generously takes care of the fetus by undergoing pain and labor while the fetus has the needs but not the rights but a woman, who terminates the pregnancy does not show this generosity and accordingly, does not take care of the needs of the fetus. “It is not the case that abortion violates the requirements of morality, therefore, but rather that continuing to incur the burdens involved in pregnancy goes beyond them”7. A woman’s ethical obligation to the fetus is inevitable irrespective of whether the abortion is legalized or not in a certain country8. One woman’s decision to terminate the pregnancy has a number of social implications, which challenges the perception that it is only ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Moral Obligation and Legal Duty Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Moral Obligation and Legal Duty Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words)
“Moral Obligation and Legal Duty Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Moral Obligation and Legal Duty

Political Obligation

...Political Obligation - Why should we obey the law The question of why the individual should obey the law is a central dilemma of any society. Most individuals have impulses that, if succumbed to, would cause them to break the law and yet most people, most of the time tend to obey the law even when the likelihood of being caught is small. This paper will consider both why we should obey the la and why, much of the time, we do obey the law. It will consider a number of important theories, such as Rousseau's Social Contract and Marxism, as well as more recent paradigms including labeling theory. The basic thesis is that obeying the law enables people to be more free within their actions than not. Rousseau's The Social...
8 Pages(2000 words)Thesis

Moral Obligation by Bentham

...Moral Obligation by Bentham Introduction Moral obligation can be viewed in the light of those facts that help us distinguish between good and bad or right and wrong. Now what are those facts that justify rights and wrongs? “Those facts prove the existence of ethics by giving ultimate justification of moral standards”. (Moore, “Moral and Political Philosophy”, p. 251) Some philosophers hold the opinion that moral obligation refers to the laws that cannot be advised. Bentham gives the justification of good and bad as ‘pleasure’ and ‘pain’. He related ‘pleasure’ with goodness and ‘pain’ with badness....
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Professional, Legal and Moral Issues in Nursing

...Professional, Legal and Moral Issues in Nursing Introduction The nursing profession is a science and an art, in which the primary aim is to promotequality of life. It include a comprehensive set of activities and duties by which individuals and families are assisted in a range of human life experiences ranging from birth, sickness and end of life. Florence Nightingale is the first person to start modern nursing practices and New Zealand was the first country to regulate nurses nationally. The American Nurses Association defines the practice of nursing as "the protection, promotion, and optimization of health and abilities, prevention of illness and injury, alleviation of suffering through...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Legal Right and Ethical Obligation

...Legality v. Ethics Introduction: When the Hon. Justice Potter Stewart opined that there is a big difference between what we have the right to do andwhat is right, he was thinking of all the situations wherein a company is well within its legal rights to do or not do something, even though the same could be questioned on ethical grounds. This time-honored statement was reiterated in the case of State ex rel. Rosenthal v. Poe (State of Texas, 2002). To find a stable balance between law and ethics certainly calls for some tight-rope walking. One needs to look at the motive behind the act; though, there are situations where even the motive does not justify the moral standing of the act. This causes a certain deviation from the law... for a...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Do we have a moral obligation to vote

...Do We Have A Moral Obligation to Vote? The Election of a new President is on the horizon for America. The question however, is whether or not we are morally obligated to vote. If we are, does our vote make any difference at all and is the act of voting even rational? The purpose of this essay is to discuss the existence of moral obligation to vote and whether making the effort to vote is even a rational act. This paper will be examining consequential argument primarily, in building a case towards voting or not voting. It will then briefly discuss other forms of argument that may be used in this case. Based on the idea of individual...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Obligation Assessment

...above. It is evident that claiming against the press people is possible. Here, the press people are interfering in the personal matters of an individual which is totally against the right of an individual within the country. Any personal questions can be asked only for legal purpose by the legal authorities. Mental harassment is more punishable than physical harassments. The press people should be penalised and must be punished severely. The press people will be supported by the respective TV channels for which they collect information. The reason behind this must be identified and necessary actions must be taken by the appropriate authority. c) Sweet Kandy on any claims the band may have against Simon...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Attorney Obligation

...representation and to avoid conflict of interest. The attorney is entitled to keep any information provided by client confidential. The attorney should ensure that they feel strongly about the client; that they portray enthusiasm about the case they are handling. The attorney is expected to wholly represent and be loyal to the client avoiding any conflict of interest in their role as the defense attorney. Prosecuting Attorney. Goldman (2006) states that the prosecuting attorney who is usually appointed by the judicial district is charged with the responsibility of conducting legal obligations on behalf of people or the state. He or she is entitled to ethical obligations just like the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Are Multinational Corporations Free from Moral Obligation

...International Corporation’s Position in Moral Obligation Insert Insert Grade Insert Morality refers to acting in ways that are considerate for the other party involved in the action. It involves a person taking full responsibility of his or her action towards another person. Moral obligation requires all the people to deal with each other while showing respect for their personal rights. This moral obligation is supposed to be extended from small groups, local organizations and even among all people in the world. Being moral entails taking an ethical consideration regarding every event or issues that is involved in interaction of all the people. This work will critically analyze the issue of there being any ethical consideration... . This is...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Reliance Theories and Moral Obligation

...Reliance Theories and Moral Obligation The fundamental western philosophy argues that human beings are to some extent self-reliant. Social institutions rely on the belief of autonomy where people have freedom to worship, marry, and work. There are various reasons that explain the use of the stakeholder’s theories. The coping strategy proposes that the chance of having a governmental intervention and regulations increases when decision making in business conflicts with the society’s expectations. The second reason involves self-interest. The goal of any business in a capitalistic society is to make a profit regardless of its effects to the society. Some scholars such as Adam smith, however, refute the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Legal, Ethical, or Moral

...Legal, ethical, or moral Legal or ethical/ moral Issue MONTEJO Hospital Rules for Hospital that Deported Jimenez The Montejo Case is a legal issue than moral considering the various legal guidelines on the decisions in the case. The other reason making the case a legal issue is that the transportation of Jimenez to Guatemala was in response to a court order and the hospital was following decisions made during a court proceeding (Florida District Court of Appeal, August 23, 2006). That decisions made were guided by a court order and presence of laws and regulations including Florida laws on court proceedings and the false imprisonment as cited in the case depict the legality of the issue. Jimenez deportation and the suit against... the...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Moral Obligation and Legal Duty for FREE!

Contact Us