Nobody downloaded yet

Etridge Case Critique: Rosemary Auchmuty's Feminist Judgment, A Better Alternative - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
ETRIDGE CASE CRITIQUE: ROSEMARY AUCHMUTY’S FEMINIST JUDGMENT, A BETTER ALTERNATIVE? Contracts1 are constituted upon the meeting of the minds between individuals or entities where one party offers to give or render service and the other accepts are bound by their promises…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Etridge Case Critique: Rosemary Auchmutys Feminist Judgment, A Better Alternative
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Etridge Case Critique: Rosemary Auchmuty's Feminist Judgment, A Better Alternative"

Download file to see previous pages This equally connotes that the parties have acquiesced with the provisions of the agreement knowingly when they affixed their signatures thereto. It can be reasonably concluded that they have read and understood the terms of the agreement and bound themselves to perform their obligations. Hence, the agreement becomes the law between the parties and operates to define their obligations and liabilities. It is therefore essential for the parties to establish that they have the legal capacity and competence to enter into a contract and to ensure that their consent was given freely without any undue influence, violence, duress or threat against their persons and sans any allegations of fraud or misrepresentation. It cannot be denied however that in contract negotiations, one party may have an advantage over the other—would this constitute as a ground to nullify the agreement? A concrete example of negotiating at a dominant position would be banks when it offers loan packages to jump start a business, increase capitalization, purchase cars, family homes and other personal amenities—the banks are at liberty to impose the terms of the loans, to accept the security offered and to further require spousal surety or “surety wife”.2 For loan transactions procured by husbands, together with their wives secured by family homes, what then is the impact of vice of consent upon the wives—does the allegation of impropriety nullify the transaction? Would it be proper and equitable then to confer more rights upon the weaker or vulnerable party—“surety wife”—as opposed to the more dominant party—banks? These are the issues raised in the Etridge consolidated cases presented for critical analysis, it was alleged that the wives—the weak and vulnerable parties submit to the will of their husbands as undue influence is exerted upon them—were not fully cognizant of the nature of the transactions entered into by their spouses, given inadequate advice and if only the gravity of the situation were explained to them, they could not have acted as sureties much more offer their family homes as security to guaranty the loans procured by their spouses to finance their business undertakings. In the consolidated Eldridge decision, the House of Lords (HL) sustained the position of some of the wives exposed to undue influence however contrary dispositions were rendered against the Etridge couple and two other couples—Gill and Coleman. This gave rise to debates and spurred legal and feminists scholars, particularly the esteemed Rosemary Auchmuty, to pursue alternative judgments and it is the task of this paper to examine whether the feminist ruling advanced is fair, just and equitable. Indeed, women are portrayed as weak, vulnerable and incapable of independent thinking such that they would succumb to pressure from their husbands and would even sell or convey by way of surety their interest in the family home to please the husband if not maintain a blissful relationship. This infirmity has been raised by wives to stop banks from foreclosing the family home in case of default in the amortization. However, as society is overzealous in protecting the rights of women, particularly the wives, it is posited that it may have deleterious effect to the public weal and interest. It is argued that public interest pitted against individual rights far outweighs the rights of wives. To afford wives greater protection would be discriminatory and ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Etridge Case Critique: Rosemary Auchmuty's Feminist Judgment, A Better Essay”, n.d.)
Etridge Case Critique: Rosemary Auchmuty's Feminist Judgment, A Better Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1440761-explain-why-rosemary-auchmuty-has-written-this
(Etridge Case Critique: Rosemary Auchmuty'S Feminist Judgment, A Better Essay)
Etridge Case Critique: Rosemary Auchmuty'S Feminist Judgment, A Better Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1440761-explain-why-rosemary-auchmuty-has-written-this.
“Etridge Case Critique: Rosemary Auchmuty'S Feminist Judgment, A Better Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1440761-explain-why-rosemary-auchmuty-has-written-this.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Etridge Case Critique: Rosemary Auchmuty's Feminist Judgment, A Better Alternative

Feminist Movement in the 1960's

...Number Due Feminist Movement in the 1960's The feminist movement in the sixties renewed the vigor in the fight for emancipation of women from a myriad of social, political, legal, and economic inequalities and prejudices which had been facing women in the hugely patriarchal society of the times. It won considerable victories for women through affirmative action and legislation and smashed through Glass ceilings to allow women to soar above what was normally their limited “flight space” this period commonly referred to as the second wave was preceded by the first wave of liberation for women. The first wave was less radical and dealt with issues such as women’s voting rights and gender...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Feminist

...A Critique of the Different Forms of Feminism What is Feminism? The definition of feminism as a concept is seen to be wrought by a number of different definitions which are all individually shaped by type of feminism that is being practiced by the individual. However, Zohrab (6) provides a definition of feminism that is seen to be widely acceptable as it essentially encompasses all the various different definitions of the term. According to Zohrab, feminism can be defined as being the application of the victims of oppression model to various different situations that are faced by women in the modern society today. In this respect a feminist can be defined by this model as being a person that believes...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

BETTER PLACE CASE STUDY

...? Better place case study al Affiliation) Key words: Strategy, Better Place Mission, Vision, and Stakeholders Mission Themission of the organization was “To reduce and eventually eliminate the automobile industry’s oil dependence”. The dependence of automobile industry’s on oil has caused several negative effects on the environment and that is the reason why Better Place comes in with the technology of electric vehicles to curb of the effects. The mission was to be achieved by forming partnerships with other companies and the Israeli government which would help launches a network of electric vehicles nationally and eventually it would be extended to the whole world after...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Money judgment

...know the cost of making will isn't expensive (single will- 80 excluding VAT, joint will- 125 excluding VAT) (Money Minder, 2005). Unless you make a will, your favourite persons may fall in problem when you will be no more in the world because the laws of intestacy suggests that your estate will not automat-you to realize easily what's the result of not making a will. Before making a will you need to be sure of the total sum of the property you have and you would like to distribute. Furthermore, you also have to know the fact among whom persons you can distribute the property by making a will. I think it's better for you to make a reciprocal will so that you and Jennifer can mirror each other in that...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Case Critique

...23 October 2008 Case Critique The case study is based on well-thought research on the topic and carefulanalysis of marketing strategy. The main strengths are a detailed explanation of the proposed strategy and evaluation of key factors such as market position, product offerings, demographics, geography, distribution options and pricing. It is clear form the analysis that the very perceptions and interpretations of environmental developments by consumers create product opportunities. The marketer considers the life-style factors influencing product development. He takes into account urbanization, leisure, competition, discretionary income, travel, styles, tastes, automobiles, informality,...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Theory Critique Feminist and Post Modern

...the text, I remember the story of the adulterous woman from the bible adjudged as a sinner worthy of being stoned to death (John 8: 3-11). The Pharisees, eager to trap Jesus asked him if he will conform to the law of Moses to stone such women. To that, Jesus merely left them to think and decide for themselves that if any of them is without sin, then that person may be the one to first throw a stone at her. His nonchalant but wise behavior seemed to have a great effect on the judgmental men, as they left her unharmed. The Pharisees are likened to society, who places expectations on women and judges them on their behavior without regard for these women’s subjective realities. Jesus is likened to a...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Feminism in The Story of an Hour by Chopin and The Yellow Wallpaper by Gilman

... Freedom is represented in each text by certain symbols, which symbols can u find in each text In each of the texts, the women involved are looking for freedom. In the story of an hour, Louise finds freedom in the supposed death of her husband Mr. Millard. In Yellow wallpaper, the woman’s symbol of freedom is the yellow wall paper that she sees moving at night. Both women are yearning for freedom and see their husbands as obstacles to their happiness. Mrs. Millard is overwhelmed with joy when she gets the news of her husbands’ supposed death and goes to a room to celebrate how her freedom has come sooner that she thought (Chopin, The story of an hour). Mrs. John, on the other hand, is watched by everyone and spends most of her... Freedom is...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Michelangelo's "Last Judgment"

...The Last Judgment The Last Judgment is the greatest work of art of the famous Michelangelo, painted on the altar wall of the Sistine Chapel in Vatican City. Unlike the earlier works of the master The Last Judgment doesn’t anthemise the powerful energy of God’s creation but describes the huge crash of the entire world as retaliation for all the sins done by humans. In the fresco Michelangelo breaks with centuries of iconographic tradition and describes not the moment when the last judgment is being made and saints and sinners are being separated from each other, but the very beginning of the Judgment. Dreadful Jesus holds his hand up retributively,...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Case's outline

...Outline for Interpretive Essay I. Introduction A. Teaching in general Teaching children in elementary school Children with special needs Teaching children with special needs B. Attention-deficit/ Hyperactivity disorder in children The definition of ADHD The causes and symptoms C. Ali’s diagnosis Who is Ali? (Personal and academic background) Which disability condition does Ali have? II. Cognitive ability A. The cognitive deficits in attention-Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder B. Understanding the cognitive aspect of Ali’s case C. The cause of Ali’s low academic performance and concrete operational stage The journal article Common Cognitive Deficits in Children With Attention-Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder and Autism:...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Alternative Fuel Company Case

...Demand Prediction Question one A start-up alternative fuel automobile company has a first year market forecast of 1000 units. Identify the forecasting model that is in use here and explain why it is the obvious choice. One of the best methods that are used in the prediction of the demand for most of the goods and services in this industry is the moving average method. The moving average model is used since it encompasses the use of numerous historical values that depict the demand for the market. In this model, it should be noted that a specific number of years must be chosen in order to help in the calculations of the demand (Nguyen, Shu, Huang, & Hsu, 2013). The average of the units demand for the previous years is...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Etridge Case Critique: Rosemary Auchmuty's Feminist Judgment, A Better Alternative for FREE!

Contact Us