Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Feminist inquiry: Three briefs Name University 27 March 2012 Sandra Harding, “Is There a Feminist Method?” Sandra Harding has a Ph.D., Philosophy from New York University. Her teaching and research interests are in feminist and postcolonial theory, epistemology, research methodology and philosophy of science…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry"

Feminist inquiry: Three briefs 27 March Sandra Harding, “Is There a Feminist Method?” Sandra Harding has a Ph.D., Philosophy from New York University. Her teaching and research interests are in feminist and postcolonial theory, epistemology, research methodology and philosophy of science. Harding’s position on feminist research is that there is no single feminist method. In her article, “Is There a Feminist Method?,” Harding argued that feminists should not be preoccupied with the pursuit of a single feminist method, because this neglects the unique aspects of feminist research. Instead, she aspired to describe the distinctive elements of feminist biological and social science research that makes feminist studies, exciting and challenging. Harding explained that traditional approaches to biology and social science research regarding women’s nature, thinking, and behaviors hardly focused on female targets and only emphasized the “fetishization” of methods (Harding, 1989, p.18). Lawrence Kohlberg, for instance, did not find it perplexing that women’s responses to his moral dilemmas were “less easy” compared to men (Harding, 1989, p.18). Biologists also prescribed cosmetics tested on male than female rats, because menstruation cycles muddled the product effects for female rats (Harding, 1989, p.18). In essence, these sciences followed methods that were based on male models of human biological or moral development (Harding, 1989, p.18). Harding also complained about the fetish of researchers, which mimicked other scientific methodological approaches, without understanding its relevance and validity to their own fields and inquiries (Harding, 1989, p.18). Harding examined and criticized the calls for single or multiple feminist methods; for her, these methods either focused on method, or methodology, or epistemology, without fully appreciate the wide range of feminist writing and research methods, methodologies, and epistemologies. MacKinnon asserted that “consciousness-raising is feminist method” (Harding, 1989, p.18). Harding argued that this method overlooks other equally valid methods of studying women’s nature, thoughts, and behaviors. Hartsock stresses the need for “specifically feminist historical materialism” (Harding, 1989, p.19). For Harding, this approach is a methodology, not a feminist method. Other sociologists emphasized the value of phenomenological research to feminist inquiries. For them, the feminist method directly opposed extreme empiricism or positivism in research and proposed the use of Marxist epistemology. Harding was concerned of the limitations of phenomenology, because it constrained feminist inquiries, does not address the lack of awareness of subjects to local forces that shape their conditions, and it does not sufficiently consider the role of studies of masculinity and men and critical studies on feminist works in feminist research. Harding proposed an understanding of what feminists do in their research, in order to appreciate feminist research, which for her, is more meaningful than striving to define a feminist method. First, feminists study gender. Gender includes masculine, feminine, and other genders. Gender studies also entail criticizing gender roles and expectations (Harding, 1989, p.27). Gender is turned into a variable like class and social status, which other traditional studies do not explore (Harding, 1989, p.27). Second, feminist research is focused on women’s experiences as legitimate source of data (Harding, 1989, p.27). Feminist questions come from women’s experiences and not from how society wants to mold women (Harding, 1989, p.27). Finally, feminist research is robustly reflexive, where interactions between gender and other social variables, such as class, race, and culture, provides a deeper understanding of the feminist inquiry (Harding, 1989, p.28). Hence, Harding stresses that it is not important that there is a feminist method. Feminist research should be free to use different methods, methodology, and epistemology that fit its line of inquiry and nature of its participants. George Noblit, “Critical Theory” George Noblit is the Joseph R. Neikirk Distinguished Professor of Sociology of Education. His teaching areas are qualitative research methods and social foundations of education. He currently teaches at the School of Education, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. His main position on critical theory methods is that there is no single critical method. In his article, “Critical Theory,” Noblit explored the nature and aims of critical theory. Critical theory aims to examine the” dynamics of power and ideology” (Noblit, 2005, p.76). Critical researchers seek to dissect power and ideological dynamics, so that they emancipate those who are oppressed in the present socio-economic and political system. Noblit argued that critical theory has no single method, because it should use all methods and methodologies that can help it attain its primary goal of revealing and dismantling unequal power relations in society. Noblit discussed the value orientation and epistemology of critical researchers. Critical research has a value orientation that: 1) uses social and cultural criticism, 2) opposes all kinds of inequality, 3) exposes oppression and fights it, 4) studies all forms of oppression, and 5) avoids mainstream epistemology that supports status quo oppression and uses critical epistemology to dismantle unequal power relations (Noblit, 2005, p.77). Critical theory is more than research; it is an action-oriented research that aims for emancipation for all oppressed sectors. Noblit did not support a single critical method or methodology, because in the study of all forms of oppression and fighting it, any form of valid method and methodology can be used. There are different ways to explore critical research: critical theory, critical ethnography, and “science with an attitude” (Noblit, 2005, p.78). Critical theory itself criticizes mainstream ideology. Critical ethnography employs critical philosophy to interpret findings of ethnographic studies (Noblit, 2005, p.78). “Science with an attitude” questions the dominance of critical ethnography in critical research (Noblit, 2005, p.78). Ladwig argued that rejecting positivism is wrong, since winning the war against mainstream research and epistemology means dominating their own methods and methodologies (Noblit, 2005, p.78). Noblit asked critical researchers to not limit their methods and methodologies, as long as they serve the overarching purpose of social emancipation for the oppressed. Crotty, “Feminism: Re-visioning the Man-made World” Michael Crotty has written numerous books on feminism and social research. In “Feminism: Re-visioning the Man-made World,” his main position is that he can be a feminist too, even if he lacks “feminist consciousness” (Crotty, 1998, p.161). He argued that it is wrong to see feminism as a work by and for women alone, because masculinity is a gendered experience that affects feminist inquiries and masculinity studies can also support feminist liberation efforts. He emphasized what Freire said that people cannot free others or even themselves. Instead, people can liberate each other (Crotty, 1998, p.162). His point is that as a man, he supports the idea that feminism should free men and women alike. His main argument is that as a man, he can also support feminism, because patriarchy limits men by empowering them through traditional roles and norms, and that feminism may have different strands, but they are all connected by their aim of understanding gender experiences and fighting for gender equality (Crotty, 1998, p.162). Crotty described the different forms of feminisms to understand that feminism may have different methods, methodologies, epistemologies, and assumptions, but they are still connected by similar goals and data sources. The main goal of feminism is like critical theory. It aims to understand social phenomena from a feminine perspective, so that it can identify gender oppression and then challenge and end it. Women may be the main sources of feminist studies, but the views of men are also important in understanding how gender empowerment can be sustainably attained. Crotty agreed that feminist research entails re-visioning history as people generally know it. Feminism is a gender liberating movement and process, where in the end, men and women benefit from a new world system, where genders are viewed as and develop as equals. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from
(Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words.
“Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry

Three Systems of Law within the European Union

The significance of ‘direct effect’ was enunciated in Van Gend en Loos v Nederlandse Administratie der Belastingen CMLR [1963] 105. In this case, the European Court of Justice ruled that ‘The Community constitutes a new legal order of international law for the benefit of which the States have limited their sovereign rights, albeit within limited fields, and the subject of which comprise not only the Member States but also their nationals...It follows from the foregoing conclusions that, according to the spirit, the general scheme and the wording of the Treaty, Art. 12 must be interpreted as producing direct effects and creating individual rights which national courts must protect.’

The doctrine o...
13 Pages(3250 words)Assignment

Benevolent Repression: The Three Major Reformatory Systems

... Benevolent Repression – The Three Major Reformatory Systems In his book Benevolent Repression, Alexander Pisciotta indicates the Elmira Reformatory was considered the founding institution for America’s reformatory system, as the concept of reform only entered other prison systems following its establishment and further systems were established either based on or inherently against this original idea. The concept of reform arose out of the concept of the ‘medical model.’ The medical model “presume[s] that the physician’s task is to diagnose diseases, to discover their causes and symptoms and design treatments. The treatments are aimed at eliminating or minimizing the symptoms of the disease, or the cause of the disease, or the disease...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

Anwering Three Questions of Philosophy

Basically, where he drew a comparison between the two, was by equating their attempt to explain concepts and constructs therein, by the use of numbers (Pythagoras) and ideas (Plato).

Aristotle believed that these were comparable in the sense, that these were arrangements of convenience, wherein additions or subtractions in the notions could be contrived at a theoretical convenience, just so that a link could be established amongst the theoretical construct originally proposed by them. Aristotle believed that Plato advocated the notion that forms (ideas) cause both existence and generation. On the other hand, Aristotle felt that Pythagoras supported the idea that numbers try to explain the connotation of the universe and...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Three Types of Unemployment

Nevertheless, whatever the reasons may be, the state of unemployment is fatal for any person if he is actively seeking employment. Any individual at any stage can be bitten by this worm of unemployment. Unemployment also gives an indication of how the economy of a country is performing, higher the number of unemployed people in the economy more is the dipping status of the economic sector. So hereby, we see that the country’s unemployment status has an inverse relationship with economic growth. The economic growth of a country is governed by inflation in the economy, which in turn is governed by the money supply in the economy.

NSSO defines Unemployment as a situation in which all those who, owing to lack of work...
15 Pages(3750 words)Assignment

Myths and Stereotypes on Womens Madness in Feminist Literature

The ultimate salvation and expression of a woman lie in providing mental support to the ever so creative man, they went on convincing young, aspiring young women. It was this background that prompted Sylvia Plath to create the character, Buddy Willard’s mother and, make her say the sentence, “what a man is is an arrow into the future and what a woman is is the place the arrow shoots off from…,” (Plath, 1972, p.58) in her novel, Bell Jar.

Anybody that refuses to conform to the norms and conventions of the society stands the risk of being branded mad. Madness is a revolt of the psyche against the social conditioning that every human being acquires from his or her surroundings. Esther goes mad prim...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Three Mile Island: Crisis Management

...Three Mile Island: Crisis Management BY YOU YOUR SCHOOL HERE YOUR HERE HERE Three Mile Island: Crisis Management Introduction In 1979, anuclear power facility in the United States experienced a large-scale radiation leak which caused a great deal of local panic from citizens and businesses. This facility is referred to today as Three Mile Island and it is one of the most terrible nuclear-related accidents to date. This nuclear facility was powered by two pressurized water reactors, one of which experienced a near meltdown, a situation in which radioactive material is unable to remain at an appropriate temperature to avoid radioactive materials to be released. Three Mile Island was a major crisis, involving a variety of stakeholders who...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Similarities and Differences of Themes, Language of Three Texts

...WITH CLOSE REFERENCE TO THE THREE OF THE TEXTS STUDIED, COMPARE THE WAYS IN, WHICH FORM IS.WRITER Customer English INTRODUCTION The three texts sonnet 18 by Shakespeare, six characters in search of an author by Pirandello and Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone by J.K Rowling belong to three different sub-divisions of literature i.e. poetry, play and novel. All the three texts are a projection of three different ideas with a variety of interpretations for the readers according to the individual capacity of understanding of life and its various aspects. However when comparing and contrasting these texts there is a variety of similarities and differences of themes, language and the techniques that the three writers have used...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

The Feminist View on the Ideology of Separate Sphere

In this thesis, I intend to delve into a detailed perspective with regards to intricacies of public and private life contexts of a woman’s life as illustrated throughout the popular literature “Little Women” and influence of these separate spheres on each other in contrast to the popular notion that these are completely independent entities with no direct influence on each other.
The thesis of this research, therefore, is the societal depiction of a woman as secure, confident and trusted in handling private, family and home-related matters. On the flip side, it offers a stark contrast when it comes to the perception of her ability to handle public responsibilities.
In analyzing the feminist view on the...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study

Three Digital SLR Cameras

...Consumer Report on Three Digital SLR Cameras TABLE OF CONTENTS Informative ……………………………………………………………………….2 Introduction ………………………………………………………………………………...3 Discussion of Findings ……………………………………………………………………. 4 Summary of Findings ………………………………………………………………………7 Conclusion ………………………………………………………………………………..... 8 Works Cited ………………………………………………………………………………..10 INFORMATIVE ABSTRACT After extensive inquiry and personal research from different sources, I plan to purchase Nikon D5300 camera. The purpose of this consumer report is to explain to other potential consumers of the process I followed in making the final but informed decision in purchasing the product. The decision to purchase the Nikon D5300 camera was based on a four criteria that were...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Argumentative Analysis of Bram Stokers Dracula using Feminist Theory

The 19th-century Victorian society underwent a change in which, women became more free and liberal with the feminist movement. Critically, the novel sheds light on modernized women and their changing roles in a patriarchal society, which was unacceptable and alienated for Stoker and other men. The female characters of the novel can be analyzed in the light of feminist theory. These characters include Lucy Westenra, Mina Harker and three women vampires residing with Dracula, also called his three brides. This paper evaluates Dracula using radical feminist theory and also includes authorial analysis of critics supporting claims.
Victorian society to which, Stoker belonged was repressive and patriarchal and with radical changes...
22 Pages(5500 words)Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry for FREE!

Contact Us