Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Feminist inquiry: Three briefs Name University 27 March 2012 Sandra Harding, “Is There a Feminist Method?” Sandra Harding has a Ph.D., Philosophy from New York University. Her teaching and research interests are in feminist and postcolonial theory, epistemology, research methodology and philosophy of science…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry"

Feminist inquiry: Three briefs 27 March Sandra Harding, “Is There a Feminist Method?” Sandra Harding has a Ph.D., Philosophy from New York University. Her teaching and research interests are in feminist and postcolonial theory, epistemology, research methodology and philosophy of science. Harding’s position on feminist research is that there is no single feminist method. In her article, “Is There a Feminist Method?,” Harding argued that feminists should not be preoccupied with the pursuit of a single feminist method, because this neglects the unique aspects of feminist research. Instead, she aspired to describe the distinctive elements of feminist biological and social science research that makes feminist studies, exciting and challenging. Harding explained that traditional approaches to biology and social science research regarding women’s nature, thinking, and behaviors hardly focused on female targets and only emphasized the “fetishization” of methods (Harding, 1989, p.18). Lawrence Kohlberg, for instance, did not find it perplexing that women’s responses to his moral dilemmas were “less easy” compared to men (Harding, 1989, p.18). Biologists also prescribed cosmetics tested on male than female rats, because menstruation cycles muddled the product effects for female rats (Harding, 1989, p.18). In essence, these sciences followed methods that were based on male models of human biological or moral development (Harding, 1989, p.18). Harding also complained about the fetish of researchers, which mimicked other scientific methodological approaches, without understanding its relevance and validity to their own fields and inquiries (Harding, 1989, p.18). Harding examined and criticized the calls for single or multiple feminist methods; for her, these methods either focused on method, or methodology, or epistemology, without fully appreciate the wide range of feminist writing and research methods, methodologies, and epistemologies. MacKinnon asserted that “consciousness-raising is feminist method” (Harding, 1989, p.18). Harding argued that this method overlooks other equally valid methods of studying women’s nature, thoughts, and behaviors. Hartsock stresses the need for “specifically feminist historical materialism” (Harding, 1989, p.19). For Harding, this approach is a methodology, not a feminist method. Other sociologists emphasized the value of phenomenological research to feminist inquiries. For them, the feminist method directly opposed extreme empiricism or positivism in research and proposed the use of Marxist epistemology. Harding was concerned of the limitations of phenomenology, because it constrained feminist inquiries, does not address the lack of awareness of subjects to local forces that shape their conditions, and it does not sufficiently consider the role of studies of masculinity and men and critical studies on feminist works in feminist research. Harding proposed an understanding of what feminists do in their research, in order to appreciate feminist research, which for her, is more meaningful than striving to define a feminist method. First, feminists study gender. Gender includes masculine, feminine, and other genders. Gender studies also entail criticizing gender roles and expectations (Harding, 1989, p.27). Gender is turned into a variable like class and social status, which other traditional studies do not explore (Harding, 1989, p.27). Second, feminist research is focused on women’s experiences as legitimate source of data (Harding, 1989, p.27). Feminist questions come from women’s experiences and not from how society wants to mold women (Harding, 1989, p.27). Finally, feminist research is robustly reflexive, where interactions between gender and other social variables, such as class, race, and culture, provides a deeper understanding of the feminist inquiry (Harding, 1989, p.28). Hence, Harding stresses that it is not important that there is a feminist method. Feminist research should be free to use different methods, methodology, and epistemology that fit its line of inquiry and nature of its participants. George Noblit, “Critical Theory” George Noblit is the Joseph R. Neikirk Distinguished Professor of Sociology of Education. His teaching areas are qualitative research methods and social foundations of education. He currently teaches at the School of Education, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. His main position on critical theory methods is that there is no single critical method. In his article, “Critical Theory,” Noblit explored the nature and aims of critical theory. Critical theory aims to examine the” dynamics of power and ideology” (Noblit, 2005, p.76). Critical researchers seek to dissect power and ideological dynamics, so that they emancipate those who are oppressed in the present socio-economic and political system. Noblit argued that critical theory has no single method, because it should use all methods and methodologies that can help it attain its primary goal of revealing and dismantling unequal power relations in society. Noblit discussed the value orientation and epistemology of critical researchers. Critical research has a value orientation that: 1) uses social and cultural criticism, 2) opposes all kinds of inequality, 3) exposes oppression and fights it, 4) studies all forms of oppression, and 5) avoids mainstream epistemology that supports status quo oppression and uses critical epistemology to dismantle unequal power relations (Noblit, 2005, p.77). Critical theory is more than research; it is an action-oriented research that aims for emancipation for all oppressed sectors. Noblit did not support a single critical method or methodology, because in the study of all forms of oppression and fighting it, any form of valid method and methodology can be used. There are different ways to explore critical research: critical theory, critical ethnography, and “science with an attitude” (Noblit, 2005, p.78). Critical theory itself criticizes mainstream ideology. Critical ethnography employs critical philosophy to interpret findings of ethnographic studies (Noblit, 2005, p.78). “Science with an attitude” questions the dominance of critical ethnography in critical research (Noblit, 2005, p.78). Ladwig argued that rejecting positivism is wrong, since winning the war against mainstream research and epistemology means dominating their own methods and methodologies (Noblit, 2005, p.78). Noblit asked critical researchers to not limit their methods and methodologies, as long as they serve the overarching purpose of social emancipation for the oppressed. Crotty, “Feminism: Re-visioning the Man-made World” Michael Crotty has written numerous books on feminism and social research. In “Feminism: Re-visioning the Man-made World,” his main position is that he can be a feminist too, even if he lacks “feminist consciousness” (Crotty, 1998, p.161). He argued that it is wrong to see feminism as a work by and for women alone, because masculinity is a gendered experience that affects feminist inquiries and masculinity studies can also support feminist liberation efforts. He emphasized what Freire said that people cannot free others or even themselves. Instead, people can liberate each other (Crotty, 1998, p.162). His point is that as a man, he supports the idea that feminism should free men and women alike. His main argument is that as a man, he can also support feminism, because patriarchy limits men by empowering them through traditional roles and norms, and that feminism may have different strands, but they are all connected by their aim of understanding gender experiences and fighting for gender equality (Crotty, 1998, p.162). Crotty described the different forms of feminisms to understand that feminism may have different methods, methodologies, epistemologies, and assumptions, but they are still connected by similar goals and data sources. The main goal of feminism is like critical theory. It aims to understand social phenomena from a feminine perspective, so that it can identify gender oppression and then challenge and end it. Women may be the main sources of feminist studies, but the views of men are also important in understanding how gender empowerment can be sustainably attained. Crotty agreed that feminist research entails re-visioning history as people generally know it. Feminism is a gender liberating movement and process, where in the end, men and women benefit from a new world system, where genders are viewed as and develop as equals. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from
(Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words.
“Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry


...A Critique of the Different Forms of Feminism What is Feminism? The definition of feminism as a concept is seen to be wrought by a number of different definitions which are all individually shaped by type of feminism that is being practiced by the individual. However, Zohrab (6) provides a definition of feminism that is seen to be widely acceptable as it essentially encompasses all the various different definitions of the term. According to Zohrab, feminism can be defined as being the application of the victims of oppression model to various different situations that are faced by women in the modern society today. In this respect a feminist can be defined by this model as being a person that believes that this model...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Appreciative Inquiry

...Isn’t It Time Someone Appreciated You? Isn’t time that someone sat you down, gave you a pat on the back, and told you what a good person you were? Isn’t it time that you sat down, and thought about what you were good at, instead of what you were bad at? Isn’t it time to think about the positives in yourself, instead of the negatives? That’s what the Appreciative Inquiry is all about. It’s all about having someone appreciate you and you appreciate yourself. The Appreciative Inquiry is about searching for the best in others. It’s about searching for the best in yourself. It’s about looking for the best in the businesses, the people, and the world around you. It’s about finding out what makes something...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Creative Briefs

...Rhetorical Analysis of Creative Briefs In the creative brief for Chock Full o’Nuts, the writer is seeking to communicate an ad idea for the product, which is coffee for home brewing, over its competitors in the coffee shop brands. It has been reported that there are more Americans brewing coffee at home ( 1), especially because it is believed to maintain high levels of freshness and better taste due to its origin from a single origin. This is in comparison to coffee shops that sell blended coffee. The last few years have seen an increasing rivalry between home brewed and specialty shop coffee, which the writer contends the ad should pick up on. The writer also wants the audience to...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper


...became successful only because of this unity principle. If there were no unity and trust in the Cohen’s family members, the company would have gone so far of where it is today. This is the gist and essence what can be learned and be taken from the Atherton case (Davis, 2006). Case 2 (Kohl Industries) Critical issues in the Case Kohl Industries was a successful family-owned business of James Kohl himself and three of his respective children. Kohl’s oldest son Brad was given the charge of Kohl manufacturing segment, second son Cameron was managing Kohl properties segment and the daughter Erin was the in charge of Kohl’s computer networking business Kohl Net. This was how Kohl industries was distributed in...
4 Pages(1000 words)Admission/Application Essay


... Freedom is represented in each text by certain symbols, which symbols can u find in each text In each of the texts, the women involved are looking for freedom. In the story of an hour, Louise finds freedom in the supposed death of her husband Mr. Millard. In Yellow wallpaper, the woman’s symbol of freedom is the yellow wall paper that she sees moving at night. Both women are yearning for freedom and see their husbands as obstacles to their happiness. Mrs. Millard is overwhelmed with joy when she gets the news of her husbands’ supposed death and goes to a room to celebrate how her freedom has come sooner that she thought (Chopin, The story of an hour). Mrs. John, on the other hand, is watched by everyone and spends most of her... Freedom is...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay


...September 11, Inquiry From the inquiry project, I was able to select a career to profile according to my personal and professional goals. I have selected the role of a health educator as a future profession. The inquiry project enhanced my awareness and knowledge of all the crucial elements that a health educator should possess; including basic responsibilities, training, educational background, tools used, personal skills and qualifications, working hours, and potentials for professional growth. The research that was undertaken provided the essential information to gain a more in-depth understanding of the role and responsibilities of a health educator. Concurrently, the results of...
1 Pages(250 words)Admission/Application Essay

Two Cases briefs

...Case Studies Case Studies e-harmony The company, e-Harmony was formed in the year, 2000.The main focus of the company is to bring single people together by making compatible matches. The company is facing issues as there are many other similar companies, which are copying the features of e-Harmony in order to broaden their scope (Piskorski, Halaburda, & Smith, 2008). In order to have an understanding on strategic position of the company and the industry, Porters five forces can be used. Porters Five Forces Rivalry among Competing Firms: High After examining the case, it can deduced that the level of competition is high as the industry growth rate is slow which makes the number of the competitors grow and as a result, they taking... Studies...
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study

Inquiry letter

...Address One Address Two ATTENTION: PARMA PDO HAM SECTOR As a in a technical writing at Indiana I am writing to request information on my term report topic: Ham production at the Parma PDO Ham Sector. Could you send me printed materials on the following questions? 1. What are the general characteristics of the Parma PDO Ham Sector in Italy? What is the company’s core product and how is it sourced? What are the regulations and provisions under its production? 2. What facilitates the large production of ham by the overall sector? Does the sector seek assistance from elsewhere so as to increase the quantity produced annually? What is the main source of capital for the firms? 3. What core difficulties does the Parma Sector experience... One...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Case Briefs

...Case briefs Case Luther R. CAMPBELL -Petitioners, v. ACUFF-ROSE MUSIC, INC. Facts: Sometimes in 1993, four singers whose stage names were Fresh Kid, Luke, Brother Marquis and Mr. Mixx sought permission from Accuff Music to use Roy Orbison’s tune. However, the group’s request was rejected but went ahead to use the tune; what followed was a court case in 1994 (Legal Information Institute, p.1). Procedural history: The case started at the district court where the plaintiff was granted the go-ahead with the case. After several months of court sessions, the district court gave the defendants a friendly judgment. Immediately, the plaintiff appealed the decision in the Court of Appeals and stated “commercial nature of the...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Case briefs

...UNITED S V. LEON 468 U.S. 897 (1984) & COMMONWEALTH V. SHEA 38 MASS APP. CT.7, 644 N.E.2D 244 (1995) Affiliation UNITED STATES V. LEON 468 U.S. 897 (1984) Statement of the Case Leon, the defendant, contended that the exclusionary rule to the fourth amendment had no exclusion of the good faith. The petitioner in this case appealed the decision made by the court of Appeals of the United States for the ninth circuit. Statement of the Facts The police officers of the United States had commenced an investigation into the sort of activities that Leon (hereinafter the defendant) had been involved in. a search warrant was subsequently issued on the same. The police were able to seize a huge amount of drugs after duly executing the search... S V. LEON ...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Three Briefs - Feminist Inquiry for FREE!

Contact Us