Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis The case of Emeh v. Kensington and Chelsea and Westminster Area Health Authority1 is submersed in a sea of decisions relating to the ability of parents to recover damages for the birth of their unwanted child…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis"

Download file to see previous pages case a blessing.3 The circumstances posed to the Court of Appeal in Emeh required that it find some form of reconciliation between the two different stances of Udale and of Thake, though it was distinct from these two cases because the child had been born with disabilities. As a result, the damages awarded were restricted to those extra costs incurred as a result of the unwanted child’s disabilities, though the court claimed that it had awarded full costs. The approach as contained in Damages for the Birth of a Child4 suggests that Emeh was a result of the equation of unwanted pregnancy with consequential economic loss, and the damages were thus calculated according to “reasonably foreseeable financial loss directly caused by the unexpected pregnancy”.5 This approach was arguably taken too far in the decision of Benarr & Another v. Kettering Health Authority6in which it was held that damages could extend to private education of the unwanted child. ...
the courts in relation to the decision of Emeh, and Ognall J in a subsequent similar case expressed his discomfort with a law that awards damages to the mother of a child, particularly if it is healthy; he said: “but there it is: that is the law”.8 Although the approach of the courts appears to be undecided on this matter, it is argued by some that awarding damages for both healthy and disabled unwanted children is perfectly acceptable according to principles of tort law,9 though decisions of the court have disagreed with this contention.10 There appears to be a major problem surrounding the distinction between unwanted healthy children and unwanted disabled children, and whether full or partial damages are to be awarded to both.11 It is suggested that the failure of the court in McFarlane to restrict its application to disabled children has caused an array of confusing exceptions to be created by subsequent cases on the topic.12 Yet what is the public policy behind the approach of the courts? It was claimed in Rees v Darlington Memorial Hospital NHS Trust13 that there are major public policy implications for making public bodies that are funded by the public to pay large sums of money to parents of healthy children.14 Such an approach has claimed that awarding damages for healthy unwanted children simply takes the law of tort “too far”.15 While this would seem to be a reasonably grounded policy which aims to establish the importance of causing healthy unwanted pregnancies and unhealthy unwanted pregnancies, highlighting the graver financial (and psychological) inconvenience of the latter, it has attracted much criticism.16 Such criticism is however warranted if one is to view the normal application of tort law which functions to award damages to healthy ...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Essay)
“The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis

United States Foreign Policy from 1945-1991

American Presidents presiding over some key events in history, such as the Cuban Missile Crisis, The Cold War, The Vietnam War, etc., were hindered from acting as public representatives due to pressure from the military-industrial complex. John Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson, Ronald Reagan, George Herbert Walker Bush, and George W. Bush – all of them were subject to these opposing interests. But eventually, the corporate-government nexus proved too powerful; and in this sense, American Presidents after the Second World War were largely restricted and powerless to uphold their higher personal values. Most of the strategic moves on part of the United States after the end of the Great War were directly in response to an anticipated th...
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

School Bullying: an Educational Problem

School bullying is a serious educational problem that is receiving increased attention. While anti-bullying programs are mandatory in Australian and American schools, they are not in Singapore (Forss, 2006). In Singapore, 95% of students in primary and secondary schools have experienced bullying (Forss, 2006).

A bully is someone who repeatedly attacks another individual who does not resist (Berger, 2006) and constantly harasses somebody else either physically or psychologically (Bosworth, Espelage, Simon, 1999). Bullying is manifested in many different ways such as physical, verbal and relational bullying (Berger, 2006). As a result of bullying, victims may experience anger, sadness, and depression which can lead to lo...
11 Pages (2750 words) Literature review

Company Strategy to the Public Sector

The definition of corporate strategies emphasizes the need for the organization to satisfy the needs of all the stakeholders if the organization is to achieve its overall objective of maximizing shareholder value. Stakeholders include employees, customers and the communities in which the organization operates. Employees, customers, and communities, therefore, have a significant impact on the success of the organization and thus on the corporate strategy of the organization. In formulating corporate strategy, organizations need to identify and priorities strategic issues, which involve scanning, selecting, interpreting and validating information. (Schneider, 1989).
The aim of this paper is to explain the strategy of an organiz...
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

The Evolution of Public Media

To instigate one to a category can now just as easily break out into a full-on discussion that may exhaust time and brain cells and yet still remain undefined.
In so much so that censorship and other restrictions, imposed by governments, critiques, audiences and other artists may condone a certain message of restraint that could bring about a new sense or in some cases lack thereof of artistic freedom. It is no longer a matter of identifying the genre and then moving along with the idea. Today’s global world will continue to embark and expand to involve all who are part of this world to be within the grasp of criticism or acclaim.
This categorizing and boxing up is now becoming obsolete as more and more works show...
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

The Problem of Surface Water Acidification

... identified internationally and has been proposed for inclusion in the World Health Organisation’s Pesticide Evaluation Scheme (WHOPES) programme of possible water pollutants. WHOPES lists a formidable list of approximately 200 toxic chemicals as potential or proven contaminants. Some of the preliminary fundamental lessons derived from surface water acidity control measures are for the need to form a committee that will work harmoniously to enact policy and legislation aimed at curbing the problem of aquatic water pollution and management. This can include the public health department, ecological, water resources, water distribution, husbandry, geological, manufacturing, and business-related authorities which will consequently elect...
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

Malnutrition: A Long Standing Problem among Children

Poverty majorly affects young children and it makes infants very prone to being malnourished. In Africa the situation is probably the worst when compared with any other continent, poverty has completely overshadowed the development of the people there and several young children die because of malnourishment. People who cannot afford even one square meal a day are the ones who are predominantly affected by malnourishment.

 Nutrition is pivotal for growth and progression of normal life and also a disease-free life. It is imperative for everybody and much more important in the case of children and infants because they are in their maximum growth stage. Malnutrition at this stage can have serious repercussions for the...
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Information Security Policy of Organization

In the modern age of information technology, there are many threats created for organizational information. Organizations need a security model that has the capability to handle and secure our information reserves. Technical administrative safety /security measures like security plans, actions and procedures are the general practices for the organizational information security procedures. The attentiveness of producing actions is concerned by the organizations to an appreciably smaller level, on the other hand at the same time these are weighed up as being further efficient organizational actions than technical administrative ones. Information security encompasses organizational features, officially authorized aspects, institution...
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

European Union Policy: Turkey

AD 47-57  St. Paul spreads Christianity and a community at Antioch is established, 638-718 Muslim Arabs besiege Constantinople,1453 The fall of Constantinople - the birth of Istanbul,1854 Crimean war,1914 Turkey allies with Germany in the first world war,1923 Foundation of the modern Republic of Turkey by Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, 1985-90 Full EU membership for Turkey impeded by Cypriot issue and questions over human rights record,1991-93 Suleyman Demirel elected Prime Minister, inflation at 70%,1993-96, Demirel President, Tansu Ciller Prime Minister, Turkey joins EU Customs Union.1997-98 5 attempts at forming coalition governments, Islamic Welfare party disbanded, reforms as Virtue and is the largest single party in parliame...

9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Increasing Public-sector Effectiveness by Changing Organisational Culture

Organizations have structures. Structures include degree or type such as horizontal differentiation, vertical differentiation, mechanism of coordination and control, formalization, and centralization of power. Classical theorists such as Taylor, Fayor, and Weber are of the belief that there is a single best way for organizations to be structured. However, organizations vary considerably on structural attributes. Modern theorists are of the belief that there is not one single best way to organize. An important aspect is a fit between the organization’s structure, size, technology and requirements of the environment. This is also known as the “contingency theory.” Size refers to the capacity, number of employees, o...
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Juvenile Delinquency and Education: A Comparison of Public and Private Education

... in order to counter the influence of gangs. The most prominent questions then seem to be whether private or public schools are more effective in reducing crime? A research into the US problem of juvenile delinquency has important findings and hypotheses. The most common cause of delinquency related to schooling is due to teacher-student conflicts. Labels which are placed onto children confining them usually result in bitterness and frustration, leading to inappropriate behaviour. Resultantly this can be solved if there is a choir available is schooling and institutions. More choices would also entail the availability of private schooling. And it becomes a given that interschool competition requires schools to keep discipline in check...
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Proposal
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis for FREE!

Contact Us