Free

Ethics in Criminal Justice - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Concern about ethics and efficiency are often held in contrasts to one another; an objection to acting in an ethical manner, for instance, is that doing so contradicts the necessity of acting in a way that achieves a stated objective in a more costly manner…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.8% of users find it useful
Ethics in Criminal Justice
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Ethics in Criminal Justice"

Concern about ethics and efficiency are often held in contrasts to one another; an objection to acting in an ethical manner, for instance, is that doing so contradicts the necessity of acting in a way that achieves a stated objective in a more costly manner. However, when an organization’s primary objective is to enforce a code of law, such as the criminal justice system, ethical outcomes are equivalent to efficient outcomes (Banks, 2008). In that sense, ethics in criminal justice is very important and should be the consideration of every person operating within that context. The reason for addressing this preliminary point is that, in the case study of Police Chief Dan Ainsworth and the Griffin Police Department, Ainsworth is more concerned about the path of least resistance: the path that is easiest to take, without a concern for the mission statement of his organization. Although this mission is not given in the case study, it is safe to assume that it has something to do with an ethical precept such as protecting or serving the community. There seem to be several competing possible explanations for Ainsworth’s behavior. There is nothing in the case study to support the conclusion that Chief Ainsworth is a characteristically unethical person; in fact, to the contrary, his lengthy time as a police officer demonstrates that he is committed to whatever ethical precepts guide the police force in Griffin. In this particular case, however, even though it would clearly protect his community to held, Ainsworth is unwilling to give in to Frawley’s requests. Ainsworth is older, approximately 61, and he is set in his ways. However, he is cautious to a rational degree, as is characteristic of elderly people (Greve, 1998). He relies on his own process for decision-making and has likely never encountered methamphetamine drug problems up close as chief of police. He is most likely acting on the perceived interests of the city, as he is used to doing in this role (Pollock, 2010). This is the likely case because Ainsworth does not want to scare the city or put his officers in danger based on limited information of a problem that is not pressing for the community. It seems that Ainsworth’s perspective on the manner, which is appropriate, is that the BCI has better resources (including more intelligence-gathering ability, more personnel, more training, and so on) to address drug problems, even outside major metropolitan areas. It is curious why the BCI would be interested in juvenile officers for a task force when these individuals lack the kinds of training requisite for highly skilled, ethical, and efficient responses to drug crime. Ainsworth is understandably cautious about lending his least-trained officers because he is skeptical about Frawley’s intent to use them in the field. Whether or not the BCI has a legal obligation to address crime that goes across state lines (their exact responsibilities are not given in the case study), it is still a matter of achieving the efficient outcome of not putting people in harm’s way unnecessarily (O’Connell, 2008). Enlarging the drug task force to include juvenile officers puts more people in danger by making the task force a larger target for particularly violent criminals with an interest in the success of the drug trafficking. Ethically, Ainsworth and Frawley are committed to similar sorts of ethical guidelines; however, one could argue that both figures are sacrificing too much: Ainsworth is sacrificing possible assistance to the task force to protect the lives of his officers, and Frawley is sacrificing possible deaths to inexperienced officers for protecting the community at large. It seems the most efficient outcome, and therefore most ethical one, would be for the BCI to obtain help from other organizations built around the fight against drugs and related crimes. This would simultaneously (1) protect the community of Griffin from further harm and (2) would not expose the task force to the risks of inappropriate actions by juvenile officers. This is certainly in Ainsworth’s best interests, but it also seems to be aligned with the interests of Frawley to the extent that it would improve the chances of success for the drug task force having highly experienced, highly trained officers from other agencies helping on the case. Chief Ainsworth is acting cautiously and, it seems, based on a principle not to put people in harm’s way unnecessarily. This applies both to his community and to his police officers, whom he feels will be unnecessarily put in harm’s way if he lends them over to the drug task force when there is a reasonable opportunity for the BCI to acquire help from other agencies. Because Ainsworth is acting upon an ethical principle that is more-or-less aligned with the mission of his organization—the GPD—he is not engaging in ethical relativism. Ethical relativism is the approach to setting standards of conduct that favors differences between societies and cultures (Banks, 2008). Ainsworth would argue that not putting people in harm’s way is an absolute principle that applies regardless of the circumstances one finds oneself in. It is unjust, for instance, to sacrifice one innocent life for ninety-nine innocent lives because that means people a person in harm’s way unnecessarily. Police officers tend to use their own code of ethics when police ethics are not clear (Felkenes, 1984). This is probably a personal belief that has been demonstrated effective over the length of his career in the police department (over 32 years). Some other major ethical considerations in the case include ethical pluralism, or the question of whether there are multiple right answers about what Ainsworth ought to do in this situation. There may also be the question of personal and professional commitments to others, such as in the debate over altruism (whether Ainsworth has a duty to others and to help by virtue of his professional position as police chief). Also, there is the question of the moral commitments of police departments in their communities, which may more-or-less be defined by their mission statements (Banks, 2008). Is there, for instance, a categorical or hypothetical imperative for the criminal justice system to act upon perceived threats to the community? And, if so, are there conflicting duties (for instance, Ainsworth’s duty to his officers and his duty to his community)? These questions offer answers in determining the extent to which the chief acted morally. References Banks, C. (2008). Criminal justice ethics: Theory and practice. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Felkenes, G. (1984). Attitudes of police officers toward their professional ethics. Journal of Criminal Justice, 12 , 211-220. Greve, W. (1998). Fear of crime among the elderly: Foresight, not fright. International Review of Victimology, 5 , 277-309. O’Connell, Paul E. (2008). The chess master's game: A model for incorporating local police agencies in the fight against global terrorism. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 31, 456-465. Pollock, J.M. (2010). Ethical dilemmas and decisions in criminal justice (6th ed.). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethics in Criminal Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Ethics in Criminal Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1431719-project
(Ethics in Criminal Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Ethics in Criminal Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1431719-project.
“Ethics in Criminal Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1431719-project.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethics in Criminal Justice

Ethics in Criminal Justice

...ETHICS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE R. PREETI 15/9/2007 Discretion, duty, honesty, and loyalty - which do you think is the most important and least important Explain your answer. Justice is the process of providing the appropriate treatment or verdict for a particular deed or crime, in the context of criminaljustice. It is not merely the concept of egalitarianism that comes into the picture, but is also inclusive of morality and ethics. Therefore, ethics in criminaljustice is a very imperative aspect in the provision of or exemption from punishment for crimes. In this scenario, according to me, being dutiful is the most important quality one needs to possess... , as a ...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ethics in criminal justice

...for the same type of crime is commonplace. There is hardly a legal system in which prosecutors do not select those which it will prosecute as opposed to those whom it will not. To further complicate matters, selective prosecution is compounded by the selective meting out of justice. This means that not only may one person not be prosecuted for a particular type of crime while another is, but sentencing of individuals for the same crime may also differ. Regardless of how widespread the identified practice is, it is ethically unjustifiable and undermines the very principle of justice which is at the core of law enforcement and the judiciary. There is hardly legal system which does not...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Ethics in criminal justice

...Zero tolerance refers to an official policy adopted by law enforcement agencies, and an unofficial one operative in many schools and organizations throughout the country, for the combating of particular offences. Targeting a diverse set of criminal behavior, from bullying to driving under the influence and, from selling drugs to engaging in sexual harassment, zero tolerance policies are predicated on the assumption that should law enforcement adopt a strictly objective attitude vis-à-vis crime, implying the refusal to consider extenuating and other circumstances, crime would decrease (McArdle and Erzen, 2001). Crime would decrease, as per the stated, consequent to the fact that the maximum penalties are allotted and,...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Adequacy of Criminal Law and Punishment

... Criminal Law Number: Project Number: 40646500 Criminal Law Criminal punishment may take various forms depending on the offence and jurisdiction in which a case is heard. Some punishments that have been applied to convicts include execution through different ways, imprisonment, fining, and being subjected to government supervision. Some of the punishments have in the past proved to be unacceptably cruel and unusual thus drawing the attention of legal experts and practitioners. The amendment of the US constitution expressly prohibits the application of unusual and cruel punishments. Some of the punishments under this category include crucifixion, burning and breaking on the wheel among other forms of punishment. The prohibition... Criminal...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

Ethics In Criminal Justice

...Ethics in Criminal Justice Introduction Ethics or moral philosophy concerns the questioning of the rightfulness or wrongness of a decision; it involves moral decision. In criminal justice, ethics has three main branches, meta-ethics, practical and normative ethics. Meta-ethics concerns the methods, logical, language, reasoning and structures used in interpretation of ethical terms. For instance, it could involve the meaning of terms and their application in criminal justice. Normative ethics concerns...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Ethics in Criminal Justice

...Summary of PEW report “One in 100 behind bars in America 2008.” The PEW Report on the prison population in the United s (2008) describes the slow rise in the proportion of citizens who are locked up in prisons, and compares the figures with those of other Western countries. The results show that Americans are significantly more likely than people in other countries to find themselves behind bars. More than one in a hundred people were in prison in 2008, which is high compared to other countries. The financial implications of this are very great, causing federal and state budgets to come under increasing pressure, at a time when resources are already tight because of other factors. More worrying than this is the social impact... of PEW report...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Ethics in Criminal Justice

...Type the document ABC Suicide by cop The moral possibility of ‘suicide by cop’ is a situation which may be argued as an ethical problem by utilitarian approach. According to the utilitarian approach to ethics, cops should think rationally before shooting individuals dead (Gandjour, 2007). The incidents of suicide by cops are a clear case of ethical failure where cops have murdered people instead of logically handling the problem. A police officer should in fact determine the logical possibilities of whether a person is committing a certain act or behavior in order to get killed. The officer should then try to reason with the individuals before pulling the trigger and should not just...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Ethics in Criminal Justice

... Section/# Ethics in Criminal Justice: A Brief Exploration of the Role of Key Figures within the Criminal Justice System Although the roles of the defense and prosecuting attorney are often idealized and misunderstood in terms of how our media represents these actors, they retain distinct ethical and moral obligations that are engendered in the jobs they perform. As such, this brief analysis will work to define the moral and ethical responsibilities that these positions necessarily engender. Likewise, the analysis will attempt to provide distinct examples of what moral and ethical responsibilities that each of these attorneys has. Lastly, these responsibilities will be analyzed and discussed from the perspective of the victim... of those...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ethics in Criminal Justice

...to discourage and disallow the potential for corruption. “The argument is that economic and political competition, transparency and accountability, coupled with the democratic principles of checks and balances, are necessary deterrence instruments.”(Amundsen ) The United States Department of Ethics has established the U.S. Standards of Conduct which are applied to all government employees. There are fourteen principles of ethical conduct and they cover everything from discrimination, to using public office for personal gain: from conflicts of interest to general ethical behaviors. ("U.s. government ethics," 2012) These rules have adapted over time and are intended to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ethics in Criminal Justice

...Ethics in Criminal Justice Affiliation with more information about affiliation, research grants, conflict of interest and how to contact Ethics in Criminal Justice It is not possible to take ethical decisions all the time. Ethics is a vast field of study in philosophy, which can be mainly expressed in terms of three common principles that then branch off into different sub-groups according to the basic theme. Ethical conduct in society basically comes down to three values that involve consideration of individual rights, rights of the masses, and the idea of distributive...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Ethics in Criminal Justice for FREE!

Contact Us