Nobody downloaded yet

Applying the Doctrines of Entrapment and Outrageous Government Conduct - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The jurisprudence surrounding entrapment and outrageous government conduct as valid defenses in a criminal prosecution remains to be much discussed, and the debates on whether and when these defenses may be employed remain to be the subject of much debate and controversy. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
Applying the Doctrines of Entrapment and Outrageous Government Conduct
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Applying the Doctrines of Entrapment and Outrageous Government Conduct"

Download file to see previous pages The need to balance the demands of law and order, on the one hand, and the rights of the accused to due process on the other, is the central dilemma that undergirds the debate. Fortunately, there are cases where the facts are of such clarity that it is not difficult to come up with a ruling that can be justified by both jurisprudence and the principles of the Constitution. It is respectfully submitted that this case is one of them. Based on the facts of the case, there is enough legal basis to rule in favor of the accused and grant his acquittal on the basis of the defense of “outrageous government conduct.” Outrageous government conduct The notion that behavior of state agents that “shocks the conscience” could constitute a violation of the right to due process of the accused and consequently, could secure the dismissal of the charges against him was first laid down in the case of Rochin v. California [342 us 165 (1952)]. In that particular case, the officers forcibly induced the accused to vomit capsules that they believed to be containing drugs. This decision served as the progenitor of the defense of “outrageous government conduct”, which essentially provides an extraordinary defense to the accused in a situation wherein the police had acted in an appalling, reprehensible manner that violated basic precepts of justice and decency. This was further refined in the case of United States v. Russell(1973):  "[W]e may someday be presented with a situation in which the conduct of law enforcement agents is so outrageous that due process principles would absolutely bar the government from invoking judicial processes to obtain a conviction (citing Rochin v. California, 342 U.S. 165. It must be underscored that only extremely exceptional cases should be considered here. A mere failure to disclose one’s role as an undercover informer does not come under the definition of outrageous conduct, as in the case of Hoffa v. United States [385 US 293 (1966)], nor does using an assumed name and identity in conducting at telephone transaction, as in the case of Lewis v. United States [385 US 206 (1966)]. In this case, while there is no showing that physical violence was employed against the accused, the behavior of the police officer Friday was equally egregious. He had practically forced the accused to commit the crime that he wanted him to commit, in a desperate attempt to have some output for his superiors who were expecting him to bust a drug ring. It must be noted that the criminal charges were for the possession of eight ounces of cocaine and conspiracy to distribute the same. The eight ounces of cocaine only came about because he forced the accused to get the other 4 ounces on credit, when the accused only wanted 4 ounces. But even more reprehensible is the use of Jane, who Friday knew to be someone that Bob had an eye for. The only reason that Bob was persuaded to proceed with the transaction was because Friday deployed Jane to tell him that she would go home with him if he had the cocaine. It is even more reprehensible that Friday had engaged in sexual relations with this woman whilst undercover in his job, and using her to achieve his ends. This kind of behavior is truly galling and deserves reproach. Entrapment In truth, it may even be argued that the defense of entrapment is available to Bob. The Supreme Court makes a distinction between the defense of entrapment and the defense of outrageous government conduct, a distinction which was laid down in the case of Hampton v. United States [425 US 484 (1976]. The defense of entrapment employs a subjective standard, it means that for the defense to be available to the accused, he has to ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Applying the Doctrines of Entrapment and Outrageous Government Conduct Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1431488-appeal
(Applying the Doctrines of Entrapment and Outrageous Government Conduct Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1431488-appeal.
“Applying the Doctrines of Entrapment and Outrageous Government Conduct Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1431488-appeal.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Applying the Doctrines of Entrapment and Outrageous Government Conduct

Doctrines in the US

...that should be applied by subsequent US presidents. The reasons given below show why a unified doctrine is the best way forward for America: History exists to teach and those who do not take the lessons of history to heart are always bound to repeat the same mistakes over and over again. In the 19th century, America did not bother with the occurrences outside of their borders (Carp 259). During the Spanish-American war and indeed during the Roosevelt Corollary, the stance was largely maintained except it had a twist. Instead of America just minding its own business, it was going to act as a broker of regional power. Many historians considered the intention of America as a power broker as just an act of...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Cold War Doctrines

.... It is necessary to note that Turman authorized the Hiroshima and Nagasaki atomic bombs which killed thousands of people in Japan. He used nuclear weapons against Japan as the Japanese government refused the terms of Potsdam Declaration (Bostdorff 160). This made the Japanese surrender on the 14th of August; 1945. The atomic bomb scene was revisited in the cold war and was recognized to have rendered convectional forces largely irrelevant to the modern battlefield. Corruption was a key issue in Turman’s government which runs through individual members of the cabinet and the senior white house staff. He relied distinctly on his cabinet and popularized such phrases as ‘The buck stops here’. Turman initiated the Berlin Airlift... . This was a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Police Entrapment

...encouragement plays upon the weakness of the innocent persons and beguiles them into committing crimes they normally would not attempt, it can be deemed improper because it is entrapment and the evidence is barred under the exclusionary rule”. It has been also said that entrapment is a confirmatory defense and can be easily raised at trial. It is based on certain belief where people should not be persuaded of a defense that is completely initiated by the government. It on the whole arises when the government representatives implant the seed with an intention of crime. This view on the contrary hold another prospective where it has been explained that by simply giving a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Conduct Disorder

...the window with his friend, and second when he crashed his bike into a store window because he didn't apply the pedal brakes. Third is lying or theft, applicable also to the case of Jeremy because according to his mother, Jeremy tells minor lies to her. The last behavior expected to manifest in someone with a conduct disorder is serious rule violation like riding his bike on the street even though his mother had strictly imposed this rule to him many times over. Jeremy's action resulted in his receiving a warning from the police. This happened a week before Jeremy's mother decided to bring him for evaluation at a mental health clinic. Evidently, Jeremy's case is one of a Conduct...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Doctrines of God and Angels

...Week 7 Reading Summary This essay is the final in a series of reading summaries for partial requirements for Theology I: Doctrines of God and Angels. This summary will expansively present the doctrine of demons and Satan. Biblical truth regarding creation and activity of these spirits will also be thrown light upon in this paper. In is integral to know that demons really exist, the New Testament Scripture throws light upon the demons over one-hundred times except in the book of Hebrews. (Ryrie p. 180). Another misconception regarding demons is that some believe that demons are spirits of deceased people, this is untrue, and nowhere in the Bible does it speak of such a belief. (Ryrie p. 180). Although...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Applying Theory

...Running head: APPLYING THEORY Applying Theory of Total Number of Words 824 Introduction The health promotion model(HPM) has been designed to promote the importance of health protection. In the process of promoting the essence of protecting the health of each individual, health care professionals are more capable of increasing the patients’ level of wellbeing. In general, HPM is considered as a multi-dimensional model since it focuses not only on the patients’ individual characteristics and/or experiences but also on the behaviour-specific cognitions and affect and behavioural outcomes. (Current Nursing, 2009) To enable the readers to have a better understanding of the subject matter, the paper will be divided into two major parts... the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

HUMAN RESOURCES MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES TOWARDS APPLYING ELECTRONIC- GOVERNMENT

...sources. Procedure In order to investigate the human resources management strategies towards applying electronic-government with the field of study being the Principality of Makkah Region a sample of 100 subjects, including both males and females, ranging from the ages 23 to 60 years, will be drawn from the Principality of Makkah Region. All the subjects will be employees from the Principality of Makkah Region. Stratified random sampling will be used. First of all written permission would be taken from the organizations where the survey will be conducted. They will be briefed about the research, its significance, time involved and the procedure. Furthermore, the sample population will be...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Entrapment by Government Agents

...Entrapment by Government Agencies Entrapment by Government Agencies Do you think that in this case, "the Government overstepped the line between setting a trap for the unwary innocent and the unwary criminal? Why or why not? Yes, one thinks that “the Government has overstepped the line between setting a trap for the ‘unwary innocent’ and the ‘unwary criminal”. As can be seen in the case the government for two and a half years has been setting up the trap for Jacobson. Jacobson may not even have pursued the idea of joining those fake organizations if they have not sounded so encouraging in their letters. In the first...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Conduct Business

...Conduct Business of Workplace Lateness One of the issues that arise in organizations and strain the relationshipbetween employees and employers is employee lateness. It is thus imperative that employers design and implement polices that keep standardized reporting and working hours so that it is clear to employees that lateness is a disciplinary issues with certain repercussions. One of the policies should be that all employees intending to be late must not only inform their seniors but also seek permission to that effect. Further, should one be late due to unavoidable or unforeseen circumstances, the relevant managers or supervisors should be notified on arrival (Mooney, 2012). One disciplinary action for lateness is...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Interpersonal conduct

...Activity Completion #2 Rude/rudeness and impolite/impoliteness are attributes of interpersonal conduct based on the concept of face whereby face isin reference to a person’s or community’s sense of prestige or dignity in the social context (Masumoto et al, 2000). The phrase “to save face” is used in the English-speaking world to denote the extent to which individuals and communities may go for the sake of preserving their established position as perceived by the society (Masumoto et al, 2000). It usually entails efforts to ensure that an individual or community is not viewed in bad light by their peers. According to Ogiermann (2009), interpersonal interaction cannot sustain itself when the interacting parties lack...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Applying the Doctrines of Entrapment and Outrageous Government Conduct for FREE!

Contact Us