Nobody downloaded yet

Law for Business - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
LAW FOR BUSINESS Author Institute The issue in this question requires an analysis in respect of the law on negligent in particular a duty of care being owed in respect of negligent misstatements and the breach of such duties. In respect of negligent misstatement the important case that can be cited is Caparo v…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Law for Business Case Study
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Law for Business"

Download file to see previous pages Finally in respect of creditors of the company the court held the no duty was owed to them. The approach had been criticized by many and had been thought to be unjustified as it was thought that reliance would be placed on the accounts of the company which is indeed due to the auditors’ manuals and other material. However, in favour of the decision a few other points for such a decision are the floodgates argument; the lack of proximity between an auditor and an investor also leads to the conclusion that no claim lies against the auditors; and the placing of undue burden on the auditors and therefore duty is only limited to the company.. (Deakin et al 2008) Another important aspect that was considered in the decision of Caparo for accountants liability as well the standard duty of care requirement was the fact that the three tier test was required to be satisfied so as establish a duty of care. This test was a reformed test for negligence.The first requirement for the establishment of duty of care was that it must be reasonably foreseeable that the conduct of defendant would cause damage to the claimant. Secondly, there must be sufficient proximity between the parties and finally ‘the situation must be one in which the court considers it fair, just and reasonable the law should impose a duty of care of a given scope on the one party for the benefir of the other’. (Elliott et al 2007) Another important aspect that had been considered by the House of Lords have held in La Banque Financiere de la Cite v Westgate Insurance Co Ltd was that if there had been an omission to speak it would not lead to construing of liability. A further important authority in respect of negligent misstatement is that of Hedley Byrne v. Heller2 wherein it was construed by the courts that there was no negligent misstatement on the basis that the facts portrayed that there had been disclaimer within the remarks that is the use of the term without responsibility which led to the possibility of a duty of care to be extinguished. There had been a controversial decision of Royal Bank of Scotland plc v Bannerman Johnstone Maclay, wherein the absence of the disclaimer of liability was considered to be pivotal so as to establish a duty of care and holding the auditors liable. The facts of the case were that BJM were auditors of APC Ltd and RBS was the principal lender of APC Ltd and due to such lending RBS had an equity interest in APC. One of the requirement of RBS in their facility letters was the provision of audited financial statements by APC to RBS within six months of the end of financial year. Such copies were provided to RBS so as to assist them for lending decision. Subsequently RBS bought an action against BJM for the losses that were suffered by RBS as a result of reliance on such audit accounts which had inaccuracies. There was an application made by BJM to strike out the claim as there was no duty of care owed to RBS. It was decided by the court as a preliminary issues that what had been pleaded by RBS was sufficient to lead to a duty of care. Thus it was found that even though there was no direct contact between the parties BJM could have disclaimed liability when it came to know that RBS would be seeing the audited accounts for lending decisions. Thus the important reason was the absence of th ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Law for Business Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Law for Business Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
“Law for Business Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Law for Business Case Study

Business law

...? Business Law Case Study First Business Law Case Study The business case study involving Jamie Clark and Joe Adamson is mainly a partnership, but due to some issues arising between the two partners Jamie has decided to take legal claims against Joe in the court of law. In order to pass judgment in this case, the partnership agreement would be examined and discussed according to the court of law case. Issues like business law, business partnership, intellectual property, and limited liability will be investigated to further our understanding of the case. According to the...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Business law

...?Business Law Table of Contents Question 4 (a)Provide a short account of the commercial background of the case, and key aspects/clauses of the standardized contract in dispute between the parties. 4 (b)Regarding the pivotal clause 7.4, what case law principles governed its ‘proper construction’, in the view of the judges (Jacobson, Lander & Foster JJ) on appeal? 5 (c)What was the nature of the term which the primary judge, Jagot J. had implied into the contract, and on what grounds and case law did the judges on appeal decide that such implied term (of fact) wasn’t required to give ‘business efficacy’ to the contract? 6 (d)Was the appeal decision ‘fair...
14 Pages(3500 words)Case Study

Business law

...?Research Paper On The applicability of common law and equity to contract and tort of Negligence Business Law Case study: Steggles Limited v Yarrabee Chicken Company Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 91 Date: April 2013 Professor: Question 1 Short account of the case (a) This case involved a standard “Broiler Chicken Growing Contract” executed between the said parties. The respondents (growers) role was to rear chicken based in “Hunter Valley Region.” These chicks were supplied to them by the appellants (Steggles) whose processing plant was at Beresfield. When chicks had grown, they were picked and paid for by appellants. The respondents was one of the growers who filed a representative suit claiming...
14 Pages(3500 words)Case Study

Business Law

...U.S.C., sec. 2). On the other hand, the Clayton Antitrust Act, another antitrust law of the United States of America, prohibits "exclusive dealings", "mergers or acquisition" if these acts substantially lessen competition (15 U.S.C., secs. 14 and 18). The US antitrust law refers to the body of laws that make illegal or unlawful certain business practices deemed to hurt businesses or consumers, or both, or violate business ethics. These include anti-competitive behaviors such as monopoly, restraint of trade and commerce, and unfair business practices like exclusive dealings, mergers, and acquisition and other practices...
5 Pages(1250 words)Case Study

Law for Business

...or an independent contractor the facts as well as the law have to be considered. However if there are written documents on whose construction it can be established then it is purely a question of law. (Davies v. Presbyterian Church of Wales)45 The distinguishing factor has been said to be contract of service or of employment which clearly point out to an employer-employee relationship allowing vicarious liability for torts of others, however if there is a contract for services then no employer-employee relationship will be found and thus no vicarious liability.6 The traditional aspect for determination of employee from independent contractor was the control test which took into account the degree and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Business Law - land law

...from another person's Last Will and Testament. Yet another common example is where two or more persons have received separate deeds to the same parcel of real estate." Black's Law (2006). With all things considered, Bill Bob would need to clarify questions that would assist legal counsel in determining whether or not he has a solid case. The questions he needs to answer are as follows: First, is he related to any of the previous owner's, if so, what is his relation to them Hill Bob could have rights to the land through a death decree due to his relation to the previous owners. "Unknown to the owner, a third person - a "squatter" - may be in illegal and unauthorized occupation of a far corner of the land parcel. If...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Business Law

...Business Law Case Study This case study demonstrates the confusion that sometimes arises between the federal laws and the state laws as business owners worry about which law has the constitutional authority to regulate their business activities (Clarkson et al., 2008). (I) In the United States, the federal government is supported by the Constitution to enact any laws that would serve the purpose of protecting the interests of US citizens; in a similar vein, state governments, which act as independent plenary bodies, can also make laws as stipulated in the diverse state constitutions (Clarkson et al., 2008). (II) The federal statute to protect endangered bird species could be challenged in US District Court located in Minnesota... 97.299,...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Business law

...against Buchanan County & Davis. Rule: In the case, Buchanan County & Davis (Appellees) violated laws that disallow negligent hiring and retention under Iowa State Laws (Center 541). Argument: Under the laws on negligent hiring and retention applicable in Iowa State, Buchanan County & Davis, were liable for wrongful conduct by facilitating Bazt’s tortious actions through failure to act on several recommendations and complaints. Conclusion: The case involved claims of negligent supervision and retention against Buchanan County & Davis. PC 8, SS, Grandchamp (1947). Facts: Ammonium Nitrate is a strong oxidizing agent that can facilitate massive...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Business Law

...Program: 24 October Business law Case Brief Case and Citation Englert v. Nutritional Sciences Court of Appeal of Ohio, 2008 Ohio-5062 Facts The case is an appeal from the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas. Englert was the plaintiff in the original case and appellant in the appeal case while Nutritional Science, with Zeune, are the appellees, previously defendants. Nutritional Sciences produced and dealt in nutritional supplement and ran a promotion in which Englert entered. A panel selected winners in different categories, over a period and one of the promotion’s regulations was that winners had to agree specific regulations before claiming their prices. A provision, put under asterisk, stated that...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Transcultural Education in Dental Schools

17 Pages(4250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Law for Business Case Study for FREE!

Contact Us