Nobody downloaded yet

The United Kingdom Supreme Court: A Physical Transparency of Independence - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The Supreme Court is the highest court in the whole United Kingdom. It is the final arbiters of all types of cases and is the final court of appeal for England, Wales and Northern Ireland. It is also the final arbiter for civil cases in Scotland…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.2% of users find it useful
The United Kingdom Supreme Court: A Physical Transparency of Independence
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The United Kingdom Supreme Court: A Physical Transparency of Independence"

Download file to see previous pages The Supreme Court is the highest court in the whole United Kingdom. It is the final arbiters of all types of cases and is the final court of appeal for England, Wales and Northern Ireland. It is also the final arbiter for civil cases in Scotland. Through Constitutional Reform Act 2005 (CRA 2005) the role of Lord Chancellor was modified to give more strength and independence to the Judiciary. The separation of the senior judges from the House of Lords was made to introduce a clear-cut separation of the judiciary from the parliament. The purpose was to maintain impartiality, as the Law Lords were somehow, less understood by the public to be a separate entity from the House of Lords. The attempt to create a separate judiciary is to give more credibility to the judgments and decisions made without political influence. But the separation of judicial functions of the House of Lords with a new Court is rather a change in form than in substance, as the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom lacks the power of judicial review to annul acts of the legislature that are incompatible with the Constitution. The Controversy The issue of judicial independence was discussed in the case of McGonnel v. United Kingdom.1 The case in summary involves a judge of the island of Guernsey who took part over a decision on appeal in the Royal Court over a case that involved an issue that he has previously dealt upon in his prior legislative capacity as Deputy Bailiff. The European Court of Human Rights held that this was a violation of article 6 (1) that requires having his rights determined by an impartial and independent court. The Court held that “with particular respect to his presiding, as Deputy Bailiff, over the States of Deliberation in 1990, the Court considers that any direct involvement in the passage of legislation, or of executive rules, is likely to be sufficient to cast doubt on the judicial impartiality of a person subsequently called on to determine a dispute over whether reasons exist to permit a variation from the wording of the legislation or rules at issue.2" The European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (ECHR) incorporates the freedom and rights of every individual citizen through the passing of the Human Rights Act of 1998 (HRA 1998) in the United Kingdom. The ECHR provides a requirement for an “independent and impartial tribunal established by law” that will secure the rights and freedom of each individual “without discrimination on any ground such as sex, race, colour, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, association with a national minority, property, birth or other status”.3 Due to the brewing conflict of the lack of physical independence of the judiciary from the House of Lords, the CRA 2005 was created to replace the appellate committee of the House of Lords with a new Supreme Court. It is to provide a sufficient transparency of the independence of the judiciary from the executive and legislative branch and avoid future controversies involving the ECHR on questioning decisions by the Law Lords on the basis of the lack of impartiality and independence to give a fair trial. The Concept of Separation of Power The concept of judicial independence although not historically linked to Montesquieu doctrine of separation of power is intimately connected. The doctrine introduces the separation from each other of the three branches of government: the executive, legislative and judiciary to avoid abuse of power. “There is no liberty, if the judiciary power be not separated from the legislative and executive..”4 It provides for a system of checks and balances in which the three branches can prevent the abuse of power of one and the other. The Supreme Court is the checking authority to make sure that the executive and the legislative ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The United Kingdom Supreme Court: A Physical Transparency of Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The United Kingdom Supreme Court: A Physical Transparency of Essay)
“The United Kingdom Supreme Court: A Physical Transparency of Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The United Kingdom Supreme Court: A Physical Transparency of Independence

Legal System: The New Supreme Court of the United Kingdom

...?The creation of a Supreme Court was an unnecessary and overly-expensive reform. The Appellate Committee of the House of Lords was independent, effective and was regarded as one of the finest courts in the world.’  Discuss. The New Supreme Court of the United Kingdom: Unnecessary and Costly Reform or Idea Whose Time Has Come? In 2009, a new innovation was introduced into the legal system of the United Kingdom. The Supreme Court was created, effectively replacing the House of Lords as the last court of appeal in the UK. It...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

United States Supreme Court

...The United s' Supreme Court acts as a check for the legislative and executive branches of government as acts as the country's highest platform for not only judicial but also political resolution. Thus, it is natural that an appointment to become a Supreme Court justice is of public interest, if not concern. The interest in the nomination of Sonia Sotomayor to the Supreme Court by President Barrack Obama garnered more than its share of scrutiny. However, there are some opinion that the hesitation stems from Sotomayor's gender and race being a Latina. The attention was not just due to her skills and experience to take up...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

United States Supreme Court

...($39,000) is less than the debt’s amount. The question presented is whether a debtor can “strip down” the lien of the creditor on the real property pledged as collateral for the debt to the value of the collateral; more specifically, the United States Supreme Court was asked to determine the applicability of section 506(d) to this particular set of circumstances. For the reasons discussed below, the Court held that section 506(d) did not allow the debtor to “strip down” the lien. As an initial matter, the Court admits that section 506(d) is ambiguous, that both parties have made valid points, but that sound policy and harmonization of the modern Code...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

Supreme Court

...The Apocalypse of Adolescence By Yuliya Having read through the article en d "The Apocalypse of Adolescence", several conclusions came to mind. First, juveniles should almost never be given the death penalty, as this provides virtually zero learning in relation to moral guidance and the receipt of understanding as to what is right versus what is wrong. The death penalty takes their young lives and forever changes them, without the opportunity to be rehabilitated by competent sociological or psychological professionals. However, when the case is similar to the one in the article, the juvenile death penalty may be imposed, especially when the children show no regret for their actions. The problem, however, appears to lie in whether...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

United States Supreme Court Case

...Case American Elec. Power CO. v. CONNECTICUT, No. 10-174 . The Supreme Court ruling and its effects on the future of greenhouse gas emissions aimed at protecting the environment. Citation: Supreme Court of the United States, cited on the 21st November, 2011 from: The facts The state of Connecticut has sought to curb the carbon gases emission citing that it was a nuisance to the public thus having drastic effects on business and employment in the electric power companies. The effects are drastic as a result of the increased global warming that has led to environmental destruction. The resolving of the...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

Supreme Court

...Supreme Court Opinions The principle responsibility of the U.S. Supreme Court is to interpret the Constitution. It has thefinal say in settling legal arguments and determining the meaning of laws thereby setting national policy. The Justices write majority and minority opinions following a decision. These fall into four categories, unanimous, divided, very divided and per curium. Unanimous decisions are written when all nine members of the court vote the same way. The Chief Justice (John Roberts) assigns any Justice the task of writing it or may choose himself. Sometimes, if the case has many nuances involved, he may have opinions from two Justices. In...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Supreme Court

...Supreme Court Data of Supreme Court In the United s, the court is considered to be the highest tribunal in the land that is expected to exercise justice to all the citizens. It acts on, and provides fair arbitration to all the controversies and cases that arise under the constitution or the law. It being the final arbiter, the Supreme Court is entrusted with the ability to provide equal justice through the use and interpretation of the law, hence, it also functions and a guardian in interpretation of the constitution (Charles, 2012). It is because of these very important functions that the Supreme Court is expected to carry out constitutional review in order to equalize the constitution with the major changes that have taken place... from...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Supreme Court

...Supreme Court Supervisor June 27, Supreme Court The argument for an originalist perspective to interpretation of the constitution is rational because of the advantages that the theory offers to the contemporary and dynamic environment. The fact that no written constitution, or any other law, can anticipate and provide for all possibilities is one of the justifications for a non-originalist perspective. Laws, such as the constitutional amendments, were developed to remedy immediate and anticipated problems and transition through the amendments’ existence have realized developments, some of which are beyond expectations of the developers of the amendments. Relying on the letter of the amendments would therefore be retrogressive... and be a...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Supreme Court

...Supreme Court case of Korematsu v. U.S Complaint The complaint in this case was that Korematsuwho was an American of Japanese descent was wrongfully evicted from his location to an internment camp. He complained that this violated his constitutional rights and hence refused to move as the order requested. This led to his arrest and conviction based on disloyalty and disobedience to the country and its laws. Brief summary of the facts At the peak of World War II, President Roosevelt signed a presidential executive order 9066 which demanded that all American-Japanese people be evacuated and taken into internment camps where they would be closely monitored. The aim of this order which was named the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Supreme Court

... DD Month YYYY ESSAY POLITICAL SCIENCE Introduction The American government is divided into various armswhich perform different functions. The arms include the judiciary, legislature and the executive. Every branch of the government has distinctive functions which they perform independent of the other branches. To achieve this each has their specific roles which they perform as led by their leaders. All branches are guided by the American constitution which details out the rule and regulations governing the Americans. This paper explores the functions of the supreme court, its roles as well as Federalism and its effects to America (R. Dye, Zeigler and Schubert). SUPREME COURT The supreme court carries out various functions... which...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The United Kingdom Supreme Court: A Physical Transparency of Independence for FREE!

Contact Us