StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Golden Rule, The Mischief Rule and The Literal Rule of Statutory Interpretation - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This research begins with the statement that Golden Rule or British Rule of statutory interpretation gives authority to the judge to dismiss the literal meaning of a word in order to prevent passing an illogical ruling. A golden rule is a compromise between the literal and the mischief rule…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
Golden Rule, The Mischief Rule and The Literal Rule of Statutory Interpretation
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Golden Rule, The Mischief Rule and The Literal Rule of Statutory Interpretation"

Download file to see previous pages An example where Golden Rule was applied was the Sigsworth, Re, Bedford vs Bedford. In this case, a son has murdered his mother who was yet to make a will. Under the Section 46 of the Administration of Estates Act 1925, there should be inheritor and in this case, the son was the sole issue, therefore, he should have inherited the mother’s property. However, the judge ruled under the golden rule and the son did not receive the inheritance. This is because it would have been illogical to give the inheritance to the son as he murdered his mother and would have been benefited by committing a crime. Mischief Rule Mischief Rule of statutory interpretation gives authority to the judge to contain the mischief in the crime and apply it in instances where there occurs an ambiguity in the law. Thus this rule aims to understand the mischief and also to lay down a solution which would correct the situation if implemented. A popular case that came under the Mischief rule was Smith vs. Hughes. In this case, prostitutes were charged for recruiting clients from a public place while within the confines of a private area, which were the windows that overlooked the street. Under the Street Offences Act of 1959, it is illegal to attract clients with the intention of offering sex services on streets. The defendants pleaded that they had not attracted clients on the streets but were within their own homes. However, the judge found them guilty since the prostitutes had mischief on their mind and were, in fact, taking clients from the streets. Literal Rule Literal Rule as the name suggests allows the judge to give out a ruling by taking into account the literal meaning of the word since they do not affect the ruling of the case. The judge, in this case, does not have to consider the meaning or the implications behind words or sentences such as in the case of the previous laws. This is usually the most preferred rule of statutory interpretation. An example of this is the R Vs Harris case under which the defendant harmed the victim by biting his nose. Since the law considers stabbing, cutting or wounding a person through an instrument as a crime, therefore the defendant was acquitted since he did not commit the crime in the literal sense. Application In normal circumstances, the literal rule is first applied before considering any other approach. When a different approach is taken, a significant reason should be presented as to why the Golden or the Mischief rule had been applied. ‘After 45 years in litigation, I have seen so much money spent, stress caused and delay encountered. Reaching settlement at the door of the court is entirely unsatisfactory’. Sir Henry Brooke in ‘Mediation; Lawyers still need convincing’, Law Gazette (18th September 2008).  Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) ADR is an acronym for Alternative Dispute Resolution. Under ADR, the dispute is resolved by allowing the conflicting parties to come to an agreement without having to go through the process of filing a case against the defendant. In this system, the dispute is resolved with or without the presence of a third party. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Golden Rule, The Mischief Rule and The Literal Rule of Statutory Essay”, n.d.)
Golden Rule, The Mischief Rule and The Literal Rule of Statutory Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1402772-introduction-to-business-law
(Golden Rule, The Mischief Rule and The Literal Rule of Statutory Essay)
Golden Rule, The Mischief Rule and The Literal Rule of Statutory Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1402772-introduction-to-business-law.
“Golden Rule, The Mischief Rule and The Literal Rule of Statutory Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1402772-introduction-to-business-law.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Golden Rule, The Mischief Rule and The Literal Rule of Statutory Interpretation

Statutory Interpretation

... of statutes as such, occurs on the basis of rules and principles developed by judges, although the Interpretation Act of 1978 does provide some definitions of provisions to facilitate the function. The Three statutory rules: The three statutory rules employed by judges in interpreting statutes are (a) the mischief rule (b) the literal rule and (c) the golden rule6. The Mischief rule derives from a time when common law prevailed with Parliamentary Supremacy in place, where statutes were not significant. Four factors were laid out for consideration in applying the statutes: (a) what was the common law in existence (b) what was the defect that presented itself which was not addressed in the common law? (c) what was the remedy devised...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

The Role Played by Cultural Difference in International Politics

The discourse of multiculturalism is inconsistent. To its advantages belongs preservation of cultural pluralism, recognition, and protection of the diverse minority, refusal from xenophobia, chauvinism, and racial prejudices. Lacks are shown in ethnisation of social relations, the institutionalization of cultural distinctions, ignoring the liberal principle of priority of the rights of an individual.

The culture of any nation, defining its spiritual uniqueness, expressing its creative power and abilities, simultaneously is a property of all mankind. “According to official multiculturalism, no individual is forced to retain his or her culture, but all cultures are granted a universal right to celebrate and even to...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

An Overcorrection of Mary Magdalenes Biblical Role

A purely theological approach to DVC would be impossible since the claims the book makes takes issue with what has been supposedly left out of the bible. This essay will in no way attempt to question whether any non-canonical gospels should be considered; that sort of investigation should be left to historians.

As Brandon Gilvin states in Solving the Da Vinci Code Mystery, “It’s difficult to start a discussion on the creation of the bible from the Bible itself” (7). As the word of God is being questioned, it does us no good to turn to the Gnostic Gospels, the main sources of the claims of Mary Magdalene’s and Jesus’ marriage. In these texts, Mary Magdalene is the most mentioned person after...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Ethics of the Rich and Poor Nations That Has to Rule the Market Place

According to Peter Singer, the rich and the poor nations are treated as equal in the world.  There are many instances in which the poor nations have not been given the same voice in the world as regards the matter of trade and other development issues. While the rich nations continue to explore all the available opportunities in order to be rich, the poor nations have remained segregated to the extreme poverty. The global distribution chain has not helped the poor nations to be given an equal access to resources.

Singer showed the there are exploitation factors that have been used by the rich nations in order to control all the levels of world resources. The injustice system has worked against the poor nations whic...

10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Dietrich Bonhoeffer's Interpretation of Scripture

... study of Barth and the emergence of his unique interpretation of the scriptures. According to him, “we shall see not only God but God’s community too. We shall no longer merely believe in its love and faith, but see it. We shall know the will of God continually ruling over us and put it into practice in the kingdom of the community.”6 From his early work, one can see that Dietrich had begun to articulate an understanding of the role of the church in society. This development in his principles would be strengthened by his exposure to American ideas of social justice when he spent time in the Union Seminary in 1930. It became fundamental in his defense of the Jews and criticism against the Nazis. Discipleship In his argument for social...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Contentious Issue of Interpretation of Trust

...Trust law Introduction: This paper seeks to consider the contentious issue of interpretation of Trust, Tort and criminal regulations laying emphasis on decided case laws, in order to help comprehend why, in certain cases, the illegality doctrine are enforced, whereas not carried out in other case settings. It is first necessary to consider the Tinsley v. Milligan case. Tinsley v.Milligan case [1994] 1 AC 340 House of Lords. [1994] 1 AC 340, [1993] 3 All ER 65, [1993] 3 WLR 126, [1994] 2 FCR 65, [1993] 2 FLR 963 The facts of this case was that two women, Stella Tinsley and Kathleen Milligan were lovers. Both of them jointly purchased a house, but its legal title vested upon Stella Tinsley alone (in order to perpetrate Department...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

Concept of the Rooney Rule

...The Rooney Rule: A Necessity? Or, an Imposition? Ever since the very concept of the Rooney Rule was heard about and since there was the minimum possibility of the Rooney Rule being introduced, there have been innumerable arguments and counterarguments both for and against it. However, with all the opinions against it, the Rooney Rule came to be established in the year of 2003 since the arguments that reinforced the necessity of the Rooney Rule were no less strong. Now that more than half a decade has passed after this rule came to be established, there no inadequacy of the arguments. It may be that the arguments have changed. There have been new points to substantiate the arguments. The arguments for and against the necessity...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

Invitation to Treat, Offer, Acceptance, Revocation of Offer and the Postal Rule

...LAW OF CONTRACT The issue in this question relates to invitation to treat, offer, acceptance, revocation of offer and the postal rule. Each of these will be discussed in turn and a conclusion on the facts will be drawn. An offer is defined as an expression of willingness to contract or be bound on certain terms which have been made with the intention that there will be a binding agreement once the offer is accepted. In case of advertisements, the courts found that an advertisement constituted an offer on the basis that the defendant had deposited a £1000 with a bank ‘to shown their sincerity’ and thus when someone agreed to perform what had been offered an effective agreement had been formed (Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co.1). However...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

Interpretation of Financial Statements: Next Plc and Ted Baker Plc

...Interpretation of Financial ments Table of Contents Interpretation of Financial ments Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 Financial analysis of Next Plc (NXT) & Ted Baker Plc (TED) 5 Recommendation 9 Reference 10 Bibliography 12 Introduction The financial statements of a company provide important financial information about the business operations. With the help of this information one can compute financial ratios relating to liquidity, profitability, gearing and efficiency that help in assessing the financial performance of the company.   Next Plc   Ted Baker Plc   2010 (£m) 2009(£m)   2010 (£’000) 2009 (£’000) PROFITABILITY  (£m)       Gross Profit 996.9 908.5   99927 89366 Revenue 3,406.50 3,271.50... of...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

The Golden Era of Soccer

ASL emerged as a very sturdy league with incredibly loyal management and very substantial sponsors. The main sponsors of the league at that time were J&P Coates Robins shipyards and the Bethlehem Steel. The sponsors’ contribution enabled the league teams to bid eminent players into the league. The inauguration of the ASL league attracted a substantial number of crowd in the stadium. The average fans in the stadium during the time of inauguration were roughly 10,000 (Duarte 45). In 1925, the league extended to include New Bedford Whalers and the Boston Wonders Workers. The Boston Wonders Workers signed extensive number of eminent player to fit the standard of the league although some of its signing caused controversies in...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Britains Economy during the Golden Age

... Extent of Britain’s Economic Golden Age The period of post-economic boom, categorically referred to as the long boom, the acme of capitalism, the post World War II economic explosion, and the period of economic prosperity was some of the names given to what ultimately was the golden age. Following the end of World War II in 1945, western countries experienced a high wave of economic growth. Britain was in that pact that enjoyed the unprecedented times of unusually high and sustained growth together with bursting employment. Britain was flourishing in raising real income rate, a raising high consumption of goods and services. This paper will give an in depth analysis of the extent to which Britain’s economy was impacted during the golden...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

How the Characters in the Literal Works Suffer from Social Struggle and How It Is Revealed

...Liberal Art Literature Affiliation Supervisors’ This work looks at how the characters in the some literal work suffer from social struggle and also how the social struggle is revealed in the literal work. By definition social struggle is the presence of conflict, tension, or antagonism that exists in a society, amongst people or organizations due to different competing interests and desires between people of different classes races and gender amongst others. Social struggles in societies have been believed to influence radical social changes. According to Milonakis & Fine (2009), social struggle is the core of any historical processes. Any kind of struggle is perceived as the engine of change in any social structure (Rummel, 1977...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Golden Rule, The Mischief Rule and The Literal Rule of Statutory Interpretation for FREE!

Contact Us