Nobody downloaded yet

Critically discuss this statement with reference to decided cases and academic opinion - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Enforcement of Rights under EU Law before the National Courts The principles of the EU law of the utmost relevance are those of non – discrimination, effectiveness and judicial protection. Case law with these features is in general, conferred under what is termed procedural autonomy…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Critically discuss this statement with reference to decided cases and academic opinion
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critically discuss this statement with reference to decided cases and academic opinion"

Download file to see previous pages Such liability is not directly applicable, as the liability of Community institutions and the liability of the Member States are not always comparable.4 An instance of this is to be found in the Brasserie decision. In Brasserie, the ECJ extended the right of individuals to claim such damages, from any organ of the Member State whose act or omission had resulted in the damage.5 This makes it reasonable to presume that the liability case law, with regard to Member States, is relevant to damages claims for breach of EC law public procurement rules.6 Such course of action is with regard to contracting authorities that are public bodies. However, the term State tends to be vague, even within the realm of Member State liability. There is considerable disagreement as to whether the definition of State aid, provided in the ruling in Foster,7 as being emergent from the State should be acknowledged. All the same, the case law makes it very clear that the term State, in the context of liability cases, has a wider connotation and includes in its ambit, the decentralized bodies and authorities. 8 Hence, there is substantial common ground between a contracting authority and State entity under liability, despite these concepts being incongruent to each other. This contention is restricted to the intersection, wherein the contracting authority is in reality a State body. The public procurement law requires an action for liability to be brought against the contracting authority. However, it is up to the internal system of the national law to identify the State instance against which the action for liability is to be made. 9 This discretion accorded to the national law, while identifying State liability issues, results in grave injustice to the individual. This is because an aggrieved person has the right of direct effect only against a State and its emanations. Moreover, in this case, the ECJ ruled that the liability arising from the damage undergone by individuals, on account of a breach of Community law, was analogous to the liability of the Community under similar circumstances. This holds good, as long as there is no specific justification for the breach of the Community law. 10 This principle was echoed in the decision in Bergaderm.11 Furthermore, in the Brasserie case, 12 the conditions resulting in the liability of a Member State were described. These are; first infringement of rules of the Community that are aimed at providing individual rights; second, the existence of a breach of sufficient gravity; and third, a causal relationship between the breach and the damage sustained.13 This ruling however, failed to address all the issues involved. For instance, the issue of seriousness of the breach of Community law was left unresolved. Moreover, the ECJ had differentiated between areas of sparse and wide discretion, during its attempt to determine whether there were grounds for State liability, as well as the precise nature of these conditions. 14 Moreover, the breach of Community law by a Member State, which caused damage to an individual, placed that Member State under an obligation to make good the loss. This principle was enunciated in the Francovich decision by the ECJ. 15 In addition, in the Francovich case, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled that the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Critically discuss this statement with reference to decided cases and Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de
(Critically Discuss This Statement With Reference to Decided Cases and Essay)
“Critically Discuss This Statement With Reference to Decided Cases and Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critically discuss this statement with reference to decided cases and academic opinion

Criminals are made, not born. Critically discuss this statement

...?Many people who try to describe crime will tell one it is indescribable. Crime is a breach of trust from one party to another. There are many reasons why one would commit a crime. There are many theories about why one commits a crime. Some of those theories include the labeling theory, biological determinism, and the Chicago school. When one thinks about these theories, one might ask why one would think there are a biological determinism, and sociological determinism. Many think people commit crimes because of sociological determinism, and biological determinism. Many think one needs to have the biological determinism, and sociological determinism together before one would commit a crime. In this paper will be discussed...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Corporate culturism facilitates excellent business performance. Critically discuss this statement

...?Corporate Culturism Facilitates Excellent Business Performance Introduction Corporate Culturism is characterized as the norms and practices in a enterprise natural environment to strengthen the one-by-one presentation of employees for betterment of the association. It advances the performance of organization by ensuring larger flexibility and firm pledge from workers. Corporate heritage refers to everything performed in an entrepreneurship business related to its norms, heritage, emblems, systems, convictions, habits, aspires, and objectives. This report critically investigates the role of business Culturism in strengthening the presentation of the business natural environment. The theory will address...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Analyse and critically discuss the statement below

... and strategist that drives the company forward. Steve Jobs’ hold on the company is absolute since he is famous for his summary removals where he has been known to let go of people working for the company in just a few minutes. His presence on the company campus is known as the reign of terror in which anything can happen (Deutschman, 2000). Normally, a company takes a lot of time in both hiring and firing individuals since there are legal questions which need to be answered and decisions like removing people from service can have far reaching consequence. By working in a method which can be theoretically described as anti-organisational, Steve Jobs’ tactics have been discussed by Deutschman (2000) as: “He had total disregard... Theory and...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

College Transfer Academic Personal Statement

...experiment made me feel more confident in academic communication. I was accorded various privileges to talk to people about my experiment. Thirdly, I realized that I am good at an interdisciplinary approach for the reason that was encouraged to explore diverse possibilities through experimentation in the laboratory and come up with interesting experiments I like, such as creating microbial paintings on culture dishes, among others. The lab experience encourages me to become a microbiologist. I realized that there are vast opportunities to discover applications of microbes, as they encompass diverse global perspectives. I would like to be instrumental in the discovery of the ultimate eradication of crucial diseases which...
2 Pages(500 words)Personal Statement

Critically Acclaimed Supreme Court Cases

... Critically Acclaimed Supreme Court Cases Engel V Vitale This is one of the most critical cases in which the Supreme Court made it clear that voluntary prayer conducted in institutions is against the First Amendment rights. The case can relate back to 1951 in which the New York State Board passed a legislature which would require students to recite a prayer before school. The ideology was to promote spiritually amongst students. However, ten students rejected to follow this tradition and filed a law suit. The question remained; did the school snatch the right to have religious liberty from students by enforcing public prayer? Engel parents definitely...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Academic and Professional Statement

...Academic and Professional ment Introduction This academic and professional ment focuses on my expertise gained at past events and experiences, experience gained with social work and my reasons for applying at the Millersville and Shippensburg University as well as my future goals. I am planning to pursue a Masters Degree in Social Work at the Millersville & Shippensburg University to start my academic level as an advanced student. This program is favorable and feasible for me because it not only fulfills my requirements for my future ambitions but the location of the university is also in close proximity to my home. The program will truly be helpful in providing me with an understanding...
4 Pages(1000 words)Personal Statement

You decided

...IRS s and accounting rules According to the International Accounting Standards (IAS) (IFRS Foundation, 2014), financial records and statements should reflect a true and fair value of the company’s audited financial statements and position; they must be complete and accurate. For an individual to qualify for a bank loan in the US one must satisfy the bank’s 3Cs, these are credibility, Collateral and Capacity. This means that one needs to prove at least a one and a half year positive cash flow: this will prove a realistic cash plan. To qualify for a loan is not an easy task for entrepreneurs. Brandt (2002), suggests that banks may discriminate for nonprofit reasons, but this discrimination diminishes with...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Academic presonal statement

...Academic Personal ment Essay 6th July, Academic Personal ment Animal Science is an area in academic field that deals with producing livestock species. I am a candidate who is interested in the state science. I want to study Animal Science because an animal scientist applies principles of biology, physical and social sciences to the problem associated with livestock production and management. It contributes to the knowledge from three different sources of science it gives a wide horizon to the scope of information gained. Along with above mentioned areas, the Animal Science also deals with the food of animal origin, which might include meat, dairy foods and eggs. Even the global forces are...
2 Pages(500 words)Personal Statement

You decided

...Case Study Number) al Affiliation) INTERNAL MEMO REF: I am writing this memo to addressthe various concerns raised by the three stakeholders during the committee meeting. To begin with, the organization will be able to understand students’ attitudes about drinking and driving by conducting a market research. This is by taking a sample of the students on a random basis and asking them questions that will help the committee have a better understanding of students’ attitudes. This can be done by either developing some questionnaires which the sample group will fill and return, or it can be done through conducting interviews (Hague, 2004). This will achieve the board member’s aim of listening first, and then delivering a...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

Haven't decided

..., it explains the reason why the state of nature leads to war. Moreover, it defines the first, second, and third laws of nature and their interrelationships. Finally, it asserts that the role of coercive power allows people to obey the laws of nature. A law of nature refers to a general law that comes from human reason, wherein people are restricted from acting destructively against life, or from removing the means to protect life, and, at the same time, this law requires people to pursue self-preservation (Hobbes 80). This view of the law of nature indicates that reason follows the basic instinct for the preservation of human life above all, most especially, one’s life before others. Hobbes knows that people find it...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critically discuss this statement with reference to decided cases and academic opinion for FREE!

Contact Us