StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The prosecution of James Phang Wah and Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat directors of an insolvent company, Sunshine Empire - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The researcher of this article reports on the prosecution of James Phang Wah and Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat’ directors of an insolvent company, Sunshine Empire, a multi-level marketing company that sold packages while promising higher returns…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
The prosecution of James Phang Wah and Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat directors of an insolvent company, Sunshine Empire
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The prosecution of James Phang Wah and Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat directors of an insolvent company, Sunshine Empire"

Media report Analysis The article reports on the prosecution of James Phang Wah and Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat’ directors of an insolvent company, Sunshine Empire, a multi-level marketing company that sold packages while promising higher returns. Criminal Law The firm swindled investors who bought lifestyle packages. The firm also promised investors returns which were not from genuine profits but were actually funds recycled from new members joining the scheme. These two scenarios constituted criminal law. Another case is where Phang’s wife was paid a commission of nearly 950,000 US dollars for her work as the company’s group sales director, a job she never had or did. Corporation Law Sunshine empire was a corporation. Therefore all its operations were governed by the corporations’ law that existed. Some of the requirements of this law are proper maintenance of books of accounts. This company never kept proper books of account. On the other hand, a company is normally formed with the sole object of not dealing in illegal trade. The company also breached this by processing uncensored and obscene films. All these cases led to the breach of corporations’ law. Property law The company is being wound up. Therefore, the Commercial affairs department has seized about twenty-one million US dollars and will establish how these funds should be disbursed to the firm’s creditors. This constitutes property law. Contract Law The directors’ intention of selling 26,000 packages and earning 180, 000 US dollars was unacceptable. They knew that the scheme would fail. An important aspect of Law of contract is ‘acting in good faith.’ The directors breached this provision. On the other hand, Phang’s wife is also being fined for falsifying payment vouchers. This constituted a breach of contract law. How the Law helps in the following Situations Allows people to Organize and Plan Law in itself can help people organize and plan their future actions. In the case of Sunshine Empire, investors are applying the provision of the law to plan their future actions. This is evidenced by the fact that they buy packages from Sunshine Empire with the hope that they will get higher returns. There was a risk though with such investment as the company could collapse in the future leading to heavy losses to investors; and true to this, the company eventually went under receivership. How Law Encourages or discourages Particular activities Law can act to encourage or discourage certain activities. The prosecution of directors is a common example where the law doe not permit swindling of investors money through fraudulent activities. The directors defrauded the public of their through false investment activities, hence had to pay for their illegal acts (Howitt, p68). The law also acts to encourage compensation in cases of losses being suffered by a given party to a contract. This is seen when the commercial affairs department of company sets aside money to disburse to the firm’s creditors. How Law Creates Rights and Duties that can be enforced The contract between Sunshine Empire and its investors is a clear indication of a situation where law can create rights and duties which can be enforced. The investors invest their funds in the hope of higher returns in the future. The company gets wound up and the Commercial Affairs Department sets aside funds to settle creditors’ claims. By settling the creditors claim, a right of compensation in case of damages or loss is being enforced. How Law Provides remedies when Rights are interfered with or duties are not discharged In this case, creditors are being given funds set aside to cover for their losses as the company goes into liquidation. This clearly shows how law can be used to provide remedy in case of interference with somebody’s rights or where duties in a contract are not fully discharged. Why it is Important to know the law in the circumstances described in the Media report Members of the public at large should know the provision of the law for any unscrupulous people not to take advantage of their ignorance. In the case of Sunshine Empire, the directors formed a company with the aim of swindling money from innocent investors who wanted to make a fortune out of their investments in form of returns. The directors’ actions did not go unpunished as criminal proceedings were leveled against the thus landing them in jail. If the people were not aware of their rights in as far as the law was concerned, may be these two directors could have gone scot- free. At the same time, knowing law would help one be aware that in case of breach of contract by a party to a contract one can get remedy for such losses in form of compensation. This is seen where the creditors get compensated when the company becomes insolvent. PART B Clarke Vs University of Lincolnshire 1) The reported case was decided in the Court of Appeal, Civil Division 2) No. This is because the common law rules that apply in the United Kingdom are different to those that apply in Australia. Secondly, no judicial precedent is cited touching on any Australian cases. 3) Name of Judges who heard the Case- The judges who heard the case were Mr. Lord Woolf and Mr. Ward Sedley Lj. 4) What were the full names of the parties? What are those parties called and why? C was Miss Clark. She was called an appellant because of bringing an appeal against her former university after the abandonment of her plagiarism case earlier. 5) Material Facts of the Reported Case The claimant, Miss Clark, bought a legal suit against the university. She was disputing her examination mark, after being awarded a mark of zero on the basis of plagiarism in her work. The university also claimed that she was late in submission of her work. She disagreed with these reason given since she claims the plagiarism case had been sorted out and that she had also informed her tutor the reasons for her late submission of work. On that basis, she decided to go to the courts for justice. 6) Main Legal issue to be decided The main legal issue to be decided was whether the contractual dispute between the student and higher education corporation was within the mandate of the courts to handle or not. Secondly, the court should determine whether there was an abuse of of the universty’s processes in as far as dealing with the students cases was concerned. Decision of the Court The court allowed Miss Clarke’s appeal to the extent of restoring the action. It was decided that both parties should sit down and dialogue, thus giving mediation a chance. A written agreement was also reached on how the university will handle the matter. This entailed the circumstances in which if at all, the action may further be prosecuted. 1) Expressing Ratio Decidendi of the Reported Case The rationale behind the court’s decision was clear. Clark made a mistake which was common to all as she failed to back up a copy of her work and on the last day before the deadline, all her stored work were lost from the hard disc. The university board of examiners also failed her for plagiarism and awarded her a mark of zero despite her explanation to her tutor so that examiners could be informed. Secondly, the academic board also failed to comply with the decision of the governor’s appeal body on remission. 2) Number of Precedents that can be identified. There are sixteen precedents. These help give a point of reference for cases that were earlier decided and are similar to the current cases. Reference Howitt, Dennis. Crime, the media, and the law. Chichester [England: Wiley, 1998. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The prosecution of James Phang Wah and Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1396339-the-prosecution-of-james-phang-wah-and-jackie-hoo-choon-cheat-directors-of-an-insolvent-company-sunshine-empire
(The Prosecution of James Phang Wah and Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1396339-the-prosecution-of-james-phang-wah-and-jackie-hoo-choon-cheat-directors-of-an-insolvent-company-sunshine-empire.
“The Prosecution of James Phang Wah and Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1396339-the-prosecution-of-james-phang-wah-and-jackie-hoo-choon-cheat-directors-of-an-insolvent-company-sunshine-empire.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The prosecution of James Phang Wah and Jackie Hoo Choon Cheat directors of an insolvent company, Sunshine Empire

Company & Insolvency Law

hellip; Fixed and floating charges are used in order for the company to secure borrowings under debentures which may be issued by the company as a source of long term loan.... whereas a floating charge is that which allows a company to undertake borrowings despite non possession of assets which may be specific in nature and the charges are placed on the company's assets like its machinery, stock in trade etc.... A debenture holder, whose debt is secured by a floating charge over the assets of a company such as its book debts and trading stock, is likely to enjoy boundless benefits should such a charge crystallize preferably before the onset of insolvency....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment

Insolvency in Private International Law

Typically, a phoenix company will use all or some of the assets of the insolvent company and will trade in the same industry and similar manner to the failed predecessor9.... Prior to the Companies Act 2006 (CA 2006), the 1989 Companies Act and the Companies Act 1985 provisions pertaining to directors' duties provided positive obligations for directors to act in good faith and in the best interest of the company, to avoid conflicts of interest and not to profit from their office1....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Creditor's Position in Case of Company's Insolvency

Creditor's position in the case of company's insolvency Introduction The instant case involves the question of the recovery of loans advanced to Norma-Creations Ltd by Cashbank ?... hellip; 30,000 by Easyloans Ltd on floating charge on stock in trade besides amounts owed to other creditors of the company.... Companies Act 2006 and Insolvency Act 1986 First, it has to be determined whether the company or its directors have violated provisions of Companies Act 2006 and Insolvency Act 1986 by knowingly taking loans from these two banks when the business of the co mpany had already started showing signs of insolvency prior to availing of the said loans....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Insolvency Law: Wrongful and Fraudulent Trading

Section 213(2) provides that the court may make a declaration pursuant to an application by a liquidator that “any persons knowingly parties to the carrying on of the business” pursuant to Section 213(1) “are liable to make contributions (if any) to the company's assets as the courts thinks proper”.... Section 993 of the Companies Act 2006 creates a criminal offence in the case of fraudulent trading calculated to defraud creditors when a company is either insolvent or on the brink of insolvency....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Company Law and director incapacity

In our present case, the directors of W&H Ltd namely Jean, Lynette, Lauren and Ryan own a quarter of the company's issued shares each.... A company upon incorporation becomes a separate legal entity, which is distinct from its shareholders and directors.... In other words, the acts of the company are not the acts of its members though the shares are held in trust for them.... hellip; All the same, situations exist where the courts disregard the separate existence of a corporation formed to conduct a portion of a company's business and thus pierce the corporate veil....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

The Duty of Directors in Protecting the Interests of the Creditors

As a strategic way of protecting the creditors from losing a large sum of money that was granted to the borrowers, the main purpose of liquidating an insolvent company is to expand the pool of asset that can be distributed to the creditors.... As soon as a company enters liquidation, the corporate directors can be held personally liable and obliged to pay back a portion of the company's debts equal to the amount of company's asset that was lost due to directors' conduct....
48 Pages (12000 words) Research Paper

Directors Legal Liabilities

In this paper, the author demonstrates how the company prior to insolvency or the threat of insolvency, creditors are largely at liberty to engage in whatever lawful enforcement activities that they desire to recover debts owed by a company.... nbsp;   … There is a line of authority in UK courts also known as the West Mercia principle, indicating that company directors are required to take into account the creditors' interest not only when it is obvious that insolvency is eminent, but also when insolvency is a significant threat....
17 Pages (4250 words) Term Paper

Company Law: Regulations of Corporate Directors Activities

The goal of this assignment "company Law: Regulations of Corporate Directors Activities" is to address the legal questions related to the international liability of corporate directors.... In short, Regal (Hastings) v Gulliver and Ors ruled that company directors were not at liberty to take advantage of corporate opportunities as the same was a contravention of the fiduciary duty.... Having determined that the directors in question had obtained a profit from business opportunity that they had come by in the course of their respective offices, the court held that the directors were accountable to the company for those profits....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us