Nobody downloaded yet

Evidence, Proof and argument - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
JUDGE’S SUMMATION: REGINA v. DUNCAN MOORE Members of the jury, before you shall retire to discuss the fate of defendant, Duncan Moore, allow me to remind you of your duties as juries which I have stated at the beginning of the trial. You were prohibited from discussing this case so as not to prejudge the guilt or innocence of this defendant1…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Evidence, Proof and argument
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Evidence, Proof and argument"

Download file to see previous pages As the jury, it is your duty to decide fairly, dispassionately and impartially based on the evidence presented by the prosecution4 since the burden of proving the guilt of defendant Duncan lies with the prosecution5 and owing to this stringent requirement, its case must stand and fall on its own merits. The prosecution cannot assert that the evidence for the defence is weak. Any claim therefore by the prosecution that this defendant has not established a valid defence should not be entertained. I would like to emphasize that the duty to prove the guilt of this defendant is the sole responsibility of the prosecution6. This defendant need not do anything since the law presumes his innocence until proven otherwise. However, Members of the jury, I would likewise caution you that the proof required of the prosecution is not absolute certainty that this defendant has committed the grievous act he is accused of. The prosecution is simply required to prove beyond a reasonable doubt(fn-case) that this defendant is guilty. Judgment beyond a reasonable doubt simply requires moral certainty that this defendant committed the offence charged. ...
With that as a backdrop, let us proceed with the task at hand. This defendant is indicted for the murder of Simon Chapman by allegedly plunging the knife into the victim’s heart with intent to hurt and cause him serious harm. The death of Simon Chapman allegedly resulted from the acts of this defendant who was then 15 years old. Allow me, Members of the Jury to walk you through the undisputed facts—the decedent, Simon Chapman and his friend Christopher Jones (Jones) were sitting in a coach aboard a train late at night when two boys, defendant Duncan Moore and David Parker (David) were smoking and running about the train passing from one carriage to another. Christopher Jones chided the boys for smoking and to which they replied to “fuck off”. At this point, David—the younger of the two—decided to pester Jones by grabbing his briefcase. A commotion ensued where Jones pushed David who retaliated with a punch landing on the Jones’ face. As Jones was about to hit David again, Duncan intervened. The ruckus is now between Jones and Duncan. They were throwing punches at each other when decedent Chapman arose from his sleep and seeing that Jones was being hit by Duncan, he, in turn, struck Duncan with his umbrella. Duncan fell on his back and decedent Chapman straddled him, the two went on throwing punches against each other when the fracas stopped. Decedent Chapman was stabbed with the use of a kitchen knife. Thereafter, two boys alighted on the next train stop. Based on this undisputed facts, you shall decide if this defendant stabbed the victim or is there a probability that somebody else on that train who could be the culprit. Before we move on to the evidence presented by either side, it is important that I discuss the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Evidence, Proof and argument Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1394743-evidence-proof-and-argument
(Evidence, Proof and Argument Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1394743-evidence-proof-and-argument.
“Evidence, Proof and Argument Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1394743-evidence-proof-and-argument.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Evidence, Proof and argument

Proof Reading

... Crime Analysis of Abu-Dhabi using GIS Techniques Using traditional methods for crime analysis have been readily utilized by law enforcement agencies. However, processing significant information for crime analysis efficiently and effectively brings concern to crime deviation agencies. With the use of a new systems there is a more effective way to integrate and analyze information by combining multiple data layers into useful information. For this reason, can the usability of the GIS along with crime analysis produce adequate results in contracting viable methods in deterring crime? The function of this analysis is to demonstrate the effect of GIS on crime analysis for Abu-Dhabi. There will be an investigation into the processes... Crime...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Proof

...? Comparison Essay of the Visual Arts and Film Studies of the Concerned June 21, Comparison Essay There is no denying the fact that every movie tends to be a unique work of creativity and imagination, yet, it goes without saying that in a cinematic context, it is viable to compare some movies. In that context the purpose of this paper is to review some movies in a comparative context. Proof happens to be really an extraordinary thriller that delves and elaborates on matters of heart and scholarship. The movie in a vivid manner elucidates the true ingenuity of a mathematical proof and the passion and emotion that is intertwined around it (Ross, 2011, p. 57). The hallmark of the movie is that it does...
3 Pages(750 words)Movie Review

Fallacy Burden of Proof

...to turn out a particular proof of its incidence so the lack of that particular proof may dependably be utilized for concluding the non occurrence of that event. (Methew, 1997) Shifting the Burden of Proof The 'shifting of Burden of Proof' is a specific instance under 'Argumentum ad ignorantiam' and is usually over the individual making a statement. In other words we can say that it is a type of fallacy where the burden of proof is put on the individual who contradicts or interrogates about that statement. This type of fallacy is based on the postulation that any statement is regarded as true if there is no evidence to prove it wrong....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Proof reading

...Introduction: A gaming company has developed its software in VC++ and DirectX. The company would like to introduce aspects of DAI and agents in its next generation of games. In addition, the company has taken a strategic decision to develop games for the Internet, mobile devices (i.e. PDA) and 3G phones. In this technical report I shall briefly summarize the aspects of DAI and agents. Furthermore, I shall put forward my recommendations in light of the company’s strategic planning objectives. We can provide a direct interface to the hardware on the host system of our software by using the DirectX application program interface. This is achieved by removing the device-specific hardware dependencies, which were previously part... A gaming company ...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Proof reading

...Need Proof Reading! The Influence of Greek Writing Ancient Greece has a greater influence in the shaping of Western civilization as we know and experience today than any other civilization. The influence that it has brought encompasses a huge number of aspects from political to cultural. One of the major aspects is Greek writing, which can be considered the ancestor of modern writing in the western world. It is an invention that provides a convincing way for modern people to communicate to each other. In addition, it gives us the ability to record anything in form of text. Whether we are aware of it or not, we are highly influenced by the past far more than we can imagine. Unlike the hieroglyphics of the Egyptians, Aegean writing... is not...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Law of Evidence Burden of Proof

...80). This is not a suitable standard for conviction of a crime because of the numerous challenges that the prosecution faces that may limit ability to prove a case beyond reasonable doubt. Increasing complexity among criminals that may tamper with evidence or interfere with validity of material components of evidence disadvantages the prosecution and requires support for justice to victims of crime. Reducing the level of burden of proof is the sure way to ensuring justice under the conditions. Other limitations such as fear among witnesses also hinder effectiveness of prosecutors’ arguments and increases chances of wrongful acquittal under the beyond reasonable doubt...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

Evidence, Proof, Argument AND Criminal Law

...Issue of Voluntary Manslaughter – Loss of Self Control R V Duncan Moore Issue of Voluntary Manslaughter – Loss of Self Control My Lady, I am Alisha Hussein, and in this matter on behalf of the prosecution, I shall be dealing with the issue of loss of control which states that: A person may be convicted of manslaughter and not murder if he/she exhibits loss of self-control that had a qualifying trigger, and an individual of the same age and sex in the situation might have taken the same or similar action given they have self-control and tolerance1. What is loss of control? In the case of R v Richens [1993] 4 All ER 877; loss of control was established to be complete loss of awareness where a person is not in control of his actions...
2 Pages(500 words)Speech or Presentation

Proof

...1. I don’t get it. Some people are always jealous in their attitude towards others, because they have what they don’t have. They tend to make rumors(gossip) about others, because they’re not happy in their life. Well, for most of these people the priority is either watching TV. When the movie they’re watching is sad they become upset and gossip about other people thinking that they’re clean and never did anything stupid in their lives. They judge others and think that they’re perfect creatures… Other people are sorry of themselves, because they are fat and always bitching about their body but they’re not doing anything except putting food in their mouth and complain. Look, if you’re not happy with your life right now, maybe you... I don’t get ...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Proof read

...Full Knowing Me My is Kevin Tjhung but all of my friends simply call me Tjhung. I was born on the 6th of December in 1995 in Jakarta, Indonesia. I am of Chinese-Indonesian descent, a minority in Indonesia. Nevertheless, I grew up in a big family with a lot of relatives from both my father’s and mother’s sides so I always felt I belonged to a huge community. My father is the oldest of six siblings and my mother is the third oldest of seven siblings so you could perhaps imagine the size of their families. Although I have only one older sister, we are closely knit with our relatives so we seldom had boring days. As a businessman, my father is always busy together with my mother who assists him in the details of his transactions... Knowing Me My...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Proof reading

...Proofreading task affiliation For successful research completion, I have distributed 20 questionnaires survey. 10 in Leeds Beckett and 10 in UQU University. First, I distributed 10 questionnaires to my tutor and employees in many places vested with green ICT information. Later, the Faculty of Arts, Environment & Technology in Leeds Beckett was my next destination, aiming tutors who have amassed intensive knowledge about green ICT. However, I did not obtain reliable information from them. In Sustainability Institute department located in Leeds Beckett University, I met some staffs who would respond to all my research project queries. I did receive crucial information regarding my survey, though they did not indicate their official... task...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Evidence, Proof and argument for FREE!

Contact Us