Union Citizenship - metaphor or source of rights - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Reich is of the view the EU citizenship is just based on the condition of nationality while at the same time, some basic rights is footed on the yardstick other than nationality / citizenship alone.As per Reich, citizenship of EU seems to be an imitative condition of nationality. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.2% of users find it useful
Union Citizenship - metaphor or source of rights
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Union Citizenship - metaphor or source of rights"

Download file to see previous pages Union Citizenship - metaphor or source of rights?

The present EU law does not define whether the citizenship of EU will cover those non-citizen individuals who are residing in a Member States for long years. In Rudy case, the concept of citizenship to offer rights for free movement, the Court of Justice has been reluctant to confer “quasi-citizenship” rights to nationals of third countries who are residing in the Union for many years.
Thus, the law relating to EU citizenship seems to be in the infancy stage where a lot of reform has to be undertaken to plug the existing loophole that is found in the present EU citizenship rules and to make the EU as a whole as a borderless territory. Reich is of the opinion that the phrase “EU citizenship “ has not been defined exactly and due to this , there are flooding of case laws as regards to free movement and social rights for non-citizens living in EU for many years. Reich is of the view that citizenship can be defined as “full membership of the community “which offers a package of rights, which consists of social, civic and political rights. Reich is more concerned about the rights of third nationals who are residing in the EU Member States for long years. He is of the view that EU citizenship should not be decided merely on the citizenship of Member States but also should include those who are residing in a Member States for many years. Reich insists that there should not be any non-discrimination for granting citizenship to those who residing in a Member State for many years as compared to those who are having natural citizenship. Reich is of the view that citizenship should be awarded both on the status path and on the rights path. Reich prefers that union citizenship as a simile with some valued added to it. Reich cites the verdict in Micheletti case, where EU citizenship is derived from the condition of nationality. The EU has no authority to grant citizenship as an outcome of nationality. The citizenship in the EU Member State has to be recognised Union-wide even where an individual who had a dual citizenship as held in Micheletti case As per Reich, for contrasting between the duties and rights of Member States’ nationals in the European Union, nationality should not be considered as a criterion unless there exists some particular variety of cross-border disputes that inflicts different norms. In concluding part, Reich is of the opinion that the question – Union Citizenship – Whether Metaphor or source of Rights – can be found to be positive only to a restricted degree. Reich is of the opinion that citizenship seems to be like a baby in a cradle who is in deep sleep who has to be awakened by a gentle kiss by the direct impact of community law. 2.How has the law relating to Union Citizenship developed since the publication of the article in 2001? ( 900 words) As per Siofra O’ Leary, there is a failure to make an obvious connection between ambit and operation of the community citizenship with that of fundamental rights of EU citizen. EU citizenship offers the following rights; right of unrestricted movement , right to stand for election both for municipal and EU parliament , the right to petition , the right of consular and diplomatic protection , the right of petition and safeguard by the Ombudsman of the European Parliament. However, EU citizenship is not essential for enjoying certain rights for those who reside in EU Member States like directives on consumer, worker, environmental protection and data. The same will hold true in the case of both European and International conventions either on the aspect of conflict of laws or on jurisdictions. Thus, ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Union Citizenship - metaphor or source of rights Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1393414-european-law
(Union Citizenship - Metaphor or Source of Rights Essay)
“Union Citizenship - Metaphor or Source of Rights Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1393414-european-law.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Union Citizenship - metaphor or source of rights

Orchestra metaphor

... of humor to keep perspective, and bring everything in on time and under budget. Politician may be an appropriate metaphor. The most important quality to have is excellent communication skills, because a project manager must ask the right questions (Answers.com), influence people, and inspire and communicate shared vision (Bennis). Of least importance is the position title and job description, because a leader leads with or without a title or job description, and general management and leadership skills are applicable to project managing. Works Cited Answers.com. Which of the Eight Traits of Being an Efficient Project Manager is Important? 2011. 26 May 2011 . Bennis, W. Learning to Lead. MA: Addison-Wesley, 1997.... May 26, Project Manager...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper

Employer/Union Rights and Obligation

...of collective bargaining through psychological and physical coercive actions. The Act has outlined various restrictions that have been placed on an employer from restricting an employee from practicing his/her rights. For example: an employer can not threaten to fire a worker or bribe a worker with employment benefits in order to stop the worker from being a member of a union. Secondly, an employer cannot even threaten workers of an organization that the organization will be shutdown if workers participate in union campaigns. An employer is not even allowed to obtain information from a worker or a union member regarding the activities that are taking place in a...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay


...activities in order to establish a just and liberal society. Therefore, it is the significant for civic, local, small, and religious groups get detailed knowledge and education significant to administer the right combination of compassion, loving and active discipline necessary for each citizen. This in turn will foster citizenship, encouraging civic pride and nurturing American families. Citizens must be ready and willing to agree and adhere to the regulations, tenets, obligations, and rules by which they are governed. Democratic governments give many freedoms to their citizens incorporating the freedom to criticize and dissent the government. Citizenship in a democratic country needs...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

EU Rights to citizenship

...EU Rights to citizenship This story is based on the lives of two groups of people: residents of the European Union and individuals who have moved from Kazakhstan and Hungary in an attempt to find work and settle in the EU. The huge differences present between the lives of the locals and the immigrants to the country are shown. Karl and Gabrielle are the two visitors from Kazakhstan while Sylvia belongs to Hungary. Charles, Bill and Muriel play an intricate role in the lives of all three foreign individuals.   The first character Gabrielle has a work permit which qualifies up to three months. Article 6(1) provides that EU citizens shall have the right of residence in...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Immigration, Nationality and Asylum Law ( British Law)

...countries' economy and the economy should be integrated world-wide. To sum it up, Green is right that immigration worries local people but they should understand the fact that it is useful for the economy and that's why they are able to live better. Green also asserts that immigration is like infinity and will never decrease. However, certain surveys draw a different conclusion. According to the study of European Commission, only one percent of people were considering the fact of working abroad even if they had been able to move without any restrictions before entering European Union. Other studies showed similar results. Another reliable source is Home office statistics, which conclude...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

European Court Of Justice and Free Movement of Persons

..., that is, within the supranational confines of an organisation such as the European Union However, this essay is not denying the progress that has been made, particularly from the input of the European Court of Justice. Yet, a true, tangible and equitable EU citizenship felt and enjoyed by the people of Europe is only possible if the people themselves are brought out of their national shells and fully educated on European social integration. References 1. Reich, N (2001) 'Union Citizenship - Metaphor or Source of Rights' 7 ELJ 4. 2. see footnote 202, pg 719 C&D). 3. Ivo Shlosark, Charles University, Prague...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Citizenship and Human rights in Australia

...in a fair and equal manner. They are expected to respect the rights of those who they come into contact with. Even when one is suspected of criminal activity, Queensland Police are required to deal with them in such a way that may not be deemed brutal or forceful. Care should be taken to make sure that the innocent are protected. (Goldsmith, 1991) Citizenship rights in Australia Under the constitution, everyone must uphold the rule of law. This means that those who are innocent ought to be protected from any criminal activity. Everyone in Australia has a freedom of speech. The latter applies to any person who my want to participate in petitions against a system or body they feel has not...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


...Your Metaphor for Life Life is a game. I believe those words. It’s like in the movie The Matrix. In this world that we are living in, technology rules our lives. This technology can certainly alter our realities, as they can also affect how people perceive realities. As a game, someone controls you for the game-play to push through. Although in The Matrix, the ones who control the lives of the people there are robots (and it is quite pessimistic), I believe that it is us who control our life. We are the players of this game and life presents challenges to us players by giving us a more difficult problem to achieve every day. Your soul is what directs you to pursue this and that; your soul is the motivation for you to...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Citizenship and civil rights

...Task: Discuss social, political, and economic s/organizations in play during the civil right movement. The most significant achievements in the History of America in trying to uphold civil rights movements was the post civil war constitutional changes, which led to the abolishment of slavery and formation of citizenship status on blacks. This allowed for the judicial decisions and legislation centered on the set amendments. Furthermore, the legal amendments, largely affected the opportunities presented to women, non-black minorities, the disabled and other subjects of discriminations (McKissack & Fredrick 9). According to McKissack & Fredrick (13), argued that, “Brown decision proved...
2 Pages(500 words)Coursework


...Citizenship Citizenship Nationalism is a harmonious relationship between the nation and the which pursue common objectives for common reasons (Steiner 2009, p. 91-92). The definition of the term citizenship is a controversial issue due to the difference in meaning it elicits from different groups of people. Knowledge in citizenship issues is profoundly important for personal enrichment and awareness of one’s civil, political and social rights as a citizen of a certain nation-state. An individual can become a citizen through different ways. One can gain citizenship by birth. The first way of gaining citizenship, being...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Union Citizenship - metaphor or source of rights for FREE!

Contact Us