Critically analyse the problems involved in Police use of discretion - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
In simple terms the use of discretion by police refers to their action and ability to choose when to intervene and when not to intervene in the enforcement of law. Reiner regarded discretion as a particular tool in police organisation to be used by officers at the very ground level …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Critically analyse the problems involved in Police use of discretion
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critically analyse the problems involved in Police use of discretion"

Download file to see previous pages In simple terms the use of discretion by police refers to their action and ability to choose when to intervene and when not to intervene in the enforcement of law. Reiner regarded discretion as a particular tool in police organisation to be used by officers at the very ground level who are operating away from the immediate supervision of management This paper shall critically analyse the problems involved in the police use of discretion. It shall specifically discuss the practice of ethnic and other subjective considerations in routine stops and searches, the evaluation of domestic violence incidents, and similar police activities.The use of discretion is far greater in the police, even at their lowest levels, as compared to other organizations. This means that the constables in police enjoy more discretion than any other organisation even in police organisation. This is because the constables have direct interaction with the public while policing and patrolling2. Issues have now come up in relation to police officers and their need to apply discretion in their activities. Various factors have to be considered in order for the police to decide how much effort is needed in order to enforce specific laws which help control lawlessness. It is also important to note how a comprehensive police guidance detailing the manner of discretion which may be applied in specific circumstances can actually be insufficient for police officers to apply in order to avoid abuse of discretion. In these cases, it is difficult to include all the scenarios where discretion may be utilized in a single book. Moreover, even racial discrimination against racial and ethnic minorities may lead to a misuse of discretion. Nevertheless, according to Goldstein, there are no set rules or even a rule-book to follow for police officers to follow in handling police encounters3. Police officers cannot also be instructed on how to handle specific situations because most of their activities are part of routine policing where they often work away from supervisory authorities. Body There are various issues which are seen with the use of discretion. One of the issues is based on the fact that police officers may not have as much experience in policing and this may sometimes lead them to misuse their discretion in the apprehension of suspected criminals4. Moreover, their discretion may be affected by factors which include the inappropriate use of subjective and demographic factors to impact on their decisions as police officers. These factors may include racial or ethnic minority and in some cases, even gender. Newburn and Reiner discuss that the pattern of police discretion which lead to issues in its application is fashioned by different elements including class, race, gender, and age5. These factors often cause society to manifest various responses to police officers. Vulnerable people and the minority groups are often subjected to the unfair applications of police discretion. Studies establish that this discretion is often abused among young, black, lower class, and among males6. Patrolling among police officers on these individuals often include strict surveillance which often leads to abuse of discretion. This negative approach in the use of discretion often causes a very negative approach against the police. In a study by the Home Office, black people have a higher likelihood of being pulled over by the police officers for routine stops and searches7. Police officers seem to be highly influenced by the stereotypes about black people being criminals or offenders. In a discussion by author and criminal analyst Frank Remington, he acknowledged the fact that police officers must have a significant role in moulding and establishing a proper law enforcement process for the general population8. He compared the Federal Trade Commission, which is an administrative agency who has the responsibility of developing enforcement policies, and the local police departments ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critically analyse the problems involved in Police use of discretion Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1392220-critically-analyse-the-problems-involved-in-police
(Critically Analyse the Problems Involved in Police Use of Discretion Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1392220-critically-analyse-the-problems-involved-in-police.
“Critically Analyse the Problems Involved in Police Use of Discretion Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1392220-critically-analyse-the-problems-involved-in-police.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
je
jeffry38 added comment 1 year ago
Student rated this paper as
This paper saved me today. I liked the structure. It was very useful for my law course.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critically analyse the problems involved in Police use of discretion

Police Use of Force

...Module Police Use of Force The issue of police use of force has become of paramount concern in the society in the contemporary world. The police force is a unit of government whose key objective is to maintain order and enforce law in a nation (Bittner 125). The profession can be described as stressful and risky since it involves violent encounters. Police may be forced to use aggression so as to control a violent situation (Bittner 125). Police often find themselves in a precarious position when determining the amount of force to use when dealing with suspects (Sacks...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Police Discretion

...at a particular instance; a fact that differentiates a good officer from an average one. Definition Discretion can be described as a police officers’ will to act upon a certain situation or not and in what way. That is for example whether to stop a speeding motorist, book him or leave him with a gentle warning. The definition may be true but more often than not discretion is associated with use of force in the field. This discretion can be in either deciding to see force and if using so, how much and to what extent (Hunt 1985). Another school of thought preaches that the discretion of a police officer is...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Police Use of Force

...privilege to resolve disagreements or deter unfavorable deeds through the application of mechanisms that discourage a person from certain actions or getting physically involved to stop such actions (Alpert & Dunham, 2004). Government administrations in most countries and realms across the world permit civilians and law enforcement to apply force in deterring looming incidence of crime. Police are particularly empowered to use force in cases where the stoppage or prevention of crime and other unlawful activities is involved. Similarly, the use of force may be invoked by the administrative arm of regime via the deployment of security forces;...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Police Discretion in Domestic Violence

...parties. However, police officers mostly rely on their experience as police officers to handle the situation as they think appropriate. Police Discretion in Domestic Violence Introduction Family problems which breed domestic violence are universal issues which affect all members of the family including parents and children. Domestic violence can be fatal, but it can be effectively controlled with the proper implementation of law and timely and appropriate intervention by the police. Police reactions to incidents of domestic violence have usually depended upon the attitude and discretion of the officer...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Police Discretion Position

...with instances of discretionary practices, many police departments will not openly admit to them and, instead, adamantly perpetuate the myth of full enforcement. One will find that it is very common throughout the country that virtually all of police work involves discretion, with the exclusion of mandatory arrests. Furthermore, it is not just the police officer who has to use discretion, but it is also the prosecutor deciding what charges to file or how the offender should be sentenced, and the judge who has the most discretion of all when it comes to setting the ultimate punishment at the culmination...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Police Discretion Position Paper

...experience, his particular area of expertise, and his insight into different situations. Discretion is therefore highly individualistic. Choice means trying to find alternative solutions to problems. This aspect of discretion involves a weighing of the costs and the benefits of alternative courses of action. Discernment refers to an examination of the underlying merits of a situation. The police officer must use discretion, for instance to determine whether someone is being scapegoated or unfairly accused. Perhaps there is some excuse that, while not legally recognized as a defense, nevertheless is a very...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Police discretion postion

...standards, shape the inevitable use of discretion, and support community involvement” (Kelling, 1999: iii). Furthermore, formal training of police personnel should include some basic factors to teach them to act democratically as well as judiciously in their work, in order to successfully achieve outcomes which are just (Marenin, 2004). The Mythical Aspects of Discretion in Police Work: Discretion in police work is prevalent since the earliest times, and historically it is a significant feature of policing. Some mythical aspects of police work include the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Critically analyse financial statemebt

...of the business. It involves deduction of expenses from sales to arrive at the taxable net profit or loss (which of course not taxable anymore because it is a loss). Figure 1. Example of a sole trader financial statement Figure 2. Example of a sole trader financial statement (Osbornebooks nd) 2. Limited Companies- Limited companies are also called as Joint stock companies or partnership where owners or shareholders pool their resources together to form a corporation. The shareholders share the profit and losses depending on the proportion of their contribution to the company. In simpler terms, Limited Companies are what we call now as corporations. During the formation or incorporation of a limited company, the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

(Criminal Justice) Police Discretion & Corruption

... that do not fit the vagueness of the misdemeanors (Reid, 2006). This means that it is left to the policeman on the street to interpret how he ought to implement this type of legislation. In crimes such as domestic battery and aggressive hate crimes, the officers in question should use the laws against these crimes to full effect. Classmate’s Post The officer is right in the suggestions he makes about a police officer using his discretion when determining the right option to take when a driver engages in a misdemeanor. Nash rightly observed that there are a range of options that police officers could use in determining the seriousness of the crime or misdemeanor that has been committed (Policedynamicschanel, 2012). Even though... Criminal...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Police Discretion

...with mentally ill people, police offices have a wide range of options that can be broadly divided into two groups: formal and informal ones. Thus, on the one hand, if a mentally ill person causes troubles officers might hospitalize one. Indeed, there is a reserved number of beds in each hospital for such instances. In more severe cases, arrest might be a suitable option (Teplin 2000:9). However, on the other hand, police officers might adopt a different approach to the situation, resulting in the use of informal methods. For example, mentally ill individuals are divided into three categories: neighborhood characters, troublemakers and quiet, unobtrusive “mentals” (Teplin 2000:9). When an...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critically analyse the problems involved in Police use of discretion for FREE!

Contact Us