StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Biotechnology and the Environment: Navigating the Uneasy Tensions of WTO-Mandated Trade and Environmental Protection - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
This research aims to cover the depth and breadth of the nexus between the environment and trade where biotechnology is concerned and to demonstrate that the relationship is a complex one – fraught with tensions and imbalances. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Biotechnology and the Environment: Navigating the Uneasy Tensions of WTO-Mandated Trade and Environmental Protection
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Biotechnology and the Environment: Navigating the Uneasy Tensions of WTO-Mandated Trade and Environmental Protection"

Download file to see previous pages The contentious processes leading up to the general agreements will be traced. The second part will look at the legal debates and issues arising from biotechnology, in chief the conflict between the “precautionary principle” and the “science-based” principle, with the end in view of identifying the direction that biotechnology will be taking in the future. The third part will be a legal analysis on the notion of liability and redress, as framed by the recently concluded Nagoya-Kuala Lumpur Supplementary Protocol on Liability and Redress to the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety. Creating a legal framework for biotechnology amidst a WTO-driven international trade regime: Tensions and uneasy concessions Biotechnology in its simplest and most straightforward definition is the modification of the genetic make-up of natural organisms to serve human use, consumption and exploitation. A popular example of biotechnology is the “golden rice” which involves genetic modification for the purported purpose of introducing more nutrients and vitamins, particularly Vitamin A. The genetic manipulation facilitates the production of carotenoids in the grain’s endosperm, thus giving it the yellow hue that gave rise to its name. (Paine, et. al., 2005: 482). Another example is the BT corn, which genetically modifies corn crops to protect it from predatory pests such as caterpillars. It is impossible to look at biotechnology without looking at the social backdrop on which it is foisted. According to Kloppenburg and Burrows (2001): In the United States, some 75 percent of all research and development is now undertaken by private industry. Worldwide, companies such as Monsanto, Novartis, DuPont, Aventis, AstraZeneca and Unilever have the almost...
This paper tells that there are very few areas where the tensions between trade and environmental protection are as clearly cut than in biotechnology. Because these tensions are set against the current backdrop of increasing liberalization and environmental degradation, the need to adequately address these tensions and strike a balance becomes urgent and compelling. Biotechnology is perceived by different people in different ways. For some, they are indications of science gone mad – the commodification of everything, of even the most basic and fundamental processes of nature. For others, it is a triumph of human innovation, an example of humankind’s superior knowledge over other organisms in the eco-system. The picture becomes even more complicated when the dispute in perspective is not North-South, but North-North, with Europe holding on to its “precautionary approach” in dealing with the issue of biotechnology and the United States maintaining that the European approach violates treade rules and that a science-based assessment approach remains more consistent with legal commitments to liberalization. The World Trade Organization has endeavoured to come up with a regulatory legal regime to govern trade in biotechnology to ensure that biosafety standards are in place and that biodiversity and ecology are not compromised. There are two particular decisions in WTO jurisprudence that bear upon this conflict: the beef hormone controversy, which began before the Cartagena Protocol, and the biotechnology crops, which was decided under the international law regime of the Cartagena Protocol.


...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Biotechnology and the Environment: Navigating the Uneasy Tensions of Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1391343-biotechnology-and-the-environment-navigating-the-uneasy-tensions-of-wto-mandated-trade-and-environmental-protection
(Biotechnology and the Environment: Navigating the Uneasy Tensions of Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1391343-biotechnology-and-the-environment-navigating-the-uneasy-tensions-of-wto-mandated-trade-and-environmental-protection.
“Biotechnology and the Environment: Navigating the Uneasy Tensions of Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1391343-biotechnology-and-the-environment-navigating-the-uneasy-tensions-of-wto-mandated-trade-and-environmental-protection.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
ve
veumpaul added comment 2 years ago
Student rated this paper as
At first, I thought 18 of pages is too much for such a question. But now I see it could not be done better. As the author starts you see the complexity of the topic. I’ve read all at once. Perfect paper

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Biotechnology and the Environment: Navigating the Uneasy Tensions of WTO-Mandated Trade and Environmental Protection

The Current Protection in England and Wales

Vis-a-vis the burden of the prosecution of proving the elements of the offense, there is the set of human rights to which the suspect is entitled and which must be respected by the police having custody of the suspect. These human rights range from the investigation stage to that of the trial stage of the criminal prosecution process and are provided partly by the conventions of the Human Rights Act of 1998. [The Stationery Office, 1998]
There is a great difference in law between the fundamental rights and liberties of individuals and the enforceability of rights and safeguards. The safeguards could only be made available through legislation and the provision of sufficient resources to give meaning thereto as well as make the...
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Proposal

International Trade Theory

 Further to this, it is also believed that international trade can bring substantial economic welfare to the countries however still most of the countries do not view it as a favorable thing. Despite having a very promising and bright outlook, international trade has been largely viewed with suspension and it is because of this that governments impose barriers to restrict international trade. There can be many reasons behind this act of imposing restrictions or blocking international trade however there are also benefits on the other side too.

International trade has driven the attention of many of the brilliant minds in economics therefore the origins of the economic theory on international trade owe much to the c...
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Political Ideologies and the Environment

Man has lost touch with the environment to gather his own empirical evidence, study it vis-à-vis the knowledge handed him down the generations and make his independent judgment. Thus his thinking process is chained to the scientific and economic superstructure.
The early part of the twentieth century saw the emergence of the knowledge society. The transmission of knowledge propels social and economic change. Out of the knowledge, society grew the energy-guzzling and environmentally unfriendly consumer society. On the vestiges of consumer society now emerges the anxiety-laden risk fraught society Man, the main protagonist, knows little of his importance and is in haste to accomplish things, knowing-well the risk fraught...
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

The Trade Union Movement in the UK

Before the ERA 1999, union membership and recognition in the UK were characterized by voluntarism, in which employers and employees could bargain over the terms and conditions of employment without any legal interference. With the statutory system ushered in by the new law, voluntary recognition of unions is no longer allowed and it becomes unlawful for British employers to deny recognition to unions under any circumstances. That conveys the impression that ERA created a radical change in British industrial relations. This paper takes the contrary view, however, and proposes that while the new industrial relations law looks revolutionary in principle, there are no fundamental changes in actuality for the change to qualify as &ldqu...
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Managerial Economics and Business Environment

Once the above said subject matter is clearly sorted out, the next emphasis would be on the concepts like the opportunity costing, incremental principle, marginal principle, discounting principle, the principle of time perspective, and calculation of economic profit as the guidelines to the scope of managerial economics. (Surender. V, 2008).
To start with, we consider a firm for which different processes have to be carried to achieve its objectives of profit maximization (assuming that all the organizations work with the view to maximize profits). If firms from different sectors are identified simultaneously, then the working of the economy as a whole could also be analyzed which in turn is useful in the decision-making proce...
15 Pages (3750 words) Assignment

Internal and External Environmental Analysis for the Bakery Business

Liberalization of foreign investment and technology policy of the government is supportive of establishing industrial units in the country.

Threat: The UK food regulatory authority is planning to enforce the EC Regulations relating to food labeling. The labeling requirements under the new regulations will affect the food industry as the suppliers will be legally obliged to disclose the GM content of foods to the caterers. Thus business firms in the bakery industry also will be effected through the exclusion of flexible manner of labeling arrangements in the case of flour confectionery involving GM Soya or maize. (Genetically modified and novel foods (labeling) (England) regulations, 2000).

Trend: The new subs...
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

U.S. Environmental Protection

Recycling is one of the proposed methods to counteract pollution and danger being posted by the accumulation of wastes in the environment. Although this is the case, there are benefits and drawbacks in the said process. Included in the benefits are reduction of different types of wastes gas emissions (e.g. green gases) and water wastes; reduction of the discarded materials due to the manufacture of new materials; and the production of materials from used products. As a result, jobs are also created thus contributing to the economy (“Benefits and Drawbacks of Recycling” Think Quest).

In terms of the drawbacks, one of the main issues is the needed resources and expenses which continuously increase due to the i...
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Organisations in the Engineering and Technology Environment: Singapore Airlines

In those days, just three flights per week, to Kuala Lumpur, Ipoh, and Penang, were all that the people in Singapore were privileged to. There were very fast developments in the situation in a span of two decades. During this period, Singapore’s Kallang Airport gained international exposure and started making huge additions to its fleet. Soon after the birth of the Federation of Malaysia on February 1963, the Malayan Airlines came to be known as the Malaysian Airlines, and in 1966, it was renamed the Malaysian-Singapore Airlines. But, in 1972, fifteen years from the day it was founded, Singapore Airlines split up with Malaysian Airlines and acquired a separate identity.
This split, however, helped the airlines to take i...
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Macroeconomics and Trade Policys

Keynes argued that prices and wages do not determine the level of employment, as many classical economists suggested, but instead the level of aggregate demand for goods and services (Case & Fair 683). Keynes realized as well during the Great Depression that the government could intervene in the economy to attain specific employment and output goals by either increasing or decreasing taxes and government spending.

For example, raising taxes will decrease the disposable income of households and thus effectively decreasing consumption. When the government decreases consumption, the household demand for goods and services decreases thus it would only seem reasonable that the amount of output that the economy would also...
7 Pages (1750 words) Article

Ethics in the Manufacturing Environment

An ethical scenario arose during my first six months in this management role involving a 21-year-old employee who I witnessed smoking pot in the parking lot over lunch break. This scenario demanded that I consider the needs of the employee, as well as satisfying my obligations for enforcing the strict drug use policy administered at the senior levels of the company. This project describes the ethical scenario in detail, offering personal reflections on the incident as well as suggesting an ethical framework for handling situations like this in the future.
The situation which occurred had a young worker smoking pot on his lunch break on the company grounds. This, according to policy, is a termination offense and it is expected...
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Biotechnology and the Environment: Navigating the Uneasy Tensions of WTO-Mandated Trade and Environmental Protection for FREE!

Contact Us