Nobody downloaded yet

An analysis of Animal Experimentation articles - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Appendix B An analysis of Animal Experimentation articles 1. Identify if the topic you chose—as presented by both articles—is a problem or an issue, and explain what makes it a problem or an issue. If you believe the articles present both problems and issues, identify and explain what the problems are and what the issues are…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
An analysis of Animal Experimentation articles
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "An analysis of Animal Experimentation articles"

Download file to see previous pages The presented arguments by the doctors and research scientists (two experts in their field) indicate that this is a subject that divides opinion between informed, intelligent people. The clear issue in the debate revolves around morality and whether animal experimentation is necessary to safeguard human beings against potentially harmful new drugs and practices in medicine, and is vehemently supported by both sides. 2. Were the problems or issues expressed effectively? Describe how the problems or issues were or were not best expressed. The two articles vary on their ability to express the issues effectively. Lankford uses the article to defend the position of support towards animal experimentation. In this manner, the article does not address the issue but just seems to provide a list of statistics to prove his point. The work highlights a number of animal research achievements and how it has led to the prevention of disease but does not suggest any form of resolution of the issue. The Carlson article does attempt to resolve the issues. The work discusses that “we can learn to improve public health by looking first at what threatens it” (Carlson), indicating a willingness to seek a resolution. This viewpoint also acknowledges that it is vital to keep questioning forms of medicine and that it can be beneficial to look at the argument from different perspectives. 3. How would you determine the credibility of the sources of information used by the authors in the articles when investigating the problems or issues presented by your topic? The two articles appear to be fairly reliable and credible sources of information regarding the animal experimentation debate. The first, written by Lankford, was written for the Foundation for Biomedical Research. The group is in favor of animal experimentation and use medical facts and statistics to back up their claims. The author is clearly knowledgeable, although the article does not highlight his position in the organization. The second article is an expert opinion in the field of research science. Her work contrasts with the first, emphasizing that the results of animal experimentation have been grossly misjudged. Carlson relies on findings from University studies and medical journals to persuade her audience. In terms of credibility, both articles appear to be so, though Carlson does provide sources for the statistics used whereas Lankford states facts such using language such as “between 1950 and 2004” (Lankford) but fails to ascertain where they come from. 4. Compare two steps that would be most effective in refining solutions to the problem and resolutions to the issues presented by your topic. The animal experimentation debate is saddled with a number of issues concerning morality and ethics. For animal experimentation to be proven necessary and useful to society, it appears that more clear research and positive results are needed that link the success of medical improvements to the need to test them on animals. The main difficulties to overcome are the beliefs surrounding animal cruelty which animal extremist groups chiefly use as their main argument against animal experimentation. These groups will perhaps never be persuaded as to the benefits of animal experimentation but scholars such as Carlson indicates that there is no proof that animal testing is necessary to ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“An analysis of Animal Experimentation articles Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1432018-appendix-b
(An Analysis of Animal Experimentation Articles Essay)
https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1432018-appendix-b.
“An Analysis of Animal Experimentation Articles Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1432018-appendix-b.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF An analysis of Animal Experimentation articles

Should animal be used for experimentation

...? Animals Should be Used for Experimentation Number and Number Number of Words: 502 Introduction Animals such as rats, mice, birds and frogs are often used as a subject when medical experts and scientists conduct experiments. After using these animals in experimentation, these animals are euthanized through intravenous injection with either a high dosage of sodium thiopental1, isoflurane2, or pentobarbital3. To shorten the painful death of animals used in experimentation, these two types of drugs could make the animals fall unconscious followed by a cardiac arrest. The use of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Can animal experimentation be justified

...?Can Animal Experimentation Be Justified? Introduction Do humans have inherent right to cause suffering to other forms of life to better our predicament? Is it morally right to experiment on animals just to develop products and medicines that would help humans? These are controversies circulating around animal experimentation. In 2009, Dixon delineates justifications from the pros and cons groups. The pros argued that animal experimentation results in an important medical breakthrough that will reduce human suffering and death; a good example of this is the experimentation on mice regarding the role of penicillin in fighting bacterial infections (Paul, 4). It can be used as well to promote interests and welfare of animals... such as...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Should Animal Experimentation Be Permitted

...a teratogenic effect by affecting the development of unborn children causing major loss of human life. Universal declaration of animal rights states, “Experiments on animals entailing physical or psychological suffering violates the rights of animals” (Action against Poisoning Article 8(a)). There have been activisms globally relating to animal rights, which are against unnecessary animal experimentation (Graph, Tom). This would be grounds for not allowing testing, as animals are subjected to multiple surgeries, long periods without food or water, and are kept away from other human contact; however, this...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Animal Experimentation

...October 17th Animal Experimentation The issue of animal testing draws some strong sentiments aimed at thebenefits and demerits of the practice. For this reason, this paper aims at examining the available attitudes relating to animal testing and the measure that should be taken to treat animals humanely. Animal testing should be conducted following its immense health benefits towards humans in relation to assisting preterm babies and children. In this light, animal experiments have helped to come up with a solution to ensure that preterm babies survive despite their weak bodies and health. This is due to experiments...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Animal Experimentation

...?Abdulaziz Alzahrani (Aziz) EAP 150 Dr. Sara Schwab December 3rd, Animal Experimentation During the second century, Galen, a Greek physician known as the father of vivisection, conducted one of the early experiments on animals when he digested a pig to describe the spinal cord and the brain functions. In the 1620s, William Harvey, an English physician, conducted his well-known experiment on animals, which was considered later to be the first experiment to provide a full demonstration of blood circulation. The William Harvey’s experiment empowered the use of animals in medical investigation by showing the significance of vivisection in comparative...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Animal Experimentation

...ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATION (A CRITICAL ANALYSIS) Introduction: The practice of testing on animals goes back many centuries. In A.D 100's, a Greek physician Galen proved that veins carry blood and not air as it was previously believed. This event was recorded as the first known use of animals in medical research. Today, animals are still being experimented for a variety of reasons. For example, they are used to test new drugs and medical procedures, which determine whether it is beneficial to humans, or harmful. Other uses include learning the harmful effects of a new product such as a cosmetic, food additive, or an insecticide. Some people...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Experimentation

...Experimentation as Means of Discovery Throughout the ages, experimentation has been used by many as a way to make new discoveries. The use of experimentation is used to validate the previously spoken hypothesis by either proving, or disproving, that which was spoken to begin with. The most common usage of experimentation is performed by those who are in the sciences as a stepping stone towards instrumental innovations, such as the creation of medicines and vaccines to heal the ailing and sick. It is these sorts of experiments which have enabled countless people to live happier and more prosperous lives throughout the ages. In keeping with the idea of scientific study,...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Why Animal Experimentation Should be Banned

...Why Animal Experimentation Should be Banned Introduction With the help of many different animal species, science has made significant inroads into combating some major diseases. However, it has all been without the animals’ consent, and it has not been without significant cost to human lives as well as millions of animals’ lives. In this report I will discuss scientific and ethical reasons against the use of animals in scientific experiments and will show that in the face of overwhelming evidence, such practices should be discontinued. There are two main categories of animal experimentation. The...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Vaccine Experimentation

...Much of what is currently done in vaccine production is based upon years of research on immunology using mouse models. As scientists soon discovered with the advent of highly sophisticated laboratory equipment and techniques, this misrepresent the processes that underlie the human immune response against diseases. As well, laboratories also do not share findings in the community for fears of their patents being stolen. This limits the potential exponential vaccine development. Moreover, our current vaccines have been limited to using just the humoral immunity and subsequently treating just infectious diseases. What about the lifestyle diseases such as cardiovascular problems that causes most of the worldwide mortality nowadays... of what is...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Scientific Experimentation & Animal Welfare

...in its natural environment. Hence, it is not unexpected that nearly all researchers of animal behavior argue that investigations of the animal in its natural environment are a must, or at best a required supplement to, controlled laboratory research of animal behavior (Nienaber 32). Unfortunately, primatology has, in several regards, endured a history of division between laboratory or experimental researchers and field researchers. This, partly, is because of the disagreement over the observation of behaviors which are manifested differently in unnatural and natural environments (Carpenter 12). The generally contrasting perspectives and models of some laboratory...
8 Pages(2000 words)Admission/Application Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic An analysis of Animal Experimentation articles for FREE!

Contact Us