Complete Analysis of the Book The Name of the Rose - Movie Review Example

The of the Rose The of the Rose Although based in 1323, the book discusses in detail the various aspects of science and other realms in life. The movie discusses science in detail. For instance, the librarian hides the books that question the authority of the church, such as Aristotle’s Comedy. Such books have existed since medieval times. However, scientists were perceptibly lost individuals since they were questioning the church's authority and the truth it holds. Science has different views from the church; hence, such books were kept as far away from people as possible, as they would bring about confusion.

Such books are preserved in the forbidden library, as they would question the authority of the church. One of the key ways through which Umberto Eco compares Brother Williams to Sherlock Holmes is through the assessment of the murders of the monks. In the contemporary setting, Sherlock Holmes was a brilliant detective who understood the inner workings of various aspects of the killers. Williams was able to think outside the box and as well, solve mysterious deaths that no one else would have solved.

1 Using such an approach, although Brother William was not a detective by nature, his ability to see through crime in a way that most people would not make him more like Sherlock Holmes. Bringing in the concept of the supernatural, such as demons, also makes this film more like Sherlock Holmes, as the detective was on a mysterious island, whose inner workings were unclear to humans, but were more of a supernatural nature. Reason is the key strategy of any investigation. Bearing in mind that most people do not have a clue on the inner workings of a murder case, because they have little, if any connection with the murderer, using reason is one of the ways through which such mysteries can be solved.

Brother Williams was willing to reason and see beyond the trees, to view the forest. In short, he used the various simple details of a case to create a hypothetical bigger picture, which was much closer to the actual truth. The book is very educational, highly intuitive and a suspense-filled packet of knowledge.