StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Randel and Puglisi - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Randel and Puglisi" gives different accounts of the journey of John Smith, his attempts to woe the Indians and put them under King James I and the historical interaction with the native King of Powhatan Indian who was referred to as Wahunsonnacoc
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
Randel and Puglisi
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Randel and Puglisi"

RANDEL AND PUGLISI The articles give an overview of the genesis of European journey into the new lands of America which wasinhabited by the Native Indians. There has been significant challenge in validating the various accounts given by historical works on the approach and tactics used by Englishmen to conquer the Natives. It has been indicated that when the whites entered America, there were people living there as native Indians with a fully functional socio-economic and political structure under chieftaincy. At the centre of America exploration by English me is John smith who wrote several books thereafter in regard to his experience and reaction towards the native Indians that lived in America before its colonization by Britain. The two articles give different accounts of the journey of John smith, his attempts to woe the Indians and put them under King James I and the historic interaction with the native King of Powhatan Indian who was referred to as Wahunsonnacoc (William, 1939). Randel and Puglisi give contradicting accounts on some aspects but converge ideologically in other sections. Critical analysis of Puglisi article shows that the arrival of James Smith was coupled with hidden motives of confusing the Wahunsonnacoc to enter a peaceful agreement with England authorities under the guise of trade. It is however, clearly indicated that this Chief was also witty and outsmarted several attempts of John Smith in many occasions.
Puglisi demonstrates that Wahunsonnacoc had priorities that included expansion of his kingdom at the time James Smith arrived in Jamestown and accepted the trade gesture. This narration shows the extent of established government structure and organized social form of the native Indians. Puglisi gives a chronological order of events and discusses the progressive interaction between Wahunsonnacoc and James Smith until Captain Christopher Newport comes into the picture. On the other hand, Randel emphasizes the perception of John Smith towards the Indians. He gives a shallow detail on how John Smith interacted with the chief who controlled the existing native Indian Kingdom by that time (Michael, 1991). He rather emphasizes the experiences of John Smith in captivity with limited information on the socio-political significance attached to such an episode to the native Indians. Randel gives much attention to the view of John Smith as a sympathizer to the Native Indians after they were overwhelmed and colonized by the British. He focuses much on James town but fails to give a detailed order of event with particular involvement of the native chieftaincy during the colonization attempts.
There is significant line of similarity as far as the concept of ethno history is addressed by Randel and Puglisi. Evident misinterpretation between the John Smith as the Englishmen agent and the native chief Wahunsonnacoc seems to underlies the interaction of the two groups. Each side is presented as having planned agenda with significant deviation and battle for superiority. The two articles note that John Smith realized that the Native Indians were an organized lot with significant level of ancient civilization and were not easy to colonize without war. The two articles present John Smith as very tricky and a political schemer who survived the wrath of captivity but wittingly lured the native Indians to the bait of British colonialist at the reign of King James I
References
Michael J. Puglisi. EducationCapt. John Smith, Pocahontas and a Clash of Cultures: A Case for the EthnohistoricalPerspective. The History Teacher, Vol. 25, No. 1 (Nov., 1991), pp. 97-103
William Randel. Captain John Smiths Attitudes toward the Indians. The Virginia Magazine of History and Biography, Vol. 47, No. 3 (Jul., 1939), pp. 218-229 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Randel and Puglisi Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Randel and Puglisi Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1647085-randel-and-puglisi
(Randel and Puglisi Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Randel and Puglisi Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1647085-randel-and-puglisi.
“Randel and Puglisi Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1647085-randel-and-puglisi.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Randel and Puglisi

Works of Ben Franklin and John Smith

...that Native Americans’ support is very crucial for establishing the settlement, Smith did not go on the offensive against them and instead tried establishing cordial relations with them. “Realizing that the very existence of the colony depended on peace, he never thought of trying to exterminate the natives…In his writings, Smith reveals the attitudes behind his actions” (Randel, 1939). At the same time, in the journal, The Generall Historie, Smith viewed some of the Native Americans particularly a Chief of a Native American tribe negatively. That is, he compared Chief Powhatan to a “devil”, and even referred the Native Americans as “barbarians”. However, on the whole, he had good relationship with them and wrote how...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Conceptualizing a Business

...? BUSINESS STRATEGY: CONCEPTUALIZING A BUSINESS Doll Beverage Company Limited is a non-alcoholic drinks manufacturing company. Its introduction into the beverage manufacturing industry starts from the conceptualization stage. The concept of business conceptualization is the most crucial step during the formation of a company. Every firm entering into the business arena should communicate its philosophies to the participants and stakeholders in the market. The act of conceptualizing an entity is essential in creating a link between the consumers’ ideas and those of the service or product providers. The current business environment comprises of firms and organization offering different kinds of products and services (John &...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Impacts of the Housing Crisis

...of their crisis experiencing frequent increase in the housing prices. The sellers too could not embark on picking house loans from banks. Moreover, the banks could not lend loan to this house owners because they were also affected. The financial crisis also posed a threat to the banks in that they could not be assured that the loaned would be able to pay the loan at the required time (Randel 5). Housing crisis has not only affected the homeowners but also the young children. These young children reside in these houses together with their families and guardians. Being highly dependent on their parents and guardian, children are vulnerable too. If parents are affected by the financial crisis, this means it will have a...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Business Strategy: Conceptualizing a Business

...different kinds of products and services (John & Randel, 2010). It is evident that researchers have attempted all explorations concerning the consumers’ needs that fit the modern times. Introduction and adoption of capitalism presented a new are of free enterprise. This led to the aspect of competition among product manufacturers and service providers. In this context, there was the establishment of many companies manufacturing the same product type and providing similar services. In this case, it is fundamental that every company defines itself in a unique manner that differentiates it from its competitors. Therefore, entry of a new business firm into the market requires thorough execution of the conceptualization step....
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Leviathan by Thomas Hobbes

5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Video report

..., the instrument used in a section of rhythm varies depending on the style used and the era (Randel, 560). Just by Myself was a jazz lyric and so instruments used had each and every role in portraying its band. Although, most of the instruments used in the music played major roles in backing up some part of the songs, some provided other musical importance. It is a norm for some instruments used in music to play soloistic roles in a given event or even play a melodic role. They prominently framed the music well as they provided background music for the singers. This makes them to be valued in the music concert as they, also, underpinned for the good performance. In the song, therefore, drums played by Art Blackey supplied...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Foreign aid

...countries for their survival. Randel & German (2013) say that multilateral aid is the aid offered by other organizations such as financial institutions, associations and agencies to needy countries. Third world countries have been seen to acquire a lot of multi-lateral aid from institutions such as World Bank, IMF, amongst others. From the chart, the aid, the need for aid rises by the day. In Africa, the forms of Foreign in Aid range from loan assistance, emergency relief assistance such as drought, health assistance, food, water, technological assistance However, the status of Africa is worsening. Africa comprises of the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC). This relates to issues such as poor governance from...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Compare and Contrast the traditional music of India with the traditional music of Korea

...was not altered by Arabian culture unlike Hindustani music, which embraced evident Persian and Arab influences from the ruling Muslim kings in the Northern states of India (“Carnatic music”). In 13th century Carnatic music localized in the Southern part of India and developed there a significant music culture (Randel, ed.). Carnatic music was quite diverse, but it utilized the main elements of Indian music which were sruti, swara, tala and raga. Out of these elements, sruti was defined as a musical pitch, and swara was the repetition of the same note; raga was a specific interchange of ascending and descending parts of the melody, and tala was a fixed rhythmic scale (Randel, ed.). Carnatic music was...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Comparison between Under the Glacier by Halldor laxness and the movie 2001: A Space Odyssey

4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

North American Music

...of extraordinary value possessed a spirit element, and more so sacred were regalia and obsidian blades. Getting wealth and maintaining the status that came with it were central to North Americans thoughts and consciousness. The rich men did not labor but spent most of the time in their homes making ceremonial costumes and arrows which they sold at a high cost. Feasts, ceremonies, and dances could not be held without the inclusion the ceremonial regalia that are owned by the rich. It was a hard and tedious job assembling the many scalps and skins that some pieces needed, but the effect was striking. In public ceremonies they were dazzling; they were prized for their uniqueness and beauty and the wealth they symbolized...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Randel and Puglisi for FREE!

Contact Us