Free

A response paper, make the topic creative - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Susan Reverby has made her name as an historian who takes overly simplistic tales, such as the Tuskegee experiments in which black men were un or undertreated for late-stage syphilis, without their knowledge, while being told that they were being treated as fully as possible…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
A response paper, make the topic creative
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "A response paper, make the topic creative"

Prof’s Escaping the Melodrama, Avoiding Under ment Susan Reverby has made her as an historian who takes overly simplistic tales, such as the Tuskegee experiments in which black men were un or undertreated for late-stage syphilis, without their knowledge, while being told that they were being treated as fully as possible. Her work has attempted to undermine the melodrama of the events while getting at the true history of what has happened. Her primary method of doing this is humanizing all people involved, showing each of them as fully developed human being with their own lives, passions, interests, and agency, while attempting to break down the victim-monster narrative that had been developed. Her challenge, however, is to do so without seeming to minimize the horror of what happened at Tuskegee.
One of the most important aspects of her research is the focus on actually interviewing and interacting, to the degree possible, with people involved with the experiments. She does this to reduce the melodrama involved with the reporting and understanding of these events. In a lecture at Loyola University, she powerfully explains the why this is important. Melodrama, she says, is a story in which the characters “aren’t important” – they are an afterthought used to “fill in the gaps,” while in a drama, the characters are central (Reverby Lecture 2012). Historians, she says, should write drama. The problem with melodrama is that it reduces everyone involved to set pieces. In a historical context, this obstructs retellings of the true history, but possibly more importantly, it makes the melodramatic experience seem exceptional, and obfuscates its connection to societal constructs of oppression. She rejects the idea that melodrama is all that could be had of an experience such as this. She powerfully states her aim in the opening of her work, Examining Tuskegee, where she asserts that “there are truths here [in Tuskegee] – facts that fit the evidence better than do others” (Reverby 9).
One such fact, for instance, patients eventually did get treatments – just not enough of them. It turned from a story of non-treatment to “under treatment” (Reverby 117). Why is this important? Under-treatment of othered people, she argues, is incredibly normative. It happens all the time. Thus, by treating the Tuskegee experiments as some sort of horrific monstrosity, the commonality of aspects of what happened there are lost, so the focus is on the exceptional horrific problem than the very common, barely less horrific one. Furthermore, melodramatic treatment of the Tuskegee narrative robs many of those involved from agency. When the black men are treated as hapless victims, it in fact reinforces oppressive views of black people. By recognizing that some of them “could and did escape” the experiments (Reverby 83), Reverby forcefully refutes the image of the helpless black victim that so many otherwise well meaning whites have used to further push down black people. Her challenge, of course, is to write this true history, which will necisarrily be less horrific (in sensationalist ways, at least) than the melodramatic narrative, without seeming to be trying to soften the horror at what actually occurred.
Reverby’s work is the pinnacle of scholarship. She recognizes her own positionality, and tries, as much as possible, to treat all of the participants in the story she writes as fully fledged humans, to recognize how such horrific events could come to pass. Thus, by putting truth above showmanship, she hopes to get at the actual events of historical tragedies such as the Tuskegee experiments, undermining and deconstructing the melodrama that surrounds such events, and treating its participants as real humans rather than hapless victims or evil monsters. This does not reduce the vitriolic distaste she shows for perpetrators of such evil experiments – it makes the vitriol more reasonable, however.
Works Cited
Reverby, Susan. Examining Tuskegee. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. 2009. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A response paper, make the topic creative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
A response paper, make the topic creative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1610636-a-response-paper-make-the-topic-creative
(A Response Paper, Make the Topic Creative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
A Response Paper, Make the Topic Creative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1610636-a-response-paper-make-the-topic-creative.
“A Response Paper, Make the Topic Creative Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1610636-a-response-paper-make-the-topic-creative.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A response paper, make the topic creative

How have archaeologists' attempts to interpret sex and gender relations in the past changed over the last thirty years

vii). However, this is the core problem with the way in which cultures have been framed through Western belief systems, thus making assumptions about the way that sex and gender are considered within those societies subject to modern standards of understanding. It is important to re-examine the nature of social structures that have been determined through biased assumptions in order to better construct a picture of an ancient societies. Studying Gender through Archaeological Inquiry In studying gender, Gilchrist states (1999, p. x), “gender is revealed as a metaphor for relations between men and women: gender is an expression of social practice and beliefs about sexual difference”. The nature of defining social structures through...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Reading Responses to Literacy in Three Metaphors, Writing Healing Introduction and Strategies

...to come to a deeper understanding of literacy along with its more important definition types. With such information now available to me, I feel that I will be a more effective educator in the future because I will know how to use the various types of literacy to help my students learn their lessons. The scholarly information contained within the pages of this research can easily be used by any educator to help make his teaching life easier. it also leaves academicians with room to research more modern definitions and usages of the term literacy. Should I feel the need to do further research on the topic in the future, I am sure that I will be able to use this article by Scribner as an excellent...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

Creative Paper

...the emotion of fear at least, does originate in the brain According to my research which builds upon the research of others, fear in particular, the human body begins to show the external physical signs of fear such as sweaty palms, muscle tension and a queasy stomach even before the individual is consciously aware of fear. This suggests definitively that the emotional response of fear is hard wired into the brain, so that with the onset of the emotion the external symptoms manifest themselves. Against: A member of the public: The proposition that the brain is linked to emotion does not appear to have much merit. Emotions in individuals are so wide ranging; moreover people tend to respond differently to the same kind of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

(help me make the topic)

...expenditure, investment expenditure, government expenditure and net exports. There is therefore a positive relationship between a government expenditure and economic growth (Stefan and Magnus 1510). However, researchers have had different views on this subject. According to by Richard Rahn, government spending lead to increased economic growth up to some optimal level above which the economy begins to contract. Proponents of the Rahn curve theory suggest that optimal government expenditure should be between 15% and 25% of GDP (Surhone, Tennoe, Henssonow 10). In a study comparing the Anglo-American Model and European Models, James, Robert and Randall (20) studies the impact of government structure and size on economic development. The...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Proposal

Help me make a topic

...countries. These countries have opened up their economies, leading to free flow of goods, resulting to commerce. There are four basic elements of globalization, namely transactions and trade, migration of people and their movements, capital movement and investments, and dissemination of knowledge (Caporaso and Mary, 33). Basing on this background, this paper analyzes the globalization of coffee in its early stages of globalization. That is the periods of 1960s and 1970s. Coffee was introduced in African, Asia and some parts of America by the colonialists. During this period, colonial governments grew the product in their colonies for purposes of satisfying their domestic markets. For example, the British introduced...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Help me make a topic

...this continent. Africa is special case as the effects of globalization can be observed vividly, in the past, present and unfortunately, in the future. All of which does cast ominous shadows on the overall modern globalization. Another thing that makes Africa a special case for contemporary globalization is the fact that many of the African states have never really enjoyed sovereignty (Kieh 98). The term Parenti uses relentlessly in his book is ‘catastrophic convergence’, and it similar to the tactics that were used in 1984 in India. Allegedly, the deliberate leakage of MIC from an American pesticide plant in Bhopal, India, left almost half a million people dead. There are rumors that it was a done on...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

You can make a topic

...the ethical aspects of the person and other things like land and animals which are relevant parts of the life of people. This means that people are likely participate in the different ways that violates the rights of the land and animals without getting subjected to any law (Leopold 163-164). Leopold (165) argue ethics is a guide that should dictate the behavior of people when they are interacting with other parts of the ecology in which they live and exploit to have their livelihood. According to him for example, land ethic makes Homo sapiens just members in the ecology as opposed to his conquering position in which he may take advantage of other individuals in the society. This means that people cannot exploit the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

You can make a topic

...to the environment. It is obvious that mechanized farming is not beneficial since it does more harm than good but efforts to indulge in agro ecology are also greatly suppressed in many ways including the government. The need to make money and the intensive advertisements by huge agrochemical corporations is really hindering farmers from adopting the best style of farming that is environmental friendly. Farming can be done in a way that animals and crops grown mutually benefit each other without inclusion of chemicals and fertilizers which are harmful to the environment such as planting cover crops, crop rotation and use of farm yard manure. The size of land does also not support crop rotation and generally the whole...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Revise Paper

... and language, which includes grammar, punctuation and stylistic analysis of the text. What helps is when the writer starts looking at a topic from different angles to get to the right ideas, hence the final draft. By making a conclusion I would like to say that creative requires balancing between one’s inner thoughts and ideas and they way those ideas are expressed via language. Writers inner voice should embodied in text by transferring precise idea using stylistically rich and grammatically correct language... Rattanakorn Ramasoot Writing 110 10pm 3 September Rose and Lamott Response Paper Based on the ideas and views presented by Mike Rose on writing rules that seem to handicap the writers in their work,...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Make a topic for me

... Critical review: Breaking the Chains of Psychological Slavery Na’im Akbar s in his book that “One of the things that helps us correct our problems naturally, is an understanding that though we have great strength, we also have real limitations. One of the things that lets human beings come back to balance, is a realization that there are things that naturally limit them”. The book “Breaking the Chains of Psychological Slavery” takes the reader through a discussion of the continuing detrimental effects of the slave trade and slave ownership on the African American community. The author, who is a notable scholar and instructor of clinical psychology, touches on important constraints that are keeping the African American community... Critical...
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic A response paper, make the topic creative for FREE!

Contact Us