StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Why Detaining terrorist in Guantanamo Bay was against American Philosophy - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Cmdr. Swift’s opinion is that the sole purpose of Guantanamo Bay is providing physical and mental torture to the detained terrorists; while, torture is just against American philosophy (Bonsignore and Katsh). The lawyer, Charles, Swift, was assigned the defense of a…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Why Detaining terrorist in Guantanamo Bay was against American Philosophy
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Why Detaining terrorist in Guantanamo Bay was against American Philosophy"

Your full December 6, Why detaining terrorists in Guantanamo Bay was against American philosophy?
Lt. Cmdr. Swift’s opinion is that the sole purpose of Guantanamo Bay is providing physical and mental torture to the detained terrorists; while, torture is just against American philosophy (Bonsignore and Katsh). The lawyer, Charles, Swift, was assigned the defense of a detainee during which, seeing how the American philosophy and the rule of law was being violated, “sued the president and secretary of defense over the new military-tribunal system”, Brenner writes in her article. Swift saw the torture his client had been going through. Salim Ahmad Hamdan, a diminutive Yemeni who had been detained in Guantanamo Bay for more than five years, was kept in a tiny room kept cold with air conditioning, while he had nothing proper to cover himself, not even a pair of socks. Swift shared his thoughts with his partner law professor, Neal Katyal, who had been preparing legal briefs on the matter of President Bushs military tribunals. Katyal made his own efforts in writing drafts for the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeals trying to figure out what the Department of Defense was going to include in the new guidelines for the Guantanamo Bay detainees. Although the Supreme Court declared the military tribunals as illegal, still Congress protested and passed its own ruling regarding the secluded Guantanamo. This was a defeat of American philosophy. So, the lawyers, Swift and Katyal, decided to challenge Congress.
Why detaining terrorists in Guantanamo Bay is against the American philosophy has many fair reasons. It is not legal in any case, according to human rights, to deprive a prisoner of war of his legal right of either being tried or released if proved innocent. The detainees at Guantanamo Bay are neither tried nor released, and they do not even know why they have been brought there and kept in brutal torture. Detainees have been held in Guantanamo Bay without charge for more than five years many of whom have been subjected to severe abuses. This has significantly torn apart American reputation of war. Guantanamo has become an epitome of lawlessness in the eyes of the whole world. American philosophy has enabled the United States to stand among one of the strongest democracies which support human rights and which make other nations comply with the international standards of human rights and humanitarian laws. But now, even the allies of the Bush’s administration are looking at Guantanamo policy as a failure and violation of American philosophy of war and human rights. Carafano and Rona state that:
That the administration’s defenders are now arguing that those who seek compliance with the laws, including the treaties the United States has promised to uphold, are somehow engaging in a kind of assymetric warfare against this country goes a long way toward explaining why the administration’s Guantanamo policy is a failure.
Hence, we see that Lt. Cmdr. Swift has been right in making appeals against the brutal policy of Bush’s administration regarding the detainees at the Guantanamo Bay. American philosophy respects and honors human rights, while what has been going on in Guantanamo is just against the definition of human rights.
Works Cited
Brenner, Marie. Taking on Guantánamo. Vanity Fair. N.p., 2007. Web. 6 Dec 2011. .
Bonsignore, John J., and Ethan Katsh. Before the Law: An Introduction to the Legal Process. USA: Houghton Mifflin Co., 2005.
Carafano, James Jay, and Gabor Rona. “Should Guantanamo Bay Be Closed?” Council on Foreign Relations. Council on Foreign Relations, Inc., 2007. Web. 6 Dec 2011. . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Why Detaining terrorist in Guantanamo Bay was against American Essay”, n.d.)
Why Detaining terrorist in Guantanamo Bay was against American Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1586254-why-detaining-terrorist-in-guantanamo-bay-was-against-american-philosophy
(Why Detaining Terrorist in Guantanamo Bay Was Against American Essay)
Why Detaining Terrorist in Guantanamo Bay Was Against American Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1586254-why-detaining-terrorist-in-guantanamo-bay-was-against-american-philosophy.
“Why Detaining Terrorist in Guantanamo Bay Was Against American Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1586254-why-detaining-terrorist-in-guantanamo-bay-was-against-american-philosophy.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why Detaining terrorist in Guantanamo Bay was against American Philosophy

American Indian Philosophy

...‘American Indian Philosophy’ Introduction American Indian philosophical beliefs provide a great modern wisdom to the individuals. The basic components are the treatment methods fundamentally. It is about how the human beings treat God, His creation and the mother earth. The practical example can be grabbed from the lives of Native Americans (Smith and Thomas, 31). They are well interested in the well being of society and the environment. They are concerned towards finding the best possible ways to treat the environmental components. According to them, we get life from this environment and it helps us to grow up. It is a most foolish thing ever if somebody does not care...
12 Pages(3000 words)Research Paper

Closing Guantanamo Prison

...?Closing Guantanamo Prison Guantanamo Bay Prison is a detention center located within the United s’ naval base on the island of Cuba. While the naval base is remnant of the 1960s Cold War era, the detention center wasn’t created until 2002 as a means of housing prisoners in the wake of the Iraq and Afghanistan conflicts. In recent years, particularly in light of the recent Presidential elections, the question of whether Guantanamo Bay should even be allowed to remain open has become a hot button issue within the American political landscape. Much of the controversy surrounding this detention center revolves around issues and practices...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Prohibition of Torture in the case of Guantanamo Bay

...up to detain suspected terrorist but was later replaced by camp delta since it was a temporarily section.”3 The first detainees to be detained in Guantanamo bay detention camp were brought on January 11, 2002. This was after the United States of America department of justice said that that the United States of America Government would have no legal liability if detainees were held in Guantanamo Bay Naval base. Initially, the Bush administration stipulated that “detainees in the Detention Camp were not protected by the Geneva Convention.” 4This can be considered one reason why torture was condoned in the...
18 Pages(4500 words)Essay

American Indian Philosophy

...American Indian Philosophy Introduction In the literal meaning, philosophy refers to the love of wisdom. In fact, philosophy is derived from a word that means love of wisdom (Fixico 2). As a result of many roles and tools that philosophy plays, different meanings of philosophy have arisen. Therefore, it can be defined as a set of theories that study of the elementary nature of knowledge, existence, reality, mind, values, language and reason. It is a tool that tries to seek the truth by questioning why things are done in a certain manner. It uses the science of reasoning to scrutinize the ideas, statements, thoughts, and...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay

.... As such, there is a basic similarity between the mainstream media in the United States and such media outlets in the Arab world, in that for neither are facts sacred. Within the United States, while the liberal traditions of the Democratic Party militate against detention camps and deprivation of the due process of law even to suspected terrorists, the conservative baggage of the Republicans is comfortable with them. Finally, the basic connection between Abu Ghraib and the Guantanamo Bay is that both are detention camps that have hit the headlines for human rights abuses. _____ "Federal authorities are...
19 Pages(4750 words)Essay

A Political Speech on Guantanamo Bay

...will never settle and will forever terrorize our minds as we try to move on. Why -because we could never come to terms of the fact that someday we will pay for all the pain and suffering we have caused to others. The sword of Damocles hangs high above our heads as we take in the Prisoners of War at our own mercy and disposal. In the guise of national security we seek to inflict pain and torture on the prisoners to extract what "-information to justify their presence in camps like Guantanamo Bay in Cuba" As POW's, these men are the mere forgotten and dispensable "soldiers-made-puppets" of another ambitious man wielding a form of power. These men are ordinary humans just like every...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

African American philosophy

...Philosophy is a detailed system of ideas about human beings and the nature of the human existence and truth. Actually it is a complete guide for living. It deals in issues which are fundamental and consider the steps we take in life for progress. It also deals with our attitude and treatment of other people. The main branches of Philosophy are: Metaphysics, which deals with reality, Epistemology, which deals with knowledge, Ethics, which considers moral values, Politics, which accounts for legal rights and governments, and Aesthetics, which looks in to nature of art. While we start to think of African American Philosophy, the first point going to pop up is the attitude...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Guantanamo Bay

...but the same got wavered and nothing came out of it. The US soldiers slam the heads of the prisoners against the cell; many more unimaginable things are done by the US soldiers' day in and day out. "The US says interrogations are yielding useful intelligence, including some from inmates who have been detained for up to two years." (Guantanamo Bay). "The current Cuban government considers the U.S. presence in Guantnamo to be illegal and the Cuban-American Treaty to have been procured by the threat of force in violation of international law" (Guantanamo Bay). There have been enough proofs found which show that the US...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Guantanamo Bay Closing

...of the Guantanamo Bay Closing Introduction Guantanamo Bay is considered to be the most contentious and controversial prison facility, which is located in Cuba. Because of its supposed and assumed unorthodox treatment towards prisoners, it has been subjected to criticism and media attacks. Located on the Cuban shore, the Guantanamo Bay detainment center is run by the Join Task Force Guantanamo. It comprises of three main camps: Camp Delta, Camp Iguana and Camp X-Ray (Londras,38). After the attacks of September eleventh, former American President George Bush had authorized an official...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

African American Philosophy

...African American Philosophy A social theory is a theoretical framework which forms the basis wherein social phenomena can be studied and interpreted. Social theories help to explain different kinds of social phenomena, including cultural and racial elements that constitute group dynamics as well as overall patterns within a particular society. While scientific methods as well as political and economic phenomena may also be ap0plied towards the explanation of social phenomena, research apply subjectivity in understanding social phenomena. Social theory explains the changes taking place in society – its development and the factors which help to facilitate or restrict those changes from taking place. Various theories have offered... ...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Why Detaining terrorist in Guantanamo Bay was against American Philosophy for FREE!

Contact Us