Free

The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust" states that I agree with Norman Finkelstein that U.S. taxpayer’s money should not be used to fund to commemorate the victims of the Holocaust. This is not to show insensitivity and disrespect for what happened to the Jews…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust"

I. The Memorial: What I like and dislike The memorial underwent a lot process and debate before its final construction and as such, it is a product of thoughtful sensitivity to remember those who perish in the holocaust. As we can glean on James Young explanation how the memorial came about (Young, 2008), there were serious effort made to commemorate the victims. Beyond the aesthetic of the memorial, it is the process and the sensitivity brought into it that I like.
What I l do not like about the memorial though is what it represents. It represents the collective guilt of the Germans for the atrocities done during the Second World War in its name.
II. The necessity of the exclusivity of commemorating Jewish  victims only 
The terrible loss and atrocity that happened during the Nazi period is such a horrible period. The deaths and mutilation that happened then cannot be compensated by erecting monuments of whatever size. But still, it has to be remembered. And to stress the sensitivity of the narrative and its sensitivity for being remorseful of what it has done, the memorial should not be placed together with other commemorative monuments.
III. Eisenman would have preferred no Ort (the subterranean museum) as part of the 
memorial. Where do you stand? 
The atrocity should be remembered in its proper perspective where it should impress a narrative that people should not forget. The proposal of having a subterranean museum was just a reaction of the Germans not to create something bombastic and authoritarian with a big rock telling them what to think. But even if a monument will be a bombastic rock telling them what to think, it should still be erected to ever remember their crimes and never to forget its lesson.
IV. Norman Finkelstein questions the use of  US taxpayers money to commemorate the victims of the Holocaust in Washington, DC  because the Holocaust was not committed here but in Europe. 
I agree with Norman Finkelstein that U.S. taxpayer’s money should not be used to fund to commemorate the victims of the holocaust. This is not to show insensitivity and disrespect for what happened to the Jews but it is the Jews and Germans who should dispense their resources for its commemoration because they are the protagonists of the holocaust. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust Essay - 2, n.d.)
The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust Essay - 2. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1580244-essay
(The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust Essay - 2)
The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust Essay - 2. https://studentshare.org/history/1580244-essay.
“The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust Essay - 2”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1580244-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust

Germany's Holocaust Memorial

...?Berlin Holocaust Memorial The Denkmal fur die ermordeten Juden Europes or Monument to the Murdered Jews of Europe was opened on May 12, 2005, the 60th anniversary of the fall of the Nazi regime and the end of the Second World War. The monument was designed by an American, Peter Eisenman, as a tribute to the Jews who died before and during World War II. It is located on what used to be the Ministry Gardens, next to a large complex of buildings which included the Reich Chancellery, Hitler’s main office. After the war, it was used to be part of the Berlin Wall. The memorial occupies a total space of 19,000 square meters (205,000 square feet) and consists of 2,711 unmarked...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Holocaust Memorial

.... This is probably what the Jews felt during the holocaust. They were afraid for their lives and were confused about ever surviving. The only thing they knew was to work in an orderly fashion. Much like ants work relentlessly to meet the goals set by their ruler. The structures themselves make no sense but their meaning is deep. They lack any form identity, or individualism. The structures are separate only by their height. I think that Eisenman is an architectural genius. He is able to evoke so many emotions from something so simple. But why does it only commemorate the Jews? There were many other people convicted for reasons other than being Jewish. Amongst those who were victims to the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Eitherv the Building of the Holocaust Memorial

...as evidence. Many prisoners have said that the crematories were kept hidden from view. But under observation there is proof that those were lies. Forensics experts have also found no evidence of any use of cyanide in the supposed gas chambers and when compared with sanitary reasons, it was found that cyanide was used as a pesticide. Is the Holocaust a giant hoax? There are many movies depicting death and slavery in the internment camps but was any of it true? Even the original number of deaths given by the Soviets seems so blown up from the real number which is 4 times less than what the Soviets have said. Somehow I get the feeling that Germany has been victimized by foreign propaganda. Well, the whole...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

How the Homeric Hymn on Aphrodite Defines the Power of the Goddess

4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper

Those who pray and those who fight

...Medieval Orders of the Society: Crusades According to Hunt 353) “in Europe during the period 1200-1340, people at all levels from workshop artists to kings and popes, expected to find order and unity in a world they believed was created by God. Sometimes their search for order lead to compromise and adaptations.” Medieval theorists identified three orders of the society, to include those who work, those who fought and those who pray. These orders were based on one’s functions in the society and defined one’s status and prestige. Those who work comprised mainly the peasants in the society; the slaves and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Germanys Holocaust Memorial

...Germany’s Holocaust Memorial The Holocaust Memorial by the New York based Architect Peter Eisenman, is symbolic of the hardships and genocide faced by the Jewish population in Nazi Germany under the dictator Adolph Hitler. In my opinion, the construction of Holocaust Memorial by the German government is the best way to pay tribute to the victims of the Holocaust. Thesis statement: I think that Holocaust Memorial by Peter Eisenman commemorates Jewish Holocaust, honors the victims, and demonstrates the culture of remembrance in unified Germany. Personally, I feel...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Holocaust Memorial Visit

...I. My like and dislike about the Memorial I like the idea that the Memorial was built to remember the suffering of the Jews during the Holocaust. Ina way, it is the Germans apology of their war crimes during the Second World War and an admission of its guilt. It is also unusual that a country would built a monument to remember its collective guilt becaue usually, countries only erect monument to honor its glory. I do not like the feel of the memorial. Its creepy especially when I am in between those two narrow cobbled stones. It also seems to look bland. II. The exclusivity of commemorating the Jewish victims For a race that was almost annihilated and made extinct by Hitler’s genocide, it is only proper that their suffering... it...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Building of the Holocaust Memorial

...Building the Holocaust Memorial” is an excellent movie which underscores the tumultuous growth of this important national monument of Berlin. It does a good job showing the opinions of a wide variety of people on some of the good and bad things about this memorial. One of the central issues talked about in the Holocaust memorial movie is the fact that this memorial only remembers the Jews who died in the Holocaust, and no others. The problem is that a wide variety of people died in the Holocaust, including people with mental handicaps and large portions of the gay and lesbian...
1 Pages(250 words)Movie Review

Building Germany's Holocaust Memorial

...Building Germany’s Holocaust Memorial Peter Eisenman’s memorial to victims of the Holocaust, located in Berlin, is composed of a series of concrete slabs of varying heights, placed in a grid pattern. The memorial has been the subject of a lot of debate, both from the Jewish citizenry and from German non-Jews as well. One of the reasons for this debate has been the fact that only Jewish people are included in this particular memorial. The commemorative structure makes no mention of the homosexuals, handicapped, or gypsies that were also murdered by the Nazis, not to mention those put to death for other reasons by the National Socialist Party. The problem with a memorial that deals exclusively with the remembrance of the Jews... is that it...
1 Pages(250 words)Term Paper

Germany's Holocaust Memorial

...Germanys Holocaust Memorial The German Holocaust Memorial is located at the center of Berlin, between Potsdamer Platz and Brandenburg Gate that is the border between West and Eat Germany. The memorial sits on a 19,000 square meters field, the size of a soccer field. The site is devoted exclusively to the murdered Holocaust Jews of Europe. The fact that the memorial site , only commemorate exclusively the Jewish victims of the Nazi, has in turn generated controversy, with some arguing out that many more thousands of non-Jews perished during the holocaust, and the fact that the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Memorial of Those Who Perish in The Holocaust for FREE!

Contact Us