E.H. Carr and Historical Thought - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The author of this essay "E.H. Carr and Historical Thought" touches upon the ideas concerning history by Carr. According to the text, the extent to which one can give a definitive meaning to the word ‘history’ has ever been an endeavor fraught with controversy.  …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
E.H. Carr and Historical Thought
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "E.H. Carr and Historical Thought"

Download file to see previous pages Though to properly assess the academic value and relevance of his claim, it is first necessary to analyze the broader intellectual context to which Carr sought to make a contribution. As such, it will be necessary to briefly address the very same question he himself posed, for the pragmatic purpose of assessing the accuracy of his claims.
The American historian and political philosopher Allan Bloom, in his cultural jeremiad on the state of university education in the closing decades of the twentieth century, lamented what he saw as the contemptuous antagonism felt for one another by the aforementioned three main divisions of modern academia. According to Bloom:
While both social science and humanities are more or less willingly awed by natural science, they have mutual contempt for one another, the former looking down on the latter as unscientific, the latter regarding the former as a philistine. They do not cooperate. And most important, they occupy much of the same ground. Many of the classic books now a part of the humanities talk about the same things as do social scientists but use different methods and draw different conclusions;... (1987, p. 357)
And yet history does not easily fit into any of these main categories. History, unlike the natural sciences, cannot conduct a controlled experiment because its object of study, being the past, is incapable of being ‘recreated.’ Bloom made note of this general dilemma, that is, the categorization of the work of the historian. History may not, on the other hand, claim to be a social science: its goal is not to predict human action (as is the case in any sort of study of human behavior), but rather to understand past actions (Bloom 1987, pp. 243-380). Thus, in many ways, history enjoys a sort of liminal existence which transcends the natural and social sciences, not to mention the humanities. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“E.H. Carr and Historical Thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
E.H. Carr and Historical Thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1559967-ehcarr-has-suggested-that-see-below
(E.H. Carr and Historical Thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
E.H. Carr and Historical Thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1559967-ehcarr-has-suggested-that-see-below.
“E.H. Carr and Historical Thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1559967-ehcarr-has-suggested-that-see-below.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF E.H. Carr and Historical Thought


...?Running head: HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Human Resource Management Module: College: Human Resource Management 1. Organisations are moving towards a new level of competitiveness both internally and externally. In order to succeed there is need for the management to enhance efficiency in all departments primarily in Human Resources. The contemporary approach in HR management has been the increased role of the Line Managers. Line managers offer the first platform for employees to report back to the top management. This is the operational level whose performance directly affects success of a firm. Therefore, line managers’ position can be used to facilitate team work, higher performance, cohesive gap between the management... head: HUMAN RESOURCE ...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Role of Individuals in Historical Thought

...?Running Head: Role of Individuals in Historical Thought Role of Individuals in Historical Thought [Institute’s Role of Individuals in Historical Thought Introduction The incomparability of the associations and arguments between social forces in finding out the course of history is among the basic suppositions of historical materialism. An individual creates history through his struggle, determination and motivation, and the better is societal development the bigger the control of the individual on society. With the progress of history, the intensifying and expansion of historical efforts, and the advancement of ‘science, technology and society’ a great number individuals take part in historical happenings and every person plays... cannot do...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Caleb Carr. The Alienist

...the street. This, as with the incident with Pomeroy, was an actual reality during this period of time – specifically, cable cars were unable to stop, and picked up speed around the curve of the east side of Union Square, and pedestrians were often killed or maimed by these speeding cable cars (Carteret, 2011). Carr brings this historical reality to life with a humorous twist – Carr describes the people in bar who would be watching these speeding cable cars and the pedestrians who are trying to make it across the street, then would take bets as to whom would make it. Carr adds to the humor of this by having it so that the main character, John Moore, who is a gambling man,...
3 Pages(750 words)Book Report/Review

James J Hill and E H Harriman Compare and Contrast

...James J. Hill and E. H. Harriman Compare and Contrast Biographies maybe written using different styles but facts will always remain the same. Facts cannot be changed unless new discoveries are made contrary to those facts. The twentieth century was a great period in time for many Americans. This was the period in which great businessmen and industrialists came up into being and had their names drop from every lip whenever their industry of choice came into discussion. John D. Rockefeller, J. P. Morgan, Andrew Carnegie, James J. Hill and E. H. Harriman were more often than not, spoken under the same breath. While J. P. Morgan stood for the banking industry, the oil...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

What Is An Historical Fact

... What is an historical fact? A historical fact refers to a sequential account entailing past events based on a substantialfoundation. Although history tends to expose past events, historians argue that not all events qualify to attain the status of historical facts. A prolonged conflict may, at times, culminate or involve historical facts. According to Carr, historians of times to come do not expect production of decisive history (7). This is because they possess expectations that their history will experience archaism after every undefined period. The notions that past knowledge originate from human thoughts make them conclude that knowledge is devoid of elemental aspects as would be in elements as atoms with nothing to transform (Carr 7...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Carr assignment

...1. your opinion regarding the correctness of Carr’s argument. While you provide an opinion, this is not an “opinion paper.” Some opinions are better than others. Focus upon the controversial aspects of Carr’s article (see above). Carr’s argument stands correct when the perspective and history is considered, even network arrangements in the economy have increased due to rapid changes in technology (Fountain 74). Carr’s perspective is from an investment point. For instance Carr is of the opinion that non-IT companies should become successful by working hard on their products, not on the IT. Applying this principle on successful companies like Boeing,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay


... How to Clean Lungs after Quitting Smoking HISTORY Leadership Slavery Politics Assassination President Colonization Hegemony Independence Loyalty Liberation Politicians JOBS Cooking Fishing Journalism Nursing Medicine Teaching Hairdressing Carpentry Weaving Sporting HABITS Drug abuse Smoking Drinking alcohol Stealing Robbery Sleeping Eating Crying Bullying Sagging How to Clean Lungs after Quitting Smoking Everyday smokers always subject their lungs to scarring. This is an effect of smoking that come as a result of long term exposure of the cigarette smoke. This leads to reduced oxygen supply to the body tissues. There are many ways that affected people can naturally detoxify their lungs and live a healthy life after quitting... How to Clean...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

E. Asia Thought/Comp Perspectv

...). From Confucius’ time to the early 20th century, the mourning period was prescribed to be 3 years which reflected the very first 3 years in a child’s life (Gardner et al, 2003). This is the period when a child is completely dependent on their parents and the parents love them unconditionally. The mourning practices are often somber and it is thought that it only attracted people due to its necessity or otherwise, the repercussions associated with failure to carry it out. Some of the practices during this period involve leaving hair unkempt, mourning in agony at specific intervals of the day, wearing simple garb or sackcloth, feeding on a restricted diet of congee twice a day and living in a grieving hut that is often...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Carr reflection

...out experiments aimed at examining if people recall information or the sources of the information. Based on the findings, it is clear that the internet has become our external memory. In this case, people no longer store information within themselves but rather on outside machines. Overall, as the amount of information on the internet increases, more people continue to rely on what is stored on these machines as opposed to what they store in their brains. Secondly, the overreliance on the internet and computers has made people less intelligent. Because more people are spending more time on the internet, the devices connected to the internet analyze our thoughts and actions based on what we do online. As a result, as...
2 Pages(500 words)Book Report/Review


...9). The first thing these devices can talk about with regard to me is about the level of drunkenness or the level of alcohol content that can be detected from my breadth for example. These modern devices have sensors and they can sense if the driver is drunk. In the event that I am drunk, they communicate with me that I cannot drive at that particular time and would need some rest before the level of alcohol content in my body subsides. The main reason for this is to ensure my safety. In most case, people who drive under the influence of alcohol are often involved in fatal crashes that lead to loss of life. According to the traffic regulations and safety expectations, it is not advisable to drive under the influence of alcohol... The first...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic E.H. Carr and Historical Thought for FREE!

Contact Us