Nobody downloaded yet

Clausewitz, Jomini, WWII and Operation Overlord - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The essay elaborates more on the most important ideas that were captured in each of the two theorists work. Furthermore, the differences in their ideas have been highlighted and, an evaluation on which would be most relevant to apply in the current strategic environment. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
Clausewitz, Jomini, WWII and Operation Overlord
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Clausewitz, Jomini, WWII and Operation Overlord"

Download file to see previous pages The paper tells that Jomini served in the Russian and French armies in the 19th century during the Napoleonic wars. He contributed largely on the terms used in modern U.S theory and doctrine. Jomini believed that war was a science and with careful study on rules one could discover its conduct. According to Jomini he depicted strategy as art of war upon the map, which comprehended the entire theater of war. “The main tactic being posting troops in accordance with the accidents of the ground, of placing them into battle, and art of fighting upon the ground, in contradiction to planning upon a map”. Jomini further stated that a defensive war had its advantages when wisely conducted. He depicted passive defense as being pernicious and the active on the other side accomplishing greater success. Jomini’s principle on political war was that the cause of defensive war is to protect the countryside that was being threatened by the enemy, and all operations to be designed to retard his enemy’s progress. This is to be achieved by increasing difficulties and obstacles in the enemy’s way, however taking care not to compromise one’s own army. The idea behind it was that for one to invade, he does so with intention of superiority. The defense on the other hand desires delay till the adversary is weakened by fatigues, marches and sending off detachments to his progress. These ideas by Jomini are important as they are the only ones that were worth considering when it comes to modern war, especially the strategy of exhaustion used to eventually strangle the Confederacy. (Archer 130). Williams in his book Lincoln and his Generals found that most of Jomini’s ideas were seen as misleading and isolated, in many cases would lead to high casualties, uncertain battles, and a war that drug on for so long (Williams 204). Clausewitz ideas on war According to Clausewitz war was a tragic and complex enterprise, always threatening to break away from human control (Archer 126). Bartholomees in his article states that much of what Clausewitz purported was either ordinary or 19th century specific with an exception of three ideas (Bartholomeees 21). First his encouragement of seeking battle. In his book he states that “… pursuit makes up the second act of the victory and in most cases is more important than the first” (Clausewitz 267). According to his view, he sees war as a nonlinear phenomenon that is naturally unpredictable through analytical means (Bayerchen 86). The second idea that Clausewitz gave was attacking the enemy’s centre of gravity. This was to be achieved by attacking the enemy’s army then followed by seizing his capital and attacking his alliances. The final idea is the “how to”, which is a concept of the culminating point. Clausewitz defines culminating point as strategic attacks that lead to the point where the remaining potency is just enough to sustain a cover and wait for peace. Past that point then tables turn and the reaction follows with force that is usually a lot stronger compared to the original attack (Clausewitz 82). Difference between the two theorists There are a lot of differences between the two theorists and their ideas but with only one that can be considered over the others. Their difference mostly came in because: Clausewitz theories mainly dealt with how to win the war unlike Jomini’s which emphasized on teaching the leaders how to fight their battles. Conclusion Jomini’ ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Clausewitz, Jomini, WWII and Operation Overlord Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1394774-clausewitz-jomini-wwii-and-operation-overlord
(Clausewitz, Jomini, WWII and Operation Overlord Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1394774-clausewitz-jomini-wwii-and-operation-overlord.
“Clausewitz, Jomini, WWII and Operation Overlord Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1394774-clausewitz-jomini-wwii-and-operation-overlord.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Clausewitz, Jomini, WWII and Operation Overlord

WWII Inventions and Innovations

...? Essay Contest WWII Inventions and Innovations There are so many interesting facts surrounding WWII. These facts have contributed to the change toward American history as well as the world’s history. There are so many significant events surrounding WWII that is was only necessary to create a museum in honor of the brave men and women that made WWII possible. One can only begin to imagine where the world would be now if WWII had not happened. The innovations that resulted from WWII are quite significant and still present in modern society. Some significant events that took place during WWII that have impacted my life as...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Principles of War, Clausewitz and Jomini

...outlook, strategic and mainly focused on the art of war. In short, the elements of Jomini’s work were offensive and maneuver kind of war, whereas the elements of Clausewitz work was characterized mostly by chance, violence, and reasons as the key elements. These theorists of war each emphasized certain warfare principles. We first look the principles advanced by Jomini. First, we must realize that the warfare principles advanced by Jomini, now referred to as Jominian principles were mostly designed for wars that were fought earlier under very different views about wars and circumstances. One of the principles of war that Jomini emphasized was the “line...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Operation

...?Business Inserts His/Her Inserts Grade Inserts 6th July, Business Processes Several processed will be undertaken in the process of ensuring that the tanning salon is run on a professional basis. All the processes within the tanning salon will be undertaken on a day to day basis. For instance the process of welcoming and making customers feel welcomed is a critical task since it engages the customer with the staff. This helps in creating value since it is part of the service that the customer will receive. The next process would be to make sure the customers are explained the services, products and technology used in the tanning process (Blais 88). As part of building value, the customer has to have knowledge of the services... Inserts...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Operation Overlord D Day

...163612 Operation Overlord D Day Did the Allied over-estimations of the level of Air threat have a serious effect on the Operation Overlord planning? The following will outline and discuss the arguments for and against the notion that the Allied planner’s over- estimations of the level of Air threat had a serious effect on the Operation Overlord planning. As a starting point it must be remembered that the military planners tasked with planning Operation Overlord were not blessed with foresight and did not know whether they were under or over estimating the level of the German Air threat to the successful...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

WWII

...World War ID] [Lecturer] The World War I started in 1914 and ended in 1919. It brought with it not only political instabilities for the European nations but also a message of death and hatred amongst the masses. Leaders enjoyed having their whims at others’ disposal while the poor were simply left to their own fates. The World seemed to have a “jungle rule” kind of situation all of a sudden. It looked like as if the new century has dawned on these people an alarum of what is more to come and what worse can there possibly be in store for them. There were certain reasons which led to the outbreak of this very war and there were the formation of the Central and Allied Alliances which eventually went a long way in lengthening... War ID]...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Carl Von Clausewitz on War

...destruction. This was a clearly defined political object and a cost-benefit analysis would have been rather straightforward. The American leadership could have determined the sacrifices, financially and in terms of lives lost, by determining the magnitude and duration of the military operation required to eliminate such weapons of mass destruction. A problem, however, has obviously arisen and the question is how does America extricate itself from its armed conflict in Iraq. A careful analysis based on Von Clausewitz would suggest that America’s problems in terminating the war can be traced to the “political object” language; more precisely, there have been many suggestions that the American...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Combined Forces Operation in WWII

...expected minimal resistance of the western Allies on the Soviet’s domination of the Eastern side of Europe. Stalin argued that the share of each of the winners should be equivalent to the soldiers’ number and the magnitude of the killed enemies. Based on this the Soviet side would have a lot. In fact the Red Army had most of its soldiers killed compared to those of the US, a fellow Allies side member country. They (the Red Soldiers) contributed directly to 93% of the lost Germany combats. Naval as well as air operations had Soviets contributions to the war stand at about 75%. In 1945 Stalin made a comparison in the partner’s gains and possessions from the WWII and considered that the UK and USA had much...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Using Jomini and Clausewitz, where do these two philosophers draw the line in war between art and science

...then as they are now, until the wars that soon followed. Thus, the Battle of Austerlitz in 1806, is a mere consequence of these earlier events, which had taken 476 years since 1330 AD from the time the state separated from the church. Carl von Clausewitz (1780-1831) was a Prussian soldier from a middle class family of noble origins and had extensive combat experience during the French Revolution who rose to the rank of Major-General at the age of 38.2 His book, ”On War” (Ger: Vom Kriege; Fr: Theorie de la grande guerre) became together with Antoine-Henri Jomini’s “Traité des grandes operations militaires” (Treatise on Grand Military Operations) the textbooks for...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

WWII

... Three Defining Events after WW-II 23 April Introduction This paper looks at three momentous events or developments which greatly influenced and defined the social, political and economic landscape of the world. These events continued to exert their influence on how world events are being shaped today and into the near future. The three defining events are the invention of the birth control pill (social and sexual mores), the Bretton Woods agreement (economic) and the Civil Rights Movement (political rights). Each of these events is discussed below and how they impact our lives today. Discussion Sexual revolution – it was largely brought about by the invention of the contraceptive pill or more popularly called as the birth... Three Defining ...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Does Harry Summers Understand Clausewitz

...Q. Does Harry Summers understand Clausewitz? Harry Summers does understand Clausewitz perspective of war. In fact, in his book On War, Clausewitz describes two main aspects of war. One is the preparation of war and the other is the war proper arrangements. On similar pattern, Summers also separates his work into two parts. First part discusses the policy failures that lead to the failure of US invasion whereas the second part discusses the prosecution of the war itself. The first part argues, Vietnam failure was due to the lack of support from common US citizens. The point is how can a country win a war when its people are against it? The end of World War II saw the rise of nuclear...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Clausewitz, Jomini, WWII and Operation Overlord for FREE!

Contact Us