Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1425134-comparison-between-novel-and-book-which-one-is
https://studentshare.org/english/1425134-comparison-between-novel-and-book-which-one-is.
Both the book and the film have many points of similarity but there are also various scenes in the movie which are completely in contrast to how they are presented in the book. One of the differences between the book and the film is the heavy fictionalization of the characters in the film as compared to the book. However, in the book, the characters are presented as real people, not fictional characters. Even if they are fictional, their lives are based on real life therefore the reader feels like he is experiencing something that might actually have happened.
In the film however, one cannot really feel what the characters are supposed to be feeling because they are all over-fictionalized. Another inconsistent with Duma’s books pertains to the death of d’Artagnan. In the Book Vicomte de Bragelonne, d’Artagnan dies some ten years later after the events presented in The Man in the Iron Mask. His death was actually caused by wounds he suffered while at battle in Maastricht. In the movie however, d’Artagnan dies as he tries to stop King Louis from Killing Philippe.
The film also implies that d’Artagnan had been the father of King Louis and Philippe through his association with Anne of Austria. Duma’s work does not indicate anywhere that D’Artagnan and Anne had any relations whatsoever. . es made in the movie are also necessary as they help the viewer to understand more of King Louis’ character and his role in the conspiracy against his own twin brother. The changes have therefore enabled the audience to relate to the chatcater sand story line much easier.
Leonardo DiCaprio plays as The Man in the iron Mask, Philippe and King Louis, the man’s twin bother. The role of the Captain of the Musketeers, d’Artagnan is played by Ganriel Byrne. John Malkovich, Gerard Depardieu and Jeremy irons star as the three Musketeers: Athos, Porthos and Aramis respectively. When Dumas was writing the story, he wanted to reflect a situation that was real then. That is, he wanted to present a situation that was relevant during his own time. The historical aspect of the book is therefore critical to the understanding of the events that occur in the story.
The movie does not really dwell much into the historical aspect of its story line. It seems that the main aim of the producers is to use the characters to stir up emotions that the audience can identify with. For the sake of the audience, the producer does well in changing some aspects of the film. At this point in time, most people already know the history if 17th century France during which time the book was written. Therefore the changes did nothing to change how people perceive that history, however, the changes did have an impact in the way people related to the film.
A new ending gave a new meaning to the whole story. D’Artagnan comes out as the tragic hero at the end of the movie, while in the book, it is not so clear what his role was. It is thorugh the changes made by the producers that the audience gets to know who really is behind the iron mask and his relation to the King and d’Artagnan. The various
...Download file to see next pages Read More