StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Critique of a given research article - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
It discusses the objectives of the writer, his study and methodology. Finally the article evaluates the writer’s analysis of data and his conclusions for…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Critique of a given research article"

Critic of “Integrative Motivation in a Globalizing World” Article Task: Critic of “Integrative Motivation in a Globalizing World” Article
This article critics a research article authored by Martin Lamb about the integrative motivation in a globalizing world. It discusses the objectives of the writer, his study and methodology. Finally the article evaluates the writer’s analysis of data and his conclusions for their effectiveness at addressing the raised question. The evaluation found the research well informed through extensive evaluation of literature, however, the research did not exhaustively evaluate the question raised.
Lamb assessed the importance of integrative impetus in the study of English amongst students of varied cultures and groups. He evaluated the motivation of first year junior high learners in Indonesia in learning English. The researcher intended to conduct a longitudinal evaluation extending for two years. He attempted to identify changes in motivation and what learners do in and out of class (Lamb 2003, p. 5-6). To do this the researcher combined survey questionnaire with semi-structured interviews. The focal group comprised of 12 individuals. The researcher, additionally, interacted with the learners to obtain qualitative data (Lamb 2003, p. 6-7). Lamb finally concluded that as English becomes adopted by many people, its learning becomes allied to conformity to globalization. Hence the motivation to learn it is dependent on identification.
The extensive consultation of up to date literature enables him to evaluate relevant facets of the question. The use of focus group was prudent in finding a solution to conduction research in a multicultural context. Focus groups are an efficient qualitative method providing access to information unavailable without interactions. It provided an avenue to discover indigenous language in order to decipher the learners understanding of phrases used in the questionnaire. However, he fails to identify the variation of focus group employed. Additionally, the researcher did not highlight the guidelines utilized in the selection of members, raising the issue of external validity. Without a representative selection, the results may be invalid.
The researcher identified the problems resulting from culture when administering a questionnaire in that they may not interpret the questions as intended by the researcher, he therefore responded to this by gathering qualitative data (Lamb 2003, p. 7). The interaction with the students helped increase the validity of the quantitative data collected through augmenting with qualitative data.
From the responses on the liking of the learning of English, the researcher found out that all the students liked learning English (Lamb 2003, p. 9). Evaluating this conclusion demystifies it as vague. The “liking” observed is not identified as either the liking for the process of learning English or the liking for the effects that result after learning English. These two phenomena are different. The liking for the process can be said to be genuine. The researcher fails to evaluate these two dissenting aspects from the concept “liking”.
In the conclusion, the researcher talks of the role model of the Indonesian youth not being English speakers but Indonesian natives with a global identity (Lamb 2003, p. 12-13). Whereas this may be true, it is, however, not evaluated during the study and appears exclusively as the researcher’s opinion. He concedes to this fact and acknowledges the fact that his study did not cover the process of identification. This is a major omission since the identification process is closely associated with motivation for language learning.
The researcher’s conclusion that instrumental motivation is more common in Asian learners is supported by the data obtained in the study (Lamb 2003, p 9 table 2). This answers the research question satisfactorily, but the data is hardly general since the subject of the study was one school, in one country in the whole continent.
Reference
Lamb, M 2003, Integrative Motivation in a Globalizing world, Leeds: University of Leeds, viewed 1 January, . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critique of a given research article Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Critique of a given research article Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1587226-critique-of-a-given-research-article
(Critique of a Given Research Article Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Critique of a Given Research Article Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/education/1587226-critique-of-a-given-research-article.
“Critique of a Given Research Article Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1587226-critique-of-a-given-research-article.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critique of a given research article

Has Government by States Given Way to Inter and Non-State Governance

The application of theories related to the state and its governance can be proved very helpful towards the creation of an effective and well-structured state. However, the phenomenon of a ‘subjective’ interpretation of the above theories is common especially when there are specific targets that need to be achieved by the interested parties (usual participants in a state’s political or social life). For this reason, it is necessary that specific rules and guidelines are followed when studying and interpreting the views of theorists regarding the position, the role and the power of the state.

Within the state, there are many ‘political’ and ‘social’ forces that try to impose their...
10 Pages(2500 words)Report

Critique of Technological Innovations, Activity Based Costing and Satisfaction Article by Davood Askarany

Many of the innovations have been introduced as early as 1980, such as “activity-based costing (ABC); activity management (AM) and activity-based management (ABM); local information system (LS); balanced scorecard (BS); life cycle costing (LCC) and target costing (TC) [and] strategic management accounting (SMA).” (Askarany, Smith and Yazdifar 54). However, few of these have been implemented and utilized to their full potential. The authors propose to find a reason for this.

ABC focuses on costs associated with activities, but also evaluates whether those activities add value, thus providing a means of understanding how to most effectively reduce costs. In addition to cost reduction benefits, applying ABC giv...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

Article Analysis of 11 Ways to Critique an Article by Mike Metcalfe

The systems for thinking perspective and T.O.P perspective styles have been chosen as this article needs to have an explicitly straight conclusion. Moreover, the ethical issues concerning the organization have also not been given adequate treatment in the article which makes it a one-sided communication on the part of the author. Also, certain other critical issues concerning the article involve lack of adequate clarification on the part of the author regarding various key issues such as what would be the resultant consequences in case of failure on the part of the employee / prospective employee to adhere to the rules and regulations governing the protection of privacy of the organizational data. Are there any legal obligations i...
11 Pages(2750 words)Assignment

Marketing Research Plan: Old Navy

Gap’s credit ratings thereby limiting access to the capital market, international trade matters which may be disruptive of the supply chain, changes to its IT systems disruptive of operations, changes in the IT services agreement with IBM that can disrupt operations and produce adverse effects on financial results, international expansion through franchising and other arrangements may impair the value of its brands if unsuccessful, products are subject to risks associated with overseas outsourcing and manufacturing, and failure of vendors to adhere to Gap’s code of vendor conduct could harm the business. From available data in the 2007 Annual Report, both the Gap and Old Navy brands have exhibited declining net sales....
11 Pages(2750 words)Business Plan

Research Methods in Linguistics

 The writer of content tries to preserve his/her culture and also wants his/her culture to get attached to his/her recent living due to which, he/she makes use of the bilingual aspect to write a narrative.

Because of this writing, the English reader faces some problem in decoding the meaning but he/she realizes the presence of another culture by means of this writing. Many writers provide a glossary at the end so that the readers face no problem in decoding the words given in another language such as Soueif has done but many take it for granted that readers know the other language as well.

The article contains a detailed evaluation of the novel by Soueif which can be categorized as the strength of the re...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Developing a Research Base for Intravenous Peripheral Cannula Resites

...Context of the Paper To begin with, the of the paper is very much apt for the content. Although the could have come up with a more direct title, the title “Developing a Research base for Intravenous Peripheral cannula re-sites. A randomized controlled trial” captures the essence of the paper and what the authors aim to address. They, however, could have made it more direct to the point by maybe saying that the study is about a comparison between 3 day cannula re-sites and cannula re-sites as dictated by clinical condition. Nonetheless, the chosen t title is suitable enough to briefly inform the reader of the topic of the research. Two hypotheses were tested in this paper. There are two groups that were compared in the paper...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

The Benefits Given By the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954

Section 22 of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 inserts new provisions into the 1927 Landlord and Tenant Act and provide that “after subsection (1) of the 1927 Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 (provisions as to covenants not to assign etc. without licence or landlord’s consent) there shall be inserted –

Accordingly, in order to challenge CPD’s position, Charlotte would have to establish that their consent has been unreasonably withheld and that the circumstances pertaining to CPD’s reasons for refusal must not be in existence as an express condition of the lease2.

Moreover, in the leading case of Ashworth Frazer Limited v Gloucester City Council3, the House of Lords held t...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Analysis of the Methods of 3 Research Papers about Child Abuse

Research ethics was maintained as the identity of the individuals participating was kept secret. As far as the validity of the study was concerned, the researchers attempted to use content validity in order to get an accurate response. The content validity focused on measuring off the ethnicities and gender percentages within the area and attempting to get a random sample of individuals via the phone. Their approach to random calling allowed for a significant random sample in the study. There were a few issues, however, with this type of approach. Those answering the phone sometimes were not always the desired individual, and not all of the desired people were surveyed. Different replacements did have to be used, and the attempt w...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Marketing Research and Its Ethical Principles

Many ethical questions are attached to market research in today’s world. Many ethical violations are taking place to achieve various motives like minimizing research costs through lack of informed consent of participants, violation of rights of the respondents, use of unauthorized information, confidentiality violations, making false statements and promises, etc. this paper will specifically focus on ethical issues about the Rights of the Respondents of marketing research.
Deontology suggests that people should fully comply with their obligations and responsibilities when it comes to ethically analyzing any situation. These obligations and responsibilities of the analyst may be towards a particular person, a group or co...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

A Framework for Critiquing Quantitative Research Papers

Relevant information of methods used from the Multifactorial Attitudes Questionnaire, Kruskal- Wallis test to ordinal regression have been elaborated.  The results, conclusions, and recommendations are clarified in the research work. Potential benefit is that it makes participants recognize that old need to be given care and inspire attitude change. The harm is that the participants may demand more from their employees relating to the topic. Approval of the Ethics Committee is noted. The findings are categorically explained. The themes include ageism, resources, professional esteem, and working environment. The findings have been explained under each sub-heading. The data have been presented with regard to each question an...

13 Pages(3250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critique of a given research article for FREE!

Contact Us