StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell - Article Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell” the author discusses the article about the purpose of the highest academic degree as “an opportunity and requirement for the candidate to “display” his or her knowledge of the field”…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell"

While Maxwell tended to accuse Boote and Beile’s approach as ‘foundationalism’ (Boote & Beile, 2006, p. 33), Maxwell himself ironically appeared -as it is revealed through the argumentation of the authors- to the adamant foundationalist who, being deviated from the generative purpose of education, is more inclined to establish the value of knowledge on some normative foundations and “conceptual framework[s] that only discusses relevant literature” (Boote & Beile, 2006, p. 32). However, it is also true that Boote and Beile have failed, to some extent, to understand Maxwell’s counter-argument behind the division between the dissertation literature review and the research literature review. Indeed Boote and Beile’s flat allegation that Maxwell advocates, “Candidates need not present a thorough analysis and synthesis of the scholarship and research” (Boote & Beile, 2006, p. 32) can be refuted on the point that Maxwell preserves, though flawed, the right of performing an independent and thorough analysis in the literature review only for the author of the research paper. Here he is more concerned with the educational value of the dissertation. Obviously, adherence to the non-generative conceptual frameworks of doctoral engenders the hollow ritualistic aspects of the highest educational programs. Therefore, Boote and Beile have taken the safest route to prevent such undesired result of reviewing the existing literatures in a particular field by granting the scholar’s independence within the conceptual frameworks of dissertation literature review and, at the same time, defying Maxwell’s approach to take prior literatures as “exemplar for the dissertation” (Boote & Beile, 2006, p. 33).
Response to “Literature Reviews of, and for, Educational Research: A Commentary on Boote and Beile’s “Scholars”
In the article, “Literature Reviews of, and for, Educational Research: A Commentary on Boote and Beile’s “Scholars”, though Joseph A. Maxwell, in the first place, deals with the educative value of the dissertation literature review by confining it from the generative purpose of educational research and by asserting that a thorough and comprehensive analysis and synthesis of literature review is a subject matter of research paper that is to be published, he, certainly to a great extent, fails to establish his claim on any firm ground. In the very beginning, the title of his article itself appears to be a problematic one in its meaning. It is problematic in the sense that ideally, literature review for research papers in the doctoral programs should not be different from the literature review of a research paper. In the article he says, “Boote and Beile confound literature review articles for publication (reviews of research) with dissertation literature reviews, which are primarily reviews for, rather than of, research” (Maxwell, 2006, p. 28). Nowhere in the article, has he, clearly, mentioned what he means by literature reviews for educational research. However, his argumentation explicitly asserts that it is obviously different from what he means by literature review of research and also the literature review of a dissertation that is “to inform a planned study—to create a focus, conceptual framework, design, and justification for the study” (Maxwell, 2006, p. 28) should follow research paper as an example. Here the arguments that he puts forward are not fortified enough to face counter-arguments. For example, he says, “literature reviews for publications…are intended to summarize and synthesize a specific field of research for a wider audience” (Maxwell, 2006, p. 28). When the first and foremost purpose of a research article is to provide a candidate for the doctoral program with the opportunity to explore independently in the field of knowledge, such purpose of a doctoral program cannot be compromised because of the audience. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell Article, n.d.)
Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell Article. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1555572-response-paper
(Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell Article)
Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell Article. https://studentshare.org/education/1555572-response-paper.
“Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell Article”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1555572-response-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell

Educational Research

...: Analysis of the literature review shows that academic cheating occurs at a high level, which demeans the value of the degree obtained. 1. Statement of the Topic Cyber researchers or cyber cheats: does the use of the internet devalue the worth of a degree to the stakeholders? 2. Review of Literature The pervasion of the Internet into educational institutions is both dramatic and striking. This increasing use of the Internet has at its roots in the benefits that Internet gives students in the form of freely accessing information from any part of the world, establish contacts with experts in different fields located almost anywhere, and transcend education from the classroom to an experience that can happen anywhere and at anytime. Yet...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Proposal

Narrative vs. Systematic Reviews in the Literature

...Narrative vs. Systematic Reviews in the Literature ABSTRACT Reviews are one of the most popular and common ways of investigating and analyzing cause and effect of the results of any research. There are many ways of writing a review. Two ways of writing reviews, Narrative and Systematic, are compared and contrasted in this report in context of robustness, strength and weakness. INTRODUCTION A critical discussion is made in this report on the aspects of writing Narrative Reviews and Systematic Reviews. Two reviews, one each of Narrative and Systematic, are selected for comparison and contradiction. Reviews are mostly written in these two forms for pharmaceutical research which relates to the health of the people. Many test cases...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Educational Book Reviews

...?Running Head: EDUCATIONAL BOOK REVIEWS Educational Book Reviews School Educational Book Reviews Introduction Teaching requires incessant learning. The success of a learning process depends heavily on the teacher who does not only plan the content of the lesson but choose the most effective strategies to achieve the learners’ goals. Therefore, it is important for every teacher to be knowledgeable of the subject matter and the strategies that lead to success. The easiest way to access information on effective teaching is through reading books. Book sources provide a panoramic view of the learner, the trends in teaching, and the educational system as a whole. They also project a view of the future direction of education, which every teacher...
9 Pages(2250 words)Book Report/Review

Methods Of Educational Research

... Methods of Educational Research Introduction Before starting any research, it is necessary for the to choose the most efficient research methodology in his study. There are many research methods that exist but the researcher must choose the most appropriate method that will suit his research. The researcher ought to consider various factors such as time and costs to be incurred in the research method. The subject of the research should be the determining factor of the research method to be used. Good researchers usually analyze various research methods before making a decision on the method they are likely to use during their research process. Questionnaire Questionnaires are defined as formulated questions that are structured...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Literature Reviews/Theoretical & Conceptual Frameworks

...? Literature Review Literature Review Introduction Literature review refers to the account of literature published about a topic and accredited to researchers and scholars. The literature considers critical points of the current knowledge including substantive findings and both the methodological and theoretical contributions to a certain topic. Apart from enlarging the knowledge about a certain topic, literature review is used in information seeking when one can scan through the literature to identify useful books and articles. Literature review also enables critical appraisal and the ability of applying the principles of the analysis that identifies valid and unbiased studies. An effective literature should be well organized and related...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Critical Reviews of Literature

...?  Critical Reviews of Literature Number:               Critical Reviews of Literature Abedi, J. (2008). Classification system for English language learners: Issues and recommendations. Educational Measurement, Issues and Practice, 27(3), 17?31. This source asserts that significant decisions concerning the teaching and assessment of English language learners are frequently made on the assumption that the classification system correctly differentiates between learners who are skillful in the use of the English language and learners who are unskilled in the use of the English language. This resource is relevant to my study because it highlights that investigation on appraisal has brought up matters concerning the validity of English language...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Educational Research

...Critical Analysis The of the research is the experience of the The from various backgrounds and the post-graduates have answered a questionnaire designed to outline their experience. The cohort of students was divided into groups according to the criteria of their living background. Those with "manual skilled" and "partly skilled" backgrounds were referred to as disadvantage students, those with "professional" and "intermediate" background were related to the advantaged group. The questionnaire included issues on seven topics concerning their educational university experience. These topics were as following: their family situation, employment, their non-educational activities, financial security, their evaluation of the quality...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Research Paper (Based on Literature Reviews)

..., which would equalize penalties for crack and powder cocaine, thus correcting the injustice. The previous seven bills similar to the Fairness in Cocaine Sentencing Act of 2009 have not been approved. Congress and the President need to review and pass this bill and make it a reality. Specific Objectives The main objective of this paper is to examine the facts or statements of truth that can be examined in the context of racial discrimination in the sentencing of drug offenders and to arrive at conclusions accordingly. It is known that disparities in sentencing are arbitrary for a number of reasons. Before the introduction of the federal compulsory minimum sentencing in 1986 for drugs related violations, the federal drug sentencing...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Literature Reviews

Karen’s review focuses on Elizabeth Cooke’s exemplary life full of challenging misfortunes, which revealed her prowess. This is evident from writings, epitaphs and monuments, which she erected bearing numerous writings on them for her beloved relatives and the husband. Thomas Hoby who her husband; passed on while in Paris leaving her pregnant and the burden of arranging his funeral (Karen, 2011). The excerpt’s core focus entails highlighting Elizabeth’s prowess especially her contribution both as a mother and as a wife figure. The latter is apparent from numerous love verses she authored concerning her marriage as a union comprising of one flesh with Thomas Hoby (Karen, 2011). Karen in her review she features Elizabeth as a dedica...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Educational Research

...Associations between socio-motivational factors, physical education activity levels and physical activity behaviour among youth Introduction This article is a quantitative study about the motivational factors that middle school students have in order to perform physical activities at daily basis and in physical education classes. The study is done by Ning Weihong, Gao Zan, and Lodewyk Ken, and they have used a proper research method of quantitative statistics and concluded the question using first hand research. Summary: Ning (2012)’s purpose of this study was to analyze the student attitudes towards physical activity and the prescribed socio-motivational factors that impact the student’s physical activities. This research...
2 Pages(500 words)Book Report/Review

Characteristic of Murder Scenes in Literature

...The following work analyzes two murder scenes, one of which is extracted from chapter forty-five of Perfume, a novel written by Patrick Süskind, and the other from chapter eleven of Thérèse Raquin, one of Emile Zola’s most famous literary works. In Perfume, Grenouille, the main character, murders a young girl in order to extract her scent which forms the ultimate ingredient required to successfully create his exquisite perfume. The enchanting odour of this perfume would serve Grenouille’s goals as it would make him hypnotize people.On the other hand, in Thérèse Raquin,Thérèse ,an adulterous wife, gives her consent to Laurent, her lover, to kill her own husband,Camille,as he’s the osbtacle standing against their mariage... following work...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Marketing Research Plan: Old Navy

Gap’s credit ratings thereby limiting access to the capital market, international trade matters which may be disruptive of the supply chain, changes to its IT systems disruptive of operations, changes in the IT services agreement with IBM that can disrupt operations and produce adverse effects on financial results, international expansion through franchising and other arrangements may impair the value of its brands if unsuccessful, products are subject to risks associated with overseas outsourcing and manufacturing, and failure of vendors to adhere to Gap’s code of vendor conduct could harm the business. From available data in the 2007 Annual Report, both the Gap and Old Navy brands have exhibited declining net sales....
11 Pages(2750 words)Business Plan

Research Methods in Linguistics

 The writer of content tries to preserve his/her culture and also wants his/her culture to get attached to his/her recent living due to which, he/she makes use of the bilingual aspect to write a narrative.

Because of this writing, the English reader faces some problem in decoding the meaning but he/she realizes the presence of another culture by means of this writing. Many writers provide a glossary at the end so that the readers face no problem in decoding the words given in another language such as Soueif has done but many take it for granted that readers know the other language as well.

The article contains a detailed evaluation of the novel by Soueif which can be categorized as the strength of the re...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Developing a Research Base for Intravenous Peripheral Cannula Resites

...Context of the Paper To begin with, the of the paper is very much apt for the content. Although the could have come up with a more direct title, the title “Developing a Research base for Intravenous Peripheral cannula re-sites. A randomized controlled trial” captures the essence of the paper and what the authors aim to address. They, however, could have made it more direct to the point by maybe saying that the study is about a comparison between 3 day cannula re-sites and cannula re-sites as dictated by clinical condition. Nonetheless, the chosen t title is suitable enough to briefly inform the reader of the topic of the research. Two hypotheses were tested in this paper. There are two groups that were compared in the paper...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Analysis of the Methods of 3 Research Papers about Child Abuse

Research ethics was maintained as the identity of the individuals participating was kept secret. As far as the validity of the study was concerned, the researchers attempted to use content validity in order to get an accurate response. The content validity focused on measuring off the ethnicities and gender percentages within the area and attempting to get a random sample of individuals via the phone. Their approach to random calling allowed for a significant random sample in the study. There were a few issues, however, with this type of approach. Those answering the phone sometimes were not always the desired individual, and not all of the desired people were surveyed. Different replacements did have to be used, and the attempt w...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Structure of the Educational System in Morocco and Its Capacity for Addressing the Needs of the Hospitality Industry

...Independent Research Study An investigation into the Structure of the Educational System in Morocco and its Capa for Addressing the Needs and Expectations of the Hospitality Industry in the Country Submitted by : Submitted to : Course : Date : September 29, 2009 Word Count : 3,069 words STATEMENT OF AUTHORSHIP “I confirm that no part of this work, except where clearly quoted and referenced, has been copied from material belonging to any person e.g. from a book, handout, another student. I am aware that it is a breach of GIHE regulations to copy the work of another without clear acknowledgement and that attempting to do so render me liable to disciplinary procedures.” ________________ Table of Contents I. Consultant’s Brief 4...
15 Pages(3750 words)Research Proposal

Asthma: Importance of Regular Reviews

Most of the patients develop symptoms in early childhood. 80-90 percent of them experience symptoms before 6 years of age (Brenner, 2009). But, the clinical presentation can occur at any age. If left unattended and in the presence of severe symptoms, asthma can contribute to morbidity and mortality. Asthma is an incurable disease and individuals with this condition will need regular follow-up and monitoring of symptoms. In this essay, the importance of regular follow up and review in asthma will be discussed along with clinical manifestations, diagnosing methods and management strategies with reference to an adult patient with asthma who is a passive smoker and is not on regular follow-up.
The most common symptoms of asthma i...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Analysis of Educational Website

.... In other words, availability of information has now become an easy process that used to be a troublesome process in the past. For this purpose, in order to recognize the contribution of internet in the field of education, the paper will specifically identify an educational website, and will carry out its analysis to evaluate the extent of internet in terms of facilitating people from different and diverse backgrounds regardless of their cast, color, and creed. In particular, the researcher chose the Google search engine (2010) to carry out its research for locating an efficient educational website, and within few minutes and with few clicks, it was the official website of “the Smithsonian Center for Education and Museum Studies” (SE, 2010...
7 Pages(1750 words)Article

10 Answers about African American Literature

This sentence describes where Linda gets her strength and hopes in achieving her freedom. Her hopes came once again from hearing her father’s voice as she passed through the old meeting house. Bringing this picture up in this part of the story actually emphasizes the soft voices of those who have been enslaved before, that these people did not put down their plans and hopes for freedom even until their death. That is why in this scenario, the whispers of his father’s voice are very effective for her renewed hopes.

2. “The calm, deliberate composure with which he spoke of his late deeds and intentions, the expression of his fiendlike face when excited by enthusiasm, still bearing the stains of the blood...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

Application of Educational Development Theories

The advances in related fields and the increasing support from research have prompted educators to be reflective and evaluative about pedagogy and curriculum in an effort to ensure that the best learning environment is provided. In short, teachers now have comprehensive tools to guarantee that no child is left behind.

Any child that sets foot into the classroom carries with him/her a myriad of experiences and backgrounds; thus, making it essential to perceive the child in relation to the systems and dynamics that surround him/her. “All areas of development depend on the context of children’s lives—children’s experiences in families, schools, neighborhoods, community organizations, cultural and et...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Article on topic Literature Reviews and Educational Research by Joseph Maxwell for FREE!

Contact Us