StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Dewey and the New Vocationalism - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Dewey raised concerns about education as social reproduction. He argued that education needed to be responsive to new circumstances and requirements, to reflect fresh insights and engage individuals' contributions and divergences, rather than being merely socially reproductive…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.4% of users find it useful
Dewey and the New Vocationalism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Dewey and the New Vocationalism"

Download file to see previous pages John Dewey argues that workers often become no more than "industrial fodder" in a society controlled by money interests. Denied access to information and accumulated wisdom, workers are disempowered and removed from the realm of decision-making. This reality holds dramatic implications for the health of a democratic society.
One such issue in the early 1900s was the proposal that industrial education be provided for children leaving school at twelve or fourteen. The need for this education was manifest in the glaring unfitness of such boys and girls for the work into which nearly all of them went. Not being able to hold their jobs, they drifted from place to place where they learned nothing and where advance became impossible. Educators, social workers, parents, employers, and organizations such as the National Society for the Promotion of Industrial Education had long advocated vocational education for these children; more recently some state legislatures had taken up the matter. Dewey, having long recognized the need of industrial education, was one of its strongest supporters.
Dewey aligned himself with those who favored a single, integrated system of education. He agreed that the dual system would involve costly duplication; that it would nullify much of what had been done in enriching and revitalizing traditional academic education by taking out of the traditional system those manual, industrial, and vocational activities just recently put in; and that it would tend to promote social cleavages among both children and adults.
For Dewey:
a society in which every person shall be occupied in something which makes the lives of others worth living, and which makes the ties which bind people together more perceptible...It denotes a state of affairs in which the interest of each in his work is uncoerced and intelligent...[19]
Another concern of Dewey was that a narrowly conceived approach to vocational education would perpetuate social divisions and in a hardened form, for both the employers and the employees would be intellectually limited. This could leave the employer class confined to issues of profit and power, and the employee class concerned only with monetary return from their labor. This would involve a limitation of intelligence to "technical and non-humane, non-liberal channels."[20] http://www.ed.uiuc.edu/EPS/PES-Yearbook/97_docs/marshall.html
Dewey urged to adopt the integrated system already in use in some of the country's more progressive schools.
The old time general, academic education is beginning to be vitalized by the introduction of manual, industrial and social activities; it is beginning to recognize its responsibility to train all the youth for useful citizenship, including a calling in which each may render useful service to society and make an honest and decent living. (1913, p. 144). (Morgan V. Lewis 2001)
Everywhere the existing school system is beginning to be alive to the need of supplementary agencies to help it fulfill this purpose, and is taking tentative but ...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Dewey and the New Vocationalism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1509284-dewey-and-the-new-vocationalism
(Dewey and the New Vocationalism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/education/1509284-dewey-and-the-new-vocationalism.
“Dewey and the New Vocationalism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1509284-dewey-and-the-new-vocationalism.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Dewey and the New Vocationalism

Admiral George Dewey and Admiral Chester W. Nimitz

... Academy Class of 1905, Nimitz started his profession as a surface officer on several ships. Later, he achieved success as one of the foremost leaders of submarine development and war after being relocated to the new submarine service. These attempts concluded with several aide ranks to flag officers and later control of ships and flotillas2. On the other hand, young Dewey was posted to the steam frigate Wabash after his graduation from the Naval Academy at Annapolis. He stayed here until 1859 when he went back to Annapolis to get his final examination. George Dewey got his first assignment on April 18 1861. He became lieutenant, and in the period from 1861 to 1863, he operated on the Mississippi, which was a steam sloop of the West Gulf...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Dewey believes that the only real education

...?Are Youth Critical Thinkers Today? Dewey made a highly valid argument when he d that “the only real education, the only kind that meaningful, involves hands-won work and critical thinking on the part of the students” in reference to the thinking ability of a modern student. However, this also opens to scrutiny the ability of the modern student to think critically and assess the merits of facts presented to him/her. We have to remember that the Internet and social media are much younger than its predecessor technologies, the newspapers and television, and as such, affects a smaller yet newer population of students who are coming of age in a new school of thought when it comes to critical thinking. Those so-called educators and journalistic...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Ethics of Democracy by John Dewey

...? Ethics of Democracy by John Dewey: A Critical Review of His Essay Having a government is really needed in running a nation as it is the group primarily responsible for the welfare of the society it belongs. It drives the country towards certain growth and development by setting goals and working upon them. Different countries have different ways of choosing their leaders as the spearhead of the government. They are supported then by civil workers in the government or better known as government employees. It would help to understand the concept of government. Understanding also the types of government that emerge throughout history would help in appreciating the importance of the government. A government is made up of people who help...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

John Dewey

... puts a question whether this technique is enough substantial to rate a teacher or there could be another way found which could result a teacher (New York Times). Online Courses versus Degrees: Various technological institutions including Harvard Massachusetts and have introduced online courses. These courses are not degree rewarding. The contemporary critiques are in opinion that if these renowned institutes can offer online courses, then they should also offer credit to course takers. Otherwise there is no significance of such courses. This is about distant learning issue because in distance education, the offering institution rewards a credit or degree as well. The question put forward for discussion is that why this discrimination...
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

John Dewey Significane to Education

... being presented. The role of teachers is to help students organize content and facilitate real-life experiences to reinforce the information included in the lessons. Dewey suggested that experiences in education should reflect the capabilities and readiness of the learner, and the quality of the experience is a critical component of his theory on experience and education. If the experience is appropriate, learners can develop the knowledge needed to apply their experiences to other situations. As a result, they have created new knowledge, have advanced to a different level of readiness, and are prepared to acquire and construct additional knowledge. Dewey was frustrated when philosophers did not view education with sufficient seriousness...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

John Dewey

... Committee on Military Affairs. While opposing compulsory military training as contrary to American ideals, he did endorse a voluntary plan. The schools could perform a significant role in social preparedness. Refusing to blame Woodrow Wilson for the aloofness of America toward the war, Dewey held that the entire tradition of no entangling alliances reflected an educational curriculum that isolated America from European affairs. The United States and Europe were part of the same world that now was becoming more tightly connected due to industry and commerce. A new way of teaching history could become "an infinitely greater factor in national preparedness than a few hours of perfunctory drill." (Dewey, 1916) American history was largely...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Vocationalism

For example, perceiving vocational education as a way to provide population with jobs and thus supply skilled workers to industry would be logically coherent with the definition of vocationalism given above. However, such scope of the research would be useless, because the main question becomes pointless: UK had lower unemployment rate under 25 year-olds than Germany in 2004 (12.1% against 15.1% correspondingly2).
Another view is applied in this essay: integration of vocational education into the social life of the country. Vocational education cannot be measured by sole employment rates, as it is only one of many factors determining employment. One may argue that detachment of vocational system from the workplace in the UK i...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Plato, John Dewey, Maria Montessori

... College: PLATO, JOHN DEWEY, MARIA MONTESSORI The allegory of the cave is associated to Plato metaphor of the sun and the analogy of the separated line. The allegory imagines of a prisoner of a prisoner since childhood in a cave. The prisoner hands, legs, and head are chained such that the only fixation of the eyes is in one direction the wall. There is a big fire and in between there is a walkway that is raised. Puppets of plants, animals and other things are moved on the walkway and they form shadows o the wall the prisoner watches the puppets moves. The prisoners tend to think that the puppets shadow speaks when the person moving the puppets talks and echo's it on the wall moving shadows. To the prisoners the shadows and objects are his...
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Dead Poest Society & John Dewey

... freedom makes the subject to go for vile preferences and decisions. For Keating, he had trained his students to develop freedom and take control of their life decisions, regardless of the existing rules (Kleinbaum & Schulman, 2012). References Dewey, J. (2012). Democracy and Education. Lanham: Start Publishing LLC. Dewey, J. (2007). Experience And Education. New York: Simon and Schuster Franklin, C. G. (2009). Academic lives: Memoir, cultural theory, and the university today. Athens: University of Georgia Press. Kleinbaum, N. H., & Schulman, T. (2012). Dead poets society: A novel. New York: Hyperion....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

New Labour In The United Kingdom

We can acknowledge the re-emergence of New Labour as a party of liberal policies, which is characterized as a belief in legal rights and duties towards a citizen, however, the party’s popularity has affected badly since 2001 for the criticism the new name with an unprecedented comment of ‘spin doctoring’ and ‘New Labour, New Danger’ has brought to it. (Wikipedia, Labour Party UK)
When we focus on the public sector response given to the New Labour’s political vision, it can be seen that New Labour’s public philosophy is a development of the socialist tradition in response to specific dilemmas conceived largely in terms associated with the New Right. This factor should also be considere...
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

The Retail Clothing Store New York and Company

I based this decision upon the knowledge that New York and Company usually holds sales of their own in conjunction with sales held at larger retailers. Although the store stayed pretty busy, I was able to get in a conversation with one of the store’s employees, the store manager and a frequent customer at the store.
With the volume of customers that come through their door, the store is structured as a formal organization in many ways. The salespeople within the store had to work together in a planned group in order to accommodate the customers that were coming in. Trying to assign one salesperson to each customer as some stores do would never have satisfied the need. These various salespeople had a relatively fixed str...
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

To What Extent Does the Concept of Emotional Intelligence Point Towards a New Means of Controlling Workers

Weber believed that ‘the specialized experts organized into smoothly functioning units by the bureaucratic managers would provide these elite managers with a decision-making ability foreign to the parliaments and the courts’ (Glassman et al., 1984, 5). However, in order for the role of managers within bureaucratic environments to be understood, it is necessary to proceed to a thorough examination to the structure and the characteristics of such an environment under normal social and political conditions.

Moreover, the acceptance of Weber’s views on bureaucracy has led to the assumption that bureaucracy (Fry, 1989, 41) ‘is not necessarily rational, it may not be efficient, that other forms of orga...
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

The Induction and Socialization of New Employees

Also, a sense of empathy seems to exist in the best organizations around the world since they think both from the organizational perspective as well as from the side of the employees who are going to give in their best and thus benefit the organization in the long run, not to forget do themselves a favor in terms of their future growth and exposure levels. However, all this is easier said than done since the problems do arise from time to time and it is significant that both the organization and the employee understand that they have to co-exist for the betterment of each other. No one of these two entities could exist in a vacuum and thus it is of paramount importance to understand the very same. The end results would be in terms...
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

The impact of Plant Disease on New Zealand

Transmission of PMTV occurs through inoculation of sap in 26 species belonging to Solanaceae or Chenopodiaceae and to Tetragonia expansa and also through grafting (A. Reavy., W. Kashiwazaki., & Barker,1995 ). In some cases, PMTV is known to be transmitted by mechanical inoculation also.

Since PMTV is vectored only through S.subterranea the infection of plants with PMTV depends on the life cycle of S.subterranea which takes about 10-14 days. The life cycle of S.subterranean takes place in 2 phases: Phase I) This is the primary stage of the life cycle initiated with the germination of resting spores known as sporangiosori or cystosori persisting in the soil as spore balls with thick cell walls into zoosporangia. These...
6 Pages (1500 words) Report

The Launch of Kones New Product

Political: 90% of Kone’s sales come from international markets. This makes it very vulnerable to political stability in its global markets for example Italy is one of the markets of Kone and elevator regulations are governed in Italy by parliament. Thus, to bring MonoSpace i.e. an elevator without a machine room in compliance with standards, it would require an act by the parliament.
Economical: The performance of the elevator industry is directly proportional to the performance of the construction industry. The construction industry has a maximum potential in developing countries rather than in developed countries. The reason for this is that the developed countries have maximized their growth potential whereas the dev...
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

The French New Wave

...The marvelous five directors that made the French New Wave were Francois Truffaut, Claude Chabrol, Eric Romer, Jacques Rivette and Jean- Luc Godard. Directors like Alain Resnais, Agnes Varda, Louis Malle and Chris Marker are also considered as belonging to the movement. But the above mentioned five formed a group of film critics who turned into film making later. The total energetic ambience for the new film movement was set by two great institutions in the history of French cinema ----Cahiers du cinema and The Cinematheque Francaise .Cahiers du Cinema is a militant journal for new film movement founded by the film theorist and critic Andre Bazin in 1950. He edited the journal until his death at the age of forty in 1958.All the five...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Info-Point: Marketing of New Touch Screen Information Technology

The development of the new Info-Point technology, a stand-alone information module designed to offer the public information on tourism, local shopping, weather, and transportation, has created the opportunity to successfully market these information technologies to different UK cities. The entire marketing concept is to establish self-service information centers that offer a wide variety of regional information, utilizing an easy-to-use touch screen methodology to cater to a broad mass market of consumers. 

Touch screen interface systems are becoming more and more common in the UK and abroad. During a pilot experiment using touch screen information technology, the automotive manufacturer Lexus piloted an informatio...
10 Pages (2500 words) Report

Comparing the Brave New World and Todays World

... A Brave New World 26 February Introduction Man has always wondered since time immemorial about his ultimate place in the big universe. He had attempted to find meaning in this scheme of things without much success. A key repeated theme is seeming failure to find that true meaning that will justify his existence. What usually happens is that the more Man goes deeper into the search for ultimate meaning, the more he finds nothing. This is confounding, to say the least, and goes to show how useless the search could be. Many people had been doing this search several times and came up with nothing. Out of this seeming hopelessness and uselessness came the philosophical idea of the absurd – that Mans search for individual meaning is bound...
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

McDonalds New Communication Strategy

McDonald's has been faced with the problem of low differentiation of its operations since it has not been able to considerably differentiate itself from other fast-food chains adequate to acquire a considerable market share rather opts to compete on price instead of new features. To be an outstanding fast-food chain, McDonald's can consider new features like restraint redesigning, addressing changes in customer habits and considering healthier foods. Adoption of the above strategies can help McDonald's differentiate itself from other food chains by having unique operations rather than competing on the basis of price.

The fast-food industry is developing significantly currently due to changes in people's lifestyle which...
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Dewey and the New Vocationalism for FREE!

Contact Us 1