StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Limitations of the Behaviourist Approach to the Study of Learning, with Reference to Chomsky's Critique of Skinner - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The limitations of the behaviourist approach to the study of learning, with reference to Chomsky’s critique of skinner Name Institutional affiliation Tutor Date The limitations of the behaviourist approach to the study of learning, with reference to Chomsky’s critique of skinner 1.0…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
The Limitations of the Behaviourist Approach to the Study of Learning, with Reference to Chomskys Critique of Skinner
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Limitations of the Behaviourist Approach to the Study of Learning, with Reference to Chomsky's Critique of Skinner"

Download file to see previous pages Chomsky’s works have been rated as the most influential pieces in the study of psychology particularly concerning behaviourism. In this case, a lot of transformations were witnessed amongst learners who studied the language. With his works labelled as classics, and having all the evidence in regard to the study of language, as opposed to behaviourism that is too general, this work shall aim to understand the limitations of the behaviourist approach, with the reference to Skinner. 2.0. Body In the views of Noam Chomsky, the aspect of behaviour cannot be understood in the study of B.F. Skinner’s operant conditioning. According to the thoughts of Routledge & Chapman (2005) Chomsky indicates that Skinner’s work is the worst ever written in the history of psychology. In this case, Chomsky indicates that his work comprises tangible evidence and conclusions as compared to the behaviourism standpoint. First, Chomsky argues against the viewpoint of Skinner’s learning through operant conditioning by arguing that one cannot study the behaviour of an individual, but not the components under study. The psychologists in this case, must not rely on the existing evidence and the abilities portrayed by the individuals, but the psychologists must go a step ahead and analyze the contents of the brain of the persons under study. From the brain, the researchers are likely to understand how the behaviours portrayed by the individuals have come into practicality. The brain, according to Chomsky (2006), is the root of the behaviours portrayed by the individual. The behaviours are simply a replica of the processes that go on in the individuals’ brain and cannot be alienated from the end product that is the behaviours of the individuals (Chomsky, 2006). In relation to Chomsky, Skinner went for end product- the behaviours portrayed- without getting to the grounds in which the behaviour has its roots. According to Altmann & Gaskell (2007), Chomsky emphasises that study of the brain gives evidence of the behaviours portrayed by the individuals. In his work, Chomsky compares the study of behaviour to referring to Physics as readings in Science without considering the fact that the readings are mere data collected after an occurrence of a certain experiment by the learners or scientists in the laboratory (Randall, 2007). The study, analysis, testing and comparisons of data in the study of any field are compulsory. The end product cannot be alienated from its components; thus, the study of behaviour by Chomsky holds much evidence as compared to Skinner’s study on operant conditioning and learning. On another view point, Chomsky indicates that yet another limitation of Skinner’s behaviourist approach is that he relied so much on speculations as compared to critical study of the conditional behaviour. Scheer (2010) indicates that Skinner applied experimental investigations that had unfounded experimental techniques that would have led to his study to having valid evidence on human behaviour. The limited significance of the techniques led to the coming up with the premise that behaviour cannot rely on inferences, but critical analysis of facts. According to Shackelford & Vonk (2012), Chomsky holds the view that language can only be understood in relation to Information ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Limitations of the Behaviourist Approach to the Study of Learning, Essay”, n.d.)
The Limitations of the Behaviourist Approach to the Study of Learning, Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1449207-discuss-the-limitations-of-the-behaviourist
(The Limitations of the Behaviourist Approach to the Study of Learning, Essay)
The Limitations of the Behaviourist Approach to the Study of Learning, Essay. https://studentshare.org/education/1449207-discuss-the-limitations-of-the-behaviourist.
“The Limitations of the Behaviourist Approach to the Study of Learning, Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1449207-discuss-the-limitations-of-the-behaviourist.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Limitations of the Behaviourist Approach to the Study of Learning, with Reference to Chomsky's Critique of Skinner

Country Study: Mali

The territory of Mali has had a great history. We have been centers of the Ghana Empire, the Mali Empire, and the Songhai Empire for about six centuries. Thereafter, during the 17th and 18th centuries, several small states developed along the Niger basin, but they fell during the holy war waged by Muslim leader Al-Hajj Umar, whose kingdom extended from Timbuktu to headwaters of Niger and Senegal. His successor, Ahmadu was defeated by the French in 1860. (http://us-africa.tripod.com /mali.html)

As is well-known, we have had a turbulent past. We were a French colony for 80 years until we achieved independence. Now we are a multi-party democracy with Presidential form of Government. While the executive power rests with the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Project Risk Assessment: Qualitative Versus Quantitative Approach

The risks may vary in terms of nature or scope according to the situation. So since the risk is so common in project management, a very important aspect of managing a project is analyzing all the possible risks that are associated with that particular project. It makes no sense of going on with a project and not giving a thought to the risks that could affect the success. Once these risks are analyzed, the project manager will have all the possible risks in front of him. He will know the degree of risk and also the benefits that the organization will get if the risk is taken. Therefore only after a risk analysis, the project manager is in a position to conclude whether or not it is worth taking the risk and going on with a certain...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Outlining Explicit Learning Objectives and Outcomes for Teachers and Students

Explicit learning is presented by teaching the specific concepts individually and mastery occurs then after. The main key in such a mode of teaching is being highly structured in every activity that is undertaken inside the classroom can be considered as part of the organization of the technique. One of the defining features of the technique is the fact that the teacher commonly points out the part of the lesson where they are in, thus, the term used is explicit teaching (Boyles, 2002).
The explicit form of teaching can be considered to fit lessons that are considered to introduce certain concepts, ideas or skills that are needed to be learned and that the students have low familiarity or experience with. For that matter, the...
10 Pages(2500 words)Report

Language Learning Strategies of Listening Comprehension

... definitions used to diagnose individuals. In order to be successful in improving the diagnosis and remediation of learning disabilities, a classification system is needed to identify different types of learning disabilities. Better research that is longitudinal in nature and has been replicated will lead to a better scientific foundation to build upon. Longitudinal research will allow us to study different types of LD and their relationships to other disorders and to construct data for a specific and relevant definition. Longitudinal studies of LD can lead to the identification of better predictors of different types of LD, their prevalence, their developmental course, and their response to intervention (Wong, 1996). The improvement...
10 Pages(2500 words)Case Study

Youth Aggression and Violence: A Psychological Approach

Fergusson et. al. (2002) state that deviant peer choices are prone to contribute to an adolescences propensity to commit the crime, and that this is consistent with a growing amount of evidence. However, their study was able to study how deviant peer choices affects on a crime committed by the adolescent at different ages. The results showed that deviant peer choices and their influence on youth crime decreases as the adolescent gets older. Fergusson et. al. (2002) believe that these results are in accordance with developmental stages, as escalating life experience would ensure less vulnerability to peer influence.

Additionally, evidence shows the affects an unstable family environment can have psychologically and behav...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

The Constructivist Approach to Teaching Science in the Primary Classroom

When students learn science, they construct meanings and develop understandings in a social context, state Duit & Treagust (1998: 4). Classroom verbal discourse in the form of teacher talk and teacher-student interactions form the basis for most of this meaning-making. Because teacher questions are a frequent component of classroom talk, they play an important role in determining the nature of discourse during science instruction. The cognitive processes that students engage in, as they undertake the process of constructing scientific knowledge, to a large extent depend on the kinds of questions that teachers ask and their way of asking the questions.

Chin (2007: 816) conducted a study to investigate questioning-bas...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

A Comparative Study of the Origins of Ethical Thoughts

Do you know what they dug out? -- Wires! It proves that two thousand five hundred years ago, in the age of Pericles, the Greeks had telephones”. The Jew laughingly retorted: “Recently they were digging in Jerusalem. They dug out nothing. This proves that three thousand years ago when Solomon was the king of Judea, the Jews had the principle of wireless!”

ETHICS AND DIVERSE DEFENITIONS: One of the Dilemmas of the civilized human society was the fight between the soul and the flesh or rather the body and desires. The question is how to divert human energy in an intelligent, controlled way? Searching answers to this question one lands in the premise of ethics, personal as well as social. Ethics (English)...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study

Learning and Memory Process

...Profile Report This report compares and contrasts the answers provided by the interviewees X and Jason. Learning and memory process Interviewee X prefers to learn by observation and has the ability to give directions to a place that X has earlier visited. Jason also prefers to learn by observation. Interviewee X prefers to work in silence to avoid distraction whereas Jason prefers distractions as they force him to concentrate. Quietude makes his mind wander. Interviewee X’s preference to work in silence points to the use of committing work to the long term memory. Jason displays a preference to utilize short term memory for his work since it has the capacity to focus on the work at hand despite distractions around. The use of short term...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Organizational Change is an Opportunity for Organizational Learning

Before we move on to how it is beneficial for everyone, even though it is perceived negatively by a large number of people and is one of their biggest fears, we need to discuss the different kinds of changes and the reason behind them.

An organization can go through a structural change. This can be due to a takeover or a complete change of management. In this type of change, the way of working and many dimensions of business activity is altered. This move is usually towards modernization and staying up with the pace but is too fast and sudden, and thus hard for the stakeholders to adjust with. Then there is a change brought about by the change in the services or goods produced and provided. This is usually a positive ch...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

Conflict Between Researh and Ethics on the Tuskegee Syphilis Study

The Declaration of Helsinki by the WHO clearly states that in clinical trials involving humans the wellbeing of the subject should be of prime importance than the interest of science or society. This has been stated because at times in order to achieve the objectives of a study the investigators might overlook the welfare of the trial subjects thus jeopardizing their health in the process. According to ethical rules while comparing two treatment options the control group of the study must receive the best-known treatment available while the study subjects are given a potential newer treatment. Only when there is no effective treatment available a placebo-controlled group can be used for the study. There have been several trials th...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Limitations of the Behaviourist Approach to the Study of Learning, with Reference to Chomsky's Critique of Skinner for FREE!

Contact Us