StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Critical Response to by Karl Hostetler - Article Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Critical Response to Article. The article by Karl Hostetler (2005) on what constitutes “Good” Educational Research considers not only the academic quality of any research in this field, but also its connection with “a robust and justifiable conception of human well-being” (Hostetler, 2005, 16)…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critical Response to by Karl Hostetler"

Download file to see previous pages This preamble marks the paper out as something a little different from the usual mainstream literature, and the impression of novelty is further enhanced by statements to the effect that researchers need to be playful and irreverent about serious subjects, and need to offend some people and annoy others. Hofstetler certainly practices what he preaches, since the article is full of provocative statements that could be taken as undermining the most fundamental values of academic research activity in most contemporary universities. The key problem that Hostetler identifies is a tendency for education researchers to focus on how their work is done, rather than undertaking a deep analysis of what they are doing and why they are doing it. Analogies such as debating which way to investigate the effectiveness of thumbscrews (Hostetler, 2005, 16-17) or herding lemmings toward the cliff (Hostetler, 2005, 17) or even sticking students with cattle prods (Hostetler, 2005, 19) are somewhat ludicrous, but the point important: too many researchers do not reflect enough about the fundamental aim of education and how far their work helps of hinders people who might be affected at some later date by the outcomes of this research. This line of argument flies in the face of standard notions of research which involve concepts such as objectivity and scientific rigor. Without the use of statistics and analytical methods, there would be very little beyond anecdotal evidence to inform policy making and practice. Hofstetler makes a valid point, but he overstates it with his deliberately “naughty” (Hofstetler, 2005, p. 17) examples, and he risks not being taken seriously by the vast majority of interested readers who are quite capable of combining scientific methods with careful ethical reflection, and see no necessary conflict between the two. A second problem that Hostetler describes is that of definitions, for example the very different ways that the conception of “character” in school programs is constituted. Clearly there are quite fundamental variations in the ideologies that can underpin such notions, and Hostetler argues that this complexity is something that needs to be more fully taken into account by researchers. On this point the article is convincing, and certainly there is a case for more clarity in the way that abstract educational terminology is used, especially in government slogans and initiative titles. Hofstetler speaks up for the particular student experiences that are hidden within the data of randomized trial procedures, for example, suggesting that some of the generalizing theories that researchers produce may contain within them actual harm to individual students, since minority results tend to be lost in the bigger picture. Hofstetler questions whether the trade-off is justified, and this is a commendable observation because it highlights the dilemma of that section of the school population with behavioural or learning disorders who are so often lost in the drive for overall quality improvements. This article raises a number of valuable questions, and provides much material for reflection, but it is rather short on concrete answers to these questions. The conclusion which is reached is little more than a platitude expressing approval of the likes of Mahatma Gandhi, Mother Teresa and other moral giants of history and calling for a more ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1436470-response-to-the-article
(Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/education/1436470-response-to-the-article.
“Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1436470-response-to-the-article.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler

Assessment or Response to Intervention/learning disabilities

... a crucial role in helping the students attain their potentials. The teachers of students with learning disabilities should acquire specialized knowledge to individualize a unique form of instruction, to construct special skills and to recommend modifications which are essential for such students, to be successful their studies. “Teachers need to know and understand the critical components of language and literacy relative to the developmental levels of their students so they can ensure that the essential areas are assessed and appropriate instruction is provided” (Colwell, 2010, p. 15). The teachers need to have the ability to determine what types of assessments are appropriate for the multi-purpose data collection in the Response...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

Article response

...Topic - Article Response - China Yawns as U.S. Complains About Auto Tariffs The article here is about the U.S response to the acceleration of tariff on American-made sport utility vehicles and midsize and large cars. The article reinstate that the Chinese government is acting soberly on the complaint of America to The WTO relating to the hike in tariff of automobile and midsized cars. The author states that Obama’s administration has complained to WTO regarding the anti –dumping and anti – subsidy of China has violated up to 22% the free trade rules. According to the article, it was not only United States but even the European Union has responded forcefully regarding the export policy of China on the export of rare earth metals...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Critical Analysis of The General Theory of Employment by J. M. Keynes

...Outline and critical analysis of “The General Theory of Employment” by J. M. Keynes Number] OutlineThesis: General Theory of Employment determines the factors, which affect the level of employment in any nation. 1) Competency of macroeconomic theory and its principles in employment, income of industrial economics and the reasons of vacillation. 2) Principle of Effective demands 3) Uncertainty of future wealth and neo-classical micro-economics 4) Psychology of society is based on conventional judgement regarding perceptions of present, past or future investment. 5) Consumption and expenditure is the main objective of economics. 6) Re-analysis of rate of interest 7) Equilibrium of proposed saving and investment 8...
4 Pages(1000 words)Article

Critical Evaluation of the Accenture on the Innovation Death Spiral

...Critical Evaluation of the Accenture on the Innovation Death Spiral Ways to track innovation in IBM limited Innovation entails the process of establishing more efficient and effective ways of doing things creatively. Innovation may be tracked via creating and implementing new idea into practice. This may help to create necessary improvements and increase organisation productivity. Innovation at IBM limited may be tracked via identifying changes on its business models used. Some of the most common features of an innovative business model that might be used to save an organisation from include: Market evaluation, developing of strategic plan of action, leadership development and empowerment, creating proper networks with customers...
4 Pages(1000 words)Article

Peer Response

...Peer ResponseResponse to O.R.’s Post: One strongly agrees with the contention that, although the experimentation was deemed to be not typical, yet feasible; the fact that there is a perceived unfairness and inequality in implementation makes it subject to ethical concerns for social and behavioral disciplines.As recognized, the findings from the study showed significant advantages for low-income tenants who had been accorded with the privilege of a legal counsel. As such, the provision of a legal counsel was confirmed to have increased the chances of being provided with rent abatements and reimbursements for fund spent for repairs. Therefore cases sharing similar characteristics with the provision of legal counsel for low-income tenants...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Critical Thinking

...CRITICAL THINKING Person with disability have for so long been ignored on human rights activities relating to sexuality.Sexuality is a quality that each and every human being possesses. It dictates matters pertaining to sexual orientation, sex life, and gender roles among many other factors. However, while people with disability have a right to their sexual lives, they are often victims of exploitation and abuse. This situations poses a great challenge to caregivers who are charged with the responsibility of protect disable persons from exploitation and abuse. Caring for disabled person is a difficult task especially when it relates to their sexual needs. Since they are humans, they have the constitutional right to express themselves...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Relationship Between Food Safety and Critical Violations on Restaurant Inspections: An Empirical Investigation of Bacterial Pathogen Content

...Critique of the “Relationship between Food Safety and Critical Violations on Restaurant Inspections: An Empirical Investigation of Bacterial PathogenContent” Name Institution Course Critique of the “Relationship between Food Safety and Critical Violations on Restaurant Inspections: An Empirical Investigation of Bacterial Pathogen Content” Introduction Yeager and her colleagues (2013) carried out a study in the American Food system to determine the level of food safety in two groups of restaurants. According to the American regulations, inspections of restaurants should take place at least thrice a year. However, restaurants that do not meet the expected standard may be subject to more investigation sessions. The purpose of the study...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

Critical Look on the Three Categories of Infant Temperament

...Critical Look on the Three Categories of Infant Temperament With the increasing rate of autism in the United States reaching epidemic proportions, parents are becoming more aware of it and its impact on their lives and that of their children (Yazbak, 2003). Because autism is a developmental disorder that does not present physical abnormalities, it cannot be diagnosed easily, especially on infants. However, telltale signs of autism can be observed through the infant’s behavior. Because of this, parents, especially new ones, are usually very anxious about the behavior of their babies. They always wonder if their babies are exhibiting normal behavior or if they might be found to have abnormal disorders like autism. When their babies show...
7 Pages(1750 words)Article

Critical Analysis of Hebrew Literature Curriculum for Arab Sector in Israel

...Critical Analysis of Hebrew Literature Curriculum for Arab Sector in Israel Abstract This paper analyses the paper “The portrayal of the Jewish Figure in Literary Texts Included in the Present Matriculation Curriculum in Hebrew for Students of the Arab Sector in Israel” written by Sara Zamir and Sara Hauphtman (2001). It was published in the Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies (JCEPS, volume 7. no. 1, pages 217 to 241), a Marxist radical left publication. Sara Zamir (affiliated with Ben-Gurion University, Eilat and Achva Academic College of Education) and Sara Hauphtman (Achva Academic College of Education) applied the capitalist’s neoliberalism framework in the discourse instead of critical pedagogy of the Marxist framework...
20 Pages(5000 words)Article

Critical Factors that Determine the successful Implementation of Knowledge Management in Organizations

... Critical Factors that Determine the successful Implementation of Knowledge management in Organizations Introduction: Knowledge is said to be the key to effectiveness and innovation at workplace, a misconception among people being that a knowledge rich organization is essentially a successful one. That however is far from the truth. Organizations today are working in an environment where the very air is laden with information. In this world of cut-throat completion, how do organizations remain one step ahead of their competitors in the knowledge game? The answer of this question first emerged in the mid-nineties, when the concept of “ Knowledge Management’ started to become common. Knowledge management has been described as the process...
12 Pages(3000 words)Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Article on topic Critical Response to Article by Karl Hostetler for FREE!

Contact Us