Union Demands - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The case study depicted a scenario in which an apartment building was threatened by the formation of a union among the janitorial staff. These janitors already received great benefits including free apartment rental, but some employees were looking to unionize the janitorial staff…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
Union Demands
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Union Demands"

The case study depicted a scenario in which an apartment building was threatened by the formation of a union among the janitorial staff. These janitors already received great benefits including free apartment rental, but some employees were looking to unionize the janitorial staff. Some of the benefits of forming a union include increase in employee wages, reduce inequality, improve fringe benefits, and better pension plans (Mishel & Walters, 2003). Orval Schimel, a union organizer, held a meeting in which he gained the support of 6 of 11 janitorial workers. In the apartment building the supervisor, Larry Melton, was very mad that the employees were interested in forming a union. Mr. Melton began a behavioral pattern that was hurting the employees because he was making inquiries to several employees about the dealings of the union with the janitorial workers. Larry Melton was harassing the employees by calling them at home with questions about the affairs of the union. Larry did not have the right to call the employees after labor hours and ask them about things that occurred outside the workplace. He was violating both the trust of the employees and their privacy. Some of the claims of wrongdoing by the union in regards to the actions of the company included: Repeatedly interrogating employees about union activities. Threats of reducing of benefits. Threatening the employees for refusal to reveal the identities of who attended the union meetings. Forcing employees to reveal the nature of the private union meetings. Making employees offers of better medical benefits if they fail to join the union. In my opinion the majority of the claims made by the union were true. Larry Melton acted in an unethical manner in regards to the union activity with the janitorial workers. He pushed the employees to tell him information that they did not have to reveal. His actions constituted harassment. The company realized that Larry Melton acted wrongly and in order to protect the firm the company decided to terminate his employment contract. One of the arguments of the company was that they were not aware of the behavior of Larry Melton and that his actions were not sponsored by the company. Despite his action being wrong the company claimed they were not coercive that that he simply wanted to know if the union had the support of the employees to determine if a true majority existed. The company also claimed that neither George Thompson nor any of the employees were really threatened. The language used by the supervisor was vague and inconclusive. The firm also claimed that the increase in medical benefits offer was a routine annual increment that was in no way used to manipulate the decision of the workers in regards into accepting or not the union. When comparing the arguments made by the union and by the company I believe that the union has the more persuasive argument. I do not think that the statement made by Nord is fully protected by free speech as the company claimed. In reality Nord was against the union from the start and one of his first directives as supervisor was to ensure that the unionization of the janitors did not occur. The union wanted the NLRB to accept the request for unionization based on the authorization cards submitted by the union prior to the election. The union believes that these cards should be accepted because the results of the election were coerced by the company. The claim of the union does not have any legal validity because the union did not prove the true existence of coercion. Coercion can be defined as the use of intimidation to obtain compliance (Dictionary, 2012). The entire ordeal with the union and the company in regards to the rights of the janitors had lots of inconsistencies that may have affected the results of the elections. I believe that the best course of action is for a new election among the janitors to occur to truly determine if the majority of the janitors want a union or are happy without its existence. This case study was very interesting because it showed a scenario in which a company felt threatened by the existence of a union. Overall I believe that the company acted in an unethical manner in their efforts to prevent the janitors of the company to become a part of a union. In the United States all non-managerial workers have the right to unionization. There are 14.8 million workers that belong to unions in the U.S. (Bls, 2012). References (2012). Union Members – 2011. Retrieved March 27, 2012 from (2012). Coercion. Retrieved March 27, 2012 from Mishel, L., Walters, M. (2003). How Unions Help all Workers. Retrieved March 27, 2012 from Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Union Demands Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Union Demands Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“Union Demands Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document


Union versus non-union

...? Union versus Non-Union of the of the Concerned January 7, Union versus Non-Union The issue under consideration is pivotal in the free market economies as they are capital driven and have to hire skilled personnel to accomplish varied tasks in the procurement, production, marketing and distribution of goods and services. There is no denying the fact that the capitalist classes enjoy leverage over other aspects of production like labor owing to their financial wherewithal and acumen. On the contrary, in the case of skilled personnel, of all the possible leverages available to them, their collective bargaining power is the most important factor that can help them match the...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Eropean Union

...?European Union In addition to the United s, the European Union represents the foremost political and economic partnership in the Western hemisphere. The EU constitutes twenty-seven independent member states through Europe. While the union has a developmental background throughout the early part of the 20th century, it did not emerge in its current incarnation until in was established by the Maastricht Treaty in 1993 (Staab). The European Union operates through a system of supranational institutions. These institutions include a variety of prominent branches, including the European Commission, the Council of the European Union, the European Parliament,...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

European Union

...International business law falls under the ambit of public international law. Basically, “public international aw governs the relations between states. It comprises a body of rules and principles which seek to regulate relations between states,” (Dugard, 1994, p.2). As such, the European Union (EU) falls under public international law since it involves different states. This is clearly outlined by the European Union (2013) when it states that “the European Union is based on the rule of law. This means that every action taken by the EU is founded on treaties that have been approved voluntarily and democratically by all EU member countries.” As such, this part of the paper seeks to outline...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

Student's Demands on and Expectations

...Demands on and Expectations of HIGH SCHOOL & Introduction: Education is a vital aspect of a modern-world-man's life. There are different level institutions for different educational levels. As a person grows older, he moves through these levels passing the lower one to reach the higher one. High school and university are two different levels of educational institutions. In a high school, the students are carefree teenagers or rather in the transition from a teenager to an adult. Although they are not completely able to take their decisions and make their choices on their own, they are way more learned and mature than typical school students. But still, they are not mature enough to take complete responsibility (although partial... ) for their...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

European Union

...Introduction The monetary and economic revolution embodied in the European Union (EU) entails far more than the elimination of 25 national currencies and the distribution of colourful new banknotes and coins across Europe. Chabot stated that this revolution involves the solidification of a European market of goods and services, major structural changes in countries plagued by fiscal negligence, and the reorganization of monetary policy in some of the world's most advanced industrialized economies (3). Chabot continues that though at a first glance it may seem that a new trans-European currency [and economic policies] would hold little significance outside of banking and tourist circles, the European Union...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

European Union

...Running head: European Union Introduction The European Union (EU) is an international organization consisting of twenty-five European states. The Maastricht Treaty established this union. The Treaty of Accession 2003, which got into force on May 1, 2004, is the union’s current legal base. It has its headquarters in Brussels. The European Union has various activities including the most important of all – a common single market. This market consists of a common agricultural policy, common fisheries policy, customs union and single currency adopted by twelve of the twenty-five member states. The union also has a range of initiatives to manage the member states’ activities (Ocana, 2003). The member states benefit from both internal... and...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Physical Demands Analysis

...Physical Demands Analysis Department Wastewater handling plant operations Reports to Regulatory duties supervisor Company depiction Real Company Practice Firm is an organization aimed at serving certain private features of Canadian ecology that the government does not have influence over. Real company practice firm processes real firm program associates with realistic and specialist trading atmosphere. This way, the organization is able to offer valued work experience in the respective domains and enable practice of job skills. Real company practice firm also assist new inhabitants of Canada to benefit from the one of a kind opportunities of practicing skills and being taught about the Canadian work surrounding. Real...
2 Pages(500 words)Admission/Application Essay

Teamsters Union

...Teamsters Union – Organizational structure Teamsters Union – Organizational structure Teamsters Union – Administration and Membership Overview Teamsters Union was established in 1903; since then, the Union has developed strong conflicts for supporting the rights of its members, i.e. of employees in all industries across USA (Organizational website, History). Today, the Union represents employees worldwide. The success of the Union has been highly related to its structure, meaning especially the administration and membership policies. Administration in Teamsters Union Teamsters Union has...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

European Union

...European Union Croatia is the 28th member of the EU. Once it joined the EU, it declared its maximum support for the EU goals. In all the new post-socialist EU states, Croatia is the first member country that is post-conflict. Croatia’s neighboring states strive to become EU members even when the union is in crisis (Vukadinovic, 2013). In the EU, the Treaty Functioning of the European Union (TEFU) is like the jewel in EU law’s crown. This is because it gives the national court power to follow up with Court of Justice and request it to make rulings regarding EU legal act. Considerable variations exist in the diverse member states and this is apparent especially in situations concerning...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Labor Unions Demands and Prioritization

...Labor Union Mock Negotiation Paper Table of Contents Labor Union’s Demands and Prioritization 3 Company’s Demands and Prioritization 5 Item’s willing To “Give” On By the Both the Sides and Its Reason 6 “Deal breakers” Issues and its Reasons 8 Length of the Contract and its Reasons 9 References 10 Labor Union’s Demands and Prioritization Labor unions are special interest groups which are formed by the organization of workers for the protection of their rights and their interests. Labor unions are responsible for negotiating with the management on behalf of the workers. In the provided case, ‘Local...
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Union Demands for FREE!

Contact Us