Nobody downloaded yet

International management - Ethics - Moral relativism vs moral universalism - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Running Head: Business Google’s Moral Compromise in China: A Struggle between Universalism and Relativism A Case Analysis Name Name of Professor Introduction The issue of moral relativism versus moral universalism involves a philosophical premise, regarding the universality of ideas, not of values…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful
International management - Ethics - Moral relativism vs moral universalism
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "International management - Ethics - Moral relativism vs moral universalism"

Download file to see previous pages This analysis starts with a brief description of the debate between moral relativism and moral universalism. The second section presents an analysis of the case, which is Google in China, in terms of its connection to the ethics debate. Particularly, the analysis tries to determine whether China’s Internet censorship approach is universalistic or relativistic, and, more importantly, whether Google’s response to the impenetrability of China’s culture and ideals reflects a universalistic or relativistic model of morality. Overview of the Moral Relativism and Moral Universalism Debate Moral relativism is the view that moral standards are particular or distinct to culture and personal judgments. It argues that a universal moral standard does not exist. On the other hand, moral universalism argues that morality is valid universally, irrespective of gender, race, religion, culture, nationality, or other unique attributes; in the debate, Universalists claim that morality have been concretely delineated in different international agreements and declarations whereas relativists relate to distinct cultural viewpoints (McDonald, 2010). The various morality theories are generated by various view of morality. These theories have built divisions and barriers in human society. The influence of these moral views on people’s lives is considerable. It affects the moral attitude and behavior of individuals. Hence, there are dilemmas of ethical conflicts and double moral standards. Individuals are not certain of the form of morality they should conform to, either moral universalism or moral relativism. This predicament is continuously experienced by Google in their operation in China. Moral relativism, in business, usually becomes traditional morality and unethical decisions are usually defended on the theory of ‘commonly accepted practice’ (McDonald, 2010, 451). A number of scholars in international business have been distrustful of circumstances where moral relativism has been employed as a kind of ‘moral sanctuary’ (McDonald, 2010, 451). For instance, companies may have carried out a decision which generally would be viewed as unethical but have asserted that the decision is ethical, or reasonable, since it falls within a particular cluster of moral norms promoted by the society where in they are in service. In reaction to this argument, which basically reinforces the arguments that deeds are impervious to common moral standards because they originate from a particular set of standards or codes that surpass general norms, Roberts (1986 as cited in McDonald, 2010) has argued that, because of the intricacies of international business, there is a certain extent of excuse for companies demanding immunity from moral censure by sheltering behind premises of moral relativism, particularly because of their need to make room for diverse cultural situations. Unsurprisingly, this argument is controversial. It may be appealing to refuse to believe that there are universal principles that can provide direction to those whose trade has to be carried out on a global arena. Maybe, multinational business firms should recognize and applaud relativism as a principle and proclaim itself in support of an ethic of conduct that is situational, domestic, and local. The strength of relativism in international ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“International management - Ethics - Moral relativism vs moral Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1433151-international-management-ethics-moral-relativism
(International Management - Ethics - Moral Relativism Vs Moral Essay)
https://studentshare.org/business/1433151-international-management-ethics-moral-relativism.
“International Management - Ethics - Moral Relativism Vs Moral Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1433151-international-management-ethics-moral-relativism.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF International management - Ethics - Moral relativism vs moral universalism

Ethics and moral character

...?Ethics and Moral character about Henry Ford Henry Ford, the automobile pioneer in the American industry, is renowned for his unique vision, social responsibility, entrepreneurship, industrial philosophy, business ethics and moral character. Ford believed in industrial mass production and he never deviated from business ethics and morality while climbing the ladders of success. His social philosophy was one of strong progressivism. He believed that the primary responsibility of any industry is towards the society and he rated the success of a business enterprise based on its ability to provide service to the society. He stressed on cost-and means-efficient production of goods whereby the public could afford to acquire these goods... figure...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Moral Management

..., the public confidence on business people and politicians has plummeted to an all time low because of high level of unethical behavior that they are engaged in to build careers, create wealth to meet their social obligations. Real integrity has been lost and people are obsessed with wrongdoing. People are more concerned with obscuring the truth and this has ruined many people’s careers and reputations in a world that is increasingly demanding transparency and accountability. References Aguilar, F. (1994). Managing corporate ethics. New York: Oxford University Press. Baron, D. (2001). Private politics, corporate social responsibility and integrated strategy. Journal of Economics &...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Moral Relativism

...Moral relativism Moral relativism is a philosophical theory that morality, principles, ethics are relative which are culturally dependent as well count on an individual’s choice. This morality is not absolute, it does not hold for all people at any place and it depends on time and situation too. Moral relativism allows people to give their point of view in accordance what is right and wrong for an individual. It does not limits a person rather offers to make his/her own decision. A professor of Philosophy at Cambridge University, Simon Blackburn describes his own opinion...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Hobbes, Machiavelli and Moral Relativism

...? The Virtue of Expediency: Hobbes, Machiavelli and Moral Relativism The Virtue of Expediency: Hobbes, Machiavelli and Moral Relativism In 1532, Niccolo Macchiavelli penned what has become accepted as the definitive treatise on political power in the history of Western literature. The Prince was written as both a philosophy and “how-to” manual for Lorenzo di Medici, scion of the ruling Florentine family with which Macchiavelli is generally associated. Macchiavelli’s seminal work is concerned with the acquisition and maintenance of power, by whatever means are available and necessary. The morality that The Prince espouses has immortalized the famous notion that the ends justify the means, that a ruler should not concern himself... with...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Moral & Cultural Relativism

...his opinion concerning the taste is right or wrong. In this case, the opinions concerning ice cream tastes are relative. In the context of mathematics, when one presents a calculation like 3+3=5, we term the situation as wrong. We do not say that the calculations depend on the taste and perception of the person doing it but we say that the person is wrong. In this case, there are clearly defined standards that differentiate right from wrong. This mathematical example amounts to a context of absolutism. When extended to the contexts of morality, these contexts lead to the aspects of moral relativism and moral absolutism (Rauchut 349). Moral...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Ethics -- Moral Theory and Moral Issue

... of ethics, according to Kant, suggests “the more difficult the duty, the greater the moral value.” By this he is implying that one should not interfere with the natural dying process, being strong, true to your morals, is more significant than ending life for self-serving reasons. Furthermore, according to Kantian Ethics the law should be obeyed because there is greater contentment in the realization that you have followed the law without applying situational ethics. Kantian Ethics also maintain that “the intentions of an act are more important than the act itself.” (Telfer, 2009). Kant feared that if society legitimized euthanasia for those mentally competent the society could also legitimize it for the incompetent using similar... was...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Ethics and Moral Principles

...in them by various stakeholders besides the fact that they are the leading bank and should take the first step in aiding over one billion persons languishing in poverty (World Bank Conference on Development Economics, Bourguignon, Pleskovic, & World Bank. (2005). References Ferrell, O. C., Fraedrich, J., & Ferrell, L. (2013). Business ethics: Ethical decision making and cases. Mason, OH: South-Western/Cengage Learning. Gillroy, J. M., & Bowersox, J. (2002). The moral austerity of environmental decision making: Sustainability, democracy, and normative argument in policy and law. Durham: Duke University Press. Hume, D., & Sayre-McCord, G. (2006). Moral...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

What is moral relativism

...Moral Relativism Literally understood, moral relativism as a philosophical idea suggests that morality is relative. “Moral truths hold for differentpeople” (“Moral Relativism,” n.d.). There is no absolute or ultimate standard of what is moral or not. In other words, moral relativism as a theory in philosophy connotes that “there is no single true morality” because what is “moral right and wrong are always relative to a choice of moral framework” (Harman & Thomson, 1996). It has two forms,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Some Moral Minima, ethics and relativism

...SOME MORE MORAL MINIMA, ETHICS AND RELATIVISM” In some more moral minima Lenn Goodman has dealt upon with four distinctive s which affect our modern society. I agree with Lenn Goodman when he deals with certain things that are simply wrong and should never be done. These ideas play an important role in our society and culture and the moral relativism is applicable on a universal scale. Goodman (2010) particularly dealt with four ideas respect for life, deference to truth, and abhorrence of theft and rejection of adultery. I agree what Goodman has to say on these specific issues because in no time in the history and the...
3 Pages(750 words)Article

Moral relativism and Moral absolutism

...situation based on bible teachings. The concept of moral absolutism has been criticized since some of the common human behaviors being currently witnessed in the world will go against some of the bible teachings followed by radical Christians. The critics have continuously argued that the notion of moral relativism plays a vital role in the analysis of various ethical along with moral matters. This is arguably because human beings do not dwell in a motionless world containing absolutes (Moral Relativism. Info). It is for this reason that Immanuel Kant introduced a categorical imperative which compels us to “act as if the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic International management - Ethics - Moral relativism vs moral universalism for FREE!

Contact Us