StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Influence of Context in Understanding of Art - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The writer of the current essay would discuss the importance of context in evaluating art pieces through comparative analysis of sculpture and painting of Three Graces. The writer would describe two drastically stories behind the piece and investigate how it affects its perception…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
Influence of Context in Understanding of Art
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Influence of Context in Understanding of Art"

Influence of context in understanding of art through comparative analysis of sculpture and painting of Three Graces. Three Graces are quite popular subjects for description in the world history of art, implemented in different genres. The objects of comparison are two realizations of the famous goddesses: the painting of Three Graces by Sandro Botticelli, and the sculpture of Three Graces (Roman copy of a Greek work of the second century B.C. (marble). A difference between the artworks is the following: even though they both describe the same subjects, the sculpture itself demonstrates almost nothing but bodies of Charites, whereas the painting gives us much more semantic information about the subjects than the sculpture does. Botticelli’s painting of Three Graces (1482) is a fragment of the tempera panel painting “Primavera”; it describes three Greek mythological goddesses Aglaia, Thalia and Euphrosyne. They are pictured dancing and holding their hands, looking at each other. The women look a kind of alike, they have the same hair color and the textures of their dresses are also similar, which shows that artist intended to picture them as a separate part from the whole composition, but didn’t want to emphasize on each of them, on the contrary, Botticelli made them as one element of the painting. The lines on the painting are soft and precise; color and shading form a three-dimensional picture – these factors influent on the naturalistic visualization of the Graces. The curling hair of the goddesses and the translucent elements of their clothes create an impression of lightness and serenity of women’s characters, and the dark background simultaneously emphasizes on this impression by contrasting, but also alienates this group of characters from the others in the painting. Three Graces are depicted extremely naturally; with a high technique Botticelli succeed to describe the goddesses both mythically and realistically. The sculpture of Three Graces (Roman copy of a Greek work of the second century b.c (marble) is an image of three young women, holding each other’s shoulders, the one in the middle is turned backwards. Some of the women have their hands cut and they all don’t have a head details, the statue was damaged, the artist created this work is unknown. Because of the damages this work of art cannot be properly interpreted. The sculpture is made of marble, white color and smooth surface; the figures of goddesses are real human sized, they stand on ovoid base surrounded by two pillars on lateral sides. Elements of the sculpture were made smooth and polished; in addition, the connection between women in the composition is obvious: they stand interwoven with each other like they are both separate persons and simultaneously the one. A balance of light and shadow was definitely maintained by sculptor, because an emplacement of the figures was made perfectly to create a contrast between dark and light accents in composition. It’s hard to understand which sides the heads of the women are tuned towards, and to recognize the emotional aspect of the sculpture, which makes big problems in interpretation and analyzing of the figures. It is even possible to say that if the name of the sculpture wasn’t known, it would be hard to understand that it’s three Graces, who are depicted in the sculpture. So there is not as much interpretative value in this sculpture as in the painting we are comparing it with; probably, the sculpture is more valuable as antique artifact. Comparing these two descriptions of Charites, it becomes pretty obvious that they are just slightly similar. First of all, because of the form of realization: sculpture and painting. The sculpture is made of marble and it is wholly white, which means that a choice of colors and shadows can’t influent on viewer’s imagination like it does in the picture. Which is even more important is that the sculpture is lack of some details, as it was mentioned before, so this fact takes a lot of interpretation. The most visible difference between the works is that the Graces in the painting are dressed, but in the sculpture they have no clothes. Also, it is worth noticing that however the sculpture is volumetric itself and a viewer can consider it from all sides, Botticelli also made his Graces volumetric operating with lines, light, and shadows, so the only side viewer can’t see the women is back, which in fact doesn’t take much from the full perception of them. Looking at the poses of Graces in both art works it is more possible to recognize their characteristics through the painting than the sculpture: painted Graces are dancing, almost soaring under the ground, when marble ones just stand holding each other, which adds some gravity into their image. In Roman mythology three Graces are the analogies of Greek Charites, goddesses, who embody the eternal youth, virtue, joy; in the “Odyssey” by Homer they are handmaidens of the goddess of love and beauty Aphrodite. In “Theogony” by Hesiod they are Zeus’s daughters and their names are: Aglaia ("shining"), Euphrosyne ("virtuous"), Thalia ("blooming"). Actually, there are many variations of Charites’ names and the amount of them in different myths, but the main idea of these mythic characters is that they are a personification of the ideal of human virtue, chastity, and joy. Because of their image as lightness and mirth in art works the goddesses frequently are described as the enjoying themselves and dancing ones. Which is worth noticing, they are never separated from each other, each of them embodies different thing, but in fact they show that these things (joy, virtue, love, fertileness, etc.) have the same nature. The subjects in both art works we considered are three beautiful women holding each other, without knowing mythological and historical discourse a viewer wouldn’t been able to estimate whether the artists, who created the works, managed to image the Graces properly. In art Charites are usually are depicted in the following way: two of them stand facing a viewer, and the one in the middle stands back. This was their antique posture, lately copied by Renaissance artists. The way they stand may show that symbolically they are the one, so they usually stand close up to one another, and, forming a closed circle, cannot be separated. In different times Graces endowed with different allegorical meanings, which diversified the way they were positioned in relation to each other and whether they had clothes or not. A lack of clothes meant that the girls are so beautiful and frank that nothing must be hidden it their bodies – they are an embodiment of beauty and virtue. In the context of Botticelli’s “Primavera” they symbolize a moral part of human nature development, penultimate phase of man’s purifying. This probably was declined by Botticelli himself, which is obvious in consideration of three Graces together with the other subjects and their positions in the painting. The three Graces (Charites) are the characters with a wide meaning in the history of art. Evidently, Botticelli’s painting is much more comprehensive in the ways of representation of the subjects, because of richer means of the image implementation and wider context in which the heroines may be considered by viewer. Unfortunately, because of some damages, the sculpture cannot give us much information about the subjects, except the bodies and their position details. Works cited: Botticelli, Sandro. Primavera. 1482. Tempera on panel. Uffizi Gallery, Florence. Marble Statue Group of the Three Graces (Roman copy of a Greek work of the 2nd century B.C.). II century A.D. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Influence of Context in Understanding of Art Essay, n.d.)
Influence of Context in Understanding of Art Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1644622-art-essay-statement-and-analysis
(Influence of Context in Understanding of Art Essay)
Influence of Context in Understanding of Art Essay. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1644622-art-essay-statement-and-analysis.
“Influence of Context in Understanding of Art Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1644622-art-essay-statement-and-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Influence of Context in Understanding of Art

How Does The Concept Of Children's Rights Influence The Work Of International Agencies And Development NGOs

Emphasising on this understanding, the paper will aim at assessing and summarising the impacts of children's right related provisions on the operations of international agencies and NGOs in the current day context.... In this context it reflects the right that are associated with the basic physiological as well as physical needs which majorly include food, health care, criminal law benefits and education and it will be discussed in this paper.... It is worth mentioning in this context that the government has taken certain initiatives which include the rescue measures, rehabilitation and active participation measures concerning children's rights protection....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Structure and Agency on Human Thought

However, according to Levine "in terms of identity formation and maintenance, two key issues pertain to (a) the relevance of the concepts of structure and agency for understanding identity, and (b) the extent to which identity is conceptualized as having an "inner" versus "outer" origin.... When taken together, this review suggests that although receiving early parental support may be an important predictor of mental and physical health outcomes in later life, the impact of early parental support can be fully appreciated only by identifying the social structural factors that are most closely associated with receiving poor support in early life and understanding how associations between levels of support received during childhood....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Self-Concept Behind the Word Self

The valid context in understanding the self-concept is through the understanding of 'I and Me'.... Cooley shaped the term identity as something which is created by the influence of others that is others play an important part in shaping one's identity.... The paper describes the concept of self-concept....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Establising Integrity and Anticipating Ethnical Challenges

In the interview process, the dialogue that is created can have an interesting turn of events if a new aspect of the concept is revealed and the… Spontaneous statements must be directly relevant to the focus, or the use of them can change the scope of the study.... When the scope is changed, the focus no longer has the clarity that is desired. During participant observation, the Participant observations can be considered observations that reveal only the public persona, while the responses of the interview will be intended to reveal the under layers of a relationship....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Assessing the Quality of Qualitative Research

Credible/clear discussion of how findings have contributed to knowledge and understanding (e.... There are two research paradigms which have two different views of reality.... Quantitative research assumes reality to be well defined and can be… While on the hand Qualitative research “is a form of social inquiry that focuses on the way people interpret and make sense of their experiences and the world they live” (Holloway, 1997, p1)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Language Development Within the Context of Amy Tans Mother Tongue

hen examining my personal experience with second language acquisition within the context of Amy Tan's 'Mother Tongue' one of the predominant connections that exist is the influence of my family on my own linguistic development.... The influence of Tan's mother on her own development becomes one of the predominant themes of the text.... The paper "Language Development Within the context of Amy Tan's "Mother Tongue" focuses on the culturally loaded nature of language....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Reasons for Freuds Regard of Dreams Interpretation as Important in Understanding the Human Psyche

Thus, appropriate interpretations, of the two aforementioned levels, and aid in one's understanding of 'when, whether, and how such human unconscious processes become truly relevant in day-to-day human interaction.... In a dream, the two contexts aforementioned – manifest and latent content – are unique in, in the quest towards understanding the sub-conscious'....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

Self as a Social Product

The concept is clear on the fact that social influences massively influence individual perceptions about issues and objects.... The paper "Self as a Social Product" discusses that the formation of the Self from human social experiences is premised upon phenomenology, behaviourism and role theory....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us