StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor” the author analyzes Garrett Hardin’s article. He comes up with convincing arguments in relation to the tragedy of the commons and he purports that the basic error of spaceship ethics is that it leads to ‘the tragedy of the commons…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor"

This is the tragedy of the commons." (Hardin) Therefore, Hardin establishes his concept of 'the tragedy of the commons in a highly convincing manner with ample illustrations and explanations and he maintains that an important task of education today should be the creation of an acute awareness of the dangers of the commons.

One of the most significant interpretations of the arguments of Hardin concerning 'the tragedy of the commons' was offered by De Young in his article "Tragedy of the commons", in which the author comes up with serious criticisms of Hardin's arguments. According to De Young, Garrett Hardin's concept of the 'tragedy of the commons has been important in understanding how humanity has come to the brink of several environmental catastrophes. He maintains that the dangerous situations in human life are the creations of the innocent behaviors of many individuals acting alone.

Analyzing the arguments of Hardin, De Young investigates if the tragedy that Hardin suggests is inevitable. Thus, he comes up with the conclusion that "Hardin's predictions for the inevitable over-exploitation of a commons were based solely on consideration of open access situations. And in fact, case studies document that tragedies do occur when an open-access system supplants a pre-existing successful CPR management system. Thus while a tragedy is not inevitable it is a more likely outcome if one is dealing with a CPR that is subtractable, able to be overused and experiencing unrestrained, open access.

" (De Young) Therefore, De Young challenges the argument of Hardin that a tragedy is inevitable if the 'pasture' becomes a commons open to all. However, a reflective analysis of both the articles makes it lucid that Hardin's predictions for the inevitable over-exploitation of the commons were not based on a single aspect of the issue. On the contrary, consideration of open access situations merely forms a part of the general framework of the pieces of evidence against the inevitable tragedy of the commons.

The general tone of the concept of lifeboat ethics confirms this notion and the fundamental error of spaceship ethics is, obviously, that it leads to 'the tragedy of the common'. In conclusion, De Young's objection is not completely acceptable in the general framework of the concept of 'the tragedy of the common', although it does not completely negate the argument by Hardin.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words, n.d.)
Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1524686-hardins-argument-concerning-lifeboat-ethics
(Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1524686-hardins-argument-concerning-lifeboat-ethics.
“Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1524686-hardins-argument-concerning-lifeboat-ethics.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor

Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor by Garrett Hardin

This book report "Lifeboat Ethics: the case against helping the poor by Garrett Hardin" discusses the arguments against the death penalty in that people change and may be rehabilitated.... In other words, the majority of the poor countries remain poor even after the introduction of globalization because of various reasons such as ethnic clashes, lack of good governance, lack of infrastructure to exploit globalization opportunities, lack of education, etc.... Under such circumstances, the argument of ecologist Garrett Hardin that rich nations should serve as lifeboats for the poor nations is relevant....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

Comparison Peter Singer's and Garrett Hardin's Positions on Helping the Poor

Garrett Hardin's article “Lifeboat Ethics ” presents a solid argument against helping the poor....  The article analyses and compares Peter Singer's and Garrett Hardin's positions on helping the poor.... (Hardin) From a utilitarian standpoint helping the poor puts a strain on the economy of the rich countries, where certain groups get financial benefit from the charity programs.... As a result of such solutions to food shortage emergencies, the poor countries will not learn to mend their ways and will suffer progressively greater emergencies as their populations grow (Hardin)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Article

Summary and strong respnes

In Lifeboat Ethics: the case against helping the poor- by Garrett Hardin Garrett Hardin s that the current global situation where the rich and the powerful dominate the poor and the weak is an inevitable fact of life.... Lifeboat Ethics: the case against helping the poor.... He declares that the resources in the world are not enough to support the entire human population and that only a few can benefit… He also considers the United Nations as a world organization to be a toothless dog whose authority is not enough to control the harmful actions which are harmful not only to the environment but also increases the gap between the rich and the poor....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

Garret Hardin Lifeboat Ethics: The case against helping people

The piece recognized as (Life Boat Ethics: the case against helping the poor) was writing by Garrett Hardin in which he uses several similarities, abstract questioning and honest reasoning to make his case against helping the poor and to counter those theorists who state that… He states that it is not the responsibility of the wealthy nations to help and assist the poor nations.... To explain why wealthy nations should not assist the poor nations he uses the example of a life boat and compares it to a wealthy Life Boat Ethics The piece recognized as (Life Boat Ethics: the case against helping the poor) was writing by Garrett Hardin in which he uses several similarities, abstract questioning and honest reasoning to make his case against helping the poor and to counter those theorists who state that the wealthy should help the poor (Hardin 1974)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor

In the report “Garrett Hardin: the case against helping the poor” the author discusses the essay of Garrett Hardin, who argues against any “system of worldwide food sharing”.... Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the PoorIn his 1974 essay, Lifeboat Ethics: the case against helping the poor, Garrett Hardin argues against any “system of worldwide food sharing” (482).... “Lifeboat Ethics: the case against helping the poor....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Will financially aid helping poor people lead to a sustainable future

Conversely, Garrett Hardin, an American ecologist who warned of the dangers of overpopulation, told a story of "Chinese Fishing" in his article "Lifeboat Ethics: the case against helping the poor" that, "As an ancient Chinese proverb goes: “Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day; teach him how to fish and he will eat for the rest of his days” (Hardin 22).... To my point of view, helping the poor is not a good way for them.... However, the main point of this issue is that, whether the rich should give financial aid to the poor....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Personal reflection

Lifeboat Ethics: the case against helping the poor by Garrett Hardin, Psychology Today, September 1974.... Mostly, this does not happen because the population the poor grows rapidly and they do not share in the increased industrial expansion.... If the world is divided into poor nations and rich nations, two-thirds of the population would be desperately poor while a third will be rich....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Lifeboat Ethics by Garrett Hardin

The article "Lifeboat Ethics by Garrett Hardin" presents the article titled “Lifeboat Ethics: the case against helping the poor” written by Garrett Hardin that emphasizes the need for sharing the earth's resources equally between all the countries of the world.... Likewise, there must always be room for excess capacity within a nation without overpopulating the land available and it is the responsibility of every individual to ensure that this capacity is always maintained irrespective of being poor or rich....
2 Pages (500 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us