Politicization of the Civil Service - Essay Example

Rouban makes interesting points that do serve to illuminate the problems inherent in a system in which all laws and institutions serve a political agenda to one degree or another. Where the article succeeds best is in showing that not all bureaucracies are the same and that the definition of a civil servant varies from one country to another. As a result, the most fascinating aspect of the article may be that it enlightens one to the shifting values of political import to be found in a country's social and cultural aspects.

The idea that educators might be subject to political pressure in following their career path is especially frightening.Relationship to this week's readings and broader literature/lecture:This article furthers the ideas of Wilsonian separation of politics from the administration while also adhering to Weber's theories on hierarchical assumptions. The problem that must be faced is that while Weber is correct in advocating the theoretical ideals of the impersonal organization, ultimately the truth must be faced that everything carries a political component.

Separating political appointments from the expectations of political administering of policy seems highly dubious. Possible insights/value to your case study:This article should prove to be valuable as a tool for studying the dynamics involved in the political process. While it may naturally be assumed that bureaucracy on account of its hierarchical structure with a definite chain of command allows for little in the way of political flexibility, in truth the very nature of a system designed for the purpose of inculcating a broad political ideology by its very nature is predisposed to the corrupting influences of political appointments.