Nobody downloaded yet

Compare & Contrast Australia's 'Reconciliation Movement with the 'Truth and Reconciliation' process in South Africa - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Comparing and contrasting Australian reconciliation movement with Truth and Reconciliation process in South Africa Introduction The post-world war saw the development, expansion and implementation of new international human rights, law and protection in response to terrible atrocities that has been taking place over the years…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Compare & Contrast Australias Reconciliation Movement with the Truth and Reconciliation process in South Africa
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Compare & Contrast Australia's 'Reconciliation Movement with the 'Truth and Reconciliation' process in South Africa"

Download file to see previous pages These frameworks were developed in order to address the economic, social and cultural rights and to ensure that they do not exist again. This essay compares and contrasts these two different models of reconciliation movement applied in the two countries and their uniqueness in adapting and dealing with particular situational context. The fundamental understanding of this essay is that it advances more knowledge in combining both the South Africa model and the Australian model in their approach of delivering justice. South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission The South African TRC main aim was not to punish with imprisonment or death the violators of human rights but to employ a restorative and system of justice this was a system of justice that seeks to return the situation to the way it was before the atrocities were committed by the use of public hearings (Gade, 2013). This system largely includes reparation, restitution of property, and restitution of cultural property, historical commission and apologies and it is strongly believed to have been influenced by Nelson Mandela who was then the president. Nelson Mandela wanted a reconciliation that is true to the harsh situation in South Africa that binds the wounds of the country by building trust and confidence to the people (Tutu, 1999). Mandela also wanted a united South Africa united as one country, one nation and one people marching together towards a common goal in future. The most important goal of South Africans was to have a unified country out of two groups of people that were least distrustful of each other since any attempt to punish the perpetrators of the terrible atrocities would have been counterproductive. The blacks and the whites in South Africa had strong negative feelings that had developed from each other over the years due to worst inhuman treatment. It was clear that both sides of the divide used violence hence harming innocent people in their attempts to have their way and therefore all sides were responsible to the atrocities done in the country (Stein, 2004). Of these several truth commissions, the South Africa’s truth and justice commission is arguably the best-developed example of all that have existed in the world due to its unique context (Worden, 1997). Just like any other models, the South African system also had several faults but its strengths are believed to have outweighed its faults making it among the best reconciliation commissions in the world (Gunstone, 2005). Strengths of South African TRC The TRC in South Africa had its emphasis, focus and detail on victims and their relatives thereby enabling them to get first-hand information on the atrocities hence making it very exhaustive in its findings (Geoffrey, 2003). They looked into the horrible crimes and established everything about them by searching for the real victims who suffered such crimes by allowing them and giving them adequate time to tell all their stories. The hearings were conducted every day and involved people in leadership positions as well as the local people in villages without any leadership position enabling them to cover a large number of people (Worden, 1997). Desmond Tutu one of the architects of South Africa’s TRC is on record saying that there is no future without forgiveness and this gave them a strong foundation in coming up with credible report (Tutu, 1999). Many of those who came to the hearings attested afterwards that they had found relief and ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare & Contrast Australia's 'Reconciliation Movement with the Essay”, n.d.)
Compare & Contrast Australia's 'Reconciliation Movement with the Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1485594-compare-contrast-australiayies-ychreconciliation
(Compare & Contrast Australia'S 'Reconciliation Movement With the Essay)
Compare & Contrast Australia'S 'Reconciliation Movement With the Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1485594-compare-contrast-australiayies-ychreconciliation.
“Compare & Contrast Australia'S 'Reconciliation Movement With the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1485594-compare-contrast-australiayies-ychreconciliation.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compare & Contrast Australia's 'Reconciliation Movement with the 'Truth and Reconciliation' process in South Africa

Establishing A Truth and Reconciliation Commission in Libya

...of their fundamental human rights. The two will eventually help Libya to have a smooth transition from the Gaddafi era to the new, and hopefully, pos-Gaddafi era. They could be the first step of leaving the Gaddafi era and moving forward with mutual goals (Libya Profile, 2011). Bibliography Pack, J. and Zaptia, S. (2011). Libya Needs a Truth and Reconciliation Commission. Retrieved on 19 Nov 2011, from: www.guardian.co.uk/.../Libya-truth-and -reconciliation-commission Libya Profile (2011). Retrieved 19 Nov 2011, http:/www.adh-geneva.ch/RULAC/state.php?id_state=128 Vora, J.A., and Vora, E. (2004). The Effectiveness of South...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Accounting Cycle/Bank Reconciliation

...about different things than a retail company. This is why these two types of companies cannot go about following similar steps of accounting cycle. There accounting cycle will be different because they are involved in different businesses. One example would be of revenue recognition. Another would be of inventory valuation. This is why accounting cycles can be different for different businesses. All firms have to produce accurate financial statements but they do not need to worry about following the same steps as this is not important. Part 2 Bank Reconciliation The purpose of a back reconciliation is to make sure that the balance of the bank per books matches with the actual balance of the bank account...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Bill Clinton and Racial Reconciliation

...that at the end of the day we are all human beings. That ought to be the connection we all ascribe to and not color. Racial reconciliation became more practical as President Clinton established a commission, aimed at convening dialogues at town halls to initiate further discourse into the issue of racism. He went on to enacting policies that saw employment opportunities for African Americans increase dramatically; besides that, he reinforced civil rights movements and appointed a significant number of African Americans and women into the judicial system. His dedication to this was visible until the end of his term where he was seen to make recommendations to health, education, civil rights efforts and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Sacrament of Reconciliation

... Sacrament of Reconciliation Introduction Repentance and forgiveness are recurrent themes of Christianity due to several reasons. God has created humanity and knows the latter’s limitations and fragilities. Therefore the door to salvation is through forgiveness and mercy. This can be achieved only if the sinner has made sincere efforts to seek forgiveness and clemency. The sacrament of reconciliation is embedded in Christian theology because it seeks to reestablish the relationship between God and humanity. This paper will seek to analyze and assess the sacrament of reconciliation. Historical The concept behind the sacrament of reconciliation can be derived from the Old Testament. The Israelites were constantly reprimanded... for their...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Truth, Justice and Reconciliation in Latin America

...07 December Truth and Reconciliation in Argentina As the head of the national reconciliation commission inArgentina, I realize the importance of my mission and the mission of the organization, for which I work. Argentina has just entered the period of renewal. The adoption of the democratic principles has already become the country’s top priority. However, democratization in our country is still in the state of infancy, making the situation even more complicated. Lots of different tasks need to be accomplished and many issues need to be examined, before Argentina grows into a stable democratic state. I am confident that, in our way to democratization and stability, our people will...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Congressional Tactic: Reconciliation

...Congressional Tactic: Reconciliation Congressional Tactic: Reconciliation The president of the United s of America made health reforms his priority in domestic policy changes. The democrats led government could have achieved this last year when it had a majority of 60 percent in the house; however, with the republican win in the special elections in Massachusetts, the tide changed against the government. Despite the fact that the Republican Party is against the reforms, some democrats are also not convinced about the necessity of the bill, making it hard for the government to achieve the supermajority of 60 percent as required to pass a bill. In a last attempt to implement the reforms,...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Reconciliation in the Community (Australia)(6)

...Reconciliation Number Department Introduction Personally, I am persuaded that there is a need to amend the constitution, so as to allow indigenous people to be recognised in their own right within it. The need to amend the constitution as a way of entrenching peaceful inter-communal existence is expedient, since the constitution is a legal document which defines the relationship between the government and an individual, and an individual and his fellow individual. The constitution also defines and underpins federal laws and institutions. One of the ideas that are cogently and satisfactorily advanced is that of social contract. The relevance of social contract and constitutionalism is clearly seen, since the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Cash Reconciliation

...Reconciling Bookkeepers Errors Cash reconciliation is a control a company adopts to ensure the cash in its accounts equals to what is recorded in the books of account (Finney & Miller, 1965). The new bookkeeper made numerous errors in recording the transactions. The first error the new bookkeeper records a deposit of $ 200 as $ 2,000. This error will result to the bank statement reflecting a less figure of $ 1,800 while the company’s cash account reflects an excess of $ 1,800. This error is reconciled by deducting $ 1,800 from the cash account. The second error the bookkeeper records a deposit of $ 530 as $ 350. This error will result to the bank statement having highest figure as compared to the cash account by $ 150. This error... is...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Can Lebanon have peace if they started a Truth and Reconciliation Committee like South Africa

..., if established, TRC can help bring peace in Lebanon. Just like in South Africa where TRC was used to gather and publicize information on the apartheid government’s misdeeds that were kept secret (Williams 277), a national truth and reconciliation commission could be an appropriate mechanism for the reconciliation and justice process after the civil war in Lebanon and the Hariri assassination. Various approaches have been used to help bring peace in Lebanese society but only reparative justice can balance the special need for justice and reconciliation in a deeply divided society like Lebanon. Agreeably, a...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Bible And Truth And Reconciliation

...Bible And Truth And Reconciliation Juliana Taimoorazy has been an activist trying to bring to the fore the plight of the Iraqi Christians living in Iraq. She has devoted most of her public life towards rescuing the Iraqi Christians from the various atrocities meted out to them by Islamist extremists. In her profile, Juliana started the nonprofit organization, the Iraqi Christian Council, to help in fostering awareness about the plight of these Iraqi Christians, and assisting in raising funds to deliver food and medicine to them. Having being born an Assyrian Christian in Iraq, she had to flee her country in 1989 due to religious persecution. She later went on to receive a graduate Degree in Instructional...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Compare & Contrast Australia's 'Reconciliation Movement with the 'Truth and Reconciliation' process in South Africa for FREE!

Contact Us