Nobody downloaded yet

The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Instructor Date The Iraqi war: Officials v Soldiers The Iraqi war is one of the most studied historical wars in modern history both in military colleges and in historical discourse due to the important lessons that can be derived from the conflict…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers"

Download file to see previous pages Like any other war fought by foot soldiers on one end and the coordinating or commanding officials on the other, the Iraqi war was characterized by the bourgeoisie and proletariat relationship. This paper will thus discuss and analyze the Iraqi war from both Weber’s bureaucracy and Karl max’s wage labor capital approach that existed between the officials and the people. In doing this, the paper will seek to bring to fore the division of labor that existed within the united states military camp during this war in relations to Weber and Karl Max theories. The relationships of soldiers at different ranks with different military roles and how they interacted during the Iraqi war can be best illustrated using Weber’s six major principles of bureaucracy and the legitimate domination principle. According to Weber, bureaucracy is way of administratively organizing a large number of people like soldiers who need to work together in a coordinated manner. Weber made critical elements of his bureaucratic principles that can be applied to the organization of people including the soldiers in a battle field. During the Iraqi war, there existed clearly defined levels of labor and authority meaning that there existed lower cadres who were under the control and supervision of a higher administrative level (Wasim 108). In this kind of organization, authority resided in the positions of hierarchy and there existed clear vertical division of labor. Before any decision was made within a battalion, communication had to move vertically from officials higher in the pecking order. Under this principle, labor was also critically divided among the soldiers depending on their position in the power hierarchy. The officials higher in the administrative pecking were tasked with communicating with the defense headquarter back in Washington. Such information was passed to the commanders of each battalion who would make the communications and decisions to the soldiers who are the ultimate implementers of the decisions. Just like evident in any army, rules guide the behaviors of each personnel and failure to follow instructions precisely leads to disciplinary action. Weber described this under his third principle in which he described how rules made at higher levels are executed by officials at the lower level. The Iraqi war was no different if compared to this principle as advanced by Weber due to the fact that rules of engagement while in the country were either made in Washington or by the coordination office in Iraq and implemented by the soldiers at the lower level. Organization within the fighting and coordination units of the United States army was also done based on functional specialties where each assignment was done by specialists (Boyer 151). As a result, the United States army in Iraq had different units at different levels that were tasked with different roles depending on their specialization. Responsibilities within the battle field were also assigned to positions and units but not to a specific individual according to the sixth principle of Weber’s bureaucracy. The Iraqi war terrain was quite foreign and unfamiliar to most United States army generals making it important to consider experience and qualification when assigning specific tasks that affected field operations to the army commanders (Eden, 213). The ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1484937-the-iraq-war-the-officials-vs-the-soldiers
(The Iraq War: The Officials Vs. The Soldiers Essay)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1484937-the-iraq-war-the-officials-vs-the-soldiers.
“The Iraq War: The Officials Vs. The Soldiers Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1484937-the-iraq-war-the-officials-vs-the-soldiers.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers

The Iraq War

...?The Iraq War The Iraq war is a military invasion of the of Iraq, situated in Western Asia. The campaign is part of the war on terror, and was primarily instigated by troops from the United States under the Bush administration and the United Kingdom under the orders of former Prime Minister Tony Blair. The invasion was justified due to the possibility that Iraq may have violated the UN resolution (Resolution 1441) on nuclear weapons and be holding weapons of mass destruction (WMD) that could be used against UN member states. This claim was later falsified and Iraq was not found to be holding WMD, but the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Iraq War

...infiltration by CIA teams, to build relationships and gain intelligence, and then the introduction of Special Operations Forces, particularly in northern Iraq and in Al Anbar province in the west”1. Supporting the development of a strategy for troop safety, a special interagency branch was assigned to identify and locate any oilfield risks that the US-led coalition army might face upon entering the country crossing its northern and southern borders.  This special branch identified probable areas of the oilfields that were supposed to be booby-trapped by the Iraqi soldiers. Also it attempted to trace out other natural oilfield dangers such as toxic gases, fire-risk and pressurized equipment.  USCENTCOM's...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

War vietnam-Iraq

...that resulted in more than 3 million American serving in the war, 58,000 American dead, and over 2000 missing in action.2 The war while officially over in March of 1973, actively carried on until 30 April 1975 and for many veterans is still raging internally. Similar Iraq has been in conflict both internally and with external powers since 1920 and the fall of the Ottoman Empire. The United States did not become directly involved until Iraq invaded Kuwait in 1990. On 9 August 1990 United States troops land in Saudi Arabia and in January 1991 the Persian Gulf conflict began. Between 1991 and 2002 when the United States launched their next full campaign...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Iraq war

...of Iraqis fled from their homeland. The chief reason behind this was terror, bloodshed and tyranny inflicted by the US soldiers. The political unrest made the lives of Iraqis so difficult that they sought refuge in other parts of the globe, especially in Jordan and Syria, who is Iraq’s neighboring countries. This was further confirmed by the Iraqi Exodus video which states that Iraqi immigrants have increased the total population of these two countries. However, lives of those new immigrants were not easy. They are facing more hardships because of lack of work permit and shelter (Benson). However, it has to be remembered that that the US- Iraq war not only carries...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Our Soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan War

...Our Soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan War Introduction Afghanistan and Iraq have been facing serious political and humanitarian crisis since the height of terror campaign that ended with ousting of their dictatorial regimes in power a few years ago. Since then, security has been a thorny issue in the two neighboring countries. Various strategies have been advanced to militate against the resultant effects of the two wars. Several years after the fall of Taliban and Saddam Hussein regimes in Afghanistan and Iraq respectively, the coalition forces led by US and Britain are still battling remnant forces of the two regimes. The...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

Iraq War

...the troops would mean to support these atrocities. Also, one must understand that if the war is called immoral, whether it was immoral right from the beginning or once it was certain that Iraq did not possess WMD. For of the war has been unethical right from the beginning, and then anyone who willingly became a part of the military after the outset of war is acting immorally. However, if the U.S can say that they were led to the war on false claims, then one cannot blame the soldiers for being a part of the war to support national security. Point here is, as it stands today, it is 'morally and ethically' right for the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Vietnam vs. Iraq

...to be subdued in order to fight the bigger war on terrorism. Differences also occur in the number of losses incurred by the US in these invasions. From 1965 to 1972, United States lost 55,750 soldiers while some 292,000 persons were seriously wounded. This loss was much more significant than the losses incurred in Iraq at the end of conflict period. On May 1, 2003 when major combat operations came to an end in Iraq, US had encountered suffered a total of 138 deaths in Iraq. [3] Even though this number increased later but still the average losses per day were far less than what US had suffered in Vietnam. Another important difference lies in principles...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Iraq war

...an emancipating effect on women, in fact it further reinforced traditional roles. He even goes on to say that such reinforcement contributed to the sense of oppression some women experienced in the post-war period. Since returning soldiers were geared up to go back to their role as breadwinners after the war and women were expected to likewise resume their homebound duties, wives were made economically dependent upon their husbands. Women war workers’ boredom at work was mostly caused by the low-level nature of their work involving routine repetition. It was not challenging their innate potentials. The reluctant move to mobilize the nation’s womanpower was out of...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Iraq war

...Background to the U.S.-Led War in Iraq Based on, the recent wars that have happened on Gaza, in December 2008 and early January 2009 as well as Lebanon in 2006 manifests that the Palestine-Israel conflict (1948) is among the leading source of war, oppression, and violence. The war is motivated by the need to control Palestine between the native Christian, Arab, and Muslim Palestinians who have kept on resisting expulsion and dispossession from the growing Jewish settlers who have the intention of making Palestine a state for the Jews. Since the United States government have kind of shown support to Israel towards this ongoing war, the...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Iraq War

...as the biggest economic beneficiary of the war by snagging five lucrative deals, hence helping the nation to overcome its security risks. It also notes that China displaced US as Iraq’s trading partner making them loose on many opportunities and trade ties. Schiavenza, Matt. Who won the Iraq war? China. The Atlantic. (March 22, 2013). http://www.theatlantic.com/china/archive/2013/03/who-won-the-iraq-war- china/274267/ The article notes that Iraq-US war led to the death of over 4500 soldiers and over 30,000 injured and more than $1 trillion operational cost in the US. Similarly, US...
4 Pages(1000 words)Annotated Bibliography
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Iraq War: The Officials vs. The Soldiers for FREE!

Contact Us