Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack BY YOU YOUR SCHOOL INFO HERE DATE HERE Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack Peggy McIntosh, it seems, intends to educate who she labels as oblivious of the perceived advantages that white individuals in America receive simply due to their skin color…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack"

Download file to see previous pages However, despite her hypothesis, I believe that Peggy McIntosh is only viewing the situation through a narrow lens without addressing the known advantages that people of color also maintain in American culture. I believe that the author is significantly exaggerating the problem in an effort to impose her own values associated with ethics and morality and is translating this into a somewhat passive, yet highly motivated attack on men and white culture. McIntosh rather expertly comes up with a variety of different examples to reinforce what she refers to as unearned white advantages. The key word in this analysis is unearned, indicating that people with white skin in America automatically experience advantages due to very long-standing cultural traditions and social system development. Now, if McIntosh is correct in her assessment that historical scenarios have provided these privileges, then there would certainly be a type of cultural bias occurring with white citizens of America that would provide some benefits over people of color. However, she seems to be focused on expressing that these unearned advantages are creating problems that white people are either unable to change (should they desire to) or simply see historically-driven advantages as a type of entitlement with most being relatively comfortable with these privileges. This is where there is an underlying sense of superiority stemming from the author about the ethical or moral issues for those who simply find comfort with their entitlements. This is why I have substantial issues with McIntosh’s position on white privilege as, despite the many examples provided to illustrate her point of view, not everyone in society shares the same values and principles related to morality. There is a concept in social psychology known as moral relativism which is the belief that there is no singular method of determining what is actually right or wrong in society. Because of this, people should be tolerant of the actions and behaviors of others as there is no framework of morality that has been adopted and accepted by the entire national population. Sociology research has shown us in society that many subcultures exist in America in which people maintain varying beliefs. There are groups that applaud violence as a lifestyle, others that believe in the merits of male-dominated households where women must remain subservient, and even groups that believe in the moral superiority of polygamy. Though these are only an example of the vastly differing value systems in today’s America, human rights advocates (as one relevant social group) continue to express to majority society that we need to respect the rights of others under a type of live and let live mentality that seems to be very common in the United States. I tend to believe more strongly in the moral relativism philosophy and McIntosh attempting to superimpose her own moral values over this relativism set of values causes me considerable concern about the validity of her arguments. Peggy McIntosh describes the ease by which she can find strong representation of the white culture in a variety of places, ranging from media sources to the wide variety of foods available in the local supermarket that tend to cater to the tastes of white citizens. However, in large metropolitan areas in this country, other ethnic ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack Essay”, n.d.)
Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1467694-perspective-view-on-the-invisible-knapsack
(Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack Essay)
Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1467694-perspective-view-on-the-invisible-knapsack.
“Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1467694-perspective-view-on-the-invisible-knapsack.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack

Invisible Buddhism in China

...?Insert Invisible Buddhism in China Generally, Chinese Buddhism involves the different learning facilities of Buddhism that have historically existed in China since time immemorial. Buddhism has immensely contributed to shaping the religious ideology of the Chinese society, influencing their art, politics, literature, beliefs, and healthcare. During the era of the Tang Dynasty, Chinese Buddhism molded several spiritual masters. Academicians categorized Chinese Buddhism into almost a dozen schools. But later on, Buddhism became superimposed in the Chinese civilization, perhaps due to the ‘emptiness’ philosophy (Adler 23-29). Chinese Buddhist schools differ on the precise description of the righteous path to liberty, the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Invisible Man

...Full Submitted The Invisible Man Divided into three parts Invisible Man’s (IM) schooling at a fictionalized version of Booker T. Washington’s Tuskegee University in Alabama (Bishop 46); (2) IM’s involvement with the Brotherhood – a euphemism for the Communist Party (Ellison xxi); and (3) IM in the Harlem race riot, inspired by the author’s own life (xxi), the plot of Ellison’s Invisible Man outlined the painful process IM undergoes in understanding who he, a Black, really is in a dominantly superior White society. How he in belying himself tried hard to be just like what his superiors told him who he is – “You are important because if you fail, I have failed by one individual, one...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ralph Ellison invisible man

...Invisible man Invisible man by Ralph Ellison is a story of a black man graduated from college in search for his identity and existence in the racially separated society. The story in the first place appears to be author’s journey as he describes a journey from awareness to enlightenment, “from Purpose to Passion to Perception”. The novel is set in the U.S. during pre civil war era. The laws at that time were stringent; they did not allow black Americans to enjoy basic human rights as their white counterparts. The novel begins in the South Carolina but majority of the action happens in North Harlem, New York. The novel opens with the author reminiscence about his life when he was young. He was a naive...
3 Pages(750 words)Book Report/Review

Racial and Ethnic Matter

...with others. McIntosh admits that she felt white privilege an invisible package of unearned assets, which she could count on cashing in each day. 2. It is hard to unscramble the various elements of unearned benefits of white privileges. It is expanded more on social class, race, economic class, religion, sex, and ethnic identity. The white privileges are bestowed upon a person even without his knowledge. The person enjoys the benefits without even realizing it as a package of unearned assets. The unearned privileges draws up images of white supremacy, the philosophy that supports the view that white race is superior to others. An effort to distinguish facts is expected, between earned strengths and...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack By Peggy McIntosh

...that the author was able to unpack the “invisible knapsack” of a privileged white person in American society. According to her, it was hard to recognize the existence of the concept simply because the manifestations of white privileges do not come into a visible form of racist violence and outright discrimination. Instead, its presence remains to be denied and protected by political leaders or other people because they benefit from the system and continue to dominate it. As such, average white Americans feel that condemning racism is enough to achieve equality. However, what they do not know is that one must recognize the existence of such privileges to fully understand the dynamics of racism. In order...
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review

Invisible Cities

...Invisible Cities: Introduction Invisible Cities, originally by Italo Calvino, explains some fifty five fantasy cities as told by the fictional character, Marco Polo, to his emperor, Kublai Khan. The book is in the form of brief poems narrated by Polo and conversations between the two main characters. Khan grows tired of the stories told to him by messengers from across the empire, but is only interested by those narrated by Polo concerning the cities that he allegedly encountered in his travels. As many as Khan insists, Polo never agrees to talk about his home city, Venice. In time, however, Khan realizes that the nonexistent places the traveler speaks of describe, bit by bit, his town of Venice (Calvino...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Ralph Ellisons Invisible Man

...description of him to the point of never even giving the character a name, even when it is changed. The narrator at one point ruminates about his history of humiliations, observing that "They were me; they defined me." (p. 508). Working form this basis, the narrator's degree of invisibility can therefore also be measured by them and, since they hinge upon racial issues, a closer examination of these instances and the people involved underscore the narrator's ultimate lesson. Likewise, the narrator is not the only "invisible character in the book, given that it applies to an outsider's view of another he is just the only one in the novel that suspects the enormity of the injustice....
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Invisible Man 3

...A book about racism, Ralph Ellison’s Invisible Man talks about racism in the American society against the Blacks. In his struggle to fit in the society and be accepted in the community, the main character tells a story of mostly disappointing experiences. From his childhood, the character illustrated his invisibility in the society from the moment he was humiliated by white men in his town. His desire to belong to a group continues until he becomes a member of a Brotherhood that leads him nowhere else but to where he used to be, an invisible man, who, according to him should simply accept his own identity and value his own individuality. Although it seems that in the modern society...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Pervasive, Invisible, and Possible Images

.... Invisible image is un-seeable and is a replication of the physical manifestation of a person to create definite self-identity (Blanco, 2014). For instance, Man resembles God, which actually means man is in the image of God. This kind image is of the nature that cannot be perceived as single handed vision and as such is a latent duplicate on a photographic emulsion as shown below. Possible picture or image is the real pic of a person or an individual. They represent the reality as portrayed by somebody. Marginalization; the image above creates a negative impression among some people, for instance, scrawny women may create unlikely typical of...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

The Invisible World

...The Invisible World  Angels Satan & Demons Heaven Hell  Table of Contents Angels . . . . . . . . . . page 2 Satan & Demons . . . . . . . . . . page 7 Heaven . . . . . . . . . . page 15 Hell . . . . . . . . . . page 19 “Angels” Our Beliefs Might Not Be Correct It is said that television and media form much of how we view and what we believe about things of this world, and things not of this world. Parts of this may be true, but probably not as much in some areas as in the area of things such as Angels, Demons, Satan, and God. There are many pre-conceived beliefs about Angels…some are true, but others are false. Let’s take a look at some of them: When we die we can...
32 Pages(8000 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Perspective View on the Invisible Knapsack for FREE!

Contact Us