StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Can we apply Hobbes argument about the state of nature to international relations - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Hobbes is regarded as one of the originators of international relations theory and his argument regarding the state of nature is predominant in political philosophy. Since the description of the state of nature was introduced, debate has been rife among scholars concerning its…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Can we apply Hobbes argument about the state of nature to international relations
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Can we apply Hobbes argument about the state of nature to international relations"

Download file to see previous pages In this regard, the state of nature considers men to be in a competition with each other for resources that include food, for example. As a result, they tend to distrust and fear one another thus instigating a pre-emptive attack due to the quest to maximise their own interests at the expense of other people. On the other hand, difference, emanates from the desire for natural equality and the fear factor that eventually leads to war. On this note, the state of nature suggests that, the alternative option for removing the contributory factors to conflict is to embrace the state by surrendering sovereignty to the Leviathan in order to enjoy security and order. According to Hobbes, the international sphere exists in a form of the state of nature (1985, p.37). This paper explores whether Hobbes argument about the state of nature can apply to international relations. While international relations emphasises a peaceful co-existence between sovereign states, the Hobbesian view focuses on the defensive character of states. This makes it difficult to apply the Hobbesian argument in international relations because; it discards the moral principles that guide the relations among states.
Hobbes advances five conditions for the state of nature that includes equality, competition, and the existence of two types of people, non- universal egoism and uncertainty. With regard to equality, Hobbesian view reiterates that people possess almost equal mental and physical capabilities. As a result, those regarded as weak also have enough power either mental or physical to destroy the strongest. The competition caused by scarcity of resources also creates a situation where everyone grapples for the same unlimited resources. The Hobbesian view further associates the scarce resource with power since not everyone can amass power. In this sense, power is often a preserve for a few individuals in the society who tend to maximise it for their own self-interest (Hampton, 1987, ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Can we apply Hobbes argument about the state of nature to Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1693388-can-we-apply-hobbes-argument-about-the-state-of-nature-to-international-relations
(Can We Apply Hobbes Argument about the State of Nature to Essay)
https://studentshare.org/social-science/1693388-can-we-apply-hobbes-argument-about-the-state-of-nature-to-international-relations.
“Can We Apply Hobbes Argument about the State of Nature to Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1693388-can-we-apply-hobbes-argument-about-the-state-of-nature-to-international-relations.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Can we apply Hobbes argument about the state of nature to international relations

International Relations: Theory and Practice (About Oman)

Oman is a unique case study because unlike other countries in the Middle East which are directed by ideological leanings and immediate benefits, the Sultanate of Oman has been driven by its own particular agenda. The Sultanate of Oman takes the position that peaceful negotiation is important for achieving long-term gains for preserving prosperity and security for Oman. This research study determines that Oman has made significant progress in foreign policy and international relations since 1970 and thus concludes that Oman’s approach to foreign policy is more rational and conducive to long-term success in international relations. Contents Chapter Five 38 Conclusions and Recommendations 38 I.Introduction 38 II.Summary of Findings...
30 Pages(7500 words)Research Paper

International Relations

...? WHAT TO DO WITH IRAN? Few can deny that one of the most serious threats to world peace is the nuclear program being designed by Iran. Iran has consistently ignored international disapproval and sanctions and continued to misled the international community about its actions. There are a number of different approaches that the United States could pursue in dealing with the menace presented by Iran. There are a number of approaches based on different international relations theories. In the first case, Washington could act in a realist manner. This would involve the Americans thinking the worst about Iran and to act out of self-interest. This probably would mean that Iran would be bombed. The second approach could be a liberal one...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The American Journalist Robert Kaplan stated that anyone who disbelieves Hobbes' state of nature argument has never visited Co

... Ivory Coast – Land of Trouble? Hobbes, often dubbed as the founder of the modern philosophical thoughts, is popular for his theories of evolution about society and human kind - theories which were completely devoid of religious aspects. Hobbes has given a very unique face to how society was created and how individual roles changed over the years. According to him, there was a ‘state of nature’ even before the formation of society. It was a state where there were no laws governing the behavior of humans and the activities were so much cruel that even if a person needs to take something from his neighbor, he would just kill him and take it in his possession. One of the most famous journalists from America, Robert Kaplan has attributed...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Hobbes and Locke views on the State of Nature

The egoism in man, is a presupposition of Hobbes which leads him to the description of nature as a constant power struggle. In a natural state, that is, in a physical state, men are generally equal in strength, mental capacity and experience (Solomon, Ed, 1992, p. 178). He asserts that everyone has a natural and equal right to everything. However, if man was without government the conflict from desire would lead to a state of war of every man against every man: Hereby it is manifest, that during the time men live without a common Power to keep them all in awe, they are in that condition which called Warre; and such a warre, as is of every man, against every man(Solomon, Ed, 1992, p. 179). Fortunately, however, Hobbes argues that...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Hobbes and the State of Nature

The concept of what is the nature of man is also unresolvable. Is man ‘evil’ and needs to be controlled? Or, is man ‘good’ and needs to institution or the elimination of institutions to achieve a sense of balance. In the world of Hobbes, man is ‘evil’ and needs to be controlled by a central authority-The Leviathan. When you view other philosophers, particularly Kant, one could say that man is not evil but needs encouragement to be good and cooperate. These are also the two tenets that are present in international politics. These are generally referred to as ‘Realism’-the Hobbesian Approach or ‘Liberalism’-the Kantian Approach. One can see elements of both in the actual practice of international politics. In this short essay, the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Political Philosophy (Hobbes' ideas about human nature)

... out of the essential human nature. (Martinich) He also went on to argue that a man cannot, by his nature, find god or evil and therefore in order to live in peace, it is important for him to subjugate him to an authority of the government which is strong enough to provide the required support to an individual. Another important aspect of Hobbes’s views on the human nature is based upon the internal urge to progress. Here Hobbes uses the scientific method to make an assertion that humans were impede to progress because of the mechanical affects of our senses. Hobbes also discussed about the innate appetites and argued that each individual’s need for power, food, riches therefore can vary. Hobbes’s ideas on human nature therefore are deeply...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Globalisation and State Authority in International Relations

..., transformed their system while Germany took up an absorption policy. One can therefore conclude that despite globalisation, states retain the ability to determine what sort of political-economic systems they will adopt. They do not necessarily have to bow to international pressure when they feel that those pressures may not necessary suite them as asserted by Evans (1997, p 62-87) Sassen (1998. p 48) brings out a very profound argument about the role played by globalisation in international relations. She believes that globalization has encouraged certain levels of involvement form the citizens of different states of the world. Most of them have a profound knowledge of what they should do to improve their economies and they also know...
8 Pages(2000 words)Literature review

Thomas Hobbes' Theory about State and Power in Leviathan

In essence, the dilemma created in Thomas Hobbes’ ‘Leviathan’ revolves around situations when the sovereign state needs to call upon the strength of its citizens to provide the state and its people the protection it needs.  In dangerous situations, a rational egoist would most likely not risk his life for the protection of the sovereign state.  However, if such protection is not provided by the citizens, then the state will revert to a state of nature. And, our lives would be forfeit if the orders of the state are not followed and protection is not provided to the state by the rational egoist. 

This paper shall be a critical analysis paper on Hobbes’ previously mentioned statement....

9 Pages(2250 words)Book Report/Review

Hobbes and Rousseau's Depiction of the state of nature and human nature

..., and in no way try to dictate the people (Hobbes and Helena 39). What,  if  anything,   do  each  of  their  respective  conceptions  of  the  “state  of  nature”  reveal  about  human   nature? Rousseau conception of the state of nature shows that human nature is compassion and naturally, human beings are not equal. Therefore, in the human nature morality, law does not only exist. Human being, driven by compassion for others naturally prevents them from causing suffering to their fellow human beings. His conception of human beings as savages reveals to us that, as human beings, we need each other for self-development. On his part, human beings are entitled to their own opinions, and the government should follow...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Argument about abortion

... proposes that everybody should be given a chance in life and that life begins with conception. Gyan is critical with the Obamacare because, the insurance scheme is taxing the taxpayers to fund abortion related cases. The issue becomes even more controversial in that the vice president Mr. Biden had travelled to China to see how the one child policy works with forced sterility. He was critical to that issue that the Obama administration wanted to borrow the same policy into the United States of America. On the other hand, Biden differs with Gyan on the issue of abortion in that the democratic government respects the views of all religions concerning abortion. He further emphasizes that the issue of abortion should be left to the judges...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Can we apply Hobbes argument about the state of nature to international relations for FREE!

Contact Us