Dissent About Nuclear Safety - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The senior and junior staff members do not arrive at a conclusion on what actions to take regarding this matter. Alison is a junior member…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Dissent About Nuclear Safety
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Dissent About Nuclear Safety"

Dissent about Nuclear Safety The case expresses conflicting interests and opinions about repairs and maintenance of the heat exchanger system in the nuclear department. The senior and junior staff members do not arrive at a conclusion on what actions to take regarding this matter. Alison is a junior member of the PNSCR, which has the task of making a recommendation concerning the likely continuity of the heat exchanger. The heat exchanger is presently in a non-functional state. Additionally, according to Alison, it is does not meet the required standards. Alison should comprehend that as a professional engineer, though a junior staff, her job is to give her best professional judgment when asked to do so (Green 56). In order to have a clear conscience, she should speak her mind. The engineering codes require that safety and welfare of public be placed supreme above all else.
The seniority of Brad over Alison pushes her to a weaker standing point. Alison is required to be careful here and be diplomatic in the way she presents her conflicting opinion. She should stick to her ethics and quote the NSPE code if she feels it is correct and necessary to do so. Most importantly, Alison should not be coerced to act in unison with other board members. Given that there has been a strong culture of unanimity, this paves way for the possibility that Alison may feel the need to act and think like the group, which is clearly wrong. This junior staff may find it necessary to abstain from voting if she feels that she should not cast a negative vote all alone.
In case subsequent calculations indicate that a single heat exchanger would be adequate, that would not be erroneous for Alison to have cast a negative vote rejecting the other member’s decision. She is not doing so to stop the report from going on to NRC, but to ensure that the committee is doing what is required of them and that it works in the appropriate manner in while making decisions. Therefore, she has an obligation, even though different from the views of other members of the committee. Also, the committee has an obligation too to make sure that the opinions of others are always taken into consideration.
Alison may be required to approach this issue from different angles. The first instance is requesting for a delay by stating that public safety is undoubtedly at risk and that the effects of a malfunction will be comparatively extensive. The tribulations and harms to the public will be instant, and the detriment to the public will be within 20 miles. The second instance is that she should not request for a delay by stating that public risk is not high and therefore, the impacts of the breakdown will be confined to a few individuals. It is recommended that Alison should appeal for a delay by arguing that the public is ta risk.
Work Cited
Green, Harold P. "Safety Determinations in Nuclear Power Licensing: A Critical View." Notre Dame Law. 43 (1967): 633. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Dissent About Nuclear Safety Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Dissent About Nuclear Safety Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from
(Dissent About Nuclear Safety Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Dissent About Nuclear Safety Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words.
“Dissent About Nuclear Safety Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Dissent About Nuclear Safety

Nuclear plants and seafood safety

.... The approval of the use of nuclear energy by the scientific community and the society as a whole has a checkered history marked by “initial optimism”, succeeding cautious retraction in “the 1980s and 1990s” and again a renewed interest in the late 2000 (Bodansky, 2004, p.21). When commercially viable technology was invented to harness nuclear energy, the world had seen an initial surge of opinion in favor of nuclear energy. As far as the energy options of countries have been concerned, nuclear energy is generally considered the most advanced and modern option. Later in nuclear energy history, apprehensions about the...
45 Pages(11250 words)Dissertation

Nuclear Plant Safety

...? Nuclear Plant Safety Introduction Nuclear power plants have become well-known as cost-effective sources of energy. However, from severe nuclear catastrophes observed in the international setting and at home, the disadvantages of nuclear reactors have been proven to surpass the advantages. The instances observed in Japan today and the previous Chernobyl catastrophe in Russia are just some of the worst nuclear meltdowns experienced in the international setting. There are over 112 nuclear plants already established in the United States (Greenwald, 1991) and some of these plants have already experienced malfunctions. There...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Rhetoric of Dissent

...that citizens are given freedom to exchange information, freedom to express their public opinions, and freedom to debate public issues. Thus, an ideal public sphere enhances participation and offers protection against abuse of power. Today, we are thriving on a public sphere in which citizens’ participation is facilitated. However, the public sphere is sometimes corrupted through economic or state influence. There are several elements of a public sphere laid out by scholars. One of them is freedom of expression, opinion and assembly. The presence of sites or locations where people gather everyday to talk about public affairs is also essential. According to The World Bank (n.d), everyday talk is one of the most important...
5 Pages(1250 words)Article

Culture of Dissent

...powers, and most specifically; the United States. Superficially it appears almost as a case of the “have nots” complaining about the nations that appear to have it all. But when one delves deeper into the topic there are some valid complaints. Among the cultures of dissent focused upon in the weekly readings and related ones are: neoliberal globalization and its affects upon all the nations of the world, the American was in Iraq, the caste system in India and the subjugation of women throughout the world, but primarily in Third World nations. “Critical Views of the World Social Forum – From Mumbai Resistance” was written by Pao Ching following his participation in the Mumbai (India) Resistance...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Rhetoric of Dissent

...FEMEN MOVEMENT AND THE BODY LANGUAGE OF THE PROTEST Over the past years the world has experienced countless numbers of protests. It was impossible to imagine these events happening even a decade ago. The dissatisfaction with the current political and socio-economical stance has reached its peak and people started expressing their negative attitudes towards it. With the help of the modern communication technologies protesters were able to mobilize and organize groups of people for demonstrations. The protests range from peaceful actions of Occupy Wall Street in the USA to more violent events of the Arab Spring in the Middle East. In this paper, I address a different kind of a protest organized by the FEMEN activists in Europe who... MOVEMENT...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Nuclear Power Plant Safety System

... Nuclear Power plant safety system Nuclear power plants have been and are still considered by the public as being extremely dangerous to use as sources of energy. This is due to the fact that they are associated with radioactive materials. These radioactive materials are too dangerous to be released into the environment due the fact their effect on humans and the land are usually dire, and may last for years thereby affecting generations. For example, radioactive materials (wastes) from nuclear power plants may cause cancer and radiation sickness to humans among others. Therefore, any leak or release of radioactive materials into the environment may render land that would have otherwise been useful useless. It is for this reason... that...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Dissent Conditions

...Dissent Dissent usually occurs when employees observe wrong events ,doings or unethical behavior in the organizational environment. Dissent can occur at low risk or high risk conditions. Case of dissent in low risk conditions The case of Margaret Haywood is a dissent of high risk condition where she exposed the ignorance of the Staff at Royal Sussex Hospital. She has brought the hospital into public and accused it of mistreating the elderly patient by showing the film clips she shot while on duty in the hospital. It is a low risk condition where the nurse point out the unprofessionalism of her organization. Another case is a case of John who observed that...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Dissent about nuclear safety

...04 March Dissent about nuclear safety: Mill’s approach to morality seems to achievetwo purposes, one of which is that an action should be considered right if it evenly maximizes utility. Second component of this theory declares that even good intentions are irrelevant when outcomes are bad or worrisome. Sound ethical theories are considered the best because they fulfil all criteria used in evaluating ethical theories (Martin and Schinzinger 72). In accordance with this theory, Alison Turner should express her reservations about the Justification for Continued Operation (JCO). The JCO clearly does not attach any importance to the consequences or outcomes...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

The safety of nuclear power generation

...from a similar explosion. However, the western countries understood the importance of coordinated safety management practices. The three accidents led to many changes in the safety and design practices of nuclear facilities. The plant design and equipment upgrades started to involve auxiliary feed water systems, the isolation of containment buildings and the inclusion of automatic plant shut down capabilities. In addition, it led to enhanced emergency preparedness among different countries. Even the different levels of government started coordinating closely on the issue. The findings from the three accidents were incorporated in future responses to nuclear accidents....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


...Scalia’s Dissent in Planned Parenthood v. Casey al Affiliation Scalia’s Dissent in Planned Parenthood v. Casey I strongly agree with Justice Scalia in disapproving the legalization of abortion by terming it as a ‘woman’s right to terminate pregnancy and a component of liberty (Murphy, et al. 2013). In conquering with women’s liberty to abortion, the court would be awarding itself sovereignty that could have led to false decisions made beyond the immediate facts of crucial cases. In addition, leaving the women to make decisions regarding abortion on to the women would end up avoiding huge issues that would be resolved through even more confusing policies. Scalia’s stand that there is no liberty in the...
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Dissent About Nuclear Safety for FREE!

Contact Us