Nobody downloaded yet

Was the Commerce Clause portion of National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius correctly decided - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
“ The patient protection and affordable care act” was enacted by the American congress in order to ensure that Americans have health insurance covers in a bid to reduce health care costs for the citizens. It had several provisions that included the individual mandate which…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
Was the Commerce Clause portion of National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius correctly decided
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Was the Commerce Clause portion of National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius correctly decided"

Download file to see previous pages This was due to a perception that the act gave individuals who did not acquire health insurance covers the charge that was to have their incomes taxed by the internal revenue service as a penalty1. They claimed that the congress which is responsible for making laws that govern them, was indulging them in a commercial responsibility of which should not be the case. I agree with this notion as it serves as a disagreement which is aimed at protecting the rights of the minority. They act also had another provision; the Medicaid expansion program. This provision stated that the various states that make up America should provide medical assistance to adults whose income is below 133% of the federal poverty line which I feel is a good idea. This overwrote the Medicaid program that was in place during the time that offered medical assistance to expectant women, children, needy families, the blind, the elderly and the disabled. The Medicaid expansion program was funded by the federal government same as it used the previous Medicaid program. The act further stated that states that did not comply with the act would be denied the entire federal Medicaid funding2.
This also did not augur well with some individuals as the national federation of independent business and also twenty six states were against it. They therefore moved to the federal district court to file a challenge against the individual mandate and the Medicaid expansion program. The court of appeal however held that the congress was working within its constitutional mandate while passing the clause on Medicaid expansion but at the same time, it lacked authority to enact the individual mandate.
Chief justice Roberts in delivering the court’s opinion concluded that “the anti-injunction act does not bar the suit (US constitution part II of 648 F. 3d 1235)3. This was because the anti-injunction act stated that anyone who wished to sue for any tax must ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Was the Commerce Clause portion of National Federation of Independent Essay”, n.d.)
Was the Commerce Clause portion of National Federation of Independent Essay. Retrieved from
(Was the Commerce Clause Portion of National Federation of Independent Essay)
Was the Commerce Clause Portion of National Federation of Independent Essay.
“Was the Commerce Clause Portion of National Federation of Independent Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Was the Commerce Clause portion of National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius correctly decided

Commerce Clause WIckard v. Filburn and Affordable Care Act

...Task Commerce Clause Wickard Filburn and Affordable Care Act Introduction We do not need another book for the constitutional revolution of the 1930s. The history of that happening has been invested a couple of times from different perspectives, and there is so much that is universally agreed that it is unlikely that new things and ideas will emerge. Fortunately, it seems that the least we can expect for some minimal disparity on the following reasons: After the elapse of approximately sixty years of constitutional reading so as to defend private belongings, the market economy and the regime, the ultimate court suddenly altered its decision in 1937, neglecting guide and giving the central government a...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

Independent Business Analysis Project

...skills audit and the learning styles questionnaire (see Appendix). One of my most significant weaknesses is over-confidence in my professional competencies that places mistrust in businesses I feel lack certain expertise to justify certain business decisions. However, today’s organisations require an individual working within the structure to be cohesive and team-focused in order to achieve strategic goals. Many organisations are multi-nationals maintaining very diverse employees hailing from different cultures that make independent work not always possible, which is actually my preferred methodology of professional practice. As illustrated by the skills audit, I am very...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Canadian Federation of Independent Businesses

... an affiliate program. This could give members an incentive of a small percentage of the new signups or give them points to get free membership renewals. VII. References Canadian Internet Commerce Statistics Summary Sheet.Retrieved March 30, 2008, from Canadian_e_commerce_statistics.pdf The Canadian Federation of Independent Business ( Whyte, G. (Speaker). (2008, February 4). Small and Medium Enterprises, and CFIB. [Lecture, ADM 1100]. Ottawa: University of Ottawa.... Running Head: CASE STUDY OF THE CANADIAN FEDERATION OF INDEPENDENT BUSINESSES Case Study of the Canadian Federation of...
10 Pages(2500 words)Case Study

Exclusion clause

...The ways an exclusion clause could enter into a contractual agreement General overview Contracts are essential documents for all commercial relationship between two or more parties that are willing and ready to go into an agreement with the hope of enjoying some certain levels of relationship as indicated in the contracts. These relationships could be in business, employment, education and other service-related transactions. Normally, there are some exclusion clauses in the contracts that state clearly what the stronger party (in this case, an employer) would not undertake for the weaker party (in this case, an employee) if certain unforeseen problems suddenly happened to the weaker...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Original need for the Commerce Clause

...Original need for the Commerce Clause The Commerce Clause is a power listed in the US constitution describing the powers of the federal government to regulate commerce between the US and foreign countries, among the several States and trade with Indian tribes. The commerce clause draws its meaning and original intend/need from the preceding mercantilist tradition. Johnson (2004) states that the original debates over the adoption of the constitution, termed as ‘regulation of commerce’ was almost purely as a cover of words for particular mercantilist proposals that were related to foreign...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper

Early interpretation of the commerce clause

...of the term among several states was commerce that occurred between the various US states, and other foreign nations/states. Early interpretations of the phrase ‘to regulate” was to adjust commerce by rule or method. It was also taken to mean, to make regular. The phrase gave the Congress the power to state how commerce activities were to be conducted among states and between US and foreign nations. However, it excluded the power to prohibit. References Barnett, R. (2001). “The Original Meaning of the Commerce Clause. “ University of Chicago Law Review. (101) pp 1-20. Grant, N. and Pushaw, R. (1999). “Rethinking the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

The current extended interpretation of the Commerce Clause

...account of the constitution. The Commerce Clause has for long been used as a weapon to limit the ability of the federal government to regulate the national economy References Exploring Constitutional Conflicts. (2011, March 1). Commerce Clause Limitations on State Regulation. Retrieved November 17, 2011, from Exploring Constitutional Conflicts: Kommers, D. P., Finn, J. E., & Jacobsohn, G. J. (2004). American constitutional law: Governmental powers and democracy (2, illustrated ed.). Rowman & Littlefield. Natelson, R. G., & Kopel , D. (2011). Commerce...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper

Exclusion clause

...requires the proferentem or the originator of exclusion clauses to incorporate them in the contract and act reasonably to draw the attention of the other party to its existence (Basedow, 2011). In the case of Parker v South Eastern Railway [1877] 2 CPD 416, the court decided that a party cannot cite ignorance as the defence for failing to read contractual terms. The court noted, however, that the party that intends to benefit from an exemption of liability has an obligation to take appropriate steps to familiarize the offeree with the terms. In the case of Thornton v. Shoe Lane Parking Ltd [1971], the court directed that the broader the exclusion clause,...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Commerce Clause

... The Commerce Clause Every in America operates autonomously with their government systems not entirely answerable to the federal government. In several instances, the states have their independent bylaws governing their operations independent of other states. However, the US as a nation has constitutional provisions that regulate socio-economic, political, and legal perspectives of its states. Furthermore, in several instances, states enact laws in line with the national constitution; some of the laws, however, conflict sharply with the provisions of the constitution. Georgia is no difference from other states pursuing conflicting laws to those of the federal government. The state’s statute establishes that all trucks and trailers... that...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

National federation of independent business vs. sebelius(2012)

...that the unconstitutional coerciveness of the provision that withheld the federal grant was clear and evident. With reference to commerce clause, the ACT is unjustified. The court has never allowed the Congress to purchase a given product mandatory by utilizing its power to control commerce between states. As such, there ought to be an item of regulation for the regulation of interstate commerce by the congress to be possible. On the other hand, a challenge towards the “individual mandate” provision’s constitutionality, as provided for under the Affordable Care Act, which provides that all citizens should get health coverage or be penalized, is not in...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Was the Commerce Clause portion of National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius correctly decided for FREE!

Contact Us