Nobody downloaded yet

Critically Assess the Claims That Animals, Particularly Chimpanzees, Have a Humanlike Understanding of Mental States - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This report critically observes the claims that animals, particularly chimpanzees have a humanlike understanding of mental states. To support its findings, it draws material from a variety of research. The conclusion is arrived at after extensively studying the material in the relevant researches. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Critically Assess the Claims That Animals, Particularly Chimpanzees, Have a Humanlike Understanding of Mental States
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critically Assess the Claims That Animals, Particularly Chimpanzees, Have a Humanlike Understanding of Mental States"

Download file to see previous pages This paper stresses that there are many debates between scientists over theory of mind and do animals have one? Those who are primatologists and other observors of animal behaviour term theory of mind ‘Machiavellian intelligence’, ‘metarepresentation’, ‘metcognition’, ‘mind reading’ and ‘pan’ or ‘pongo-morphism’. Now a researcher who would use the term ‘mental state attribution’ is likely to believe law-like generalisations underlie mental state ascription.
This report makes a conclusion that the report states, ‘theory of attention in which organisms are subjectively connected to the world not through any particular sensory modality such as vision but rather through other (as-of-yet unspecified) behavioural indicators’. As observed, behaviour is not always valid indictor of having a theory of mind. Hence it will not be obvious to the untrained individual if or not chimps have a human like understanding of mental states. In research like povinelli’s ‘reasoning about beliefs, a human specialisation?’ a very striking point is brought up that ‘theory of mind is unique to our species, and that its original function was to provide a more abstract level of describing ancient behavioural patterns (such as deception, reconciliation, and gaze following)-behaviours that humans share in common with many other species.’ This material sheds knew light on what we thought we knew bout the human mind’s ‘theory of mind’. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critically Assess the Claims That Animals, Particularly Chimpanzees, Essay”, n.d.)
Critically Assess the Claims That Animals, Particularly Chimpanzees, Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1537065-critically-assess-the-claims-that-animals-particularly-chimpanzees-have-a-humanlike-understanding-of-mental-states
(Critically Assess the Claims That Animals, Particularly Chimpanzees, Essay)
Critically Assess the Claims That Animals, Particularly Chimpanzees, Essay. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1537065-critically-assess-the-claims-that-animals-particularly-chimpanzees-have-a-humanlike-understanding-of-mental-states.
“Critically Assess the Claims That Animals, Particularly Chimpanzees, Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1537065-critically-assess-the-claims-that-animals-particularly-chimpanzees-have-a-humanlike-understanding-of-mental-states.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critically Assess the Claims That Animals, Particularly Chimpanzees, Have a Humanlike Understanding of Mental States

Critically Assess the Claim that States are Necessary Evils

...is peculiar to them. Despite us being modern society, we have hardly been able to find any means of eliminating the notions of discrimination from our lives. On the contrary, it continues its living with us, finding roots in more and more world cultures. As far as we can see, every social group is looking for the root of evil and tries to find it in the most vulnerable area for them. Critical perspectives on the state have been always existed, as well as positive ones. The state’s evil has been currently considered from two different perspectives: on the one hand, there is a need to introduce minor changes in the state’s functions and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Animals

..., some people have compared pets to children. For example, for someone always working, with little or no time to take care of a pet, a cat would be highly recommended instead of a dog since cats are mostly indoors. This scenario presented by a cat is quite unlike the case of a dog, which might feel lonely and develop separation-related anxiety due to absence of mental and physical stimulation by the owner (Radford 72). Although it is perhaps the commonest debate among pet and animal lovers, whether a cat, a dog, or a reptile is the best pet is a matter of one’s opinion. There are in fact, valid arguments that support each kind of pet. Unfortunately, while some present good scientific...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Claims

...Module Skill discovery In management, there are extremely many management skills and competences that have been pinpointed by different scholar. Different managers have strengths and weaknesses in various skills and competences. The most common competences and skills required of managers include the following: motivating people so that they can produce maximum by compensating their efforts; delegating authority effectively in all levels of management to ensure communication and commands follow scalar chain unless where the chain is creating delay; decisions making to enable the organization achieve set goals and objectives; understanding team dynamics, to ensure cooperation of all...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Vaginitis particularly

...nature of this infection as compared to other sexually transmitted diseases coupled with the lack of effect on fertility of infected patients (Sorvillo, 2001). However, given the complications as well as the staggering prevalence of this type of vaginitis, particularly among African American women and urban communities in the US, additional studies would have to be undertaken. Such would help evaluate the incidence of T. vaginalis infection and determine the risk factors (Sorvillo, 2004). Furthermore, implementing additional control programs my help people to become better informed about this infection, hence, contain the spread of this disease. References Gor, H.B. (2006). Emedicine. ...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Animals

.... And from 2013, the marketing of cosmetics developed using animal experiments will be prohibited even if there are no alternative methods available."5 Today around 38,000 animals are killed in cosmetics testing in the EU every year. This legislation should have been a welcome reminder in the light of cosmetics bans already having been imposed in several EU countries, including Britain, but France was forced to challenge the directive recently at the ECJ under huge pressure from its cosmetics industry. . The French argued that the ban was too severe, incompatible with World Trade rules, that its wording was ambiguous and that it would damage European business...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Animals

...that a population boom takes place that produces lots of animals of one species which may destroy the natural environment. Overpopulation is likely to happen when a new species is introduced into the environment. In this case, having advantages over native inhabitants quickly turns into plague. Overpopulation of one species is usually associated with driving away some native species. An example of an overpopulated species in the United States is white-tailed deer (“Hunting Facts”). The latter inhabit the southern part of Canada and most of the territory of the United States. Image 3. American Alligator Image 4 White-tailed...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Human Mental States

...Mental States I would contend that the patient has mental states. On this view, I would back the position taken by Doctor 2. I base my argument on two main points. First, I dispute the argument that an organic brain is necessary for the existence of mental states. Secondly, I challenge the view that the absence of an organic brain necessarily implies the absence of a non-material soul. The patient lacks an organic brain but has a computer in its place. From the observations of the doctors and from my own assessment of the patient, I would quickly argue that the computer fulfills all the roles that an organic brain could....
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Claims

...Skill discovery al affiliation In management, there are extremely many management skills and competences that have been pinpointed by different scholar. Different managers have strengths and weaknesses in various skills and competences. The most common competences and skills required of manages include the following; motivating people so that they can produce maximum by compensating their efforts. Delegating authority effectively in all levels of management to ensure communication and commands follow scalar chain unless where the chain is creating delay. Decisions making to enable the organization achieve set goals and objectives. Understanding team dynamics, to ensure cooperation of all...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Critically assess Renaissance understandings of humankind

... Critically assess Renaissance understandings of humankind Renaissance understanding of humankind is multi-faceted, considering that different individuals have different understanding of the Renaissance of humankind. However, while critically assessing the different understanding, it is fundamental to start with the understanding of Pico Mirandola, a philosopher who approaches the concept of Renaissance from the very core of human kind; the creation. The Renaissance understandings of humankind by Pico, centers on the concept of freedom, as the major factor that differentiates man from the rest of the creatures and organisms placed in the world (Mirandola, 1965 p5). The aspects of sharp senses, power of reason, and high level... that mankind...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Understanding Mental Health

...of human health; secondly, that mental health is a wide concept and cannot be defined as merely the absence of disease; and thirdly, that mental health is intricately connected to physical health and behavior. (Herrman, Saxena & Moodie, 2005) Though Peter was not suffering from any obvious physical disease or disorder, his addiction to alcohol and drugs had severely affected his physical and mental health, which was manifested in many of his bodily symptoms like dependence on drugs, restlessness in their absence, inability to sleep etc. Any deviation from the state of mental health can be termed as a mental disorder. A serious...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critically Assess the Claims That Animals, Particularly Chimpanzees, Have a Humanlike Understanding of Mental States for FREE!

Contact Us