StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Critical Reading Assignment Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Sixteenth-Century Spain - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
25 July 2012 Critical Reading Assignment: "Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Sixteenth-Century Spain" In “Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Sixteenth-Century Spain”, Gillian. T, W Ahlgren provides background information on how women sought to achieve sanctity under the authority of the Catholic Church and the Spanish Inquisitors…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Critical Reading Assignment Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Sixteenth-Century Spain
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critical Reading Assignment Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Sixteenth-Century Spain"

Download file to see previous pages This assignment provides a critical review on Ahlgren’s work based on her writing on women position in church, in Catholic Spain, during the sixteenth century. In addition, the assignment highlights arguments supporting and disagreeing with Ahlgren’s assertions. In her work, she asserts that canonization provided a significant hurdle to women in recognition of their holiness and sanctity. The church canonized fewer congregants both female and male due to pressure from protestant churches on the practice of sanctity among the Catholics. Furthermore, Ahlgren says that the revival of canonization in the seventeenth century of five saints was symbolic of the moralistic value of the process, but she seems to suggest that the lack of it undermined women’s position in the church. Sanctity is negotiable to the extent that the church determined who was worthy to be a saint through canonization. Nevertheless, she does not point out if there were consensus by the ordinary people with regards to the issue of canonization (Ahlgren 375). Additionally, Ahlgren seems to suggest that the canonization of saints enhanced sanctity since more men than women underwent canonization they achieved sanctity than women. Equating saints with sanctity is not necessarily correct; according to Kleinberg (183) saints were a cultural symbol in the medieval times. Thus, even in the sixteenth century people venerated saints, not because of their sanctity but because the society could not live up to their own hopes and beliefs. The saints provided an avenue of redemption on behalf of the society within the cult of saints rather than for their value in sanctity. The role of confessors as symbols of sanctity became more prominent in the late medieval period onwards, whilst the role of martyrs declined substantially (Kleinberg 184). Even though confessors faced numerous challenges, the fact that more men than women became recognized as confessors meant that for women negotiating sanctity became harder in a society valuing more male saints than females. The article seems to suggest that the catholic officials in Sixteenth century Spain relegated holy women into minor roles, through trials by the Spanish Inquisition. While this analogy is correct, it nonetheless paints the Spanish church as intrinsically misogynist to mention the role of Rome and the Spanish monarchy in instituting the laws governing. Similarly, the prevailing political structure and power in most of Europe constituted of monarchial systems mostly headed by male figures regardless of whether the nations were Catholic or Protestant. Cultural biases inhibited women’s position in the Church, which was not necessarily a Catholic Phenomenon but an all prevailing fact in the society at large. Ahlgren points out that, in the church’s opinion, personal and private prayer among women provided less opportunity for recognition of their sanctity. To support his point, he mentions a meeting in 1525 among some Catholics who were subsequently accused of neglecting church sacrament in favor of personal prayer; connoting that this seemed to go against church doctrine. She assumes that women chose prayer in pursuit of sanctity after failure to gain recognition in the church (Ahlgren 376). However, prayer could be a trait common among women where women had a greater role in mysticism even before the sixteenth ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Reading Assignment Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Essay”, n.d.)
Critical Reading Assignment Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1455002-critical-reading-assignment-after-read-negotiating
(Critical Reading Assignment Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Essay)
Critical Reading Assignment Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Essay. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1455002-critical-reading-assignment-after-read-negotiating.
“Critical Reading Assignment Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1455002-critical-reading-assignment-after-read-negotiating.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical Reading Assignment Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Sixteenth-Century Spain

Women Prostitution

Women indulge in prostitution are sometimes considered to be “exclusive” of this society irrespective of the fact that they are the mirrors of those dilemmas which we ignore or which we feel shame to admit to ourselves. Society should consider and face this dilemma in the form of “prostitution”. We will discuss some of the most common problems faced by the women of Canada today.
Because of the pervasive and deeply rooted attitudes toward the legitimacy of sexual coercion in our society, our conceptions of normal males and females derived from taking coerced sexuality as the natural standard. And given that this is true, it is scarcely surprising that it should be considered to be normal for men not to...
16 Pages(4000 words)Assignment

Women and Law - Infanticide and Forced Caesareans

Ethical issues are posed in this connection, especially in the violation of a woman’s fundamental right to autonomy in her reproductive decisions, which has been guaranteed under Articles 8 and 12 of the European Convention of Human Rights and incorporated into the UK law through the Human Rights Act of 1998.

The first forced caesarean section in Britain was sanctioned by the High Court in 1992. Subsequent petitions were made on an emergency basis, against the women’s wishes, when the lives of the fetuses were perceived to be in danger. As Dyer reports, one of the women had a history of psychiatric treatment but did not have any mental disorder, while there was no question at all about another woman’s...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Critical Concepts in Political Science

Globalization, accompanied by liberal rhetoric, is accused in losses of the cultural identity, the insufficient accountability of large transnational corporations, deterioration of the rights of workers, an increase of distance between the rich and poor countries and between classes. Liberalism is also suspected in promoting the capture of authority by the countries of the West and in particular the USA above the whole planet.
The modern world experiences fundamental and dynamic changes. Transformation of international relations, the termination of confrontation and consecutive overcoming of consequences of the Cold War have expanded opportunities of cooperation on the international scene. The threat of the global nuclear con...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

How Can Seeing a Live Performance Enhance Your Experience or Reading of a Drama

The same is the case with human intellect. It receives some inputs which can be called perceiving the stimulus, interprets it in the light of his previous knowledge and experience and then it reacts accordingly and inputs just processed becomes the part of one’s experiences. This is how a person enhances his experience.  There can be a number of sources that stimulate this process of experience enhancement. Two of them, related to dramatics, are reading a drama and a live performance. Obviously, in both the situations, the thinking process in the human being activates upon receiving the stimulus by reading or watching or performing, this stimulus is then interpreted by the brain and then becomes the part of an individua...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

African-American Women: Dying to Live

In order to manage this epidemic, CDC and other public health practitioners generally apply individual-based theories. However, individual-based theories are inadequate because they assume that an individual is fully equipped to make the necessary behavior changes that have been suggested. These theories have a propensity to overlook the individuals’ environment, socio-economic status, shelter accessibility, and various other circumstances as they relate to the prevention of high-risk behaviors. This paper will specifically define how poverty and homelessness serve as explanations for the increased incidence and prevalence of HIV in the African-American community, and African-American women in particular.
Human Immunode...
16 Pages(4000 words)Assignment

Free Will and Its Critical Concepts in Philosophy

The ethical view is that we can hold individuals morally responsible for their actions. Thirdly, Free will in scientific terms means the body actions of the body, including mind and brain do not have only physical causes (Fischer, 2005). Here defining the basic terms used in the context of free will would be helpful:

 It is the view that all current & future events are regulated by past events coupled with the laws of nature. It is the view that all current & future events are regulated by past events coupled with the laws of nature. Determinism has a variety of meanings with the corresponding different problem of free will.

• Under Causal (or nomological) determinism past, present...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Traditional Women in the Modern World

It is within the family that many attributes of gender inequality are generated and replicated. Economic and interpersonal dependence on both genders and in various instances more vicious forms of inferiority, are classic elements of marriage and family. Women’s long-established roles leave them with the trouble of widespread domestic and nurturance obligations in addition to limited authority within the family. These trends represent gender inequality within the home and are echoed in the ideology justifying a gender-separated workforce in which women’s earnings and prospects are disproportionate to men’s. While almost every woman has some family bonds to men, by their kinship ties to their fathers and brothers,...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

Critical Review of 4 Papers about Education

The author argues in this article that the real problem between races in Great Britain goes beyond individuals that discriminate and hate one another base don race. He argues that institutional racism is a real problem. Part of the problem is that Citizenship Education has been touted as the cure for the nation’s racial strife. The author argues that Citizenship Education does little more than making people feel good because it looks like the government is doing something to address the problem. In reality, the author contends that Citizenship Education acts as a placebo. He argues that it is impossible for the institution to eliminate racism if the institution itself is racist.

Much of the author’s foundati...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

On Peter Jennings 4000-Year History of Jerusalem and Roots of Conflict in Holy Land

...On Peter Jennings’ 4000-year history of Jerusalem and Roots of Conflict in Holy Land In specific, does the video give the viewer a brief and accurate historical feedback on the significance of Jerusalem to Jews, Christian and Muslims? In order words, does the video report a balanced view for all three Abrahamic faiths or not? For about 45 minutes, the “Jerusalem Stories” by Peter Jennings did attempt to provide a balanced view for all three faiths. Jennings succeeded in presenting that Jews, Christians, and Muslims have common roots. It attempted to present a brief and accurate historical narration of the significance of Jerusalem to all of the three faiths. However, in my view, the video has stressed on the subjective rather than...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Beautiful Women Enhancing the Beauty of Advertising in 1890s

...Beautiful Women Enhancing the Beauty of Advertising in 1890’s Art has always played a key role in enhancing the beauty of women through various mediums. In art women have been the strongest subject through which one can best express this medium. Before 1890, women were not given enough independence to express themselves; they were neglected by a large part of the society. However, with the passage of time until 19800, women actively participated in politics, media and art industry. Their strength grew year by year and thus, their contributions in different fields were recognized by the society and the critics; who used to take women as the weakest and fragile part of the society (Janet Boles and Katherine Scheurer). Similarly, art...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critical Reading Assignment Negotiating Sanctity: Holy Women in Sixteenth-Century Spain for FREE!

Contact Us