StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Rav Shimi Bar Ashi and Rav Papa: Text Study - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
What would be different ways to understand Rabi Papa's perception of Rabi Shimi posing questions? One way to understand this, aside from perceiving the questioning as insolence, would be to accept and encourage Rabi Shimi's questioning as an example of a curious mind…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
Rav Shimi Bar Ashi and Rav Papa: Text Study
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Rav Shimi Bar Ashi and Rav Papa: Text Study"

Download file to see previous pages What would be different ways to understand Rabi Papa's perception of Rabi Shimi posing questions? One way to understand this, aside from perceiving the questioning as insolence, would be to accept and encourage Rabi Shimi's questioning as an example of a curious mind. We could understand Rabi Shimi's opinion of Rabi Papa's role in many different ways. Here, Rabi Shimi seems to believe that the role of Rabi Papa is to answer questions and help him to understand his educational goals. Perhaps Rabi Papa wishes Rabi Shimi to learn through observations (“do as I do, not what I say”) which may be more beneficial in some cicumstances as educators.
3. What would be different ways to understand Rabi Shimi's understanding of Rabi Papa's reaction in prayer? It could be suggested that Rabi Shimi misinterpreted the words of Rabi Papa in prayer. Rabi Shimi perhaps felt that Rabi Papa was asking him to be quiet, whereas Rabi Papa was perhaps just asking for patience and understanding when dealing with the insolence of the pupil. It could be construed in many different ways.
4. What would be different ways to understand Rabi Shimi's decision? We could understand Rabi Shimi's decision as an overreaction to a simple request from Rabi Papa. Rabi Shimi could have perhaps been hurt from the comments on his insolence, but a truly patient and understanding man may have continued to ask valid and important questions of his teacher to try and understand the ways of the Talmud.
5. What would be different ways that Rabi Papa might have explained Rabi Shimi's silence? Rabi Papa would not have known that Rabi Shimi heard his prayer. He may have felt that his prayer was answered and that it was not this simple overhearing that led to the silence of Rabi Shimi. Rabi Papa may have also felt gratitude that his prayer was answered and become more patient with his pupil thanks to the protection from insolence. 6. What each one of them thought, felt or where wondering about? There are many different emotions portrayed in this short piece of text. For one, the teacher seems to have perhaps overreacted and not have the patience that a teacher should. Rabi Papa may have been aggravated or even annoyed at the questioning. He may also have felt relief that the questioning had stopped. There is also a lot of hurt felt on behalf of Rabi Shimi, who may have been insulted or confused as to why his teacher did not welcome his questioning and learning. 7. Why no one try to find out what lies behind the behavior of this colleague? There is no clear answer to this, but it could be said that each one may feel shame at their emotions and perhaps this would lead them not to directly ask about the emotions and behavior of their colleagues. There may also be embarrassment at having to ask for help dealing with the insolence of a student Rabi. 8. What might this story be about? This story seems to be about issues that can be present in trying to correctly deal with the teacher-student roles. It could be about bad teaching practice, or simply about how emotions can lead to prayer. 9. Is the narrator critical of one of the characters? Explain. The narrator seems to be critical mostly of Rabi Papa for not having the patience to deal with the questioning and needing help to deal with the insolence of his pupil. The narrator seems not to be proud of someone needing to 'fall to his face' to deal with problem-solving. 10. What might have been alternative ways to deal with the problem from RabiPapa's perspective; from R. Shimi's perspective? Rabi Papa could have dealt with the problem by discussing it with his pupil and trying to understand where these questions came from. There could have been a bit more ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Rav Shimi Bar Ashi and Rav Papa: Text Study Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1434192-rav-shimi-bar-ashi-and-rav-papa-text-study
(Rav Shimi Bar Ashi and Rav Papa: Text Study Essay)
https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1434192-rav-shimi-bar-ashi-and-rav-papa-text-study.
“Rav Shimi Bar Ashi and Rav Papa: Text Study Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1434192-rav-shimi-bar-ashi-and-rav-papa-text-study.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Rav Shimi Bar Ashi and Rav Papa: Text Study

The Use of Scientific Methods to Study the Law

...Is it useful to use scientific methods to study the law? In answering the question “What is law?” Saint Augustine d: “Lex iniustanon est lex” (Unjust law is not law). This attributes a moral dimension to the law, which is disputed in the positivist approach that postulates legal validity as being conditioned by social facts rather than moral content. When applying a scientific approach to a study of law, the basic premise that holds good is the existence of certain immutable principles that condition our understanding of reality. According to Hans Kelson, the “law functions as a scheme of interpretation”1 and it is that system or set of rules that orders the manner in which we view the world. Hence the study of law, when applied...
9 Pages(2250 words)Coursework

Welfare to Work and Social Policy: Comparative Study of Various Nations' Approaches

The social policy varies differently by the needs of individual nations and can include assistance to youth unemployment in an attempt to provide temporary aid until an individual is able to sustain a regular income through work incentives. One of the main theories regarding welfare to work programs is that working parents contribute to the economy and are less likely to rely solely on the state for their welfare (Walling, 2005). With this concept being one of the primary motivators for welfare to work policies, different nations adopt a policy to provide an allotment of skills training, aid with transportation issues, financial support, and even child care as an incentive to drive the welfare recipient back into full-time work. T...
9 Pages(2250 words)Report

Quality Systems in the Public Sector: A Study of Quality Initiatives in the NHS, Scotland

The disintegration of some service provisions covered by the public sector is the cause of concern. In some cases where services, earlier provided by public sector organizations, were privatized led to the dramatic change in the quality and cost of service. This makes a study of concepts of quality management in the context of the public sector necessary to understand the reasons behind the ‘market failure’ of public sector service providers.

The problems that assail these services are inherent in any government enterprise such as lack of coordination, slow decision making, inflexibility, lack of incentive to perform and so on. Consider the following observation of Joseph Stiglitz (1998).

"Making...
55 Pages(13750 words)Dissertation

Text of Comparative Politics

For their case study, Somers and Block chose to use for their examination was the social and political motivation behind the New Poor Law of 1834 in England and Wales, compared with the United States social security legislation passed during 1996. The main objective of the article by Somers and Block is to argue that these two pieces of legislation were intended to decrease the level of welfare provision in their respective countries. Such a reduction was they argued due to the growing influence of free-market ideology, which regarded all such provision as morally wrong, as well as encouraging people not to work.

For the people that introduced the New Poor Law and the American social security legislation, there was a st...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

A Systematic Approach to Training and Development In Organic Juice Bar

 Prior to the discussion of training needs assessment, I would discuss several issues in the human resources management process that determine why training is important.
Daft and Fitzgerald (1992) indicate that in order to manage an organization effectively in a competitive environment, planning for human resources strategy requires several factors several external factors to be considered.

1. Attract an effective workforce. This includes planning on the number of employees required, job analysis or what types of jobs should be conducted or jobs associated with the types of business, forecasting future recruitment, recruiting because good employees need to be recruited, and selecting.
As stated by Daft an...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

Country Study: Mali

The territory of Mali has had a great history. We have been centers of the Ghana Empire, the Mali Empire, and the Songhai Empire for about six centuries. Thereafter, during the 17th and 18th centuries, several small states developed along the Niger basin, but they fell during the holy war waged by Muslim leader Al-Hajj Umar, whose kingdom extended from Timbuktu to headwaters of Niger and Senegal. His successor, Ahmadu was defeated by the French in 1860. (http://us-africa.tripod.com /mali.html)

As is well-known, we have had a turbulent past. We were a French colony for 80 years until we achieved independence. Now we are a multi-party democracy with Presidential form of Government. While the executive power rests with the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Conflict Between Researh and Ethics on the Tuskegee Syphilis Study

...Opinion paper The Declaration of Helsinki by the WHO clearly s that in clinical trials involving humans the wellbeing of the should be of prime importance than the interest of science or society. This has been stated because at times in order to achieve the objectives of a study the investigators might overlook the welfare of the trial subjects thus jeopardizing their health in the process. According to ethical rules while comparing two treatment options the control group of the study must receive the best known treatment available while the study subjects are given a potential newer treatment. Only when there is no effective treatment available a placebo-controlled group can be used for the study. There have been several trials which have...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Value Management Study for TechWatt Corporation

...Value Management Study for TechWatt Corporation Executive Summary This Report focuses on TechWatt Corporation’s request for a VM study regarding itsplanned expansion program. The firm wants to build a regional headquarters, and has asked this consulting firm to provide a VM study wherein functional benefits of the construction are emphasized. A background of the project is first provided and analyzed. The members of the study group are then formed, and the agenda, the techniques to be used, and problems to be discussed, are formulated. Functional analyses in the construction of the project is of primary objective of the study. The VM study group will come up with a conclusion and recommendations to the CEO of TechWatt Corporation...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Does Political Theory Have Any Importance for the Study of Politics

The system has evolved significantly and whether directly or indirectly every citizen is affected and influenced by the political happenings. Moreover, citizens also affect political events in one way or the other, either directly or indirectly. Therefore, we all live in a society where most of us are passive political actors or audience, in either case, closely connected to the system (Hoffman & Graham, pp. 403-408, 2006). Over the past centuries, experts and authorities have developed a theoretical framework to help us understand political behavior and events. However, the fundamental question that arises here is that how this political theory or political philosophy helps us to understand political behavior or facilitates o...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

The Epistemological Assumptions Schommer-Aikins and Hutters Study

The authors, however, have made several philosophical assumptions even before the actual study began. These assumptions have bearing on the entire research because they guided the studies thesis, the method of investigation and the way the researchers interpreted the collected data.
Referring to previous works, Schommer-Aikins and Hutter embarked on several bouts of theorizing regarding the nature of knowledge and how people learn about issues that they face every day. Citing the body of literature, for example, on epistemological beliefs, the authors assumed that "individuals’ beliefs about the nature of knowledge and learning are linked to their comprehension, metal comprehension, interpretation of information, and pe...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Rav Shimi Bar Ashi and Rav Papa: Text Study for FREE!

Contact Us