StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud's Theories of Human Behavior - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The purpose of this essay is to introduce the most known psychological theories of Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud. Furthermore, the essay will comparatively discuss the definition of unconsciousness according to Freud and Jung. Specifically, the essay will analyze Carl Jung’s theory on the Unconscious…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
Carl Jung and Sigmund Freuds Theories of Human Behavior
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud's Theories of Human Behavior"

Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud Introduction Carl Jung (1875-1961) and Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) were two individuals whose theories on human personality would completely affect the way that people viewed the human mind. Carl Gustav was a practicing psychotherapist while Sigmund Freud was created the discipline of psychoanalysis. The two men had seemingly identical beliefs about human behavior, but also had contrasting beliefs about concepts such as the ego, the psyche, and the state of unconsciousness. Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud’s Theories Sigmund Freud’s beliefs about personality were based on past experiences in an individual’s childhood. Freud stated that all human beings had three personality levels. These were the ego, the id, and the superego. The level of the id is the one that houses a person’s primitive drives and supports the enactment of decisions that are purely based on pleasure. The id’s objective is to avoid pain at all costs and only seek for pleasurable sensations. The ego, on the other hand, identifies the significance of reality and makes decisions based on concepts such as judgment, perception recognition, and memory. The last level, the superego, is dedicated to seeking for perfection (Reber, 2006). This level houses the individual’s accepted social morals and ideals in the conscience. Jung had different views about the different mental levels in the conscious mind. Instead of the ego, id, and superego, Jung perceived the human thought process as constituting of an individual level of unconsciousness, an ego, and a collective unconscious. According to Jung, the ego was actually the conscious mind which had connections with the individual unconsciousness level. Jung also stated that while the personal unconsciousness level was tied to an individual’s emotions and had the ability to affect a person’s behaviours, the level of the collective unconscious is responsible for connecting humanity on various levels. For instance, experiencing religious communion in places of worship, falling in love, or even having identical dreams are all occurrences that result from collective consciousness. In regards to the collective unconscious, Freud and Jung had different references to its contents. While Jung referred to the unconscious’ contents as archetypes, Freud referred to them as instincts (Reber, 2006). For Jung, the archetypes that filled the unconscious realm were of a spiritual nature; Freud, on the other hand, believed that the instincts in the unconscious were of biological extraction. Jung would go on to generate personality typologies which included the concepts of extroversion as well as introversion. Analysis of the Unconscious according to Freud and Jung For Carl Jung, Freud’s analysis on the meaning of the instincts contained in the unconscious was unnecessarily negative (Schultz and Schultz, 2004). Jung did not entirely dismiss the premise that some reactions in the unconscious were based on negative past experiences. Moreover, he went on to find other reasons for the vast majority of archetypes contained in the unconscious. Jung stated that while Freud was accurate in emphasizing on the existence of a personal unconscious, there was an even more deeper level- the collective unconscious. Jung also expressed doubts about Freud’s connection of dreams with generalized subjects. For Jung, dreams have a lot of significance which can only be deciphered when psychoanalysts become cognizant of the individual’s personal history. Another aspect in which Freud and Jung had different meanings of subjects had to do with the contents of the collective unconscious. For Freud, the unconscious contained elements that were received by the unconscious even without the conscious realm recognizing this reality. This action is driven by numerous environmental determinants which the conscious mind is not aware are even present. While Carl Jung recognized the existence of such factors, he did not believe that they existed due to personal experiences (Schultz and Schultz, 2004). He instead believed that human activities are motivated by unconscious material that are evolutionarily inherited. The accuracy of Carl Jung’s theory on the Unconscious Carl Jung was initially Sigmund Freud’s student. However, Jung did not believe in Freud’s assertions about past negatives being the only things that affected the unconscious realm of the human thought process. One of the main reasons why Jung’s interpretation of the human collective unconscious is more practical and constructive than that of Freud’s psychoanalysis is because Jung’s interpretation has positive aspects that help rather than heal. For instance, Jung’s theory seeks to psychologically explain the significance of the role that religion plays in the formation of unconscious thoughts. Jung’s theory holds that people are mainly shaped by experiences that they have gone through even as they strive towards self-actualization. In addressing the significance of self-actualization within the collective unconscious, Jung demonstrated that it was his belief that the collective unconscious is an area that has constructive tools which help individuals to achieve their life goals (Nystul, 2006). Sigmund Freud’s belief in repressed negative memories being held in the collective unconscious was more indicative of the notion that the collective unconscious was quite destructive because it held all the things that people did not wish to confront. Another reason why Jung’s theory is more useful and believable than that of Freud is because Freud’s psychoanalysis hypothesis cannot provide an explanation for children’s dream imagery in the same way that Jung’s might. Children usually have vivid dreams about different subjects. In addition, children tend to have more complex dreams than adults. Moreover, children cannot be said to have repressed memories from earlier life experiences. Jung’s theory accepts the reality of dreams without ascribing their existence to negative experiences. This is the more positive outlook and is thus more useable in environments such as counseling settings. Another reason why Jung’s theory is more believable than Freud’s is because it can be applied in different environments with similar results. Carl Jung did not merely create a theory after engaging in lengthy periods of self-reflection. Jung gained a lot of experience by conducting studies on the human thought process in different societies across the world. Jung studied oriental as well as African cultures (Schultz and Schultz, 2004). This allowed him to come up with a theory that was more well rounded than that of Freud. While Freud was too dependent on his individual battles when determining the basis of his theory on human thought, Jung, as a result of his experiences, created a more holistic theory on the human mind which could be applied in different cultures. Jung’s theory also gives more acceptable explanations for occurrences in the course of personality development. Essentially, Jung’s theory asserts that the real personality development can only realistically take place during an individual’s adulthood (Castellana and Donfrancesco, 2005). According to Jung, the passage of childhood witnesses the struggle of the child’s ego to differentiate from those of the child’s parents. In the early years of human existence, the child is more easily affected by his or her parent’s actions because he or she has not developed the personal ego- and so is vulnerable to the will of his or her parent’s egos. With the passage of years, the child’s ego develops further and becomes independent from the parent’s egos. With the development of the child’s ego, the parent’s actions slowly begin to cease having a big effect on the child. Such revelations could not be conduced from Freud’s one-sided argument on the significance of repressed memory in children as well as adults. Conclusion Both Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud created theories that benefited humanity. Jung was a student of Sigmund Freud and learned a lot of facts from him. However, Carl Jung would create a more practical theory after further developing Freud’s theories. Even though both Jung and Freud felt that there was an actual hierarchical connection between the “conscious” or “unconscious”, it was Jung who elected to develop this premise further. Jung believed that Freud was accurate in stating that instinct was one of the motivations of the collective unconscious; however, Jung also believed that there were deeper functions beyond instinct which inspired the generation of instinct. In general, Jung’s theory is more acclaimed in modern psychology than Freud’s because it digs deeper into the factors that form the collective unconscious. References Castellana, F., & Donfrancesco, A. (2005). Sandplay in Jungian analysis: Matter and symbolic integration. Journal of Analytical Psychology, 50, 367-382. Nystul, M. S. (2006). Introduction to counseling: An art and science perspective (3rd ed.). Boston: Allyn and Bacon. Reber, J. S. (2006). Secular psychology: What’s the problem? Journal of Psychology and Theology, 34, 193–204 Schultz, D. P., & Schultz, S. E. (2004). A history of modern psychology. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thomson Learning. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud's Theories of Human Behavior Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud's Theories of Human Behavior Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1809220-carl-jung-vs-sigmund-freud
(Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud'S Theories of Human Behavior Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud'S Theories of Human Behavior Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1809220-carl-jung-vs-sigmund-freud.
“Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud'S Theories of Human Behavior Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1809220-carl-jung-vs-sigmund-freud.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud's Theories of Human Behavior

Looking for Sigmund Freud

But I distinctly remember going through the "feminine Oedipus attitude" phase or Elektra complex as how carl jung called it.... When I came across Freud's theory on the human psyche, I thought that it might explain those responses.... His theories were complex and are quite intriguing.... His theories were complex and are quite intriguing.... His theories were complex and are quiteintriguing.... But emerging theories and recent studies have challenged the theories put forth by Freud....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

William James and Phenomenology

lfred Adler examined human personality around the same time as carl jung and sigmund Freud.... If Freud said that the goal of therapy was to make the unconscious conscious, a younger colleague of his, carl jung, was to make the exploration of this "inner space".... Freud based his notions of the unconscious mind as a reservoir for repressed memories of traumatic events that continuously influence conscious thought and behavior.... For Jung, an empirical investigation of the realms of dream, myth, personality, and soul represented the manner to understand the "inner space" of the human psyche....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Emergence of the Discipline of Psychology

Considerably influenced by Freud, carl jung and Alfred Adler perceived psychology in theories of personality and psychotherapy.... For Watson, "introspection forms no essential part of its methods" Other early contributors to modern Psychology include Hermann Ebbinghaus, Ivan Pavlov, and sigmund Freud.... Behaviorism states that Psychology should be a science of behavior, not the mind, and rejected the idea of internal mental states such as beliefs, desires or goals, believing all behavior and learning to be a reaction to the environment....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

TV Character Evaluation

Sigmund Freud developed an entirely different perspective on human behavior and he remains to be the most influential among the psychodynamic theorists.... Carl Roger identified ‘self actualizing tendency' which is the tendency of human mind to become the best of what ever a particular person's innate capacities born with.... Morris and Maisto (2002) stated that carl jung's analytical psychology concept agrees with some of the tenets of Freud's theory, but, it is still different in many other ways....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Carl Jung's Approach to Personality Theory

This definition seems very complicated and difficult and helps to The question has been studied by people such as Carl Rogers, carl jung and sigmund Freud.... Among these models, though, carl jung developed a relatively uncomplicated approach on which many of the personality theories today have been based.... Originally building his research off of the ideas of sigmund Freud, who was his mentor for a while, Jung proposed that the personality was comprised of the interaction among four essential factors that related to the way in which a person gathers information and then how that person processes the information gathered....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Theories by Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud

As the last born in his family, Jungs family intrigues, including his mothers sickness affected parenting experiences that influenced his Impact of Household Background on Theories by carl jung and sigmund Freud Full s of Affiliation Impact of Household Background on Theories by carl jung and sigmund FreudCarl Jung and Sigmund Freud had different interpretations on personality theories, largely owing to their different upbringing backgrounds.... Freud contested Jungs religious interpretation of the human psyche mainly due to his view of religion as an illusion....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Facts Related to the Relationships of Siblings in Light of Authentic Theories

"Facts Related to the Relationships of Siblings in Light of Authentic Theories" paper is made on the siblings' rivalry that is a normal part of siblings' relationship in families, under the light of the sigmund freud's theory of “sibling rivalry” and on the topic of Birth order among the siblings.... The critique is made over the topics, issues, and solutions presented within the theories that are mentioned in this paper.... ccording to freud's studies, it is shown that the greatest rivalry takes place between the male siblings or brothers as compared to the rivalry found between sisters....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Particular Stage Of Human Development

Freud on Sue's caseAccording to Freud the human psyche is composed of three parts: the id, the ego and the super ego.... Sue's case was subjected to several psychoanalytic theories which includes Freudan, Banduran and Humanistic approaches.... … For the sake of anonymity, we shall refer to the subject as “Sue”....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us