Nobody downloaded yet

The False Memory Illusion - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In the Brainerd & Wright model of verbal recall illusion semantic differences are arbitrary and corrupt. Forward and backward association of words is dependent upon semantics and not, as claimed, on any genuinely memorable association. Their results, used to argue the illusory nature of false memory, are unreliable because of a false premise: the Deese-Roediger-McDermott false memory illusion…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
The False Memory Illusion
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The False Memory Illusion"

Download file to see previous pages the lists are a product of free recall. Semantic associations must not be applied in reverse because they are generated using free recall and their only possible scientific application is semantically probabilistic.
Brainerd & Wright mistakenly interpret their higher FAS result scores as a result of suppressive processes used inappropriately "to reject studied items that preserve the gist of experience." (Brainerd & Wright 2005) This mistake has nothing to do with suppressive processes; in fact the rejection of these items is because their semantic association with the previously listed word is weaker and the probability of semantically associating from the first word to the second word should already have been known from the probability score, or the free recall. The priority of words is itself an illusion, not a false memory illusion; for example, each list must start with a word and it must end with another word. It is nonsense to suggest that the word following the first word might in some way be illusory. The semantic association that leads to the last word must take priority over any associative strength, whether forwards or backwards, because the lists are not illusory.
In a free recall exercise, as shown by Deese in his original paper, the first word is given to the subject who produces a second word. Until the experimenter has a set of words of sufficient size - and Brainerd & Wright's lists, at five words, are super short - there can be no backwards association. The lists are generated semantically. The final word is semantically associated only with its predecessor but not necessarily with the first word; however, the first word, is necessarily semantically associated with the final word. BAS is the illusion.
False memory is not an illusion that can be researched through experiments that involve free recall or semantics. False memory research by Brainerd can be traced to earlier research whose methodological errors produced Brainerd & Wright's current paper, also co-authored by Brainerd. (Brainerd & Reyna 2002, Brainerd, Reyna & Mojardin 1999, Brainerd, Reyna, Wright & Mojardin 2003) Each of these papers methodologically errs because it focuses on false memory, not true. This is noted by Brainerd (Brainerd, Reyna, Wright & Mojardin 2003, p. 762) but none of his research is about true memory. All research must attempt to establish the true facts and memory research is no exception to this rule. Brainerd therefore commits errors in scientific methodology.
Methodology in memory research must not be imaginative. Memory is not the imagination and researchers are not like novelists who create the future as they see fit using imaginary characters. The characters in memory experiments are subjects who must not be deceived intentionally, for example through the use of such devices as "critical distractors [sic]." (Brainerd & Wright 2005) These imaginary devices are semantically associated with words already in the lists and do not produce result that are meaningful - or memorable.
Section 2
In The Truman Show, a movie directed by Peter Weir, a character called Christof directs The Truman Show, starring Truman - or "true-man" - played by Jim Carrey. Christof (perhaps the false man) sits in the Lunar Room playing the part of Jim's father who died in a drowning accident, actually a false memory created by ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The False Memory Illusion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
The False Memory Illusion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1529656-the-false-memory-illusion
(The False Memory Illusion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
The False Memory Illusion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1529656-the-false-memory-illusion.
“The False Memory Illusion Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1529656-the-false-memory-illusion.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The False Memory Illusion

Literature Review on False Memory

...Psychology Topic:  M2 FALSE MEMORY Overview As the implies, false memory is a kind of memory that is not accurate but distorted and based on source of true memory. What false memories actually depict are not the weaknesses and in capabilities of persons involved to think straight or get their memories right but then it is a natural phenomenon that is sparked by a person’s attempt to get his or her memories right by basing them on previous experiences or what is normally known as clues (Jolene, 2007). For one reason or the other therefore, it is right to argue that we...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Lab Report on false memory

...? False memory in the DRM paradigm Insert (s) False memory refers to the distorted recollection of events that did not actually happen. Generally, human memory is often prone to fallacies and the memory of an experience can easily be distorted by a diverse number of factors such as by confusing the fragments and details of the memory of events. The primary aim of this experiment is to explore occurrence of false memories. The procedure used (DRM procedure) involved presenting a list of thematically and semantically related words to the participants. Each of the subjects were required to...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Memory

...Topic: External stimuli performance Approximate word count: 600. Memory can be defined as the capa of an organism to remember and recall objects, items, events, individuals, etc. Although, memory, generally, is associated with brain and nervous system of an organism; immunological memory defined as the capability of an organism's immune system to recognize a pathogen on subsequent encounters, may not have anything to do with brain or the nervous system. Human beings represent the highest point of evolution with regard to all types of memory; memory has also been demonstrated in almost all animals irrespective of whether they are vertebrate or...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Creating False Memories

...of both studied and nonstudied material. The results reveal a powerful illusion of memory: People remember events that never happened. Free Recall as a Means to Detect False MemoriesFalse memories-either remembering events that never happened, or remembering them quite differently from the way they happened-have recently captured the attention of both psychologists and the public at large. The primary impetus for this recent surge of interest is the increase in the number of cases in which memories of previously unrecognized abuse are reported during the course of therapy. Some researchers have argued that...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Research paper on false memory for psychology

...Females and 90 Males). Introduction According to Roediger III, H et al. (2001), visual objects are better remembered than are words which are just memorized. To him, imagery aids are remembered since they are retained in the memory. All recall phenomenon depend on the interaction and retrieval process of the words to be recalled. To Roediger III, H. and McDermott, K.B. (1995), words which are associated with related words presented earlier on are false fully recalled. In a research, Roediger III and McDermott proved that, words which are related in a certain order are easier to false-recall than those that not related. This is so because, the memory tends to recall words...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Memory

...Memory is a process of storing and retention of information sent by sensory organs which is then interpreted as per the requirements of the events. It is one of the main functions of the brain which is used on a daily basis and the more it is used and manipulated, the stronger it becomes in terms of retention of information for a longer time and comprehension of the same. The following three types of memories are discussed as below: Episodic Memory This type of memory is closely linked to the events and object reality of association and therefore, contextual in nature. It is for these reasons that some places and things look familiar and may trigger a sequence of...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

False Confessions

..., however, is that the innocent’s person memory may be altered, making its “original contents potentially irretrievable.” (Kassin, 1997, p. 226). These types of cases have two factors in common, namely: A suspect who is vulnerable The presentation of false evidence e.g. a rigged polygraph Coerced-compliant false confessions can be explained by the innocent’s suspect’s wish to escape an aversive experience and ensure a pleasant consequence. Conclusion There are significant numbers of wrongful convictions in the United States. A study by Bedau and Radelet found that the primary conviction of about 49 out of the 350 cases of miscarriages of justice was a false confession...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

False Memories

...ARTICLE CREATING FALSE MEMORIES BY ELIZABETH F. LOTUS Introduction Memories are easily modified as the time passes and it allows the true and original memories to fade. In order to evaluate the authenticity of this statement, the experimenter tried different experiments on participants to check how much they remembered about their true events. If any fake event would be presented in front of them, what would be their reaction? According to the experimenter, “these studies show that when people who witness true event and are later exposed to new and misleading information about it; their recollections often become distorted” (Loftus, 1997). Method The participants were...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

False Claims

...False Claims False Claims New York Times news report on gun ownership among households show inconsistency in the survey data compared with other investigating firms such as Gallup. New York Times used incomplete, psychological tactics and omitted information in reporting gun ownership among United States citizens. The news center uses an obsolete data from General social survey to claim that the rate of gun ownership has significantly decreased. The report stipulates that there has been an overall drop in the percentage of gun ownership using data that does not match those of crime prevention center (Johnrlott, 2013). New York Times reports indicate that 34 percent of American households possessed guns in...
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework

False memory

...of the main ingredients of many mnemonic languages (Goff & Roediger). Another view point is that “Information in memory that supported false recognition was retrieved in combination with perceptual information encoded from presented items. Because of this mixture of retrieved information, subjects may have subjectively experienced illusory recollection of the critical item in a particular modality, in the absence of attributions or imaginative processes” (Gallo et.al.). Here, one can infer that illusion may also turn to be the root cause of false memory. To conclude, one can state that there are various reasons for false...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The False Memory Illusion for FREE!

Contact Us