Nobody downloaded yet

The Constitution - Thesis Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The argument that the creation of the Constitution was a conflict founded on competing economic and financial interests by two groups of individuals - those who expected to gain benefits from its approval and those who oppose its ill-effects - was pioneered by Charles A…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
The Constitution
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Constitution"

Download file to see previous pages He further contends that many were disenfranchised and discriminated by the common law and thus were not represented in the Convention during its drafting which included countless adult males. In addition, most of the states at that time imposed property qualifications on the voters and consequently barred non-taxpayers. As most of the members of the conventions were lawyers and representatives of personalty, these individuals were 1'directly and personally interested in the outcome of their labors' and would economically benefit from the passage of the Constitution (Beard 59). Furthermore, Beard asserts that since these men were mostly merchants, shippers, bankers, speculators, and private and public securities holders, the Constitution was not crafted by 'the whole people.'
Beard's assertions remained undisputed until 1956 when Robert Brown's critique titled Charles Beard and the Constitution: A Critical Analysis of An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution dispels and attacks Beard's thesis and conclusions for their lack of merit. Brown, attacking Beard's objectivity, argues that Beard failed to collect compelling data and evidence to support his contentions. In his critique, Brown scrutinizes the support for the Constitution among diverse economic and social divisions, the democratic character of the country, and the franchise within the states in eighteenth-century America. He holds that Beard was misguided and further added that, eighteenth-century America was democratic, the franchise was common, and there was extensive backing for the Constitution, alleging that his evidence contradicts Beard's arguments about the lack of democracy and the insubstantial support for the Constitution. According to Brown, since the Founding Fathers upheld the Federal voting system done by indirect representation, the ratification of the Constitution was a democratic process and everyone's interests were aptly represented. Brown further argues that the constitution was not merely an economic document in which property was protected but it also stressed safeguards to life and liberty. This protection of property, Brown adds, is also essential to the protection of the individual and liberty.
A close scrutiny of the US Constitution is necessary in order to resolve this conflict as the issue has its precedence in the Constitution itself. The textbook, 'We The People,' states that the charter 2'attempts to create a government that would be strong to protect commerce and property rights yet weak enough to threaten individual liberty.' The statement strengthens Brown's contentions that the provisions governing the protection of property are significant parts of the constitution. The Constitution also emphasizes that that the framers, 3'feared the call of equality' which could result to equal allotment of property, and consequently violate the freedom of property owners. Although Beard is right with his assertions that the economic interests of the framers and those who represented the public were given utmost importance, the focus on economic interests and rights to property as well as protection of those rights fortified individual freedom. It is also important to note that these economic interpretations of the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Constitution Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The Constitution Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
“The Constitution Thesis Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document


The Constitution and Guns

...?The Constitution and Guns In “The Constitution and Guns,” Michael Belksiks divulges into the background and creation of the Constitution and the Second Amendment. It was not until the Revolution that North America caught its first glimpse of a gun culture among white males. This was due to the thousands of muskets that had been brought to America from Europe to supply an army that was gradually becoming smaller. There were more guns than North Americas knew what to do with; they did not need to make weapons themselves, yet they could not entirely decide what to do about the guns that remained. This history of gun culture reveals that while Congress and governments were willing to force...
3 Pages(750 words)Term Paper

Analysis of the Constitution

...? Analysis of the Constitution Americans have been troubled for an extended time with their civil rights for years. The liberty to practice creed and religious convictions though, they desired was among the most important reasons the initial settlers arrived to America from Great Britain. The right of image and self-purpose was among the major and primary the motives that initiated the Revolutionary War. The liberty for all individuals to be liberated was among the reasons that coerced the Civil War. The history of America is filled up with bills of rights. From the mainly well known incorporated in the Constitution, to the Rights Declaration provoked by the Stamp Act to the Avowal of Rights of Virginia...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Preamble to the Constitution

...? Preamble to the Constitution Suzie Mizoyan With the words; “We the People”, Establish Justice”, “the United s”, “Common Defence”, “Security of Liberty”, and “the General Welfare”1; the writers of the Preamble to the 1787 Constitution, managed to appease the Federalist national perspective, and create an opening that offered 18th Century America and 21st Century America a sense of continuity and legitimacy with its traditional use of wording similar to other foundation documents,2 and managed to create an emblematic symbol of our constitutional history; all in one sentence. The wording of the Preamble plays a large part in its value as a foundation document; it states the reasons for...
4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper


5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Counseling male rape victims

6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Development of The Constitution

...years of imprisonment. The defence then approach Florida Supreme Court and challenged the rulings of the Florida state court on the basis that defence was not provided with legal counsel. The defence claimed that access to justice was the fundamental right of the American national, and this right was protected under Constitution and the Bill of Rights by the United States Government (Thomas, 2004). The Supreme Court ruled out in the favour of the defence, the decision of the court was based upon the interpretation of the Sixth Amendment and Bett v. Brady case. The Sixth Amendment stated that the accused should be granted services of legal counsel during criminal prosecutions. The ruling of the case entitled Bett v. Brady...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Slavery and the Constitution

...Slavery and the constitution The acts of slavery plus servitude in America were evident in the 1700s when the was still the colony of Britain. It thrived mostly in the south where slaves worked in plantations. Slavery continued until when United States adjusted their constitution. Large sections of the captives were Africans and were held captive by the whites. There were little white slaves as it was compared to the Africans. Most Africans found their way in America due to the existence of trade. They were conveyed through ships to the destinations. Slaves worked mainly in the regions where the soil was good and supported crops like coffee, cotton, sugar and other crops. Thomas Jefferson, a former...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The constitution

... of Essay Factors that led to the drafting of the constitution In 1780’s America faced the critical period for their new nation. There was discontent and reconsideration caused by the danger of the economic crisis the disillusionment that came with the collapse of revolutionary expectations for dramatically improved conditions. A new plan for the country had to be developed, and this was the federal constitution, which was drafted by a group of national leaders in Philadelphia in 1787, who then presented it to the whole public for consideration1. Why it was necessary to change the articles of confederation The articles of confederation were considered far too weak and ineffectual in running a national government, so a combination... males...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Principles of the Constitution

...Principles of the Constitution Principles of the Constitution Self-Government A political system in which citizens of a country rule themselves and control their own affairs 2. Separation of Powers The independence in powers and operations of the three arms of government, executive, legislature and the judiciary 3.Checks and Balances Controlling the powers of the various arms of government in order to prevent one form usurping power and protect the minority Checks and balances in the federal government The federal government has three arms. These three arms work together in order to serve the American people. However, each arm of government enjoys its independence, which frees it from interference,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Creating the Constitution

...Various s in America started to come together and their leaders saw the importance of having a binding constitution. The leaders saw that it was important to have a fundamental law in the American land. This was the basis for the creation of American constitution. The American constitution was drafted in 1787. It was then adopted officially in 1789 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Since that time it has been amended twenty-seven times. The first ten amendments are known as the bill of rights as they were collectively formalized to protect the human rights. The bill of rights is a vital constituent of American law and the government. It symbolizes culture and freedom of the United States...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Thesis on topic The Constitution for FREE!

Contact Us