Scientific Relism vs Dennett's Instrumentlism, Elimintive Mterilism in the Philosophy of Mind - Literature review Example

The topic of philosophy of the mind (dualism) which is referred to as soul has over the centuries been marred by controversy.... Student's Name Course Tutor Date philosophy of the Mind Introduction The topic of philosophy of the mind (dualism) which is referred to as soul has over the centuries been marred by controversy.... Dualism is therefore closely associated with the views forwarded by a French philosopher, Rene Descartes who held that the mind is not a physical substance....

The paper "Dominant Points Of The Eliminative Materialism" looks for elaborating the eliminative materialism perspective of mind by making its comparative analysis with Cartesian dualism articulated by Rene Descartes and reductive materialism theory of mind by the psychologist E.... Citing the example of the negation with regards to the existence of devil-loving demonic witches has strictly been observed by the modern scientific evidence, eliminative materialism claims that the non-existence of the state of mind will also be proved by modern science with the passage of time (Mind as Myth, 145-46)....

There is a common conception that the mind controls the behavior or nature of a person but many times a person reacts to a situation without being controlled by his mind, rather on the basis of how his body is reacting.... Dennett in his story "Where Am I" suggests that the nature of a person depends not only upon the mind or the brain but also on the body.... There is a common conception that the mind controls the behavior or nature of a person but many times a person reacts to a situation without being controlled by his mind, rather on the basis of how his body is reacting....

Hilary Putnam claims that 'The positive argument for realism is that it is the only philosophy that does not make the success of science a miracle' as quoted in Curd and Cover.... The use of word no-miracle is associated with this argument in a way that it shows that scientific realism is just another philosophy stating the theoretical aspect of scientific success (Moran, 2004).... The research paper 'Argument of scientific Realism' will analyze scientific realism, which tends to explain generally that the world we live in is totally realistic world....

Dualism – this is the philosophy which states that for any particular domain, there are always two kinds or categories of things or fundamental principles.... Dualism – this is the philosophy which states that for any particular domain, there are always two kinds or categories of things or fundamental principles.... It posits the theory of the body and the mind (as an example) by accepting the reality of a physical world as well as the existence of another dimension which is the mental (Robinson, 2011). ...

This often-quoted statement came about as Descartes attempted to prove that even if there is some sort of great deceiver working to alter his perceptions of his own existence, the fact that he could be fooled proved he had a conscious mind.... This concept of separating thought from physical perception also led to the development of a theory of consciousness called dualism, which stipulated that the conscious mind was something other than and apart from the physical brain, yet also somehow connected so as to receive the sensory impressions of the body while exerting a tremendous amount of control over it....

The paper "The Problem of mind and Body in Philosophy" shows us that Eliminativists postulate that everyday cognitive concepts are so poorly defined that they have no objective neurological basis and that the neurological basis of cognition will provide stable definitions for these concepts.... An argument that has been launched against many theories of mind, and not just eliminativism, is the argument from qualia, where qualia is a sensation known independently of any physical considerations—or, in other words, the irreducible primaries of subjective experience (Walter, 2007)....

This study, scientific Realism & Anti-realism, highlights that scientific realism is the idea that 'the physical world exists independently of human thought or perception'.... The aim of realism is to use the clues that the world provides to create an accurate picture of the world as a whole....