StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Gettier's Problem - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Gettier's Problem" tells us about the understanding of descriptive knowledge. Attributed to American philosopher Edmund Gettier, Gettier-type counterexamples (called "Gettier-cases") challenge the long-held justified true belief (JTB) account of knowledge…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.8% of users find it useful
Gettiers Problem
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Gettier's Problem"

Defining knowledge has been a topmost issue in the field of epistemology since the ages. Epistemology is the branch of philosophy that is mainly associated with the discussion about the concept of knowledge (Ichikawa). The problem of defining knowledge has been discussed by the ancient philosophers like Socrates to the contemporary philosophers around the world. In 1963, ‘Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?’ by Edmund, Gettier was published in the journal, Analysis (Turri 1). In this 3-paged paper, Gettier challenged the classic theory of knowledge which defines knowledge as ‘justified true belief’. Gettier presented two cases in which subjects achieve the justified true belief, but fail to recognize it, proving that knowledge varies from justified true belief. Consequently, the cases refute the classic definition of knowledge, generating the ‘Gettier’s problem’ to satisfy the exact definition of knowledge (Gettier 121-123).

According to the traditional theory, justified true belief (JTB) is knowledge when three necessary and fundamental conditions are fulfilled. In other words, “S knows P if and only if (iff) – 1. P is true; 2. S believes P, and 3. S is justified in believing P” (Gettier 121). With the help of two cases, Gettier exposed the flaws of the definition. In his first example, Gettier showed that Smith had a justified belief that a man with ten coins in his pocket will get a job. Smith had evidence aboofut ten coins in Jones’ pocket and hence, he believed that Jones would get a job. But he was unaware of the ten coins in his pocket. Based on this belief, Smith got the job instead of Jones. Here, though Smith’s justified belief was true, it was based on a false assumption, hence one can’t say that Smith had knowledge (Gettier 121-122). Similarly, in another example, Smith had strong evidence about Jones’ ownership of a Ford car. Also, Smith had another friend, Brown, whose location was unknown to Smith. Based on this belief, Smith concluded three outcomes- “1. Either Jones owns a Ford, or Brown is in Boston; 2. Either Jones owns a Ford, or Brown is in Barcelona; 3. Either Jones owns a Ford, or Brown is in Brest-Litovsk” (Gettier 122). Gettier further revealed the fact that the car was rented by Jones and Brown was located in Barcelona. In this case, though the second conclusion was true, Smith didn’t know that it was true. Consequently, it violated the first condition of JTB, leading to the conclusion that Smith had no knowledge (Gettier 122-123). In a way, Gettier’s examples created Gettier’s problem which showed that the traditional three conditions are not capable of satisfying the definition of knowledge.

Since the late 1960s, many theories and solutions have been proposed by philosophers and experts in the field of epistemology, but none of them could provide flawless solutions. According to Gilbert Harman’s solution, interpretation from false belief leads to the preclusion of knowledge to Getter’s subjects (Turri 2). In Gettier’s Ford case, the reasoning about someone’s ownership of Ford in the office proceeds through a false belief that Jones owns the car. So according to Harman’s solution, knowledge is justified by true belief (JTB) where the interpretation of belief doesn’t proceed through a false step (Turri 2). But, suppose Jones was cleaning a Ford and whistling the Ford advertising jingle. Based on it, Smith concluded that someone in the office was waxing a Ford and whistling the Ford jingle. This belief was true. Further, on the basis of justified belief, Smith concluded that someone in the office owned a Ford which is true as Sam, a new employer, owned that car. Though here belief didn’t proceed through any false steps, it failed to consider as knowledge (Turri 2). Similar to Harman, various other solutions such as Zagzebski’s solution, Greco’s solution, Sosa’s solution, fallibilism, and contextualism tried to respond to the problem by presenting their own theories, modifying the present conditions, replacing or adding new conditions to it (Ichikawa; Turri 2-4). The failure of such theories was further analyzed by Linda Zagzebski in 1994. According to her, “any solution of the form JTB (justified true belief)+ X, where X is a condition or number of conditions logically distinct from belief, truth, and justification, would be prone to Gettier-type counter-cases” (Ichikawa).

According to my solution to Gettier’s problem, knowledge is a comprehensive belief. The Getteir’s subject didn’t believe comprehensively, hence they didn’t know. Though his subject managed to succeed in their sense, their belief didn’t reveal their knowledge. Outcomes are often affected by surroundings, processes, and events. For instance, the knowledge about the ability of microwaves to boil water can be presented in two beliefs. One with an ordinary case of boiling water in the microwave and the other due to the fire caused by short-circuits during the process. In both cases, the outcome is the same, i.e., boiling water, but only the first case manifests the knowledge, while the second is the case of ‘pure luck’. Also, it is possible to achieve knowledge by interpreting false beliefs. It is further explained by John Turri with the help of various examples. According to him, even if we assume the approximate value of pi to be 3.14, it is enough to know that a 15-diameter circle has a greater area than a 10-diameter circle (Turri 8).

In a way, defining knowledge has been a crucial problem for many years. Many efforts were done to solve Gettier’s problem, but none of the solutions or theory is immune to its counterexamples. Hence, the significant impact of Gettier’s problem on modern epistemology can’t be denied.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Gettier's Problem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Gettier's Problem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1657688-gettiers-problem
(Gettier'S Problem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Gettier'S Problem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1657688-gettiers-problem.
“Gettier'S Problem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1657688-gettiers-problem.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Gettier's Problem

The Gettier Problem

I believe that it satisfies Gettier's Problem but this is infect a terrible logic, there is no relevance between the two objects.... n his paper, is justified true belief knowledge of 1963, Edmund Gettier raised a problem which he argued and viewed in the traditional knowledge theory.... Many attempts by a number of epistemologists have failed, for example, Thomas Paxson and Keith Lehrer put across a theory, which utilized the defeasibility argument to attempt solving the Gettier problem (Lehrer and Paxon 225- 237)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Discuss Whether Justified True Belief Can Be Considered Knowledge

Justified True Belief (JTB): Can It Be Considered Knowledge?... Immediately, JTB could be perceived as knowledge, because chat else could it be?... The mere fact that a belief is true and justified means it is valid.... Therefore, it is proven true, and knowledge is truth.... hellip; What more should there be that JTB is still being doubted as knowledge?...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Of Pandas, People, and Propaganda

Until the time when Edmund gettier's paper was published in 1963, most epistemological philosophers had relied upon the JTB Theory of knowledge acquisition.... Learning and the acquisition of knowledge are two of the most ubiquitous and at once most mysterious processes in our lives....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Branches of Reliabilism in Philosophy

his theory was refuted by Gettier in the Gettier problem, whereby the concept of ‘knowledge' as it pertains to ‘justified true belief' was challenged.... The Gettier problem or the Gettier cases... Historically, there have been several debates and arguments both – in favor of and against the elements such as – knowledge, beliefs and reliability of the evidence on which such knowledge is based....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Pandas, People, and Propaganda

Until the time when Edmund gettier's paper was published in 1963, most epistemological philosophers had relied upon the JTB Theory.... In the paper “Pandas, People, and Propaganda” the author looks at learning and the acquisition of knowledge, which are two of the most ubiquitous and at once most mysterious processes in our lives....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Gettier's Problem of Knowledge

The article "Gettier's Problem of Knowledge" describes and defines the concept of knowledge, where a philosopher must first conclude what exactly are the necessary and sufficient conditions for declarative knowledge: that class of knowledge focused on facts that can be put into sentences either true or false.... The problem is that Gettier's arguments have not been properly dismissed and the difficulties they give rise to still remain.... Therein lays the effect the so-called “Gettier problem” has on the account of knowledge....
7 Pages (1750 words) Article

True Belief Can be Considered Knowledge

I agree with Sellars (1975) that despite the pitfalls of JTB as knowledge – as gettier's problems illustrate – it remains essentially sound (cited in Turri, p.... The paper "True Belief Can be Considered Knowledge" describes that JTB can be considered knowledge.... 1)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Plato's three conditions for knowledge

However, contradicting Plato's Theory of Knowledge is gettier's Theory.... Plato, the Father of Western Philosophy, and some philosophers before him, attempted the same dispute and formulated assertions on knowledge.... In accordance with Plato's philosophy, to possess… A belief is basically similar to an opinion....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us